Parallax

31 May, 1786

A cardinal is acquitted and a queen is condemned by it

After an eighteen-hour sitting, the judges of Paris cleared Cardinal de Rohan of stealing the most expensive necklace in Europe. Marie Antoinette, who had never seen the diamonds, was the real loser.

Paris, France

The judges of the Parlement of Paris took their seats at six in the morning on Wednesday 31 May 1786. Outside the Palais de Justice a crowd had been gathering since before dawn. Nineteen members of the Rohan family, dressed in mourning, stood in a line at the door and bowed to each magistrate as he entered. It was past nine at night when the result was announced. Cardinal Louis de Rohan, Grand Almoner of France, was discharged of every accusation, by 26 votes to 22 as the count is usually given. The crowd cheered him home and shouted for the Parlement.

He had been arrested nine months earlier in the most public manner possible: in his scarlet robes, on the feast of the Assumption, in the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles, on his way to say mass before the court. The king had just learned that the cardinal had bought, in the queen’s name, a necklace of 647 diamonds priced at 1,600,000 livres, that the jewellers had not been paid, and that the queen knew nothing about it.

The explanation was a confidence trick. Rohan had been out of favour with Marie Antoinette for years and was desperate to be forgiven. Jeanne de La Motte, an adventuress with a genuine but distant descent from the Valois kings, persuaded him that she was the queen’s intimate friend. She fed him forged letters signed ‘Marie Antoinette de France’, a form no queen used. One night in August 1784, in a grove in the palace gardens, she had him meet a veiled woman who handed him a rose and murmured a few words. The woman was Nicole Leguay, a young prostitute hired for her resemblance to the queen. When the supposed queen then asked him to buy the necklace discreetly on her behalf, he signed the contract and handed the case to a man he took for a royal valet. Jeanne’s husband sold the stones in London.

The Parlement’s other verdicts were less kind. Jeanne de La Motte was sentenced to be flogged, branded on both shoulders with a V for voleuse, thief, and shut up for life. The forger was banished. Leguay and the mystic Cagliostro, whom Jeanne had tried to implicate, were let go. On 21 June Jeanne was branded in the courtyard of the Palais; she fought so hard that the second iron landed on her breast.

At Versailles the acquittal was understood at once. Madame Campan, the queen’s lady-in-waiting, found her in tears. Louis XVI stripped Rohan of his court office and sent him to a remote abbey in the Auvergne, which made the king look vindictive and the queen look guilty.

How it came to this

The necklace had been assembled in the 1770s by the court jewellers Boehmer and Bassenge, who hoped Louis XV would buy it for Madame du Barry. He died first, and they were left owing a fortune for stones nobody could afford. They offered it to Marie Antoinette more than once and she refused. Rohan, meanwhile, belonged to one of the grandest houses in France and had been ambassador in Vienna, where his worldliness disgusted the queen’s mother, the Empress Maria Theresa. Marie Antoinette had not spoken to him since.

By 1785 the queen was already the target of an underground literature of songs and pamphlets that accused her of extravagance, of serving Austria and of affairs with both sexes. Louis XVI could have dealt with the cardinal privately. Angry on his wife’s behalf, he chose a public trial, and Rohan chose to be tried by the Parlement of Paris, a court of hereditary magistrates with a long record of resisting the crown. Printed briefs by the lawyers for each accused sold in tens of thousands and turned a fraud case into a national entertainment.

How each side saw it

Marie Antoinette and the court

The queen had done nothing but decline a necklace, and she wanted that established in public. In letters to her brother Joseph II she called the cardinal a vile and clumsy forger who had used her name to pay his debts. To her, the offence was that a prince of the Church had thought her capable of a midnight meeting and a secret purchase. Madame Campan’s memoirs record that she took the verdict as a personal insult from judges who hated the court. That Rohan had himself been deceived was a possibility the royal couple never seem to have accepted.

Rohan, his family and the judges

The cardinal’s lawyer, Target, argued that his client was the victim of a fraud so well staged that an honest man might have believed it, and that foolishness is not a crime. The Rohans and their allies treated the arrest of a prince-bishop in his vestments as an outrage against the nobility and the Church; the clergy of France formally protested. For many of the magistrates the case was a chance to show that the king’s displeasure could not convict a man. The crown’s prosecutor had asked that Rohan at least apologise and resign his office. The majority refused even that.

Jeanne de La Motte

Jeanne never admitted the fraud. At the trial she blamed Cagliostro and then the cardinal. After escaping from the Salpetriere prison in 1787 she reached London and published memoirs claiming that the queen had been Rohan’s lover and her own, had wanted the necklace all along, and had sacrificed her to cover it. The court tried to buy up the edition. She presented herself as a king’s descendant ruined by the great, and readers in 1789 were ready to believe her. She died in London in 1791 after a fall from a window, apparently while fleeing creditors.

The Paris public and later historians

Parisians followed the case through the lawyers’ printed briefs and took sides against Versailles. The assumption that a queen known for spending must somehow have been involved proved impossible to dislodge. Sarah Maza reads the affair as a moment when private scandal became a way of talking about despotism, with the public cast as judge. Others warn against hindsight: the monarchy’s bankruptcy, which forced the calling of the Estates General, owed nothing to diamonds. A remark attributed to Napoleon, that the queen’s death should be dated from this trial, is often quoted and poorly sourced.

