Parallax

27 May, 1564

Calvin dies in Geneva and asks for no gravestone

The French lawyer who had remade a Swiss city, and whose book reshaped Protestantism from Scotland to Hungary, told his colleagues at the end that everything he had done was worth nothing, and was buried in an unmarked grave.

Geneva

John Calvin preached for the last time on 6 February 1564. He was fifty-four and his body had been failing for years: kidney stones, gout, migraine, recurring fevers, and a disease of the lungs that made him cough blood. That day a fit of coughing stopped him in the pulpit of Saint-Pierre. After that he was carried about Geneva in a chair. At Easter, on 2 April, he was brought into the church and took communion from the hands of Theodore Beza, his chosen successor.

He put his affairs in order methodically. On 25 April he dictated his will to a notary. It disposed of a small estate, a little over two hundred crowns, among his brother’s children and the city’s school and poor fund. Two days later the magistrates of the Small Council came to his room in the rue des Chanoines. He thanked them for their patience with his quick temper, asked their pardon for it, and told them to distrust their own importance.

On 28 April the ministers of Geneva came in their turn. The farewell he gave them, taken down by one of those present, is the nearest thing to a self-portrait he left. When he first arrived, he said, there was preaching and that was all; people hunted out idols and burned them, but there was no reformation, and everything was in uproar. He recalled being mocked in the streets, dogs set at his heels and guns fired outside his door. He asked them to change nothing after he was gone. He added that he had had many failings, that all he had done was worth nothing, and that he was a miserable creature who had nonetheless meant well.

One visitor came against his wishes. Guillaume Farel, who had first bullied him into staying in Geneva in 1536 and was now well into his seventies, walked from Neuchatel to see him, although Calvin had written telling him not to tire himself. The two men ate supper together and Farel went home.

Calvin died at about eight in the evening on 27 May, as the sun was setting, with Beza close at hand. The next afternoon he was wrapped in a shroud, put in a plain wooden coffin and buried in the common cemetery at Plainpalais, with much of the city following. As he had asked, there was no stone. Within a few months, Beza wrote, visitors were already asking to be shown the spot, and nobody could say for certain where it was.

How it came to this

Calvin was born at Noyon in Picardy in 1509 and trained as a lawyer and humanist. He broke with the Roman church in the early 1530s, left France when persecution began, and in 1536 published at Basel the first version of the Institutes of the Christian Religion, which he went on enlarging until 1559. Geneva was not his choice. Passing through that summer, he was told by Farel that God would curse his studies if he refused to help a city that had just thrown off its bishop. The council expelled both men in 1538 and asked Calvin back in 1541.

He never held civil office and became a citizen only in 1559. His instrument was the Consistory, a board of ministers and lay elders that summoned people for quarrelling, adultery, dancing, drunkenness and absence from sermons, and could bar them from communion. Old Genevan families resented it, and resented the thousands of French refugees who filled the city. They were broken as a party after a riot in 1555. Two years earlier the council, with Calvin acting for the prosecution, had burned the Spanish physician Michael Servetus for denying the Trinity.

How each side saw it

Theodore Beza and the Reformed churches

Beza published a Life of Calvin within months of the death, and it set the terms for his followers. His Calvin is a worn-out servant who slept little, ate one meal a day, dictated from his sickbed and died poor, having turned a disorderly town into a school of Christ. The Scottish reformer John Knox, who had lived there, called Geneva the most perfect school of Christ since the apostles. In this tradition the discipline of the Consistory was pastoral care, applied to rich and poor alike, and the refusal of a tombstone was a last sermon against the cult of saints.

Sebastian Castellio and the defenders of Servetus

Castellio, a scholar who had once taught in Geneva’s school and left after falling out with Calvin, answered the burning of Servetus from Basel. His collection Concerning Heretics appeared in 1554, and in a reply to Calvin that could not be printed in his lifetime he wrote that to kill a man is not to defend a doctrine, it is to kill a man. For Castellio and for later advocates of toleration, Calvin had fled one persecution to set up another. Servetus left his own voice in the trial record, including his pleas from a cell where he complained of being eaten by lice.

Catholic writers

To Rome Calvin was the arch-heretic of a second generation, more dangerous than Luther because more systematic. In 1577 Jerome Bolsec, a former Carmelite whom Geneva had banished for attacking predestination and who had returned to the Catholic church, published a life of Calvin charging him with ambition, cruelty and sexual crime, and describing him as dying in despair and calling on devils. The book was reprinted for two centuries. No evidence supports its charges and modern Catholic historians do not use it, but it shows how the death was told on the other side of the confessional line.

The old Genevans

The families who had won the city’s independence in the 1530s called themselves the children of Geneva, and Calvin called them Libertines. Their leader Ami Perrin had helped bring him back in 1541. Their complaint, recorded in council minutes and Consistory registers, was that foreign preachers were telling citizens what to name their children, what to wear and whom they might dance with, while French immigrants were bought into citizenship to outvote them. After 1555 Perrin fled, four of his associates were executed, and their side of the argument survives mainly in their opponents’ records.

