Parallax

19 May, 1935

Lawrence of Arabia dies after a motorcycle crash

He had spent thirteen years in the ranks under assumed names, trying to get away from his own legend. Six days after swerving to avoid two boys on bicycles on a Dorset lane, he died without regaining consciousness.

Bovington Camp, Dorset, England

On the morning of 13 May 1935 a small man of forty-six rode his Brough Superior motorcycle from his cottage at Clouds Hill to the post office at Bovington Camp, a mile and a half away, to send a telegram inviting the writer Henry Williamson to lunch. He had left the Royal Air Force eleven weeks earlier and was not sure what to do with himself. To friends he wrote of feeling like a leaf fallen from its tree.

On the way back, coming over a rise in the road, he met two errand boys on bicycles riding in the same direction. He braked and swerved, clipped the rear wheel of one, and was thrown over the handlebars. He wore no helmet; hardly anyone did. He was taken to the military hospital at Bovington with a fractured skull.

For six days the hospital issued bulletins while some of the best surgeons in England came down to Dorset. Among them was a young neurosurgeon, Hugh Cairns. Nothing could be done. T. E. Lawrence, known to his neighbours and to the air force as T. E. Shaw, died a little after eight on the morning of Sunday 19 May.

The secrecy he had cultivated worked against a quiet end. The War Office took control of the hospital and the information, sentries were posted, and the cottage was guarded against souvenir hunters and, some said, against anyone looking for papers. At the inquest a soldier who had seen the crash, Corporal Ernest Catchpole, said that a black car had passed in the opposite direction just before it happened. The two boys had seen no car. The jury returned a verdict of accidental death.

He was buried on 21 May at Moreton, the village nearest his cottage. The mourners were an odd company that only his life could have assembled: Winston Churchill, the generals and officials of the Arab campaign, the poet Siegfried Sassoon, artists and booksellers, and private soldiers and aircraftmen who had known him as a barrack-room companion with a strange fund of stories. Churchill, in tears, called him one of the greatest beings of his time.

Cairns went away troubled by what he had seen. He began to collect data on head injuries among army dispatch riders, and his papers, published during the Second World War, led to the compulsory use of crash helmets by military motorcyclists and, decades later, by civilians.

How it came to this

Thomas Edward Lawrence, born in Wales in 1888, was an Oxford-trained archaeologist who had dug at Carchemish in Syria before 1914 and spoke Arabic. Posted to military intelligence in Cairo, he was sent in 1916 to the Hejaz, where Sharif Hussein of Mecca had risen against Ottoman rule with British encouragement and promises. Lawrence became liaison officer to Hussein’s son Faisal, and for two years rode with Arab irregulars who raided the Hejaz railway, took the port of Aqaba in July 1917 and entered Damascus in October 1918.

Britain had meanwhile agreed with France, in the Sykes-Picot arrangement, to divide the Arab lands between them, and had promised a Jewish national home in Palestine. Lawrence knew of these commitments while urging the Arabs on. In 1919 the American showman Lowell Thomas turned him into ‘Lawrence of Arabia’ with a lecture and film show seen by enormous audiences. Lawrence wrote his own account, Seven Pillars of Wisdom, advised Churchill on the Middle East settlement of 1921, and then enlisted as an aircraftman under a false name.

How each side saw it

Arab historians

The Jordanian historian Suleiman Mousa, who interviewed surviving veterans and used Arabic records, argued in T. E. Lawrence: An Arab View (1966) that the revolt was planned, led and fought by Arabs, and that Lawrence was one capable British officer among several whose book turned their war into his adventure. The capture of Aqaba, on this account, was the work of Auda abu Tayi and Sharif Nasir. George Antonius, in The Arab Awakening (1938), was kinder to the man but put the weight elsewhere: on the pledges of independence made to Hussein and broken at the peace.

The Turkish view

In Ottoman and later Turkish memory the Arab Revolt was a rebellion against a Muslim empire at war, paid for with British gold, and its military effect was slight: the garrison of Medina under Fakhri Pasha held out until January 1919, after the armistice. Lawrence’s name passed into Turkish as a byword for the foreign agent who stirs up subject peoples. Turkish historians have also pointed out that the decisive blows in Palestine and Syria were struck by Allenby’s regular army, with the Arab forces on its desert flank.

Lawrence himself

His own verdict was harsher than the legend. In Seven Pillars of Wisdom he wrote that he had encouraged the Arabs with promises he suspected would not be honoured, and that the fraud made him ‘continually and bitterly ashamed’. In 1918 he declined the decorations George V was about to pin on him. He described his enlistment in the ranks as a kind of monastic retreat. He also helped Lowell Thomas with his show, sat for many portraits and revised his memoir obsessively, and friends such as Bernard Shaw thought he hid in the limelight.

Debunkers and defenders

Richard Aldington’s ‘biographical enquiry’ of 1955 called Lawrence a habitual liar who had invented or inflated his exploits, and made public that he was illegitimate. It caused outrage among his friends, led by the military writer Basil Liddell Hart. The authorised biography by Jeremy Wilson (1989), using official files closed to Aldington, concluded that contemporary reports largely bear out Seven Pillars on matters that can be checked. Later writers, including Lawrence James, remain sceptical about episodes for which Lawrence is the only witness.

