Parallax

8 December, 65 BC

A freedman’s son is born at Venusia

Horace fought on the losing side of a civil war, by his own account ran away, and lost his family’s land. He ended as the friend of the man who beat him, and wrote the lines that schoolchildren were still made to learn two thousand years later.

Venusia (now Venosa), southern Italy

Quintus Horatius Flaccus was born on 8 December in the consulship of Cotta and Torquatus, which is 65 BC, at Venusia, a garrison town on the Appian Way where Apulia meets Lucania. He tells us the year himself, in a poem addressed to a jar of wine laid down at his birth. His father had been a slave. By the time of the boy’s birth he was free and working as a collector at auctions, a trade that brought in enough to buy a small farm.

The father is the hero of Horace’s early poems. Rather than send his son to the local school with the hulking sons of centurions, he took him to Rome, paid for the education a senator’s son would have, and walked him to his lessons himself to keep him out of trouble. The schoolmaster was one Orbilius, whom Horace remembered chiefly for his cane. At about nineteen he went on to Athens to study philosophy.

He was there in the autumn of 44 BC when Marcus Brutus arrived, fresh from the killing of Caesar, and began recruiting among the young Romans in the lecture halls. Horace joined, and was given the rank of military tribune, an astonishing commission for a freedman’s son that he says earned him sneers. Two years later he was at Philippi, where the armies of Brutus and Cassius were destroyed by Antony and Octavian. In an ode written long afterwards he says he left his little shield behind, not very gloriously, and that Mercury carried him off through the enemy in a cloud.

He came back to Italy under an amnesty to find his father dead and the farm confiscated for the victors’ veterans. He bought a clerk’s post in the treasury and began writing verse, he says, because poverty made him bold. The poets Virgil and Varius took him to see Maecenas, Octavian’s friend and the great patron of the age. Horace stammered a few words; Maecenas said little; nine months later came an invitation to join the circle. In about 33 BC Maecenas gave him a farm in the Sabine hills, with eight slaves and five tenant families, which he celebrated for the rest of his life.

From it came the Satires, the Epodes, the Epistles and four books of Odes, the last a deliberate attempt to do in Latin what Alcaeus and Sappho had done in Greek. He died on 27 November 8 BC, a few weeks after Maecenas, and was buried beside him on the Esquiline.

How it came to this

Horace’s lifetime covered the death of the Roman republic. He was two when Cicero put down Catiline, sixteen when Caesar crossed the Rubicon, twenty-one when Caesar was stabbed, and thirty-four when Octavian defeated Antony and Cleopatra at Actium and became sole master of the Roman world. For Italians of his generation the experience was two decades of proscriptions, conscription and land seizures, followed by a peace whose price was one-man rule under republican forms. Octavian took the name Augustus in 27 BC.

His origins matter because Roman society was graded by birth. Slaves freed by citizens became citizens, but carried the stigma for life, and their sons, though freeborn, could expect to be reminded of it. Venusia had been punished for rebelling against Rome in the Social War of 91-88 BC, when many inhabitants were enslaved, and it has been suggested that Horace’s father was an Italian captured then and not a foreigner at all. Poetry, meanwhile, had become a matter of state interest. Maecenas gathered and rewarded writers who might give the new order a voice: Virgil above all, Propertius, and Horace.

How each side saw it

Augustus

Suetonius, who had access to the imperial archives, quotes the emperor’s letters. Augustus asked Maecenas to release Horace to be his private secretary; Horace declined and was not punished for it. The emperor teased him for his short, round figure and complained that he was not mentioned in the poet’s verse letters: ‘Are you afraid that it will count against you with posterity to seem to have been my friend?’ He commissioned the hymn sung by a choir of boys and girls at the Secular Games of 17 BC, and pressed him for odes on the victories of his stepsons. The patron wanted praise and got it, on the poet’s terms.

The republicans he had fought beside

Horace never denied Philippi. He addresses an ode to an old comrade from the campaign, names Brutus as his commander, and praises the unbending Cato. But he made his peace early, and the men who died on that field would hardly have recognised the poet who wrote that with Caesar guarding the state no civil madness would disturb the peace. Whether this was conversion, gratitude, exhaustion or prudence, the poems do not say. Ronald Syme classed him among the regime’s publicists. Other readers hear in the odes on civil war a survivor’s guilt that no official poet would have needed to express.

The vanquished of Actium

The ode that begins ‘Now is the time for drinking’ celebrates the death of Cleopatra, whom it never names. She is a maddened queen plotting ruin for the Capitol with a diseased gang of half-men. This is the victors’ picture, and it is almost the only one there is: no Egyptian or Antonian account of the war survives, and what is known of her comes from Roman writers and from Plutarch a century on. Yet the poem turns in its last stanzas. She looks on her fallen palace with a calm face, handles the snakes without flinching, and refuses to be led in a Roman triumph: no humble woman.

Wilfred Owen and the readers of 1917

One line from the Roman Odes, that it is sweet and fitting to die for one’s country, was carved on war memorials and taught in every British public school. Owen, an infantry officer, ended his poem about a soldier choking in a gas attack by calling it ‘the old Lie’. Whether Horace meant it straight is itself debated, since the same stanza observes that death also catches the man who runs, and its author had run. For much of the twentieth century he was read as a comfortable apologist for power. More recent critics stress the ironies and the evasions.

