Parallax

4 May, 1891

The day Sherlock Holmes was thrown off a waterfall

It never happened: 4 May 1891 is the date a tired author chose for the death of a character he had come to resent. What his readers did next was real, and new.

Reichenbach Falls, Meiringen, Switzerland

The event belongs to fiction, and the date is the one its author gave it. In ‘The Final Problem’, Dr Watson relates that his friend Sherlock Holmes spent the spring of 1891 closing a net around Professor Moriarty, a mathematician who secretly ran half the crime in London. With the professor’s gang about to be arrested and the professor himself at large, Holmes and Watson slipped across to the Continent and wandered up the Rhone valley and over the Gemmi Pass to the village of Meiringen in the Bernese Oberland.

On the afternoon of 4 May they walked up to see the Reichenbach Falls. A Swiss boy ran after them with a note asking the doctor to come back to the hotel for a dying Englishwoman. It was a ruse. When Watson returned to the falls he found Holmes’s alpenstock leaning on a rock, a farewell letter weighted down by a silver cigarette case, and two lines of footprints leading to the edge of the chasm, with none coming back.

The man who wrote this was Arthur Conan Doyle, a thirty-four-year-old doctor turned author. The short Holmes stories he had been writing for the Strand Magazine since July 1891 had made him famous and well off, and he thought them a distraction. In November 1891 he told his mother he was thinking of slaying Holmes, who took his mind from better things, by which he meant his historical novels. She told him he must not. In 1893 he visited the Reichenbach Falls on a Swiss holiday with his wife Louise and found a place fit for the purpose. His notebook entry on finishing the story read simply: ‘Killed Holmes.’

It appeared in the Strand in December 1893. Readers wrote in protest by the sackful; one woman, Conan Doyle recalled in his memoirs, began her letter ‘You brute’. The magazine is said to have lost twenty thousand subscribers. Its proprietor, George Newnes, spoke of the affair to his shareholders as a dreadful event.

Conan Doyle held out for eight years. In 1901 he wrote The Hound of the Baskervilles, taking care to set it before the fall. Then American and British publishers offered sums he could not sensibly refuse, and in ‘The Empty House’, published in the autumn of 1903, Holmes walked into Watson’s consulting room disguised as an old bookseller and explained that he had never gone over the edge at all. He went on appearing in new stories until 1927.

How it came to this

The detective story was about fifty years old. Edgar Allan Poe had invented the brilliant amateur reasoner in the 1840s, and Emile Gaboriau in France and Wilkie Collins in England had built on him. Conan Doyle, a struggling doctor in Southsea, added a method borrowed from his Edinburgh teacher Joseph Bell, who could tell a patient’s trade and travels from his hands and boots. The first two Holmes novels, in 1887 and 1890, sold modestly.

What changed things was a format. The Strand, launched in 1891 for the new mass readership of commuters and clerks, wanted fiction in every issue. Conan Doyle saw that a serial lost any reader who missed an instalment, whereas a run of complete stories about the same character would bring readers back without punishing them. With Sidney Paget’s illustrations supplying the gaunt profile, the formula made the character more vivid to many readers than his author. Letters addressed to Holmes arrived asking him to take cases. Conan Doyle, who wanted to be remembered as a second Walter Scott, found himself the proprietor of a figure he could not control.

How each side saw it

Arthur Conan Doyle

In Memories and Adventures, his autobiography of 1924, Conan Doyle says he had decided that Holmes was keeping him from higher work and that he was amazed by the concern the public showed at the death. He was unrepentant, and compared the act to justifiable homicide in self-defence. The months in which he wrote the story were hard ones: his father died in an asylum in October 1893 and his wife was diagnosed with tuberculosis. He always maintained that The White Company and his other historical novels were his real achievement, a verdict almost no reader has shared.

Readers and the magazine

For the Strand the stories were the reason many people bought the magazine, and queues at bookstalls on publication day were reported. Readers who wrote to complain treated the death as a personal loss and the author as answerable to them. This was something new in the relationship between a writer and a mass public: the sense that a character belonged to the audience. Later campaigns by fans to reverse an author’s or a studio’s decision have an early model here. No letters from the 1893 postbag are known to survive, so the reaction is known mainly through Conan Doyle and the Strand’s staff.

The Sherlockians

Since Ronald Knox’s mock-scholarly essay of 1911, enthusiasts have played what they call the Game: the pretence that Holmes and Watson lived, that Watson wrote the accounts, and that Conan Doyle was merely his literary agent. Within the Game, 4 May 1891 is a real date, and the three years that follow are the Great Hiatus, a field for theories. Some hold that Holmes did die at the falls and the later stories concern an impostor, citing their weaker quality. Others argue Moriarty never existed outside Holmes’s mind. Societies in many countries mark the anniversary.

Meiringen

The village that Conan Doyle chose as a scene of death has made the association its living. A plaque marks the ledge above the falls, reached by a funicular; a bronze Holmes sits in the square named after Conan Doyle; and a museum opened in 1991 in the basement of the former English church, with a reconstruction of the Baker Street sitting room. The town made Holmes an honorary citizen. The real Meiringen of 1891 had other concerns: most of the village burned down in a fire that October.

