Parallax

2 December, 1859

John Brown rides to the gallows on his own coffin

Virginia hanged an old man for treason, murder and inciting slaves to revolt. He handed a note to a guard on the way out predicting that the country would pay in blood, and within eighteen months it did.

Charles Town, Virginia (now West Virginia), United States

A little before eleven on the morning of Friday 2 December 1859, John Brown came out of the jail at Charles Town with his arms tied at the elbows and climbed into a furniture wagon. He sat down on the box that held his coffin. On the way out he had handed one of his guards a slip of paper. ‘I John Brown am now quite certain that the crimes of this guilty land will never be purged away but with blood,’ it said. ‘I had as I now think vainly flattered myself that without very much bloodshed it might be done.’

Six weeks earlier, on the night of 16 October, Brown had led twenty-one men, five of them Black, across the Potomac into Harpers Ferry and seized the federal armoury. His plan was to arm the enslaved people of the district, withdraw into the Blue Ridge and wage a spreading guerrilla war on slavery from the mountains. He had brought a thousand pikes for the purpose. The rising did not come. The first man his raiders killed was Heyward Shepherd, a free Black baggage handler on the railway. By the next day the town’s militia had Brown penned in the armoury’s fire-engine house, and on the morning of the 18th a company of marines under Colonel Robert E. Lee battered in the door. Ten of the raiders died, among them two of Brown’s sons.

Virginia tried him within the week, while he lay wounded on a cot in the courtroom. He refused to let his lawyers plead insanity. Convicted on 2 November, he told the court that had he acted on behalf of the rich and powerful everyone present would have thought it worthy of reward, and that if he must mingle his blood with the blood of millions in the slave country, ‘I say, let it be done.’

Governor Henry Wise, fearing a rescue, ringed the field with some fifteen hundred soldiers and kept civilians away. Among the troops were the cadets of the Virginia Military Institute under a professor named Thomas Jackson, not yet called Stonewall, and in the ranks of a Richmond militia company an actor, John Wilkes Booth. Brown looked at the hills and remarked that it was beautiful country. He mounted the scaffold steadily, and stood hooded for some ten minutes while the troops were shuffled into position. He asked only that they be quick.

In the North church bells tolled at the hour and meetings were held in his honour. His widow took the body home to North Elba in the Adirondacks, where it was buried six days later beside a boulder on the farm.

How it came to this

Brown was born in Connecticut in 1800 into a strict Calvinist family and raised in Ohio. He failed at tanning, land speculation and the wool trade, fathered twenty children, and held, with unusual consistency for a white American of his day, that Black people were his equals; he lived for a time in a Black farming settlement in New York. After a pro-slavery mob murdered the abolitionist editor Elijah Lovejoy in 1837 he vowed in church to give his life to destroying slavery.

The occasion came in Kansas. An act of 1854 left it to settlers to decide whether the territory would allow slavery, and both sides sent armed men. In May 1856, days after pro-slavery forces sacked the town of Lawrence, Brown and a small party dragged five pro-slavery settlers from their cabins on Pottawatomie Creek at night and hacked them to death with broadswords. He then spent three years raising money and guns in New England, backed by six wealthy abolitionists who knew roughly what he intended. Frederick Douglass, who knew exactly, met him in a quarry three weeks before the raid and declined to come.

How each side saw it

Virginia and the white South

To slaveholders Harpers Ferry was their oldest fear made real: armed men come to put weapons in the hands of the enslaved, as in Haiti or Nat Turner’s revolt of 1831. Governor Wise, who interviewed Brown, called him cool and truthful, and hanged him as a murderer and traitor after a trial held in open court under Virginia law. What alarmed the South more than the raid was the tolling of Northern bells. The fire-eater Edmund Ruffin, who watched the execution, sent one of Brown’s pikes to each Southern governor as a sample of the favours intended for them. Militias drilled across the region that winter.

Black Americans

Frederick Douglass thought the plan a ‘perfect steel-trap’ and fled to Canada when it failed, but he never disowned the man. Speaking at Harpers Ferry in 1881 he said that his own zeal for the slave was as the taper light to Brown’s burning sun: ‘I could live for the slave, but he could die for him.’ Harriet Tubman, who helped recruit for the raid, held him the greatest white man she knew of. Black communities in Northern cities closed their businesses on the day of the hanging. W. E. B. Du Bois’s biography of 1909 concluded simply that John Brown was right.

The enslaved people of the district

They left no testimony of their own. Virginia’s officials insisted that not one slave had willingly joined, which was what owners needed to believe. Osborne Anderson, the one Black raider to escape, wrote in A Voice from Harper’s Ferry that local slaves came forward eagerly and that several fought. Modern historians lean towards a middle position: a number took up pikes or helped, most had no warning and no reason to trust armed strangers, and a rash of barn fires on the farms of Brown’s jurors in the following weeks suggests that people nearby had been paying attention.

Northern opinion

Republican politicians ran from him. Abraham Lincoln, at Cooper Union in February 1860, called the raid an absurd attempt by white men to get up a revolt among slaves in which the slaves refused to take part, and said that Brown’s thinking slavery wrong could not excuse violence, bloodshed and treason. William Lloyd Garrison, a pacifist, called it misguided and then honoured the man. Thoreau delivered a plea for him while he was still alive, and Emerson was reported as saying that Brown would make the gallows glorious like the cross. The reaction mattered to the South as much as the deed.

