Parallax

5 December, 1791

Mozart dies with a Requiem unfinished on the bed

He was thirty-five, in debt, and writing a mass for the dead to an anonymous commission. Almost everything popularly believed about his end, from the poisoning to the pauper’s grave in a snowstorm, was added afterwards.

Rauhensteingasse, Vienna

Wolfgang Amade Mozart took to his bed on about 20 November 1791 in the first-floor apartment on the Rauhensteingasse that he shared with his wife Constanze and their two sons, one of them four months old. His hands and feet swelled until he could not turn over; his sister-in-law Sophie sewed him a nightshirt that could be put on from the front. He had a high fever and bouts of vomiting. His mind stayed clear. He followed performances of The Magic Flute, then playing across town, with a watch in his hand, and said that now the Queen of the Night would be singing her aria.

It had been an extraordinary year even for him. Since the spring he had written the last piano concerto, the clarinet concerto, the motet Ave verum corpus and two operas. La clemenza di Tito was composed in a matter of weeks for the coronation of Leopold II in Prague in September, where Mozart first felt ill. The Magic Flute opened in a suburban Vienna theatre on 30 September and was drawing full houses.

On the bed lay the score of a Requiem. In the summer a stranger had called with an unsigned letter commissioning a mass for the dead, paying half in advance and insisting that Mozart not try to learn the patron’s name. The patron was Count Franz von Walsegg, a landowner who liked to have works performed as his own and wanted one in memory of his young wife. Mozart did not know that. According to Constanze he came to believe that he was writing it for his own funeral.

On the afternoon of 4 December, by an account published years later, friends from the theatre gathered at the bedside to sing through what was written, Mozart taking the alto line. At the Lacrimosa he broke down and put the pages aside. That evening Sophie found him worse and ran for the doctor, Thomas Closset, who was at the theatre and would not leave until the piece was over. He ordered cold compresses on the burning forehead. Mozart lost consciousness. Sophie remembered that his last movement was an attempt to shape with his mouth the drum passage in the Requiem. He died at five minutes to one on the morning of Monday 5 December.

The funeral was held at St Stephen’s Cathedral a day or two later, and the body was taken by cart to the cemetery of St Marx outside the walls. Nobody followed it there, which was usual. He was buried in an ordinary shared grave, unmarked, which was also usual.

How it came to this

Mozart had been famous since he was six, when his father Leopold toured him around the courts of Europe as a prodigy. In 1781 he broke with his employer, the Archbishop of Salzburg, and settled in Vienna as a freelance, living on teaching, publishing, subscription concerts and opera commissions. For some years it paid very well. He married Constanze Weber in 1782; of their six children two survived infancy.

From about 1788 things grew harder. Austria’s war with the Ottomans emptied the concert rooms and scattered the aristocracy who paid for music. Mozart’s court post as chamber composer brought 800 florins a year, a respectable salary but well short of what the household spent, and his letters to his fellow Freemason Michael Puchberg begging for loans survive in a painful series. In November 1791 a court entered judgment against him for a debt of more than 1,400 florins owed to Prince Lichnowsky. Yet his earnings in that last year were high, the new opera was a success, and admirers in Hungary and Amsterdam had just offered him annuities. He died as his prospects were turning.

How each side saw it

Constanze Mozart

She was twenty-nine, with two small boys and debts. She had the Requiem finished in secret, first approaching Joseph Eybler and then Mozart’s assistant Franz Xaver Sussmayr, so that it could be delivered as her husband’s and the balance of the fee collected. She obtained a pension from the emperor, organised memorial concerts, sold the manuscripts and with her second husband, the Danish diplomat Georg Nissen, produced the first full biography. Nineteenth-century writers dismissed her as frivolous and blamed her for the absence from the burial. Recent scholarship regards her as the capable manager of his legacy, and notes that the unflattering portrait descends largely from Mozart’s father and sister.

Antonio Salieri

The court Kapellmeister was Mozart’s senior and sometime rival, but he had applauded The Magic Flute from Mozart’s own box that October and later taught Mozart’s younger son. A Berlin newspaper reported within weeks of the death that the swollen body made people suspect poison, and gossip settled on Salieri. In 1823, old and confused in hospital, he was rumoured to have accused himself; the composer Moscheles, who visited him, recorded that Salieri denied it on his word of honour. Pushkin’s short play of 1830, then Rimsky-Korsakov’s opera and Peter Shaffer’s Amadeus, fixed a guilt for which there is no evidence.

The doctors, then and now

The parish register gives the cause as ‘severe miliary fever’, a description of a rash and temperature, not a diagnosis. Closset and his colleague Sallaba apparently suspected nothing unnatural, and a Viennese physician who collected the evidence in 1824 called it a rheumatic inflammatory fever then epidemic in the city. Later proposals number well over a hundred, among them kidney failure, trichinosis from undercooked pork, and complications of a streptococcal infection, the last supported by a 2009 study of Vienna’s death records for that winter. The repeated bleedings prescribed in his last days may have hastened the end.

The Freemasons

Mozart had been a committed Mason since 1784, and his last completed work was a cantata for the opening of his lodge’s new rooms. His brethren held a lodge of mourning and printed the oration. In the nineteenth century a contrary story appeared, that the order had killed him for revealing its secrets in The Magic Flute. It was promoted in 1930s Germany by Mathilde Ludendorff, who added Jews and Jesuits to the plot. No contemporary source supports it, and the opera’s librettist, Emanuel Schikaneder, a Mason too, lived another twenty years.