What is disputed

Several details of the legend are shaky. The figure of twenty thousand cancelled subscriptions comes from later recollection at the Strand, not from audited records. The often-repeated story that young men in the City of London wore black crape bands in mourning has no known source from the time and is probably an embellishment. Who suggested the method is contested: the novelist Silas Hocking claimed he proposed dropping Holmes down a crevasse during an Alpine walk with Conan Doyle in 1893. Whether the author left the body unfound on purpose, to keep a way back, is also argued. Candidates for a real Moriarty include the master thief Adam Worth.

What followed

Holmes returned for three more collections and a novel, sixty adventures in all. Conan Doyle was knighted in 1902, officially for a pamphlet defending Britain’s conduct in the Boer War, and gave his last years and much of his fortune to spiritualism. The character has since been played on stage, film and television more often than almost any other, and the return from Reichenbach became a stock device: the hero whose death is shown without a body. The episode is studied today as an early case of an audience overruling an author.

Read further

  • Arthur Conan Doyle, ‘The Final Problem’, in The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes (1894)
  • Arthur Conan Doyle, Memories and Adventures (1924)
  • Daniel Stashower, Teller of Tales: The Life of Arthur Conan Doyle (1999)
  • Andrew Lycett, Conan Doyle: The Man Who Created Sherlock Holmes (2007)
  • Jon Lellenberg, Daniel Stashower and Charles Foley (eds), Arthur Conan Doyle: A Life in Letters (2007)

Same day, other years

1799

Tipu Sultan dies in the breach at Seringapatam

Srirangapatna, Mysore, IndiaAsia

After a month’s siege, East India Company troops and their allies from Hyderabad stormed the island capital of Mysore at one in the afternoon, when the defenders were expected to be resting from the heat. The assault was led by David Baird, who had once spent nearly four years as a prisoner in the city. Tipu Sultan, who had fought the British in three previous wars, used rockets against them and sought an alliance with France, was shot down in the fighting at a gateway and found that night under a heap of bodies. The city was sacked. His treasury, his library and a mechanical tiger mauling a European were carried off to Britain.

Seen from elsewhere. British writers of the time drew a cruel fanatic. Indian nationalists later honoured him as the ruler who died resisting the Company. In Kodagu, Malabar and Mangalore he is remembered for forced conversions and deportations of Hindus and Christians, and official celebrations of his birthday in Karnataka were cancelled in 2019. Historians warn that each picture leaves out half the evidence.

1919

Students march in Beijing against the peace terms

Beijing, ChinaAsia

News had arrived that the peacemakers at Paris intended to hand Germany’s former rights in Shandong province to Japan and not back to China, which had sent well over a hundred thousand labourers to the Western Front. About three thousand students from Peking University and other colleges gathered at the Gate of Heavenly Peace and marched towards the foreign legations. Turned back, they went to the house of a minister regarded as pro-Japanese and set it alight. Arrests followed, then strikes and boycotts across the country. In June the Chinese delegation refused to sign the Treaty of Versailles. The protest gave its name to a wider movement for science, democracy and writing in everyday language.

Seen from elsewhere. The Communist Party, founded two years later by men prominent in the movement, claims May Fourth as its origin; the student protesters of 1989 invoked the same date against the Party. Cultural conservatives blame the movement for an assault on Confucian tradition. Japan held that Beijing had agreed to its Shandong claims in exchanges of 1915 and 1918.

1970

National Guardsmen fire on students at Kent State

Kent, Ohio, United StatesThe Americas

Four days after President Nixon announced that American troops had entered Cambodia, and two days after the university’s officer training building was burned down, Ohio National Guardsmen broke up a midday rally on the campus with tear gas. At the top of a hill a group of them turned and fired more than sixty rounds in thirteen seconds. Four students were killed: Allison Krause, Jeffrey Miller, Sandra Scheuer and William Schroeder. Nine were wounded, one paralysed for life. Two of the dead had been walking to class. Hundreds of colleges closed in the student strike that followed.

Seen from elsewhere. Guardsmen said they had been pelted with stones and feared for their lives; a presidential commission judged the shooting unnecessary, unwarranted and inexcusable. Polls at the time found that most Americans blamed the students. Criminal charges against eight guardsmen were dismissed in 1974, and whether anyone gave an order to fire has never been settled.

1978

South African forces attack Cassinga

Cassinga, AngolaAfrica

South African aircraft bombed, and paratroopers then assaulted, a camp run by the Namibian liberation movement SWAPO at a former mining town about 250 kilometres inside Angola. Around six hundred people in the camp were killed, a large number of them women and children, and hundreds more wounded. A Cuban armoured column that came to help from a nearby base was caught by air attack on the road and lost men as well. The paratroopers were flown out by helicopter the same afternoon. It was the largest single loss of Namibian lives in the long war over South African rule of the territory.

Seen from elsewhere. South Africa described a legitimate strike on the headquarters and training base of SWAPO’s army. SWAPO and the United Nations called it a massacre of refugees. South Africa’s Truth and Reconciliation Commission later concluded that the camp held both fighters and civilians and that the raid breached humanitarian law. Namibia keeps 4 May as Cassinga Day.

Also on 4 May