Parallax

7 December, 43 BC

Cicero puts his head out of the litter

Rome’s greatest orator had spent a year attacking Mark Antony in speech after speech. When Antony came to share power, the price was Cicero’s head, and the hands that wrote the speeches.

Near Formiae, on the coast of Latium, Italy

Marcus Tullius Cicero was at his villa at Tusculum, in the hills outside Rome, when he heard that his name was on the list. The three men who had just divided the Roman world between them, Mark Antony, Lepidus and the young Caesar whom we call Octavian, had posted the names of citizens who could be killed on sight, their property forfeit, a reward payable on delivery of the head. Cicero’s brother Quintus and his nephew were listed too. The brothers set out together for the coast, meaning to sail to Marcus Brutus in Macedonia, and parted on the road in tears. Quintus turned back for money and was betrayed and killed with his son.

Cicero reached the sea at Astura and took ship. Then, according to Plutarch, he lost his resolve. He landed again, walked some miles towards Rome, changed his mind, talked of going to Octavian’s house and killing himself on the hearth to bring a curse on it, and at last let his slaves take him by sea to his villa near Formiae. He was sixty-three, exhausted and seasick. He is reported to have said that he would die in the country he had so often saved.

On 7 December his slaves, hearing that soldiers were near, half persuaded and half forced him into a litter and carried him through the woods towards the shore. The detachment was led by a centurion, Herennius, and a military tribune, Popillius Laenas. They found the house empty and were pointed down the right path. When Cicero heard them running up he ordered the litter set down.

Plutarch, drawing on accounts that went back to witnesses, describes him with his chin in his left hand, as was his habit, looking steadily at his killers, unwashed, his hair unkempt, his face worn with anxiety, so that most of the soldiers covered their eyes. He stretched his neck out of the litter. By Appian’s account the blow was botched and it took three strokes.

On Antony’s orders they cut off the head and the hands. Antony had them nailed up on the Rostra in the Forum, the speakers’ platform from which Cicero had addressed the people for forty years. Romans came to look, Plutarch says, and thought they saw there not the face of Cicero but an image of Antony’s soul.

How it came to this

Cicero was born in 106 BC at Arpinum, a hill town sixty miles from Rome, into a family of local gentry with no senator among its ancestors. He made his name in the law courts, reached the consulship in 63 at the earliest legal age, and in that year suppressed the conspiracy of Catiline, having five of its leaders put to death on the Senate’s advice without trial. He considered this the salvation of the republic and never stopped saying so. His enemies considered it the unlawful killing of citizens, and he was exiled for it for a year in 58.

In the civil war between Caesar and Pompey he chose Pompey’s side late and unhappily, was pardoned, and sat out Caesar’s dictatorship writing philosophy. He was not told of the plot to kill Caesar in March 44 BC but rejoiced at the result. With the assassins gone east and the consul Antony manoeuvring for Caesar’s place, Cicero, the senior statesman left in Rome, delivered the fourteen speeches he called Philippics, urging that Antony be declared a public enemy. His instrument was to be Caesar’s nineteen-year-old heir and his private army. In the summer of 43 the heir marched on Rome himself, and in November he made terms with Antony.

How each side saw it

Antony and Fulvia

Antony had personal and political reasons. His stepfather, Lentulus Sura, was one of the men Cicero had executed in 63. The Second Philippic, published as a pamphlet, called Antony a drunkard, a debauchee and a hired gladiator and described his wife Fulvia as a woman fatal to her husbands. Throughout 43 Cicero had pressed the Senate to make war on him to the death, and Antony had been beaten at Mutina in consequence. From his side the killing was the reply in kind to an enemy who had sought his destruction. Antony left no memoir; his case survives only in fragments quoted by those who defeated him.

Octavian

The future Augustus had courted the old man, called him father, and used his authority to gain a command. Cicero was said to have remarked that the young man should be praised, honoured and got rid of, a pun that reached its subject. Plutarch says Octavian held out for two days at the conference before giving Cicero up in exchange for the deaths of Antony’s uncle and Lepidus’s brother. Later Augustan writing blamed Antony alone. Plutarch adds a late scene in which the emperor finds a grandson hiding a book of Cicero’s, reads in it for a long while, and hands it back, saying he was a learned man and a lover of his country.

The proscribed and their households

Cicero was one of perhaps three hundred senators and two thousand knights named, on Appian’s figures. Appian’s history preserves dozens of their stories, collected because Romans found in them a test of character: wives who hid husbands, sons who informed on fathers, slaves who died in a master’s clothes. Cicero’s slaves fought to save him, and Plutarch notes that he forbade it. The triumvirs’ published edict, which Appian quotes, justified the killings by Caesar’s fate: he had spared his enemies and they had murdered him. The lists were also, plainly, a way to seize estates to pay forty-odd legions.

Modern historians

Verdicts on Cicero have swung widely. Theodor Mommsen in the nineteenth century saw a vain trimmer without convictions; Ronald Syme’s The Roman Revolution of 1939 treated the Philippics as a reckless and fraudulent campaign that helped destroy the constitution it claimed to defend, since it armed a private adventurer against a consul. Others, among them Elizabeth Rawson, find a man of real principle outmatched by soldiers, whose last year was the bravest of his life. Because some nine hundred of his letters survive, more is known of his doubts than of any other figure of antiquity, which has not helped his reputation.

