Parallax

2 May, 1519

Leonardo dies in France, far from his unfinished work

The painter of the Last Supper spent his final three years as the guest of a young French king. Whether that king was at the bedside when he died has been argued about for more than four centuries.

Clos Luce, Amboise, France

In the autumn of 1516 Leonardo da Vinci, aged sixty-four, crossed the Alps for the first and last time. He travelled with his pupil Francesco Melzi, his long-time companion Salai, and trunks that held his notebooks and at least three paintings he had never handed over to anyone: a Saint Anne, a Saint John the Baptist, and the portrait of a Florentine woman now called the Mona Lisa. Francis I of France, who was twenty-two and had recently conquered Milan, gave him the manor house of Cloux beside the royal castle of Amboise, a generous pension, and the title of first painter, engineer and architect to the king.

Little was asked of him. A cardinal’s secretary, Antonio de Beatis, who called at Cloux in October 1517, noted that a paralysis had affected the old man’s right hand, so that nothing more of real quality could be expected from his brush, though he could still draw and teach. Leonardo sketched a new palace and a canal scheme for the king at Romorantin, staged a court entertainment with a moving model of the heavens, and went on reordering notes on anatomy, water and geometry that he had been promising for decades to turn into books.

On 23 April 1519 he sent for a notary. His will asks for three high masses and thirty low ones, and for sixty poor men to carry tapers at his funeral. Melzi was to have all the books, drawings and instruments. Salai and a servant, Battista de Vilanis, shared a vineyard outside Milan. The cook, Mathurine, got a cloak of good black cloth lined with fur. His half-brothers in Florence, with whom he had fought a lawsuit, were left the money in his Florentine account.

He died on 2 May, aged sixty-seven. A generation later Giorgio Vasari described the scene: the king, who visited often, came into the room; Leonardo raised himself out of respect, spoke of his illness and said he had offended God and mankind by not working at his art as he should have; a seizure took him, and Francis held his head as he died.

Melzi wrote to the family in Florence on 1 June that Leonardo had been like the best of fathers to him, and that nature would not be able to make such a man again. He does not mention the king. The body was buried that August in the church of Saint-Florentin inside the castle walls. The church was pulled down in the early nineteenth century and the graves were disturbed. Bones dug up on the site in 1863 now lie in the castle’s chapel of Saint-Hubert under a stone that describes them, carefully, as the presumed remains.

How it came to this

Leonardo had lived on patrons all his adult life. Trained in Florence, he spent nearly two decades at the Sforza court in Milan as painter, stage designer and military engineer, and lost his place when the French drove the duke out in 1499. Years of wandering followed: Venice, Florence, a spell mapping fortresses for Cesare Borgia, Milan again under French governors, then Rome, where the Medici pope gave him rooms in the Vatican but few commissions while Michelangelo and Raphael took the great ones. He was known as a marvel who rarely finished anything.

Francis I had come to the throne in 1515 and within months won the battle of Marignano and with it Milan. He wanted Italian art and Italian artists to give his court the standing of those he had seen south of the Alps. A French king, by Vasari’s account, had already wanted the Last Supper cut from its wall and carried home. An ageing master with a famous name and no settled employer was exactly what he was looking for, and the offer seems to have been one of the few in Leonardo’s life that came with no deadline attached.

How each side saw it

Vasari and the Florentine account

Giorgio Vasari never met Leonardo and published his Lives in 1550, thirty-one years after the death. His deathbed scene serves his larger argument that great artists deserve the company of princes. It also carries a moral: in the first edition he wrote that Leonardo had held unorthodox ideas and thought himself more a philosopher than a Christian, a remark he cut in 1568, and the dying man is shown turning devoutly to the Church. Vasari gathered material from people who had known Melzi, so the story may go back to the household, but he gives no source for it.

Francesco Melzi

Melzi, a Milanese nobleman who had joined the studio as a boy, is the one witness whose words survive. His letter to Leonardo’s half-brothers speaks of grief and of a peaceful death with the sacraments of the Church, and says nothing of any royal visit, an odd omission if it happened. He took the notebooks home to his villa at Vaprio d’Adda and guarded them for fifty years, compiling from them the treatise on painting. After he died around 1570 his heirs let them go, and they were scattered, cut up and in part lost.

The French crown and French tradition

Benvenuto Cellini, who worked for Francis I in the 1540s, reports hearing the king say he did not believe any man had ever been born who knew as much as Leonardo. For France the story of the king cradling the dying genius became a national image, painted by Menageot in 1781 and Ingres in 1818, of a monarchy that honoured talent. It also underwrites possession. The paintings Leonardo brought to Amboise entered the royal collection, and the French state holds that they were lawfully acquired there.

Italian claims on the exile

Italians have long felt that Leonardo’s last pictures left the country only because his own cities failed to keep him. In 1911 Vincenzo Peruggia, an Italian workman, walked out of the Louvre with the Mona Lisa and said at his trial that he meant to return to Italy what Napoleon had stolen, though the painting had been in France since before Napoleon was born. Requests for its return, or its loan, recur. The dispute over Leonardo loans before the 2019 anniversary showed that the question of whom he belongs to is still alive.