What is disputed

The birth date comes from the short Life attributed to Suetonius and falls in the Roman calendar as it stood before Caesar’s reform, so it does not correspond exactly to a modern 8 December. The lost shield is suspect as autobiography: the Greek poets Archilochus and Alcaeus, his models, both claimed to have thrown theirs away, and the line may be a literary gesture. Gordon Williams argued that ‘freedman’s son’ was itself a pose exaggerating humble origins. The location of the Sabine farm near Licenza is probable but not proven. To call him ‘poet laureate’, as popular accounts do, is an anachronism; Rome had no such office.

What followed

Horace predicted in the last ode of his third book that he had built a monument more lasting than bronze, and that he would be read as long as the priest climbed the Capitol with the silent Vestal. He underestimated. His poems were school texts within a century and never ceased to be copied. Phrases of his, ‘seize the day’, ‘the golden mean’, ‘in the middle of things’, passed into the languages of Europe. Petrarch, Ronsard, Ben Jonson, Pope and Pushkin all wrote in his shadow. The slaves who worked the farm that gave him his leisure are named in the poems only in passing.

Read further

  • Suetonius, Life of Horace
  • Eduard Fraenkel, Horace (1957)
  • R. O. A. M. Lyne, Horace: Behind the Public Poetry (1995)
  • Peter Levi, Horace: A Life (1997)
  • Horace, The Complete Odes and Epodes, translated by David West (1997)

Same day, other years

1660

A woman plays Desdemona on the London stage

Vere Street Theatre, LondonEurope

For as long as England had had professional theatres, women’s parts had been played by boys and young men. The theatres were closed by Parliament in 1642 and reopened when Charles II returned from exile in 1660, with a court that had spent years watching actresses in Paris. On 8 December the King’s Company staged Othello in a converted tennis court off Lincoln’s Inn Fields, and a special prologue by Thomas Jordan announced that the audience was about to see the first woman to act on the stage. It did not give her name. Two years later a royal patent required that women’s roles be played by women.

Seen from elsewhere. Her identity is unknown: Margaret Hughes is the traditional candidate and Anne Marshall the other. Puritan opinion, voiced earlier by William Prynne, held actresses to be no better than whores, and many early ones were treated accordingly by the men in the audience. Women had long acted in court masques, and professionally in Italy, Spain and France.

1941

Japan lands in Malaya, an hour before Pearl Harbor

Kota Bharu, MalayaAsia

Because of the date line, the first blow of Japan’s Pacific offensive fell on 8 December. Shortly after midnight local time, more than an hour before the bombs dropped on Hawaii, Japanese troops came ashore through heavy surf at Kota Bharu on the north-east coast of British Malaya, while others landed unopposed in southern Thailand. Before the day was out Singapore had been bombed, Hong Kong attacked, and American aircraft destroyed on the ground in the Philippines. General Yamashita’s army advanced six hundred miles down the peninsula in ten weeks, many of its men on bicycles, and took the surrender of Singapore and some 80,000 British, Indian and Australian troops on 15 February 1942.

Seen from elsewhere. Japan proclaimed Asia for the Asians, and some Malay and Indian nationalists at first welcomed the fall of the colonial power. For the Chinese of Singapore and Malaya it brought the Sook Ching screening, in which the Japanese army killed at least 5,000 people by its own admission and perhaps ten times as many by local estimates.

1982

Fifteen opponents of the regime are shot at Fort Zeelandia

Paramaribo, SurinameThe Americas

Suriname had been independent of the Netherlands for seven years and under military rule since a sergeants’ coup in 1980. In late 1982 trade unions, lawyers and students were pressing for a return to elections. In the early hours of 8 December soldiers took sixteen prominent critics from their beds to the old Dutch fort that served as army headquarters. Fifteen were shot over the following day: lawyers, journalists, university teachers, two army officers, a businessman and the union leader Cyrill Daal. The sixteenth, the union man Fred Derby, was released. Soldiers also burned down opposition radio stations and a newspaper office.

Seen from elsewhere. The commander, Desi Bouterse, said on television that the men had been shot while trying to escape after plotting a coup. He later accepted political responsibility but denied being present. Twice elected president, he was convicted in 2019 and sentenced to twenty years; when the sentence was upheld in 2023 he disappeared, and died in hiding a year later.

1987

A road crash in Gaza sets off the first intifada

Jabalia, Gaza StripMiddle East

On the afternoon of 8 December an Israeli army tank transporter collided with cars carrying Palestinian labourers home through the Erez crossing. Four were killed, three of them from the Jabalia refugee camp. Word spread that the crash was deliberate revenge for the stabbing of an Israeli in Gaza two days earlier. The funerals that evening turned into demonstrations, and the next morning soldiers shot dead a seventeen-year-old in the camp. Within days strikes, stone-throwing and barricades had spread across Gaza and the West Bank, twenty years into Israeli occupation. The uprising, called the intifada, the ‘shaking off’, lasted until the Oslo accord of 1993.

Seen from elsewhere. Israel said the crash was an accident and at first treated the unrest as riots to be put down by force. The Israeli rights group B’Tselem counts more than a thousand Palestinians killed by Israeli forces over six years and about 160 Israelis killed by Palestinians. Several hundred Palestinians were also killed by other Palestinians as suspected collaborators.

Also on 8 December