Parallax

3 May, 1481

The conqueror of Constantinople dies on the march

Mehmed II had just led his army into Asia without telling anyone where it was going. A few days out he was dead at forty-nine, and Europe rang its bells.

Near Gebze, Anatolia (now Turkey)

In the last days of April 1481 the Ottoman sultan Mehmed II crossed the Bosphorus from Istanbul and joined the army assembled on the Asian shore. As was his habit he had told no one the objective. He is supposed to have said once that if a hair of his beard knew his plans he would pluck it out. The troops could only guess: Egypt, perhaps, or Rhodes, where his fleet had failed the year before, or a return to Italy, where an Ottoman force was holding the port of Otranto.

He was forty-nine and in poor health. He had grown very heavy, and gout had swollen his legs so badly that he had trouble riding. A day or two into the march he was seized with violent abdominal pain. His Persian physician, Lari, treated him without success. A second doctor, Yakub Pasha, an Italian-born Jew who had served him for decades, was brought in and is said to have judged that it was too late. On the afternoon of 3 May, at a camping ground near Gebze known afterwards as the Sultan’s Meadow, Mehmed died.

The grand vizier, Karamani Mehmed Pasha, tried to keep the death secret. The army was told the sultan was unwell and needed the baths, and the body was taken back to the capital in a closed carriage. Mehmed left two sons, both governing provinces deep in Anatolia: Bayezid at Amasya and the younger Cem at Konya. Whoever reached Istanbul first would probably rule. The vizier favoured Cem and tried to stop the troops from crossing back into the city.

It did not hold. The Janissaries learned the truth, seized boats, crossed the strait and killed the vizier, carrying his head through the streets on a lance. They then plundered Jewish and Christian quarters of the city. The riot ended only when Bayezid’s young son Korkud was set on the throne as a stand-in for his father. Bayezid arrived on 21 May, promised the soldiers a rise in pay, and buried his father beside the great mosque the Conqueror had built on the site of the Byzantine Church of the Holy Apostles.

The news took almost four weeks to reach Venice. From there it went to Rome, where Pope Sixtus IV ordered cannon fired from Castel Sant’Angelo, bells rung and three days of processions of thanksgiving. Nine months earlier, with the Turks ashore in Apulia, he had been considering flight to Avignon.

How it came to this

Mehmed came to the throne for good in 1451, aged nineteen, and two years later took Constantinople after a siege of fifty-three days, ending the eastern Roman empire and giving the Ottomans a capital that joined their European and Asian lands. He spent the next three decades almost continuously at war. Serbia, the Greek Morea, the empire of Trebizond, Bosnia and much of Albania were annexed; the Crimean khanate became a vassal; the Turkmen ruler Uzun Hasan was beaten in eastern Anatolia; and a sixteen-year war forced Venice to pay tribute. He failed at Belgrade in 1456 and at Rhodes in 1480.

He also rebuilt his capital, resettling it by force and by invitation with Muslims, Greeks, Armenians and Jews, and confirming a Greek patriarch in office. He read widely, employed Greek and Italian scholars, and sat for the Venetian painter Gentile Bellini. To pay for the wars he debased the silver coinage several times and took into state hands a great many estates that had belonged to pious foundations and old Muslim families. By 1481 the army was tired, the landed class resentful, and the succession between two adult sons unsettled.

How each side saw it

Ottoman chroniclers

Tursun Beg, a secretary who served on the campaigns, wrote a history that presents Mehmed as the model of a just and victorious ruler, the fulfilment of a saying attributed to the Prophet about the conquest of Constantinople. The dervish chronicler Asikpasazade is cooler. He blames the vizier Karamani Mehmed for the confiscation of endowment lands, speaks bitterly of the doctor Yakub, and voices the grievances of the frontier families and religious orders who felt that a centralising court had taken what their fathers had won. Both were written under Bayezid II, who reversed several of his father’s policies.

Greeks under the new empire

Two Greek contemporaries give opposite pictures. Kritovoulos of Imbros, who became an Ottoman governor, dedicated to Mehmed a history that treats him as a new Alexander and the legitimate emperor of the Romans. Doukas, who had served the Genoese of Lesbos, calls him a wild beast and the forerunner of Antichrist, and dwells on the enslavement of the people of Constantinople after its fall. The Orthodox Church, whose patriarch Gennadios Mehmed installed in 1454, kept its faith and its courts under the sultans, and its later tradition contains both gratitude for survival and mourning for the City.

Latin Christendom

In the West Mehmed was the Grand Turk, the terror of the world. Popes from Nicholas V to Sixtus IV preached crusades against him that the Christian powers were too divided to mount. The capture of Otranto in August 1480, and the killing there of about eight hundred men who by local tradition refused to convert, convinced many Italians that Rome was next. His death was greeted as a deliverance. A Venetian report is said to have announced it with the words ‘The great eagle is dead’, though the phrase is known only from later tellings.

Modern Turkey and modern historians

In Turkey he is Fatih, the Conqueror, a founding hero. The fall of Constantinople is celebrated every 29 May, and bridges, districts and a university carry his name. Historians divide on the man. Franz Babinger’s biography drew a brilliant, cruel and restless despot, relying heavily on hostile Western sources. Halil Inalcik answered in a long critical review that Babinger had neglected the Ottoman archives and the logic of Ottoman statecraft, and described instead the builder of a centralised empire with a deliberate legal and economic programme. Both portraits remain in circulation.

