The event belongs to fiction, and the date is the one its author gave it. In ‘The Final Problem’, Dr Watson relates that his friend Sherlock Holmes spent the spring of 1891 closing a net around Professor Moriarty, a mathematician who secretly ran half the crime in London. With the professor’s gang about to be arrested and the professor himself at large, Holmes and Watson slipped across to the Continent and wandered up the Rhone valley and over the Gemmi Pass to the village of Meiringen in the Bernese Oberland.
On the afternoon of 4 May they walked up to see the Reichenbach Falls. A Swiss boy ran after them with a note asking the doctor to come back to the hotel for a dying Englishwoman. It was a ruse. When Watson returned to the falls he found Holmes’s alpenstock leaning on a rock, a farewell letter weighted down by a silver cigarette case, and two lines of footprints leading to the edge of the chasm, with none coming back.
The man who wrote this was Arthur Conan Doyle, a thirty-four-year-old doctor turned author. The short Holmes stories he had been writing for the Strand Magazine since July 1891 had made him famous and well off, and he thought them a distraction. In November 1891 he told his mother he was thinking of slaying Holmes, who took his mind from better things, by which he meant his historical novels. She told him he must not. In 1893 he visited the Reichenbach Falls on a Swiss holiday with his wife Louise and found a place fit for the purpose. His notebook entry on finishing the story read simply: ‘Killed Holmes.’
It appeared in the Strand in December 1893. Readers wrote in protest by the sackful; one woman, Conan Doyle recalled in his memoirs, began her letter ‘You brute’. The magazine is said to have lost twenty thousand subscribers. Its proprietor, George Newnes, spoke of the affair to his shareholders as a dreadful event.
Conan Doyle held out for eight years. In 1901 he wrote The Hound of the Baskervilles, taking care to set it before the fall. Then American and British publishers offered sums he could not sensibly refuse, and in ‘The Empty House’, published in the autumn of 1903, Holmes walked into Watson’s consulting room disguised as an old bookseller and explained that he had never gone over the edge at all. He went on appearing in new stories until 1927.
How it came to this
The detective story was about fifty years old. Edgar Allan Poe had invented the brilliant amateur reasoner in the 1840s, and Emile Gaboriau in France and Wilkie Collins in England had built on him. Conan Doyle, a struggling doctor in Southsea, added a method borrowed from his Edinburgh teacher Joseph Bell, who could tell a patient’s trade and travels from his hands and boots. The first two Holmes novels, in 1887 and 1890, sold modestly.
What changed things was a format. The Strand, launched in 1891 for the new mass readership of commuters and clerks, wanted fiction in every issue. Conan Doyle saw that a serial lost any reader who missed an instalment, whereas a run of complete stories about the same character would bring readers back without punishing them. With Sidney Paget’s illustrations supplying the gaunt profile, the formula made the character more vivid to many readers than his author. Letters addressed to Holmes arrived asking him to take cases. Conan Doyle, who wanted to be remembered as a second Walter Scott, found himself the proprietor of a figure he could not control.