What is disputed

Whether Brown was sane was raised at once: affidavits listing insanity among his mother’s relatives were sent to Governor Wise, and historians from the 1940s often wrote of monomania. Stephen Oates and David Reynolds reject the diagnosis as a way of not hearing what he said. Whether he should be called a terrorist, because of Pottawatomie, or a freedom fighter remains a live argument. So does his competence: he lingered in the town until he was trapped, and some think that after the first hours he chose martyrdom. The story that he kissed a Black child on his way to the scaffold is legend, spread by a newspaper report and a poem by Whittier.

What followed

Six more raiders were hanged in the following months. The raid deepened Southern conviction that the Union could no longer protect slavery, and Lincoln’s election a year later brought secession. In 1861 Union soldiers marched to a song about John Brown’s body mouldering in the grave, to whose tune Julia Ward Howe wrote the ‘Battle Hymn of the Republic’. Robert E. Lee and Thomas Jackson commanded the armies of the Confederacy; Booth shot Lincoln. Brown is still claimed by people who agree on almost nothing else, from civil rights campaigners to those who attack abortion clinics.

Read further

  • David S. Reynolds, John Brown, Abolitionist (2005)
  • Stephen B. Oates, To Purge This Land with Blood: A Biography of John Brown (1970)
  • W. E. B. Du Bois, John Brown (1909)
  • Tony Horwitz, Midnight Rising: John Brown and the Raid That Sparked the Civil War (2011)
  • Osborne P. Anderson, A Voice from Harper’s Ferry (1861)

Same day, other years

1804

Napoleon puts the crown on his own head

Notre-Dame, ParisEurope

Eleven years after France beheaded its king, a Corsican artillery officer of thirty-five was consecrated Emperor of the French in Notre-Dame. Pope Pius VII had been brought from Rome to anoint him. When the moment came Napoleon took the crown from the altar and placed it on his own head, then crowned his wife Josephine, who knelt before him. The gesture was not a surprise sprung on the pope: it had been settled in negotiation beforehand. The ceremony lasted some three hours in a freezing cathedral, and Jacques-Louis David was commissioned to paint it, with flattering adjustments.

Seen from elsewhere. Republicans saw the Revolution buried; Beethoven is said by his pupil Ries to have torn up the dedication of a symphony on hearing of the title. Royalists saw a usurper. And he was not the year’s first emperor made by revolution: Jean-Jacques Dessalines, who had beaten Napoleon’s army, was crowned Emperor of Haiti in October.

1942

The first chain reaction, in a squash court

Chicago, United StatesThe Americas

Under the stands of a disused football stadium at the University of Chicago, a team led by the Italian physicist Enrico Fermi had stacked some 40,000 graphite blocks and several tonnes of uranium into a flattened sphere. On the afternoon of 2 December Fermi ordered the last cadmium control rod pulled out a few inches at a time, checking his slide rule at each step. At about 3.25 pm the neutron count kept climbing by itself: the first self-sustaining nuclear chain reaction made by human beings. It produced about half a watt. Fermi shut it down after some four and a half minutes, and someone opened a bottle of Chianti.

Seen from elsewhere. Leo Szilard, who had conceived the chain reaction in 1933 and helped build the pile, recalled shaking Fermi’s hand and saying the day would go down as a black one in the history of mankind. The pile had no shielding and stood in a city of three million; its builders judged the risk acceptable in wartime.

1956

The Granma runs aground in a Cuban mangrove swamp

Playa Las Coloradas, Oriente, CubaThe Americas

Eighty-two men had left the Mexican port of Tuxpan a week earlier in a leaking motor yacht built for a dozen. Their leader, Fidel Castro, had promised to be in Cuba, free or a martyr, before the end of 1956. The crossing took two days longer than planned, so the uprising in Santiago timed to cover the landing had already been crushed. At dawn on 2 December the Granma stuck in mud well short of the beach and the men waded ashore through mangroves, leaving most of their supplies. Three days later Batista’s army scattered them at Alegria de Pio.

Seen from elsewhere. The government announced that Castro was dead. The revolution’s own account says twelve survivors regrouped in the Sierra Maestra, a number with apostolic echoes; historians count nearer twenty. For Cubans who later fled, the date marks the start of a dictatorship rather than the end of one.

1971

Six sheikhdoms become the United Arab Emirates

Dubai, Trucial CoastMiddle East

Britain had run the foreign affairs and defence of the small Gulf sheikhdoms since the nineteenth century under a series of truces, which gave the coast its name. In 1968 London announced that it could no longer afford to stay. Three years of talks about a federation of nine followed; Bahrain and Qatar chose to go alone. On 2 December 1971, the day after the treaties lapsed, the rulers of Abu Dhabi, Dubai, Sharjah, Ajman, Umm al-Quwain and Fujairah met in Dubai and proclaimed a union, with Sheikh Zayed of Abu Dhabi as president. Ras al-Khaimah joined ten weeks later.

Seen from elsewhere. Two days before the union, Iran landed troops on Abu Musa and the two Tunb islands, which it regards as Iranian and the Emirates still claim. Arab nationalists saw Britain leaving behind client monarchies. The migrant workers who came to form most of the population have no path to citizenship.

Also on 2 December