Parallax

30 December, 1916

Rasputin is lured to a prince’s cellar

A prince, a grand duke and a right-wing deputy set out to save the monarchy by killing the empress’s favourite, then each wrote a different account of how they did it.

Moika Palace, Petrograd, Russia

Shortly after midnight on 17 December 1916 by the Russian calendar, 30 December in the West, Prince Felix Yusupov collected Grigory Rasputin from his flat on Gorokhovaya Street in a car driven by one of his fellow conspirators. Rasputin had been told he would meet Yusupov’s wife, Princess Irina, a famous beauty and the tsar’s niece. She was in fact in the Crimea. Yusupov took his guest down to a basement room in the family’s palace on the Moika canal, newly furnished for the occasion, while upstairs the other plotters played a gramophone record of Yankee Doodle to suggest a party in progress.

There were five of them: Yusupov; Grand Duke Dmitry Pavlovich, the tsar’s cousin; Vladimir Purishkevich, a monarchist deputy in the Duma; an army doctor, Stanislaus Lazovert; and a young officer, Sergei Sukhotin. According to Yusupov’s own account, he offered Rasputin cakes and Madeira that Lazovert had laced with potassium cyanide, and waited for more than two hours while his guest ate, drank, asked for gypsy songs on the guitar and showed no sign of distress.

At last Yusupov went upstairs, came back with Dmitry’s revolver, and shot Rasputin in the chest. The others came down and found him apparently dead. But when Yusupov returned to the body some time later, Rasputin, by his telling, opened his eyes, seized him by the shoulder and then scrambled up the stairs and out into the snowy courtyard. Purishkevich ran after him, fired, missed twice, and then hit him, and Rasputin fell near the gate. A policeman who came to ask about the shots was told a dog had been killed.

The conspirators wrapped the body in cloth, tied it with rope, drove to the Petrovsky Bridge over the Malaya Nevka and pushed it through a hole in the ice. A boot found on the ice gave the place away. On 19 December, by the Russian calendar, divers recovered the frozen body.

The autopsy, carried out by the surgeon Dmitry Kosorotov, found three gunshot wounds, any of which might have proved fatal, the last fired into the forehead at close range. It found no trace of poison. Despite the most enduring part of the legend, Kosorotov is reported to have found no water in the lungs: Rasputin was dead before he went into the river. Yusupov and Purishkevich were not punished in any normal sense. The tsar exiled Dmitry to the Persian front and sent Yusupov to his estates.

How it came to this

Rasputin was born around 1869 in the Siberian village of Pokrovskoye, a peasant who left his wife and children in his late twenties to become a wandering pilgrim. By the early 1900s he had a reputation as a holy man and healer, and in 1905 he was introduced to Nicholas II and Alexandra. Their only son, Alexei, born in 1904, had haemophilia, which was kept a state secret. Rasputin appeared to calm the boy’s bleeding episodes, perhaps by calming the boy and his mother, perhaps by persuading them to stop the doctors’ interventions. To the empress he became Our Friend, a man sent by God.

His drinking and his sexual adventures with women of all classes became public scandal, fed by police surveillance reports and a hostile press. After Nicholas took personal command of the army in 1915 and left Alexandra to manage affairs in the capital, Rasputin was widely believed to choose ministers, and the government changed prime minister and interior minister with bewildering speed. With the war going badly, rumour held that the German-born empress and her peasant adviser were betraying Russia. In November 1916 the liberal leader Pavel Milyukov asked in the Duma whether the government’s conduct was stupidity or treason.

How each side saw it

The assassins

Yusupov and Purishkevich both published accounts: Purishkevich a diary in 1918, Yusupov a book in 1927 and memoirs later. Both present the murder as a patriotic duty to rescue the throne from dark forces, and both make Rasputin a near-supernatural figure who would not die, which flattered the killers and made the story famous. Their versions conflict on details, including who fired the fatal shot. Yusupov spent decades in exile retelling the tale and later sued MGM in London over a film that implied his wife had been seduced by Rasputin, winning damages.

Alexandra and the imperial family

In her letters to Nicholas, Alexandra had defended Rasputin for years as a man of God slandered by jealous courtiers. On his death she was devastated; she had him buried privately at Tsarskoe Selo, and her letters and those of her daughters mourn him. Many in the wider Romanov family welcomed the killing: sixteen grand dukes and duchesses signed a letter asking for leniency for Dmitry, which Nicholas refused, saying no one had the right to commit murder. The rift between the couple and their own dynasty became complete.

Rasputin’s family and later defenders

His daughter Maria, who escaped to the West, wrote memoirs presenting him as a devout peasant father traduced by aristocrats who could not bear a muzhik at court. Some Russian Orthodox monarchists have since venerated him as a martyr, though the Church has refused to canonise him. Historians such as Douglas Smith, working through police files, have concluded that many stories of orgies came from hostile sources and political rumour, while confirming much heavy drinking and a large number of affairs.