What is disputed

The cause of death is the oldest question. Rumours of poison began at once. Babinger thought it likely, and suggested Yakub Pasha had acted for Venice, which is known from its own archives to have backed more than a dozen plots to kill the sultan; others have pointed at Bayezid’s supporters. A cryptic verse in Asikpasazade is read as a hint. Most Ottomanists consider a natural death from long illness more probable, and nothing has been proved. The army’s destination is also unknown; Mamluk Syria and Egypt is the commonest guess. Some sources give 4 May. The so-called law of fratricide in his code is of debated authenticity.

What followed

Bayezid defeated Cem in battle that June. Cem fled to Egypt, then to the Knights of Rhodes, who shipped him to France and later handed him to the pope; Bayezid paid a large annual sum to keep him confined, and he died in Italy in 1495. With the brothers at war the Otranto garrison was not reinforced and surrendered in September 1481. Bayezid gave back many confiscated estates and is reported to have sold off his father’s Italian pictures. The state Mehmed had centralised, with Istanbul at its heart, lasted until 1922.

Read further

  • Franz Babinger, Mehmed the Conqueror and His Time, translated by Ralph Manheim (1978)
  • Kritovoulos, History of Mehmed the Conqueror, translated by Charles T. Riggs (1954)
  • Halil Inalcik, The Ottoman Empire: The Classical Age 1300-1600 (1973)
  • Colin Imber, The Ottoman Empire, 1300-1650: The Structure of Power (2002)
  • John Freely, The Grand Turk: Sultan Mehmet II (2009)

Same day, other years

1493

A pope grants Spain the lands across the ocean

RomeWorldwide

Less than two months after Columbus came back from his first voyage, Pope Alexander VI, the Valencian Rodrigo Borgia, issued the bull Inter caetera at the request of Ferdinand and Isabella. It granted the crowns of Castile and Aragon the islands and mainlands their envoys had found or might find, provided no Christian prince already held them, and charged them to bring the inhabitants to the Catholic faith. A further bull bearing the next day’s date drew a line from pole to pole a hundred leagues west of the Azores and Cape Verde islands. Spain and Portugal moved the line west by treaty at Tordesillas the following year.

Seen from elsewhere. None of the peoples concerned was consulted or knew. In the 1530s the Dominican Francisco de Vitoria argued that the pope had no power to give away the lands of non-Christians. The bulls were later cited in the legal ‘doctrine of discovery’, which the Vatican formally repudiated in 2023. Indigenous groups continue to ask that the bulls themselves be rescinded.

1791

Poland adopts a written constitution

Warsaw, PolandEurope

In a session at the Royal Castle, the parliament of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth adopted a Government Act, the first written national constitution in Europe and the second in the world after that of the United States. Its backers, among them King Stanislaw August and the reformers Hugo Kollataj and Ignacy Potocki, chose a day when many opponents were still away after Easter. The act ended the single-member veto that had paralysed the state, made the throne hereditary, gave townspeople new rights and placed the peasantry under the protection of the law without freeing them. It was in force for little more than a year.

Seen from elsewhere. Conservative magnates saw a coup against their ancient liberties and asked Catherine II of Russia to intervene; she called the reform a French contagion and sent an army. Poland was partitioned again in 1793 and erased in 1795. Some Lithuanian historians have regarded the act as weakening Lithuania’s separate standing, and serfs gained little from it.

1928

Chinese and Japanese troops clash at Jinan

Jinan, Shandong, ChinaAsia

Chiang Kai-shek’s Nationalist army, marching north to reunify China, entered the Shandong capital, where Japan had stationed troops on the grounds of protecting some two thousand Japanese residents. Shooting broke out on the morning of 3 May. During the fighting Japanese soldiers killed the Chinese negotiator Cai Gongshi and members of his staff. After an ultimatum, the Japanese army bombarded and stormed the walled city between 8 and 11 May. Chinese dead, soldiers and civilians, ran into the thousands. Japan held Jinan until March 1929, and Chiang had to route his advance around it.

Seen from elsewhere. Japanese accounts said Chinese soldiers had looted and murdered about a dozen Japanese civilians and that the army acted to protect its nationals. Chinese accounts describe unprovoked aggression meant to block unification. Who fired first has never been established, and casualty figures differ widely. Chiang began heading his diary entries with a vow to avenge the humiliation.

1947

Japan’s post-war constitution comes into force

Tokyo, JapanAsia

The constitution that still governs Japan took effect, replacing the Meiji charter of 1889. The emperor, formerly sovereign and sacred, became the symbol of the state with no powers of government. Women gained the vote and legal equality. Article 9 renounced war as a sovereign right and the maintenance of armed forces. The first draft had been written in English in about a week in February 1946 by staff at General MacArthur’s headquarters, after he rejected a cautious Japanese revision. Among the drafters was Beate Sirota, aged twenty-two, who wrote the equality clauses. The Diet debated and amended the text before adopting it.

Seen from elsewhere. Japanese conservatives have long called it an imposed constitution written by an occupier, and the governing Liberal Democratic Party has sought revision since 1955. Defenders reply that the public embraced it and that it has never once been amended. Who first proposed Article 9, MacArthur or the prime minister Shidehara Kijuro, remains uncertain.

Also on 3 May