Parallax

1 December, 1919

A Virginian viscountess takes her seat at Westminster

The first woman to sit in the House of Commons was not a suffragette, not British-born, and not the first woman elected. Nancy Astor walked in anyway, between a prime minister and a former one.

Westminster, London

On the afternoon of Monday 1 December 1919 the public galleries of the House of Commons were full, and a good many of the people in them were women. At the bar of the chamber stood a small figure in a black coat and skirt, a white blouse and a three-cornered hat, an outfit she had chosen so that no newspaper could write about her clothes. On one side of her stood the prime minister, David Lloyd George, and on the other Arthur Balfour, who had held the office before him. The three bowed, advanced, bowed again, and Nancy Astor took the oath as member for the Sutton division of Plymouth.

She had got there by an accident of inheritance. Her husband Waldorf had held the Plymouth seat since 1910. In October 1919 his father died, Waldorf became the second Viscount Astor whether he liked it or not, and the rules removed him to the House of Lords. The local Conservatives asked his wife to stand in the by-election. She was forty, a mother of six, a teetotaller and a Christian Scientist, born Nancy Langhorne in Danville, Virginia, and divorced from a first husband in Boston before she married one of the richest men in England.

Her campaign became a national entertainment. She toured the Plymouth docks and back streets in a carriage with a coachman in livery, and took on hecklers with a speed that her opponents never matched. Polling was on 15 November; the count was held back until the 28th so that votes from servicemen still abroad could arrive. She beat the Labour candidate, William Gay, by more than five thousand votes, with the Liberal, Isaac Foot, third.

Inside the House the welcome was thinner than the ceremony suggested. Men she had entertained at her country house, Cliveden, would not speak to her in the corridors. For almost two years she was the only woman among more than six hundred members, with no cloakroom and no women’s lavatory near the chamber. Winston Churchill, by her account, admitted that the members had hoped to freeze her out, and said that her arrival had felt like a woman walking in on him in his bath.

She made her maiden speech in February 1920, defending wartime restrictions on drink, a subject guaranteed to annoy the House. In 1923 she carried a private member’s bill that barred the sale of alcohol to anyone under eighteen, the first piece of legislation steered through by a woman. She held Plymouth Sutton through seven elections and left, unwillingly, in 1945.

How it came to this

Women’s suffrage had been argued in Britain since the 1860s and fought for, with petitions by the constitutional suffragists under Millicent Fawcett and with window-breaking, arson and hunger strikes by the Pankhursts’ Women’s Social and Political Union, in the years before 1914. The Representation of the People Act of February 1918 gave the vote to women over thirty who met a property test, about 8.4 million of them. In November, almost as an afterthought, a second and very short act allowed women to stand for the Commons, and to do so at twenty-one, nine years before they could vote.

Seventeen women stood in the general election of December 1918. Christabel Pankhurst came within 800 votes at Smethwick. Only one won: Constance Markievicz, a veteran of the 1916 Easter Rising, elected for a Dublin seat while she was a prisoner in Holloway. As a Sinn Fein member she refused the oath to the king and never went near the chamber, sitting instead in the revolutionary Dail in Dublin. So the first woman to appear in the Commons would be whoever won a by-election, and the first by-election to offer the chance fell to a Conservative peeress.

How each side saw it

The suffrage campaigners

The women who had spent decades on the cause greeted the result with public warmth and some private wryness. Astor had taken no part in the campaign, and the victory had gone to a rich hostess standing in for her husband rather than to anyone who had been to prison for it. Millicent Fawcett’s organisation nonetheless saw the practical point and supplied her with briefings and a secretary. Astor accepted the role: she described herself as the women’s member, answered thousands of letters from outside her constituency, and worked across party lines with the Liberal Margaret Wintringham and Labour’s Ellen Wilkinson once they arrived.

Constance Markievicz and Irish republicans

For Sinn Fein the Westminster first was beside the point. Markievicz had won her seat a year earlier on a platform of not taking it, and in 1919 she became Minister for Labour in the Dail government, one of the first women anywhere to hold cabinet rank. She is reported to have dismissed Astor as a member of the upper classes who knew nothing of working women’s lives. In Irish memory the first woman elected to the Commons is Markievicz, and Astor’s ceremony belongs to the parliament that Ireland was at that moment fighting to leave.

Labour and the Plymouth opposition

William Gay and the local Labour movement argued that a millionaire’s wife who lived on a great estate in Buckinghamshire could not speak for dockyard families, and that her canvassing in pearls was a performance. Her supporters replied that she and Waldorf had paid for housing, nurseries and clinics in the town. Labour critics at Westminster later noted that she voted with the Conservatives on most economic questions, including during the General Strike, while pressing for nursery schools, a higher school leaving age and women police. Both things were true, and Plymouth kept returning her.

Her later critics

Astor’s reputation was damaged in the 1930s. The journalist Claud Cockburn named the weekend guests at her house the Cliveden Set and accused them of steering Britain towards an accommodation with Hitler; historians think the influence was exaggerated, but her support for appeasement was real. Her letters and remarks contain hostility to Jews and to Catholics that her biographers do not excuse. When a statue of her was unveiled in Plymouth in 2019, on the centenary of her election, protesters cited those remarks and defenders cited the nursery schools and the 1923 act.

