Parallax

25 May, 1895

Oscar Wilde is sentenced to two years’ hard labour

Three months after the first night of The Importance of Being Earnest, the most celebrated playwright in London stood in the dock of the Old Bailey and heard a judge call his the worst case he had ever tried.

Old Bailey, London, England

The jury at the Central Criminal Court retired on the afternoon of Saturday 25 May 1895 and came back within a few hours. They found Oscar Wilde guilty on all but one of the counts of gross indecency put to them. Mr Justice Wills did not hide his feelings. He said it was useless to address men who must be dead to all sense of shame, that this was the worst case he had ever tried, and that the heaviest sentence the law allowed, two years’ imprisonment with hard labour, was in his view wholly inadequate. There were cries of ‘Shame’ from the public benches. Wilde, grey in the face, was heard to say, ‘And I? May I say nothing, my lord?’ The judge waved the warders to take him down.

It was the third trial in eight weeks, and the first of them had been Wilde’s own doing. On 18 February the Marquess of Queensberry, father of Wilde’s lover Lord Alfred Douglas, had left a card at the Albemarle Club addressed to ‘Oscar Wilde posing somdomite’, the spelling being his own. Urged on by Douglas, who hated his father, Wilde prosecuted Queensberry for criminal libel. Queensberry pleaded that the words were true and published for the public good, and his detectives went looking for proof.

They found it among the young men, some of them professional blackmailers, whom Wilde had met through a procurer named Alfred Taylor. In the witness box on 3 and 4 April Wilde was brilliant about literature and then, under Edward Carson’s cross-examination, careless about a servant boy he said he had not kissed because he was too ugly. When Carson announced that he would call the young men themselves, Wilde’s counsel withdrew the case. That evening he was arrested at the Cadogan Hotel.

A first criminal trial ended on 1 May with the jury unable to agree. It was there, asked about a line in one of Douglas’s poems, that Wilde made his speech on ‘the love that dare not speak its name’, which drew applause from the gallery. Released on bail, he was pressed by friends to cross to France, as Douglas already had. He stayed. The Crown tried again, this time with the Solicitor General, Sir Frank Lockwood, leading in person.

Wilde was taken to Pentonville, then Wandsworth, and in November to Reading Gaol, where he was prisoner C.3.3. His plays had already come off the London stage, or stayed on with his name pasted over. His house in Tite Street had been stripped by the bailiffs to pay Queensberry’s costs. His wife Constance took their two sons abroad and changed the family name to Holland.

How it came to this

The law under which Wilde was convicted was ten years old. Section 11 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act 1885, added late at night by the radical MP Henry Labouchere to a bill about the protection of girls, made any act of ‘gross indecency’ between men an offence, in public or in private, punishable by up to two years with hard labour. Sodomy itself had been a capital crime until 1861 but was difficult to prove. The new clause needed far less evidence, and lawyers soon called it a blackmailer’s charter.

Wilde was forty and at the height of his success, with two comedies running in the West End at once. He had been married since 1884. He met Lord Alfred Douglas, sixteen years his junior, in 1891, and through him and others entered a world of hotel suppers with clerks, grooms and rent boys, paid for with cigarette cases and cash. Queensberry, a violent and litigious man best known for lending his name to the rules of boxing, had already lost his eldest son in a shooting in 1894 and had pursued Wilde for months, at one point arriving at a first night with a bouquet of vegetables.

How each side saw it

Oscar Wilde

In the long prison letter to Douglas later published as De Profundis, Wilde blamed himself less for his conduct than for the lawsuit. He wrote that he had let himself be drawn into a quarrel between a father and son who loathed each other, and had gone to the law for protection from a society whose laws he had spent his life mocking. He did not accept that his love for men was a vice. After his release he wrote to the Home Secretary and the Daily Chronicle about the treatment of children and the mentally ill in English prisons, the cause to which his last published work, The Ballad of Reading Gaol, belongs.

The Marquess of Queensberry

Queensberry presented himself, in letters to his family and in his plea of justification, as a father trying to rescue a son from a corrupter. He claimed no quarrel with Wilde’s writing except as evidence of his influence on the young. Much of the press agreed with him in the spring of 1895 and he was cheered outside the court. His own family did not: his son Percy stood surety for Wilde’s bail, and father and son came to blows in Piccadilly during the trials. Douglas maintained all his life that his father’s motive was hatred of his own children.

The Crown and the press

For the prosecution the case was about a rich man in his forties using money and position to corrupt youths of the servant class, some of them under twenty, and the evidence of hotel staff put it beyond argument. Newspapers such as the Daily Telegraph welcomed the verdict as the end of the ‘aesthetic’ cult. A minority dissented at the time. W. T. Stead observed that had Wilde ruined girls instead of consorting with boys, no one would have laid a finger on him, and the Reverend Stewart Headlam, who barely knew him, went bail on the grounds that he had been condemned before he was tried.

Later readers

The twentieth century turned Wilde into the best known victim of the laws against homosexuality, and campaigners for their repeal used his name freely. Some recent historians, among them Michael Foldy, set the trials in the politics of 1895 and the fears of a governing class. Others point out that the modern picture leaves out the witnesses: working-class teenagers and young men, paid for sex and then paid again by Queensberry’s agents and maintained by the Crown, who had no voice in the matter beyond their depositions and who vanished from the record once the verdict was in.