What is disputed

The word theocracy is the old charge and most specialists now qualify it: the ministers were salaried employees of a council that kept criminal justice in its own hands, as William Naphy and Robert Kingdon have shown, though Calvin’s influence on it after 1555 was very great. His share in the death of Servetus is argued both ways. He denounced him and supplied the theological case; he also asked for beheading in place of fire, and the other Swiss Protestant cities approved the sentence. Counts of executions in Calvin’s Geneva vary with what is included, since many were for witchcraft and alleged plague-spreading.

What followed

Beza led the Genevan church for another forty years, and the academy founded in 1559 sent ministers into France, the Netherlands, Scotland, the Palatinate, Hungary and Poland. Reformed churches, with elders and synods in place of bishops, travelled on to New England and South Africa. Max Weber’s argument that Calvinist anxiety about salvation fed the spirit of capitalism has been debated since 1905. A stone marked J.C. was placed at Plainpalais in the nineteenth century on a guess. In 1903 Reformed Protestants raised a monument at the place where Servetus was burned, describing the act as an error of Calvin’s age.

Read further

  • Bruce Gordon, Calvin (2009)
  • T. H. L. Parker, John Calvin: A Biography (1975)
  • William G. Naphy, Calvin and the Consolidation of the Genevan Reformation (1994)
  • Theodore Beza, The Life of John Calvin (1564)
  • Sebastian Castellio, Concerning Heretics, translated by Roland H. Bainton (1935)

Same day, other years

1905

The Russian fleet is destroyed at Tsushima

Tsushima Strait, between Korea and JapanAsia

Russia’s Baltic Fleet had steamed some 18,000 nautical miles over seven months, round Africa and across the Indian Ocean, to relieve a Pacific base that had fallen before it arrived. On the afternoon of 27 May 1905 Admiral Togo Heihachiro’s Japanese fleet met it in the strait between Korea and Japan. By the next day almost every Russian battleship had been sunk or had surrendered. More than four thousand Russian sailors were dead and about six thousand were prisoners, with the wounded commander Admiral Rozhestvensky among them. Japan lost three torpedo boats and a little over a hundred men. Russia sued for peace, and the treaty was signed in September.

Seen from elsewhere. In Russia the defeat fed a revolution already under way; the Potemkin mutinied weeks later. Across Asia it was greeted as proof that a European empire could be beaten, and Sun Yat-sen and the young Nehru both recalled the excitement. Koreans drew a different lesson: Japan made their country a protectorate that November and annexed it in 1910.

1942

Heydrich is ambushed in Prague

Prague, Protectorate of Bohemia and MoraviaEurope

Reinhard Heydrich, head of the Reich Security Main Office, a chief organiser of the murder of Europe’s Jews and acting ruler of the occupied Czech lands, was driven to work each morning in an open Mercedes. On 27 May 1942, at a hairpin bend in the suburb of Liben, two soldiers trained in Britain and dropped by parachute stepped out. Jozef Gabcik’s Sten gun jammed. Jan Kubis threw a grenade that tore into the car. Heydrich died of infection on 4 June. The two men and five comrades were betrayed and died in the crypt of an Orthodox church on 18 June after a six-hour fight.

Seen from elsewhere. Leaders of the resistance inside the country had begged the exiled government in London to cancel the operation, predicting the reprisals that came: the villages of Lidice and Lezaky were destroyed and several thousand Czechs shot or deported. The exiles judged that the nation’s standing with the Allies required it. Czechs still argue over the price.

1960

The Turkish army overthrows Adnan Menderes

Ankara, TurkeyMiddle East

In the early hours of 27 May 1960 army officers took over Ankara and Istanbul and announced on the radio that the armed forces had assumed the government. It was the republic’s first military coup. The prime minister, Adnan Menderes, whose Democrat Party had won three elections since 1950, was arrested with the president and most of his deputies. A committee under General Cemal Gursel ruled for eighteen months. The fallen politicians were tried on the island of Yassiada on charges running from breach of the constitution to corruption. Menderes was hanged in September 1961, as were his foreign and finance ministers.

Seen from elsewhere. The officers and their civilian backers said they had saved Ataturk’s republic from a government that had muzzled the press and set up a commission to investigate the opposition. Menderes’s voters saw an elected leader killed by the old elite. Parliament rehabilitated him in 1990, and Turkey’s later conservative governments have claimed his memory.

1967

Australians vote to change the constitution on Aboriginal people

AustraliaOceania

On 27 May 1967 Australians were asked to remove two phrases from their constitution: one that stopped the federal parliament making laws for ‘the aboriginal race in any State’, and one that excluded ‘aboriginal natives’ from the count of the population. Just under 91 per cent voted yes, with a majority in every state, the largest margin in the history of Australian referendums. The vote followed a ten-year campaign of petitions and meetings by Indigenous and white activists, among them Faith Bandler and the Federal Council for the Advancement of Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders.

Seen from elsewhere. The referendum is often said to have given Aboriginal people citizenship and the vote; it did neither, since federal voting rights dated from 1962. Many campaigners were disappointed when Canberra made little use of its new power for years. The No vote was highest in rural districts of Western Australia, Queensland and South Australia with large Aboriginal populations.

Also on 27 May