What is disputed

The black car at the inquest has fed theories that he was killed by the secret service, by foreign agents or by his own wish; no evidence supports them, and the car may have been a delivery van seen earlier or a mistake. His story of being captured, flogged and sexually assaulted at Deraa in November 1917 cannot be confirmed, and his diary page for those days is missing; biographers divide on it. His sexuality, the identity of the ‘S.A.’ to whom Seven Pillars is dedicated, and how far his campaign shortened the war are all still argued.

What followed

Faisal, driven from Syria by the French in 1920, was made king of Iraq by the British; his dynasty was overthrown in 1958. His brother Abdullah’s line still reigns in Jordan. The frontiers drawn in those years, and the promises broken in drawing them, remain a grievance across the region. Lawrence’s fame was renewed for a new generation by David Lean’s film of 1962, which many viewers take for history. Clouds Hill belongs to the National Trust, and a roadside stone marks the place of the crash.

Read further

  • T. E. Lawrence, Seven Pillars of Wisdom (1926)
  • Jeremy Wilson, Lawrence of Arabia: The Authorised Biography of T. E. Lawrence (1989)
  • Suleiman Mousa, T. E. Lawrence: An Arab View (1966)
  • Richard Aldington, Lawrence of Arabia: A Biographical Enquiry (1955)
  • Scott Anderson, Lawrence in Arabia (2013)

Same day, other years

1536

Anne Boleyn is beheaded

Tower of London, EnglandEurope

Henry VIII’s second queen, for whom he had broken with Rome, was executed within the Tower before a small invited crowd. A swordsman had been brought from Calais to do it in the French manner, with one stroke as she knelt upright. She had been arrested seventeen days earlier and convicted of adultery with five men, one of them her brother George, and of plotting the king’s death. All five men were already dead. Two days before her execution Archbishop Cranmer had declared her marriage null, which made her daughter Elizabeth illegitimate. Henry was betrothed to Jane Seymour the next day and married her before the month was out.

Seen from elsewhere. Most historians think the charges were false; several of the alleged meetings fall on dates when she was demonstrably elsewhere. Eric Ives saw a coup by Thomas Cromwell; G. W. Bernard has argued that some of the accusations may have had substance. Even the imperial ambassador Chapuys, who detested her, doubted the evidence. Catholic polemic later gave her a sixth finger.

1919

Mustafa Kemal lands at Samsun

Samsun, Ottoman Empire (Turkey)Middle East

Four days after Greek troops occupied Smyrna with Allied approval, an Ottoman general stepped off an old steamer at a Black Sea port. Mustafa Kemal had been sent by the sultan’s government as an army inspector to restore order and oversee disarmament in Anatolia. He used the post to do the opposite, contacting commanders and local committees and calling congresses at Erzurum and Sivas that rejected the partition of the Turkish-majority lands. The sultan’s government dismissed him and later condemned him to death. Four years of war and diplomacy produced the Republic of Turkey in 1923. He later gave 19 May as his birthday, and it is a national holiday.

Seen from elsewhere. Greece marks the same date as a day of remembrance for the Greeks of the Pontus, the Black Sea region, tens of thousands of whom were killed or died on forced marches between 1914 and 1923, many during the nationalist campaign that began here. Turkey rejects the term genocide and describes wartime security measures against armed bands.

1961

Police fire on Bengali language protesters at Silchar

Silchar, Assam, IndiaAsia

In 1960 the state of Assam made Assamese its sole official language. In the Barak Valley in the south of the state, where most people spoke Bengali, a campaign of non-violent protest demanded equal status for their language. On 19 May 1961, during a general strike, volunteers sat on the tracks at Silchar railway station. In the afternoon armed police opened fire on the crowd. Eleven people were killed, among them Kamala Bhattacharya, a schoolgirl of sixteen who had just finished her examinations. Within months the law was amended to make Bengali the official language of the valley’s districts. The date is kept there as Language Martyrs’ Day.

Seen from elsewhere. Assamese speakers saw the 1960 law as protection for a language they feared would be overwhelmed by migration from Bengal, a fear with a history: under British rule Bengali had been imposed as the language of Assam’s courts and schools for nearly forty years. The findings of the official inquiry into the shooting were not made public.

2010

The Thai army clears the Red Shirt camp in Bangkok

Bangkok, ThailandAsia

For two months tens of thousands of ‘Red Shirt’ protesters, many of them from the rural north and north-east and loyal to the ousted prime minister Thaksin Shinawatra, had occupied Bangkok’s main shopping district demanding new elections. At dawn on 19 May armoured vehicles broke through their barricades of tyres and bamboo. By early afternoon the leaders had surrendered to prevent further deaths. As the crowd dispersed, more than thirty buildings were set alight, including one of Asia’s largest shopping centres. Six people were shot dead inside a Buddhist temple that had been designated a safe zone. About ninety people were killed during the protests as a whole, most of them civilians.

Seen from elsewhere. Abhisit Vejjajiva’s government said it had faced armed militants hidden among the demonstrators and had acted lawfully. A Thai court inquest in 2013 found that the six in the temple were killed by soldiers’ bullets. No soldier or official has been convicted, while Red Shirt leaders were prosecuted. Thaksin’s allies won the election of 2011.

Also on 19 May