What is disputed

Whether the government pressed the second trial to protect itself is still argued. Queensberry had hinted at a connection between his dead eldest son and the Prime Minister, Lord Rosebery, and some biographers think the Solicitor General led the case to show that nothing was being hushed up; the evidence is circumstantial. The wording of Queensberry’s card is itself uncertain, since his handwriting can be read more than one way. The story that Carson asked Lockwood to ‘let up on the fellow’ comes from later memoirs. Reports of women dancing in the street outside the court rest on a few press and memoir accounts.

What followed

Wilde served every day of the sentence and was released on 19 May 1897. He left for France the same night and never returned, living under the name Sebastian Melmoth. Constance died in 1898 and he did not see his sons again. He died in a Paris hotel on 30 November 1900, aged 46. The Labouchere clause convicted men in England and Wales until 1967, Alan Turing among them. In 2017 an Act of Parliament granted posthumous pardons to those convicted under it for acts no longer criminal, which is generally understood to include Wilde.

Read further

  • Richard Ellmann, Oscar Wilde (1987)
  • Merlin Holland, Irish Peacock and Scarlet Marquess: The Real Trial of Oscar Wilde (2003)
  • H. Montgomery Hyde, The Trials of Oscar Wilde (1948)
  • Michael S. Foldy, The Trials of Oscar Wilde: Deviance, Morality, and Late-Victorian Society (1997)
  • Oscar Wilde, De Profundis (written 1897)

Same day, other years

1085

Toledo passes from Muslim to Christian rule

Toledo, SpainEurope

Alfonso VI of Leon and Castile rode into Toledo on 25 May 1085, after a long blockade and a negotiated surrender by its ruler al-Qadir. The city had been the Visigothic capital before the Muslim conquest of 711 and was the first great city of al-Andalus to fall to a Christian king. The terms promised its Muslims their property and their chief mosque. Within a couple of years the mosque had been consecrated as a cathedral under a French archbishop. Toledo kept its Arabic-speaking Christians, its Jews and many Muslims, and in the next century became the place where Arabic science and philosophy were put into Latin.

Seen from elsewhere. For the Muslim rulers of the other Andalusi kingdoms the loss was a catastrophe that left them a choice between Alfonso and the Almoravids of Morocco. They called in the Almoravids, who beat Alfonso at Zallaqa in 1086 and then deposed their hosts. Arabic poets wrote laments for the city; the taking of the mosque was remembered as a broken oath.

1810

Buenos Aires removes its viceroy

Buenos Aires, Viceroyalty of the Rio de la PlataThe Americas

News that Napoleon’s armies had overrun most of Spain reached Buenos Aires in mid May 1810. An open meeting of leading citizens on 22 May argued that with the king a prisoner, authority had returned to the people. On 25 May, with militia and a crowd in the square outside the town hall in the rain, the viceroy Baltasar Hidalgo de Cisneros was replaced by a governing junta under the militia commander Cornelio Saavedra. It swore to rule in the name of the captive Ferdinand VII. Argentina dates its nationhood from that day, although independence was not declared until 1816.

Seen from elsewhere. Cordoba, Montevideo, Paraguay and Upper Peru refused to obey Buenos Aires, and the junta had the former viceroy Santiago de Liniers shot. Historians still dispute whether the oath to Ferdinand was sincere or a mask, and how many people actually stood in the square. For Indigenous peoples and the enslaved, the change of government altered little at first.

1963

Independent Africa founds a continental organisation

Addis Ababa, EthiopiaAfrica

Leaders of 32 independent African states, meeting in Addis Ababa as guests of Emperor Haile Selassie, signed the charter of the Organisation of African Unity on 25 May 1963. It committed them to end colonial and white minority rule on the continent, and a liberation committee based in Dar es Salaam channelled aid to movements fighting in the Portuguese colonies, Rhodesia and South Africa. The charter also bound members to respect one another’s sovereignty, and a resolution the following year accepted the frontiers inherited from the colonial powers. The date is kept as Africa Day. The organisation was replaced by the African Union in 2002.

Seen from elsewhere. Kwame Nkrumah of Ghana had wanted a union government with a common army and thought the charter a defeat. Critics, including Julius Nyerere, later complained that non-interference had made the body a club that protected heads of state while it stayed silent on Idi Amin, Biafra and Burundi. Defenders answer that it kept border wars few.

2020

George Floyd dies under a policeman’s knee

Minneapolis, Minnesota, United StatesThe Americas

Police in Minneapolis were called on the evening of 25 May 2020 to a shop where a man was said to have paid with a forged twenty-dollar note. George Floyd, a 46-year-old Black man, was handcuffed and held face down in the street while officer Derek Chauvin knelt on his neck for about nine and a half minutes, as Floyd said repeatedly that he could not breathe. A seventeen-year-old passer-by, Darnella Frazier, filmed it. Protests followed in more than two thousand American towns and cities and in dozens of other countries. Chauvin was convicted of murder in April 2021 and sentenced to twenty-two and a half years.

Seen from elsewhere. Chauvin’s defence argued that heart disease and drugs in Floyd’s system caused the death and that the restraint followed training; the jury and the medical examiners called by the state rejected this. The first police statement had described only a ‘medical incident’. Some of the protests turned to arson and looting, and Americans remain divided over what the summer achieved.

Also on 25 May