Parallax

28 December, 1895

Thirty-three people pay a franc to see pictures move

In the basement billiard room of a Paris cafe, the Lumiere family charged admission for twenty minutes of projected film, and within weeks the queues stretched down the boulevard.

Salon Indien, Grand Cafe, boulevard des Capucines, Paris

The room had been a billiard hall decorated in an oriental style, under the Grand Cafe on the boulevard des Capucines. Antoine Lumiere, a portrait photographer turned manufacturer, rented it for the evening of Saturday 28 December 1895 after more fashionable venues turned him down. Chairs were set in rows, a white sheet hung at one end, and a man named Clement Maurice took the money at the door: one franc a head. According to the family’s later accounts, thirty-three people came on that first night, and the takings did not cover the rent.

The machine stood at the back of the room on a stand. It was a wooden box not much bigger than a hatbox, with a lens at the front and a crank at the side, and the same box had filmed the pictures it now projected, with a lantern behind it to throw them onto the screen. The operator turned the handle at a steady pace, about sixteen frames a second. Each film was a single shot of roughly seventeen metres and lasted under a minute.

There were ten of them. Workers, most of them women, streamed out of the gates of the Lumiere plate factory in Lyon at the end of a shift. A gardener was soaked when a boy stepped on his hose and then let go. A baby was fed at a garden table by Auguste Lumiere and his wife, with the leaves on the trees behind them stirring in the wind, a detail that seems to have struck early viewers as much as the action. Blacksmiths hammered at an anvil, swimmers jumped into the sea, and a young man tried again and again to vault onto a horse and kept falling off.

Word spread quickly. Within days the room was full, and within weeks the Lumieres were running shows every half hour from morning to night, with police reportedly called in to manage the queue. Georges Melies, the conjurer who ran the Theatre Robert-Houdin a few streets away, was in the audience early on and asked to buy a machine. He was refused.

The brothers Auguste and Louis, the elder born in 1862 and the younger in 1864, had built the cinematographe the year before. Louis had solved the hardest problem, moving the film one frame at a time and holding it still while it was exposed, with a claw mechanism he likened to the foot of a sewing machine. They patented it in February 1895 and had shown it to scientific and photographic societies several times that year. The Grand Cafe was the first time they sold tickets.

How it came to this

Moving pictures were already in the air. Since the 1870s Eadweard Muybridge and Etienne-Jules Marey had been breaking motion into rows of photographs. Emile Reynaud had been projecting hand-painted animated strips at the Musee Grevin since 1892. Thomas Edison’s company, with W. K. L. Dickson doing most of the work, launched the Kinetoscope in 1894, a cabinet in which one person at a time could watch a short film through an eyepiece. It was a success in amusement parlours across America and Europe.

Antoine Lumiere saw a Kinetoscope in Paris in 1894 and urged his sons to improve on it. The family business made them well placed: their factory at Monplaisir in Lyon had become one of the largest makers of photographic plates in Europe, built on a fast dry plate Louis had developed in his teens. They had capital, chemists and skilled workers. What they added was projection to an audience, in a light machine that could also be carried anywhere and used as a camera.

How each side saw it

Rival inventors

In Berlin the brothers Max and Emil Skladanowsky had projected films with their Bioscop to a paying audience at the Wintergarten music hall on 1 November 1895, nearly two months earlier, and German film history has long claimed them as first. In New York the Latham family had shown projected film in May 1895, and in Atlanta Charles Francis Jenkins and Thomas Armat demonstrated their Phantoscope that autumn. Their machines were clumsier or less reliable than the Lumieres’, but the claim that cinema began on one night in Paris has always been a French national tradition as well as a fact.

The workers on the screen

The first film shown was of the Lumiere factory’s own employees, filmed at least three times in 1895, and the different versions show the scene was arranged: the workers are in their best clothes, the gates open on cue. They left no recorded opinion of becoming the first film extras. Their presence is a reminder that the family fortune rested on several hundred workers, many of them young women in the plate-coating and packing rooms, and that the brothers’ early films are largely of their own family, staff and property.

Audiences beyond Europe

Within months Lumiere operators were carrying the machine around the world, both showing films and shooting new ones. They projected in Bombay in July 1896, in Cairo, in Mexico City, where Gabriel Veyre filmed President Porfirio Diaz, and in Russia, where they filmed the coronation of Nicholas II. Local newspapers reported the shows as a European marvel. For many places the first moving images of their own streets and people were made by a French company for sale in its catalogue, an early form of the picturing of empire that later film would continue.

What is disputed

The best-known story, that audiences ran from their seats as a train pulled into a station on screen, is doubtful twice over: the train film was not on the 28 December programme, being added in January 1896, and the historian Martin Loiperdinger has found no contemporary report of panic. The remark that cinema was an invention without a future is attributed to Antoine Lumiere through Melies’ later memories and may be legend. Claims of who was first depend on whether one counts private demonstrations, paying shows or peep-show viewers. The figure of thirty-three spectators comes from later recollection.

