On the afternoon of Monday 1 December 1919 the public galleries of the House of Commons were full, and a good many of the people in them were women. At the bar of the chamber stood a small figure in a black coat and skirt, a white blouse and a three-cornered hat, an outfit she had chosen so that no newspaper could write about her clothes. On one side of her stood the prime minister, David Lloyd George, and on the other Arthur Balfour, who had held the office before him. The three bowed, advanced, bowed again, and Nancy Astor took the oath as member for the Sutton division of Plymouth.
She had got there by an accident of inheritance. Her husband Waldorf had held the Plymouth seat since 1910. In October 1919 his father died, Waldorf became the second Viscount Astor whether he liked it or not, and the rules removed him to the House of Lords. The local Conservatives asked his wife to stand in the by-election. She was forty, a mother of six, a teetotaller and a Christian Scientist, born Nancy Langhorne in Danville, Virginia, and divorced from a first husband in Boston before she married one of the richest men in England.
Her campaign became a national entertainment. She toured the Plymouth docks and back streets in a carriage with a coachman in livery, and took on hecklers with a speed that her opponents never matched. Polling was on 15 November; the count was held back until the 28th so that votes from servicemen still abroad could arrive. She beat the Labour candidate, William Gay, by more than five thousand votes, with the Liberal, Isaac Foot, third.
Inside the House the welcome was thinner than the ceremony suggested. Men she had entertained at her country house, Cliveden, would not speak to her in the corridors. For almost two years she was the only woman among more than six hundred members, with no cloakroom and no women’s lavatory near the chamber. Winston Churchill, by her account, admitted that the members had hoped to freeze her out, and said that her arrival had felt like a woman walking in on him in his bath.
She made her maiden speech in February 1920, defending wartime restrictions on drink, a subject guaranteed to annoy the House. In 1923 she carried a private member’s bill that barred the sale of alcohol to anyone under eighteen, the first piece of legislation steered through by a woman. She held Plymouth Sutton through seven elections and left, unwillingly, in 1945.
How it came to this
Women’s suffrage had been argued in Britain since the 1860s and fought for, with petitions by the constitutional suffragists under Millicent Fawcett and with window-breaking, arson and hunger strikes by the Pankhursts’ Women’s Social and Political Union, in the years before 1914. The Representation of the People Act of February 1918 gave the vote to women over thirty who met a property test, about 8.4 million of them. In November, almost as an afterthought, a second and very short act allowed women to stand for the Commons, and to do so at twenty-one, nine years before they could vote.
Seventeen women stood in the general election of December 1918. Christabel Pankhurst came within 800 votes at Smethwick. Only one won: Constance Markievicz, a veteran of the 1916 Easter Rising, elected for a Dublin seat while she was a prisoner in Holloway. As a Sinn Fein member she refused the oath to the king and never went near the chamber, sitting instead in the revolutionary Dail in Dublin. So the first woman to appear in the Commons would be whoever won a by-election, and the first by-election to offer the chance fell to a Conservative peeress.