What is disputed

Historians accept that the queen was innocent. Rohan is harder to read: most think him a dupe, but he had his papers burned on the day of his arrest, and what they contained is unknown. The vote is reported as 26 to 22 or 26 to 23 depending on the source. Whether Louis XVI erred in choosing a public trial is a judgment made with knowledge of 1789. Some popular accounts date the verdict to 31 May 1785; the arrest was in August 1785 and the verdict came on 31 May 1786.

What followed

Jeanne’s memoirs and their imitators supplied the pamphleteers of the Revolution with their picture of the queen, and the necklace was raised against Marie Antoinette at her own trial in October 1793. Rohan sat briefly in the Estates General, refused the revolutionary oath required of clergy and died across the Rhine in 1803. The jewellers were never paid in full and went bankrupt. Most of the diamonds were dispersed in London and have not been traced with certainty. Dumas made a novel of the story, and Carlyle a celebrated essay.

Read further

  • Frances Mossiker, The Queen’s Necklace (1961)
  • Jonathan Beckman, How to Ruin a Queen: Marie Antoinette, the Stolen Diamonds and the Scandal that Shook the French Throne (2014)
  • Sarah Maza, Private Lives and Public Affairs: The Causes Celebres of Prerevolutionary France (1993)
  • Madame Campan, Memoirs of the Private Life of Marie Antoinette (1823)
  • Antonia Fraser, Marie Antoinette: The Journey (2001)

Same day, other years

1902

The Boer republics sign away their independence

Pretoria, South AfricaAfrica

Sixty delegates of the Boer commandos, meeting in a tent at Vereeniging, voted by 54 to 6 on 31 May 1902 to accept British terms, and their leaders signed the treaty in Pretoria shortly before midnight. The war had lasted two years and eight months. Britain had put nearly 450,000 soldiers in the field, burned some thirty thousand farms and confined the civilian population in camps, where about 28,000 Boers died, most of them children, along with at least 14,000 and probably over 20,000 Black Africans held in separate camps. The Transvaal and Orange Free State became British colonies, with a promise of self-government and three million pounds for rebuilding.

Seen from elsewhere. The treaty put off any vote for Africans until after self-government, which in practice meant never. Black South Africans, many of whom had worked or fought for the British expecting better, were excluded from the Union formed in 1910. Among Afrikaners the camps and the ‘bitter-enders’ who had voted to fight on became the core of a nationalism that took power in 1948.

1921

A white mob destroys the Greenwood district of Tulsa

Tulsa, Oklahoma, United StatesThe Americas

On 31 May 1921 a Tulsa newspaper reported that a Black teenager, Dick Rowland, had been arrested for assaulting a white lift operator. By evening hundreds of white men had gathered at the courthouse where he was held. A group of armed Black men, several of them war veterans, came to offer the sheriff help in preventing a lynching. A shot was fired and fighting spread. Through the night and the next morning white crowds, some of them deputised by the police, invaded Greenwood, the prosperous Black quarter, and burned some thirty-five blocks. About ten thousand people were left homeless. Deaths were officially put at 36; a state commission in 2001 estimated between 75 and 300.

Seen from elsewhere. A grand jury at the time blamed the armed Black men who went to the courthouse, and no white rioter was convicted. Insurers refused claims. The event was left out of Oklahoma’s schoolbooks for decades and was called a riot, a word survivors’ families reject. A suit for reparations by the last survivors was dismissed by the state supreme court in 2024.

1970

An earthquake buries Yungay

Ancash, PeruThe Americas

At 3.23 on the afternoon of Sunday 31 May 1970 an earthquake of magnitude 7.9 struck off the coast of northern Peru. It shook loose a mass of ice and rock from the north peak of Huascaran, the country’s highest mountain, which fell and then ran down the valley at well over a hundred miles an hour. Within minutes it had covered the town of Yungay and much of neighbouring Ranrahirca. In Yungay only a few hundred people lived, among them children who had gone to a circus in the stadium and people who climbed the cemetery hill. Across the region about 70,000 died, the worst natural disaster recorded in the Americas up to that time.

Seen from elsewhere. Two American climbers had warned in 1962 that the glacier above Yungay was unstable, and by their account were pressed by the authorities to retract. The military government used the relief effort to advance its reforms and proposed moving survivors far away; they insisted on rebuilding close by. The buried town was declared a national cemetery and has never been excavated.

1981

The Jaffna Public Library is burned

Jaffna, Sri LankaAsia

On the night of 31 May 1981, during a tense local election campaign in northern Sri Lanka, policemen were shot at a rally of the main Tamil party in Jaffna. Police and paramilitaries brought in from the south then went on a rampage that lasted into the following nights. They burned the party’s office, a newspaper press, shops and the home of the local member of parliament. They also set fire to the Jaffna Public Library. It held about 97,000 volumes, including palm-leaf manuscripts and the only copies of some works of Tamil history. Almost all were lost. Senior government ministers were in the town at the time.

Seen from elsewhere. The government blamed policemen acting out of control and no one was tried. Tamils took the fire as an attack on their existence as a people, and many who later joined the armed movements named it as the reason. The library reopened in the 2000s, and in 2016 the prime minister, Ranil Wickremesinghe, apologised in parliament.

Also on 31 May