What followed

The Lumiere catalogue grew to more than 1,400 films, shot across five continents by travelling operators, before the firm withdrew from production in the early 1900s to concentrate on photography, including the autochrome colour plate. Melies built his own camera and invented much of film trickery; Pathe and Gaumont turned cinema into an industry. Sixteen frames a second remained the silent-era norm until sound film fixed the standard at twenty-four. The site of the Grand Cafe carries a plaque.

Read further

  • Georges Sadoul, Louis Lumiere (1964)
  • Laurent Mannoni, The Great Art of Light and Shadow: Archaeology of the Cinema (2000)
  • Charles Musser, The Emergence of Cinema: The American Screen to 1907 (1990)
  • Deac Rossell, Living Pictures: The Origins of the Movies (1998)
  • Martin Loiperdinger, ‘Lumiere’s Arrival of the Train: Cinema’s Founding Myth’ (2004)

Same day, other years

1835

Seminole warriors destroy Dade’s column

Near present-day Bushnell, FloridaThe Americas

Major Francis Dade was marching about 108 soldiers from Fort Brooke on Tampa Bay to reinforce Fort King when, on the morning of 28 December, Seminole and Black Seminole fighters hidden in the palmettos opened fire. Dade fell in the first volley. The survivors threw up a log barricade and held out for some hours before it was overrun. Only two or three soldiers survived. On the same day Osceola and his men killed the government agent Wiley Thompson outside Fort King. These attacks opened the Second Seminole War, which lasted until 1842.

Seen from elsewhere. The war was resistance to removal west under a treaty most Seminole leaders said they had not truly agreed to, and to the seizure of Black Seminoles as slaves. The Seminole leader Alligator later gave his account to an army officer, recorded by John Sprague. The United States called it a massacre and spent years and thousands of lives fighting it.

1885

The Indian National Congress meets for the first time

Gokuldas Tejpal Sanskrit College, Bombay, IndiaAsia

Seventy-two delegates, mostly lawyers, journalists, teachers and merchants from the presidencies of British India, gathered in Bombay for three days under the presidency of the barrister Womesh Chunder Bonnerjee. A retired British civil servant, Allan Octavian Hume, had done much of the organising. Their resolutions were moderate: an inquiry into the administration of India, Indian members on the legislative councils, and simultaneous examinations in India for the civil service. They professed loyalty to the Crown. Over the next sixty years the Congress became the main vehicle of the independence movement under Tilak, Gandhi and Nehru.

Seen from elsewhere. An old view, drawn from Hume’s biographer, held that Congress was set up as a safety valve to channel discontent; nationalist historians such as Bipan Chandra rejected this. Some Muslim leaders, notably Syed Ahmad Khan, urged Muslims to stay away, fearing a Hindu majority body would not represent them.

1908

An earthquake and tsunami destroy Messina and Reggio

Strait of Messina, ItalyEurope

At twenty past five in the morning a powerful earthquake struck beneath the Strait of Messina, between Sicily and the toe of Italy. In less than a minute most of the buildings in Messina and Reggio Calabria collapsed, and minutes later a tsunami several metres high swept the shores of the strait. Fires broke out among the ruins. The dead are usually estimated at between 75,000 and 82,000, and some estimates exceed 100,000. Sailors from a Russian squadron at anchor nearby were among the first rescuers, followed by British and American ships.

Seen from elsewhere. Italian critics accused the state of a slow and chaotic response; martial law was declared and some looters were shot. Messina had been destroyed before, in 1783, and was rebuilt with low reinforced buildings. Residents long complained that much of the city lived in temporary huts for decades.

1948

Egypt’s prime minister is shot by a Muslim Brother

Ministry of the Interior, Cairo, EgyptMiddle East

Mahmoud Fahmi al-Nuqrashi Pasha, prime minister of Egypt, had ordered the dissolution of the Society of the Muslim Brothers on 8 December, accusing it of plotting revolution and of bombings in Cairo. Twenty days later, as he entered the lift at the Ministry of the Interior, a young member of the society dressed as a police officer shot him dead. The country was also reeling from defeat in the war in Palestine. The Brotherhood’s founder, Hassan al-Banna, publicly condemned the killing, saying those who did it were neither brothers nor Muslims.

Seen from elsewhere. Al-Banna was himself shot dead in a Cairo street on 12 February 1949, a killing widely attributed to agents of the government; nobody was convicted until after the 1952 revolution. Brotherhood histories describe a persecuted movement, government accounts a secret armed wing out of its leaders’ control.

Also on 28 December