The jury at the Central Criminal Court retired on the afternoon of Saturday 25 May 1895 and came back within a few hours. They found Oscar Wilde guilty on all but one of the counts of gross indecency put to them. Mr Justice Wills did not hide his feelings. He said it was useless to address men who must be dead to all sense of shame, that this was the worst case he had ever tried, and that the heaviest sentence the law allowed, two years’ imprisonment with hard labour, was in his view wholly inadequate. There were cries of ‘Shame’ from the public benches. Wilde, grey in the face, was heard to say, ‘And I? May I say nothing, my lord?’ The judge waved the warders to take him down.
It was the third trial in eight weeks, and the first of them had been Wilde’s own doing. On 18 February the Marquess of Queensberry, father of Wilde’s lover Lord Alfred Douglas, had left a card at the Albemarle Club addressed to ‘Oscar Wilde posing somdomite’, the spelling being his own. Urged on by Douglas, who hated his father, Wilde prosecuted Queensberry for criminal libel. Queensberry pleaded that the words were true and published for the public good, and his detectives went looking for proof.
They found it among the young men, some of them professional blackmailers, whom Wilde had met through a procurer named Alfred Taylor. In the witness box on 3 and 4 April Wilde was brilliant about literature and then, under Edward Carson’s cross-examination, careless about a servant boy he said he had not kissed because he was too ugly. When Carson announced that he would call the young men themselves, Wilde’s counsel withdrew the case. That evening he was arrested at the Cadogan Hotel.
A first criminal trial ended on 1 May with the jury unable to agree. It was there, asked about a line in one of Douglas’s poems, that Wilde made his speech on ‘the love that dare not speak its name’, which drew applause from the gallery. Released on bail, he was pressed by friends to cross to France, as Douglas already had. He stayed. The Crown tried again, this time with the Solicitor General, Sir Frank Lockwood, leading in person.
Wilde was taken to Pentonville, then Wandsworth, and in November to Reading Gaol, where he was prisoner C.3.3. His plays had already come off the London stage, or stayed on with his name pasted over. His house in Tite Street had been stripped by the bailiffs to pay Queensberry’s costs. His wife Constance took their two sons abroad and changed the family name to Holland.
How it came to this
The law under which Wilde was convicted was ten years old. Section 11 of the Criminal Law Amendment Act 1885, added late at night by the radical MP Henry Labouchere to a bill about the protection of girls, made any act of ‘gross indecency’ between men an offence, in public or in private, punishable by up to two years with hard labour. Sodomy itself had been a capital crime until 1861 but was difficult to prove. The new clause needed far less evidence, and lawyers soon called it a blackmailer’s charter.
Wilde was forty and at the height of his success, with two comedies running in the West End at once. He had been married since 1884. He met Lord Alfred Douglas, sixteen years his junior, in 1891, and through him and others entered a world of hotel suppers with clerks, grooms and rent boys, paid for with cigarette cases and cash. Queensberry, a violent and litigious man best known for lending his name to the rules of boxing, had already lost his eldest son in a shooting in 1894 and had pursued Wilde for months, at one point arriving at a first night with a bouquet of vegetables.