What is disputed

Almost every vivid detail rests on the assassins’ memoirs. The poisoned cakes are doubted because no poison was found; the drowning story is contradicted by the autopsy as reported. Andrew Cook and Richard Cullen have argued that a British intelligence officer, Oswald Rayner, was present and fired the shot to the forehead, to stop Russia making a separate peace; Smith and others find the evidence thin. The prophetic last letter promising death to the dynasty if nobles killed him appeared only after the revolution, through his secretary Aron Simanovich, and is generally regarded as a fabrication.

What followed

The murder solved nothing. Ten weeks later, in February 1917, strikes and mutinies in Petrograd brought down the monarchy. In March soldiers dug up Rasputin’s body and burned it. Nicholas, Alexandra and their children were shot at Ekaterinburg in July 1918. Yusupov and Dmitry, both exiled for the murder, survived the revolution abroad because of it. Rasputin has since become a stock figure of popular culture, from films to a disco hit, more famous than any minister he is said to have appointed.

Read further

  • Douglas Smith, Rasputin: Faith, Power, and the Twilight of the Romanovs (2016)
  • Joseph T. Fuhrmann, Rasputin: The Untold Story (2013)
  • Edvard Radzinsky, The Rasputin File (2000)
  • Andrew Cook, To Kill Rasputin: The Life and Death of Grigori Rasputin (2005)
  • Felix Yusupov, Lost Splendour (1953)

Same day, other years

1066

The massacre of the Jews of Granada

Granada, al-Andalus (Spain)Europe

Granada was ruled by a Berber Zirid dynasty, and for decades its chief minister had been a Jew, Samuel ibn Naghrela, scholar, poet and commander of the army. His son Joseph succeeded him as vizier to King Badis. On 30 December 1066, amid rumours that Joseph planned to betray the city to a rival ruler, a Muslim crowd stormed the royal palace, killed him and crucified his body. The crowd then turned on the Jewish quarter. Later Jewish sources speak of some 1,500 families or about 4,000 people killed, figures that cannot be checked.

Seen from elsewhere. A hostile poem by the jurist Abu Ishaq of Elvira, accusing the Jews of arrogance and power over Muslims, had circulated beforehand. The memoirs of Badis’s grandson Abd Allah blame Joseph’s own ambitions. The episode complicates both the picture of al-Andalus as a land of easy coexistence and the opposite picture of constant persecution.

1896

Jose Rizal is shot in Manila

Bagumbayan (Luneta), Manila, PhilippinesAsia

Jose Rizal, ophthalmologist, linguist and author of two novels attacking the friars and the colonial order, Noli Me Tangere and El filibusterismo, was executed by a Spanish firing squad at dawn. He had been exiled to Mindanao for four years and was on his way to serve as an army doctor in Cuba when the Katipunan revolt broke out in August 1896. He was brought back, tried by a military court for rebellion, sedition and illegal association, and condemned. The night before, he wrote the farewell poem now known as Mi ultimo adios.

Seen from elsewhere. Rizal had in fact disavowed the armed revolt and argued for reform and representation within Spain. The historian Renato Constantino argued in 1969 that the American colonial government promoted him as the national hero because he was safer than revolutionaries such as Andres Bonifacio. Filipinos mark 30 December as Rizal Day.

1922

The Soviet Union is founded

Bolshoi Theatre, MoscowEurope

A congress of soviets in Moscow approved the treaty uniting four republics, Russia, Ukraine, Belorussia and Transcaucasia, into the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. It followed a quarrel within the Bolshevik leadership. Stalin, as commissar for nationalities, had proposed simply absorbing the other republics into Russia as autonomous units; Lenin, partly paralysed by strokes, insisted on a formal union of equals with the right to secede. Lenin, too ill to attend, won on paper. In practice the single Communist Party ruled every republic, and the right of secession existed only in the constitution, which was adopted in 1924.

Seen from elsewhere. Georgian Communists who resisted Moscow’s control in the same months were overruled and abused, an affair that turned Lenin against Stalin in his last writings. Ukrainian historians see the union as the reconquest of a briefly independent state. Soviet history presented it as a free association of peoples.

2006

Saddam Hussein is hanged

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

Saddam Hussein, ruler of Iraq from 1979 until the American-led invasion of 2003, was hanged at dawn in a former military intelligence building in Baghdad. He had been sentenced by the Iraqi High Tribunal for the killing of 148 Shia men and boys from the town of Dujail after an attempt on his life there in 1982. Further trials, including the one for the Anfal campaign against the Kurds, in which tens of thousands died, were left without a verdict on him. The execution took place on the first day of Eid al-Adha for Sunni Muslims.

Seen from elsewhere. A mobile phone video showed guards taunting him with the name of the Shia cleric Muqtada al-Sadr. Many Sunnis saw sectarian revenge; human rights groups criticised the trial’s fairness and the death penalty. Many Shia and Kurdish Iraqis, whose families he had killed, welcomed it as overdue justice.

Also on 30 December