Parallax

12 May, 1820

Florence Nightingale is born

The legend is a gentle woman with a lamp. The record is of a formidable administrator and statistician who came home from the Crimean War convinced that the hospital she had run had killed men who need not have died.

Florence, Grand Duchy of Tuscany

She was named after the city where she was born on 12 May 1820, during her wealthy English parents’ long honeymoon tour; her elder sister, born in Naples, had been given that city’s Greek name, Parthenope. The girls grew up between a house in Derbyshire and another in Hampshire. Their father taught them himself, and Florence, the abler, learned Greek, Latin, history and mathematics to a standard few men of her class reached.

A private note records that on 7 February 1837, when she was sixteen, God called her to his service, without saying how. Over the next decade she decided that the service was nursing, an occupation her family associated with drink and low morals. Her mother and sister fought her for years. She turned down a patient suitor, the politician Richard Monckton Milnes, trained briefly with Protestant deaconesses at Kaiserswerth on the Rhine, and in 1853 took charge of a small hospital for gentlewomen in London.

In October 1854 The Times printed dispatches describing British soldiers wounded in the Crimea dying untended in the base hospitals across the Black Sea. The Secretary at War, Sidney Herbert, a family friend, asked Nightingale to take a party of nurses out. She reached the Barrack Hospital at Scutari, opposite Constantinople, on 4 November with thirty-eight women, days before the casualties of Inkerman arrived. She found miles of corridors lined with men on straw, few basins, almost no bedding and a purveyor’s department that would issue nothing without a signed form. Using money raised by The Times and her own funds she bought shirts, scrubbing brushes and kettles, set up a laundry and a kitchen, and made herself, in effect, quartermaster of the hospital.

At night she walked the wards alone with a folding Turkish lantern. A Times report of February 1855 described her as a ministering angel making her solitary rounds with a little lamp, and the image went round the world. That same month the death rate at Scutari reached its peak: more than four in ten of those admitted. The building stood over blocked sewers. In March a Sanitary Commission sent from London flushed them, cleared the water supply and opened the windows, and by summer the rate had fallen to about two in a hundred.

She came home in 1856 under the name Miss Smith to avoid the crowds, and spent the next half-century, much of it as an invalid, working from a couch: on army health, hospital design, a training school for nurses and the sanitation of India. She died in London in 1910, aged ninety.

How it came to this

In early nineteenth-century Britain, hospitals were charitable institutions for the poor; anyone with money was nursed at home. Hospital nurses were untrained domestic servants, and the only organised nursing was done by religious sisterhoods, Catholic and, from the 1840s, Anglican. For a woman of Nightingale’s class, paid work of any kind meant a loss of caste. Her unpublished essay Cassandra, written around 1852, is a furious account of the enforced idleness of educated daughters.

The Crimean War began in 1853 as a quarrel between Russia and the Ottoman Empire, which Britain and France joined in March 1854 to keep Russia out of the Mediterranean. The British army had not fought a European enemy for forty years, and its supply and medical services were divided among departments that did not answer to one another. An expeditionary force landed in the Crimea in September 1854 to take the naval base of Sevastopol and settled into a winter siege for which it had neither huts nor transport. Cholera, dysentery, typhus and scurvy killed far more men than the Russians did, and the electric telegraph and the first war correspondents told the public at home within days.

How each side saw it

Mary Seacole

Seacole, a Jamaican of Scottish and Creole parentage who had nursed cholera and yellow fever in Kingston and Panama, applied in London to join the nurses and was turned away at every office. In her memoir, Wonderful Adventures of Mrs Seacole in Many Lands, published in 1857, she asks whether it was because her blood flowed beneath a somewhat duskier skin. She went at her own expense and ran a store and canteen near Balaclava, treating soldiers there and on the battlefield. Nightingale, in a private letter of 1870, acknowledged her kindness but disapproved of her selling drink.

The army doctors

Dr John Hall, chief of the army’s medical staff in the East, regarded the nurses as an intrusion forced on him by politicians and newspapers, and reported that the hospitals lacked for nothing. Many surgeons resented a civilian woman with a direct line to the minister and a private purse larger than their budget. Their case, set out in official correspondence, was that they had been starved of supplies by the same government that now blamed them. Nightingale’s opinion of Hall is preserved in her remark, when he was knighted, that the letters KCB must stand for Knight of the Crimean Burial-grounds.

The Irish Sisters of Mercy

A second party of nurses that reached Constantinople in December 1854 included fifteen Irish nuns under Mother Francis Bridgeman, experienced in the cholera wards of Ireland. Bridgeman would not place her sisters under Nightingale’s sole authority or forbid them to speak of religion to Catholic soldiers, and the two were at odds for the rest of the war. The sisters’ own journals describe being kept idle while men died, and attribute it to anti-Catholic feeling. Nightingale, who worked well with other Catholic nuns, called her ‘Mother Brickbat’ and accused her of proselytising.

The Russian tradition

Inside besieged Sevastopol the surgeon Nikolai Pirogov organised the sorting of casualties by urgency and worked with the Sisters of the Exaltation of the Cross, a community of nurses founded in 1854 by the Grand Duchess Elena Pavlovna, who served under bombardment at the dressing stations. Russian accounts also honour Dasha of Sevastopol, a sailor’s orphan who tended the wounded on the field at the Alma in September 1854, before any British nurse had sailed. In Russian memory the pioneers of wartime nursing are these women, and Nightingale is a contemporary, not the origin.