What is disputed

The claim to be first needs its qualifiers: Astor was the first woman to take a seat, Markievicz the first to be elected. The Churchill bathroom exchange exists only in Astor’s own retellings, which improved with age, and many of the famous insults traded between the two (the poisoned coffee among them) cannot be traced to any contemporary record and are attached to other people in earlier joke books. How much she achieved is also argued. Brian Harrison and others credit her with making a woman’s presence in the House ordinary; critics count one act and a great many interruptions.

What followed

Margaret Wintringham joined her in 1921, also succeeding a husband. Eight women sat by 1923, and Margaret Bondfield became the first woman cabinet minister in 1929, a year after women finally got the vote on the same terms as men. Astor stood down in 1945 at her husband’s insistence and resented it for the rest of her life; she died in 1964. Women did not reach a tenth of the House until 1997. Hereditary peeresses, the class she belonged to, were not admitted to the Lords until 1963.

Read further

  • Christopher Sykes, Nancy: The Life of Lady Astor (1972)
  • Adrian Fort, Nancy: The Story of Lady Astor (2012)
  • Brian Harrison, Prudent Revolutionaries: Portraits of British Feminists between the Wars (1987)
  • Karen J. Musolf, From Plymouth to Parliament: A Rhetorical History of Nancy Astor’s 1919 Campaign (1999)
  • Nancy Astor, My Two Countries (1923)

Same day, other years

1834

Slavery ends at the Cape, on paper

Cape Colony, southern AfricaAfrica

The act of the British parliament abolishing slavery took effect in most colonies on 1 August 1834. At the Cape it came into force four months later, on 1 December. Some 36,000 people were legally freed. They or their forebears had been brought by the Dutch East India Company and private traders from Madagascar, Mozambique, India and the Indonesian islands, or born into bondage in the colony. Freedom was deferred: the law bound them to their former owners as unpaid ‘apprentices’ for four more years, and the real day of release was 1 December 1838, when many simply walked off the farms.

Seen from elsewhere. Compensation went to the owners, not the freed, and had to be claimed in London, so Cape farmers received well under the assessed value. The grievance fed the Great Trek; Anna Steenkamp, a trekker, wrote that the offence was less the freedom than being placed on an equal footing with Christians. In Cape Town 1 December is still marked by descendants of the enslaved.

1934

Sergei Kirov is shot in the Smolny corridor

Leningrad, Soviet UnionEurope

Kirov, the Communist Party chief in Leningrad and a member of the Politburo, was walking to his office on the third floor of the Smolny Institute when a former party worker, Leonid Nikolaev, shot him in the back of the neck. Stalin took a train north that night and questioned the killer himself. A decree issued the same day stripped those accused of terrorism of the right to defence or appeal and ordered death sentences carried out at once. Within weeks the murder was blamed on followers of Zinoviev; within four years it had served as the opening charge in the purges that killed hundreds of thousands.

Seen from elsewhere. Khrushchev hinted in 1956 that Stalin was behind the killing, and Robert Conquest argued the case in detail. Historians who have worked in the opened archives, including Alla Kirilina and Matthew Lenoe, find a lone, embittered gunman and a leader who exploited the event. The death of Kirov’s bodyguard in a lorry crash the next day keeps the doubt alive.

1944

French troops fire on West African soldiers at Thiaroye

Thiaroye, near Dakar, SenegalAfrica

The men in the transit camp at Thiaroye were tirailleurs from across French West Africa who had fought for France in 1940 and spent four years as prisoners of the Germans. Shipped home in November 1944, they were refused the back pay and demobilisation money owed to them and protested, briefly detaining a general. At dawn on 1 December French colonial troops and gendarmes surrounded the camp with armoured cars and opened fire. The army reported 35 dead. Thirty-four survivors were tried for mutiny and sentenced to up to ten years; they were amnestied in 1947 but not cleared.

Seen from elsewhere. The army called it the suppression of an armed mutiny. Historians such as Armelle Mabon, working from incomplete and in places altered files, argue the men were unarmed and the dead numbered in the hundreds. France acknowledged 70 deaths in 2014 and used the word massacre in 2024. Senegal is still asking for the full archives and the location of the graves.

1955

Rosa Parks stays in her seat

Montgomery, Alabama, United StatesThe Americas

On the Cleveland Avenue bus that Thursday evening the driver, James Blake, told four Black passengers to give up their row so that one white man could sit. Three moved. Rosa Parks, a 42-year-old seamstress and the secretary of the local NAACP branch, did not, and was arrested. Overnight Jo Ann Robinson of the Women’s Political Council ran off tens of thousands of leaflets calling for a one-day boycott of the buses. It lasted 381 days, made a national figure of a 26-year-old minister called Martin Luther King, and ended when the Supreme Court ruled bus segregation unconstitutional.

Seen from elsewhere. The city and the White Citizens’ Council called it an NAACP plot and prosecuted the organisers; Parks and her husband lost their jobs and left Alabama. The tale of a tired seamstress irritated her: she wrote that the only tired she was, was tired of giving in. Claudette Colvin, fifteen, had done the same nine months earlier and was passed over as a test case.

Also on 1 December