What is disputed

The deathbed scene is the main issue. In the nineteenth century the scholar Leon de Laborde pointed to a royal act issued at Saint-Germain-en-Laye, some two days’ ride away, at the start of May 1519, which suggested Francis could not have been at Amboise. Defenders reply that such acts were issued by the chancellor in the king’s name and do not fix his whereabouts. Most biographers, including Charles Nicholl, think the story unproven and probably too good to be true. How the Mona Lisa passed to the crown is also unclear: a large payment to Salai in 1518 may record a sale. The identity of the Amboise bones has never been tested.

What followed

Leonardo published nothing in his lifetime. His studies of the heart, of flight and of fossils, which in several cases anticipated later science by centuries, sat unread in private hands until scholars began printing the notebooks in the 1880s, so they had almost no influence on the science they foreshadowed. His reputation rested for three hundred years on a handful of paintings and a ruined mural. The Mona Lisa, hung in a king’s bath suite at Fontainebleau and later in the Louvre, became the best-known painting in the world only after its theft made front pages in 1911.

Read further

  • Giorgio Vasari, Lives of the Artists (1550, revised 1568)
  • Charles Nicholl, Leonardo da Vinci: The Flights of the Mind (2004)
  • Martin Kemp, Leonardo da Vinci: The Marvellous Works of Nature and Man (1981)
  • Carmen C. Bambach, Leonardo da Vinci Rediscovered (2019)
  • Walter Isaacson, Leonardo da Vinci (2017)

Same day, other years

1808

Madrid rises against Napoleon’s army

Madrid, SpainEurope

French troops had entered Spain as allies and stayed as occupiers. When a crowd outside the royal palace tried to stop the youngest prince being taken away to France, Marshal Murat’s guns opened fire, and the city turned on the garrison with knives, tools and roof tiles. There was hand-to-hand fighting in the Puerta del Sol against Mameluke cavalry, and two artillery officers, Daoiz and Velarde, died holding the Monteleon barracks. By afternoon the rising was crushed. That night and the next morning the French shot hundreds of prisoners. Goya painted both days six years later, and the rising set off a war that lasted until 1814.

Seen from elsewhere. Murat reported a riot whipped up by priests and thought the executions had settled the matter. Some educated Spaniards, the afrancesados, backed the French-imposed king Joseph, who abolished the Inquisition and feudal dues. For them the patriots were defending absolutism, and the war that followed was partly a Spanish civil war.

1889

One treaty, two meanings, at Wuchale

Wuchale, EthiopiaAfrica

Menelik, king of Shewa and about to be crowned emperor of Ethiopia, signed a treaty of friendship with the Italian envoy Pietro Antonelli. It recognised Italian possession of the northern highlands that became Eritrea in return for money and rifles. The treaty existed in Amharic and Italian. Article 17 of the Amharic text said the emperor could, if he chose, use Italy’s services in dealing with other powers. The Italian text said he consented to do so, and Rome told Europe that Ethiopia was now its protectorate. Menelik protested, repudiated the treaty in 1893, and in March 1896 destroyed an Italian army at Adwa.

Seen from elsewhere. Italy’s government maintained that its version was binding and had been properly notified to the powers, most of which accepted it. Whether the difference was a deliberate trick by Antonelli, a translator’s slip or an ambiguity both sides preferred to leave alone is still argued. Eritreans note that the border drawn that day was agreed over their heads.

1982

A British submarine sinks the General Belgrano

South Atlantic, off the Falkland IslandsThe Americas

A month after Argentina seized the Falkland Islands, the nuclear submarine HMS Conqueror fired three torpedoes at the Argentine cruiser General Belgrano, an American-built veteran of Pearl Harbor. Two struck. The ship sank within the hour and 323 of her crew died, many of them conscripts, about half of all Argentine deaths in the war. The cruiser was outside the 200-mile exclusion zone Britain had declared around the islands and was steaming west at the time. The British war cabinet had changed the rules of engagement that day to allow the attack. The Argentine navy stayed in port for the remainder of the war.

Seen from elsewhere. Critics in Britain, led by the MP Tam Dalyell, argued the sinking was ordered to wreck a Peruvian peace plan. The government said the ship was a threat wherever it was. The cruiser’s captain, Hector Bonzo, and later the Argentine defence ministry accepted it as a lawful act of war, while many Argentine families regard it as a war crime.

2011

Osama bin Laden is killed in Abbottabad

Abbottabad, PakistanAsia

Shortly after one in the morning, American Navy commandos flown by helicopter from Afghanistan stormed a walled house less than a mile from Pakistan’s military academy. Inside they shot dead Osama bin Laden, founder of al-Qaeda and the man behind the attacks of 11 September 2001, along with one of his sons, two couriers and a woman. He had probably lived there for five years. The body was flown out and buried at sea within a day. President Obama announced the death late on 1 May, Washington time. Pakistan had not been told of the raid in advance.

Seen from elsewhere. Pakistan’s parliament condemned a violation of its sovereignty, and an official inquiry blamed its own agencies for failing either to find him or to detect the raid. Whether he could have been taken alive, and whether anyone in the Pakistani state knew he was there, remain disputed. No photograph of the body has been released.

Also on 2 May