What is disputed

The date, 7 December, comes from Cicero’s freedman Tiro by way of Tacitus and is not seriously doubted, though the calendar then ran slightly out of true. The details differ by author. Plutarch says head and both hands were displayed, Appian the head and right hand. Only Cassius Dio, two and a half centuries later, has Fulvia stabbing the tongue with a hairpin. The claim that Popillius was a former client whom Cicero had defended on a charge of killing his father was, according to the elder Seneca, invented by teachers of rhetoric. The dying words in Livy are a historian’s composition; the quip about killing him properly, common in modern books, has no clear ancient source.

What followed

Brutus and Cassius were beaten at Philippi the following autumn. Antony and Octavian fell out in their turn, and in 30 BC it was Cicero’s son Marcus, serving as consul alongside Octavian, who announced Antony’s death to the Senate and had his statues pulled down. The republic Cicero defended did not return. His writings did the rest: his Latin became the standard for European prose, his philosophical dialogues carried Greek thought to the Middle Ages and the Renaissance, and the American and French revolutionaries read him as a martyr of liberty.

Read further

  • Plutarch, Life of Cicero
  • Appian, The Civil Wars, Book 4
  • Seneca the Elder, Suasoriae 6 and 7
  • Ronald Syme, The Roman Revolution (1939)
  • Elizabeth Rawson, Cicero: A Portrait (1975)

Same day, other years

1895

An Italian column is destroyed at Amba Alagi

Amba Alagi, Tigray, EthiopiaAfrica

Italy, established in Eritrea, claimed that a treaty of 1889 had made Ethiopia its protectorate; the Amharic text said no such thing, and Emperor Menelik II repudiated it. In 1895 Italian forces pushed south into Tigray. Their most advanced detachment, some two thousand men under Major Pietro Toselli, nearly all of them Eritrean soldiers in Italian service, held the mountain of Amba Alagi. On 7 December the vanguard of Menelik’s army, tens of thousands strong under Ras Makonnen, came up the slopes on three sides. Toselli, whose order to withdraw never arrived, was killed with most of his command.

Seen from elsewhere. In Italy the defeat was presented as a heroic stand and used to demand reinforcements, not withdrawal. Ethiopians remember it as the first victory of the campaign that ended at Adwa three months later, where an African army kept its country independent. The Eritrean askari, who did most of the dying on the Italian side, are little commemorated by either.

1941

Japanese aircraft attack Pearl Harbor

Oahu, HawaiiWorldwide

At 7.55 on a Sunday morning the first of 353 aircraft from six Japanese carriers came in over the American naval base on Oahu. In under two hours they sank or grounded four battleships, damaged four more, and destroyed some 180 aircraft, most of them parked wing to wing. The dead numbered 2,403, almost half of them in the Arizona, whose forward magazine exploded. The three American carriers were at sea, and the fuel tanks and repair yards were left intact. The next day Congress declared war with one dissenting vote. Germany and Italy declared war on the United States four days later.

Seen from elsewhere. Japan’s leaders saw the American oil embargo of July 1941 as slow strangulation and judged a first strike the only chance. Their note breaking off talks was delivered after the attack began. The claim that Roosevelt knew in advance is rejected by most historians. Within months some 120,000 people of Japanese descent on the American mainland were interned.

1970

Willy Brandt kneels in Warsaw

Warsaw, PolandEurope

The West German chancellor had come to sign a treaty accepting Poland’s post-war western border, and with it the loss of a quarter of Germany’s former territory. On the morning of 7 December he laid a wreath at the monument to the Jewish fighters of the 1943 ghetto uprising. He straightened the ribbon, stepped back, and then, without warning to his staff, went down on both knees on the stone and stayed there for about half a minute with his head bowed. Brandt had spent the Nazi years in exile as an opponent of the regime. He wrote later that he did what people do when words fail.

Seen from elsewhere. A poll for Der Spiegel found 48 per cent of West Germans thought the gesture excessive and 41 per cent appropriate; associations of Germans expelled from the east called the treaty a betrayal. Poland’s communist press gave the image little space: two years earlier the party had driven out most of the country’s remaining Jews.

1975

Indonesia invades East Timor

Dili, East TimorAsia

Portugal’s revolution of 1974 had left its half of the island of Timor adrift. After a short civil war the left-leaning party Fretilin declared independence on 28 November 1975. Nine days later, at dawn on 7 December, Indonesian warships shelled the capital, Dili, and paratroopers dropped on the waterfront. Civilians were shot on the wharf, among them members of the Chinese community and an Australian journalist, Roger East. President Ford and Henry Kissinger had left Jakarta the day before; American records later released show that they had told President Suharto they would not object. The occupation lasted twenty-four years.

Seen from elsewhere. Indonesia said it had been invited by Timorese parties to prevent a communist state on its border, and annexed the territory in 1976; the United Nations never recognised this. East Timor’s truth commission estimated at least 102,800 deaths from killing, hunger and disease, out of fewer than 700,000 people. Independence came in 2002 after a UN-run vote.

Also on 7 December