What is disputed

The deathbed is known mainly from recollections written down more than thirty years on, above all Sophie’s letter of 1825, and details such as the bedside rehearsal rest on a single late report. Constanze told visitors in 1829 that Mozart had believed himself poisoned, which says something about his state of mind and little about the cause. The snowstorm that supposedly turned mourners back first appears in 1856; a diarist recorded mild, misty weather. The grave was the standard burial for a Viennese of his standing under the reforms of Joseph II, not a pauper’s pit. How much of the Requiem as performed is Mozart’s and how much Sussmayr’s is still argued bar by bar.

What followed

The completed Requiem was delivered to Walsegg, who duly conducted it as his own in 1793; Constanze had already kept a copy and arranged a performance for her benefit. When cemetery workers were asked in later decades where Mozart lay, no one could say, and the monument at St Marx stands on a guess. Within a generation he had been remade as the Romantic image of genius destroyed by an indifferent world. The music needed no legend. The Requiem was sung at the funerals of Haydn, Chopin, and, in 1840, at the reburial of Napoleon.

Read further

  • H. C. Robbins Landon, 1791: Mozart’s Last Year (1988)
  • Otto Erich Deutsch, Mozart: A Documentary Biography (1965)
  • William Stafford, The Mozart Myths: A Critical Reassessment (1991)
  • Christoph Wolff, Mozart’s Requiem: Historical and Analytical Studies, Documents, Score (1994)
  • Maynard Solomon, Mozart: A Life (1995)

Same day, other years

1484

A papal bull gives two inquisitors a free hand against witches

RomeEurope

Heinrich Kramer, a Dominican inquisitor working in southern Germany, had complained that local clergy and magistrates were obstructing his pursuit of witches. On 5 December 1484 Pope Innocent VIII obliged him with the bull Summis desiderantes affectibus. It declared that many people of both sexes in the German lands had given themselves to devils, blighting crops, killing infants in the womb and making men impotent, and it ordered that Kramer and his colleague Jakob Sprenger be allowed to proceed unhindered. Two years later Kramer printed the bull at the front of his manual for witch-hunters, the Malleus Maleficarum.

Seen from elsewhere. The bishop of Brixen, Georg Golser, stopped Kramer’s trials at Innsbruck in 1485, freed the accused women and described him as a senile old man. Historians stress that the bull invented no doctrine and that the worst hunts came a century later, mostly in secular courts, Protestant as well as Catholic. Some 40,000 to 60,000 people were executed in all.

1492

Columbus sights the island he will call Hispaniola

Windward Passage, between Cuba and HaitiThe Americas

After five weeks coasting Cuba, which he took for a province of Asia, Columbus left its eastern cape on 5 December and saw high land to the south-east. His Taino guides called it Bohio or Haiti. He anchored the next evening in a harbour he named for St Nicholas, whose feast it was, and soon named the whole island La Espanola because its fields reminded him of Castile. His journal praises the people as handsome, generous and unarmed, and adds that they would be easy to rule and to set to work. On Christmas Day the Santa Maria was wrecked there, and from her timbers he built Europe’s first settlement in the Americas.

Seen from elsewhere. The Taino left no written account; they are known through Columbus, and through the friar Bartolome de las Casas, who witnessed what followed. Estimates of the island’s population in 1492 range from a few hundred thousand to several million. A Spanish count in 1514 found about 26,000. Forced labour, killing, famine and imported disease had done the rest.

1934

Shots at the wells of Walwal

Walwal, Ogaden, EthiopiaAfrica

Walwal was a cluster of wells in the Ogaden desert, well inside Ethiopia on most maps, where Italy had quietly built a fort garrisoned by Somali irregulars. In November 1934 a British and Ethiopian boundary commission arrived with an escort of several hundred Ethiopian troops and found the way barred. The two forces faced each other for a fortnight. On the afternoon of 5 December firing began, and the Italians brought up armoured cars and aircraft. More than a hundred Ethiopians and several dozen of the Somali troops were killed. Mussolini demanded an apology and compensation; Haile Selassie took the matter to the League of Nations.

Seen from elsewhere. Italy maintained that the wells lay in Italian Somaliland and that Ethiopia had attacked. A League arbitration panel concluded in September 1935 that neither side was to blame, having been barred from ruling on whose land it was. Italian documents show Mussolini had ordered plans for conquest before the clash. Italy invaded on 3 October 1935.

2013

Nelson Mandela dies at ninety-five

Johannesburg, South AfricaAfrica

Mandela died at his home in the suburb of Houghton on the evening of 5 December after months of lung illness, a legacy of tuberculosis caught in prison. He had been a lawyer, a founder of the African National Congress’s armed wing, a prisoner for twenty-seven years, most of them on Robben Island, and from 1994 to 1999 the first president of South Africa chosen by all its people. He served one term and stepped down. Crowds sang outside the house through the night. Some ninety heads of state and government attended the memorial in Soweto, and he was buried at Qunu, the village of his childhood.

Seen from elsewhere. The tributes came from many who had once called him a terrorist; he remained on a United States watch list until 2008. A younger generation of South Africans argues that the settlement he negotiated ended white rule but left land and wealth largely where they were. He himself objected to being treated as a saint.

Also on 5 December