What is disputed

How much credit Nightingale deserves for the fall in deaths is argued. Hugh Small contended in 1998 that mortality at Scutari was worse than in other hospitals during her first winter, that the sanitary engineers and not the nurses reduced it, and that her own later study of the figures brought her to that conclusion and to a breakdown. Lynn McDonald, editor of her collected works, rejects much of this. Her long invalidism has been attributed to brucellosis caught in the Crimea, to other illness, and by Lytton Strachey’s generation to strategy. Whether Seacole should be called a nurse at all is a continuing quarrel between the two women’s admirers.

What followed

The Nightingale school at St Thomas’s Hospital opened in 1860 and its graduates carried her model of trained, disciplined, secular nursing across the British Empire and the United States. Her diagrams of army mortality, drawn with the statistician William Farr, are landmarks in the visual presentation of data, and she was the first woman elected to the Statistical Society. Her birthday is International Nurses Day. In 2020 Britain named its emergency Covid hospitals after her, as some nursing organisations were questioning whether a figure so tied to empire and deference should remain the profession’s emblem.

Read further

  • Mark Bostridge, Florence Nightingale: The Woman and Her Legend (2008)
  • Cecil Woodham-Smith, Florence Nightingale, 1820-1910 (1950)
  • Hugh Small, Florence Nightingale: Avenging Angel (1998)
  • Florence Nightingale, Notes on Nursing: What It Is and What It Is Not (1859)
  • Mary Seacole, Wonderful Adventures of Mrs Seacole in Many Lands (1857)

Same day, other years

1881

The Bey of Tunis signs under the guns

Ksar Said palace, Le Bardo, TunisiaAfrica

In April 1881 a French army crossed from Algeria into Tunisia, giving as its reason raids by Khroumir tribesmen across the frontier. A second force landed at Bizerte and marched on the capital. On 12 May General Breart rode with an escort to the palace of Muhammad as-Sadiq Bey and presented a treaty, with a few hours to answer. The bey signed that evening. The Treaty of Bardo left him his throne and handed France his foreign relations and the right to station troops; a second convention in 1883 completed the protectorate. Tunisia’s government had been bankrupt and under European financial supervision since 1869.

Seen from elsewhere. France described a temporary measure to secure Algeria. The south and centre of the country rose that summer under leaders such as Ali ben Khalifa; Sfax was shelled and Kairouan occupied before the revolt was put down. Italy, with far more settlers in Tunisia than France, called it a slap in the face and joined Germany and Austria in alliance the next year.

1885

The fall of Batoche

Batoche, North-West Territories (now Saskatchewan), CanadaThe Americas

For four days from 9 May 1885 some 250 to 300 Metis and their Cree and Dakota allies, dug into rifle pits around the village of Batoche on the South Saskatchewan River, held off a Canadian force about three times their number under General Frederick Middleton, which had a steamboat, artillery and a Gatling gun. By 12 May the defenders were firing nails and stones for want of bullets, and a charge by the militia overran them. Their military leader, Gabriel Dumont, escaped to the United States. Louis Riel, who had led a provisional government, gave himself up three days later and was hanged for treason at Regina in November.

Seen from elsewhere. Ottawa called it a rebellion. The Metis account is of a people whose petitions over land title had gone unanswered for years while surveyors and settlers arrived, and many now speak of the North-West Resistance. Riel’s execution divided French and English Canada for generations; Manitoba has since recognised him as its founder.

1916

James Connolly is shot in a chair

Kilmainham Gaol, Dublin, IrelandEurope

James Connolly, the socialist trade union leader who had commanded the rebel forces in Dublin during the Easter Rising, had been badly wounded in the ankle in the fighting at the General Post Office. Before dawn on 12 May 1916 he was brought by ambulance from the hospital at Dublin Castle to the stonebreakers’ yard at Kilmainham, carried in on a stretcher, placed on a chair because he could not stand, and shot by firing squad. Sean Mac Diarmada had been shot in the same yard that morning. They were the last of fourteen men executed in Dublin after courts martial held in secret.

Seen from elsewhere. The British commander, General Maxwell, saw armed rebellion in wartime, in league with Germany, that had left some 485 people dead, most of them civilians. Dubliners had jeered the prisoners as they were marched away. The drawn-out executions turned that feeling around, as John Dillon warned the Commons they would, and London halted them.

2008

The Wenchuan earthquake

Sichuan, ChinaAsia

At 2.28 in the afternoon on 12 May 2008 a fault beneath the mountains north-west of Chengdu ruptured along more than two hundred kilometres. The earthquake, of magnitude 7.9, was felt in Beijing and Bangkok. Whole towns such as Beichuan were flattened or buried by landslides. The official toll was 69,227 dead and 17,923 missing, with close to five million people left homeless. The premier, Wen Jiabao, flew to the area within hours, more than a hundred thousand troops were sent in, foreign rescue teams were admitted and for some weeks Chinese reporters covered the disaster with unusual freedom.

Seen from elsewhere. Thousands of the dead were children in schools that collapsed beside buildings left standing. Parents blamed corrupt, shoddy construction and were pressed to stay silent; the government put the number of students lost at 5,335. Activists who compiled their own lists, among them Tan Zuoren and Huang Qi, were imprisoned, and the artist Ai Weiwei was beaten by police.

Also on 12 May