Parallax

21 May, 1927

Lindbergh lands in Paris

A 25-year-old airmail pilot flew alone from New York to Paris in thirty-three and a half hours, with no radio and no view straight ahead. He was not the first to fly the Atlantic, and the fame that met him on the ground proved harder to survive than the ocean.

Le Bourget, Paris, France

At 7.52 on the morning of 20 May 1927 a small silver monoplane lumbered down the wet clay of Roosevelt Field on Long Island, bounced twice, and cleared the telephone wires at the far end by about twenty feet. It carried 450 gallons of petrol, five sandwiches, two canteens of water and one man. Charles Lindbergh had left out a radio, a parachute and a navigator to save weight, and had put the main fuel tank in front of the cockpit, so that he could see forward only through a periscope or by leaning out of the side window.

He followed the coast to Newfoundland and turned out over the ocean as night fell. He flew through ice cloud and around thunderheads, sometimes at 10,000 feet and sometimes ten feet above the waves. His real enemy was sleep. He had been awake all the night before take-off, and by the second morning he was holding his eyelids open with his fingers and, as he later wrote, sensing phantoms in the fuselage behind him.

In the twenty-seventh hour he saw fishing boats, circled one and shouted down to ask the way to Ireland. Nobody answered. An hour later he crossed the Irish coast at Dingle Bay, within three miles of his planned course, then Cornwall, then the Channel at dusk. He picked up the Seine and followed it to Paris, circled the lit Eiffel Tower, and went looking for an aerodrome that his map placed north-east of the city.

What puzzled him was a long string of lights where he expected dark fields. They were the headlamps of cars jammed on the road to Le Bourget. He landed at 10.22 pm on 21 May, 3,600 miles and thirty-three and a half hours from New York. A crowd that the French police put at well over 100,000 broke through the fences and ran at the machine. Lindbergh was hauled out and passed over heads until two French airmen put his helmet on an American reporter as a decoy and got him away to a hangar. Souvenir hunters were already tearing fabric off the fuselage.

He spent the night at the American embassy. Within a month he had been decorated by the French president, received by kings in Brussels and London, brought home on a US Navy cruiser and paraded up Broadway before crowds estimated in millions.

How it came to this

The Atlantic had been flown before. In May 1919 a US Navy flying boat crossed in stages by way of the Azores, and the following month two British airmen, John Alcock and Arthur Whitten Brown, flew non-stop from Newfoundland to an Irish bog. Airships had made the crossing with passengers. What had not been done was the far longer flight between New York and Paris, for which a French-born New York hotelier, Raymond Orteig, had offered a prize of $25,000 in 1919.

By 1927 engines were reliable enough to try, and the contest turned deadly. The French ace Rene Fonck crashed on take-off in 1926, killing two of his crew. In April 1927 two American naval officers died testing their machine, and on 8 May the French war heroes Charles Nungesser and Francois Coli took off from Paris for New York and vanished. Lindbergh’s rivals at Roosevelt Field had bigger aircraft, crews and money. He had the backing of some St Louis businessmen, a plane built to his order in San Diego in sixty days, and a belief that one engine and one pilot meant fewer things to go wrong.

How each side saw it

France, in mourning for Nungesser and Coli

Paris had spent a fortnight waiting for news of its own airmen, and some French newspapers had printed false reports of their arrival in New York. The American ambassador, Myron Herrick, had warned that an American attempt so soon might be badly received. The opposite happened. Lindbergh’s first calls were on Nungesser’s mother and on the wounded veterans at Les Invalides, and the French public adopted him. A body of French opinion has always held that the White Bird reached North America before it was lost, which would make its crew the first to fly from Paris to the New World; searches in Newfoundland and Maine have found nothing conclusive.

The other fliers

Alcock and Brown had crossed non-stop eight years earlier and were by then half forgotten; Alcock had been killed in 1919. Two weeks after Lindbergh, Clarence Chamberlin flew from New York to Germany, further than Paris, carrying his backer as the first transatlantic aeroplane passenger, and Richard Byrd’s crew followed. Fellow pilots admired Lindbergh’s navigation and nerve but pointed out that the feat was a matter of endurance and preparation, not a first crossing, and that the acclaim owed much to his being alone, young and photogenic at the moment when newsreels, radio and tabloid newspapers could turn a man into a sensation overnight.

Amelia Earhart and women pilots

In 1928 Earhart became the first woman to cross the Atlantic by air, as a passenger; she said she had been carried like ‘a sack of potatoes’ and wanted to earn the fame she had been handed. On 20 May 1932, five years to the day after Lindbergh’s take-off, she left Newfoundland alone in a Lockheed Vega. With ice on the wings and a cracked exhaust manifold she gave up Paris and landed in a pasture near Derry, in Northern Ireland, the next day. In her book The Fun of It she argued that women were kept out of aviation by training and custom, not ability.

Later critics of Lindbergh

The hero of 1927 became one of the most divisive Americans of the following decade. He inspected the German air force, accepted a decoration from Goering in 1938, and led the America First campaign against entering the war. In a speech at Des Moines in September 1941 he named the British, the Roosevelt administration and American Jews as the forces pushing the country to fight. His defenders, including his biographer A. Scott Berg, stress his sincere dread of a European war and his later combat flying in the Pacific. Critics see the speech, and his writings on race, as of a piece.

What is disputed

Whether Nungesser and Coli crossed first cannot be settled without wreckage. Crowd figures for Le Bourget range from 100,000 to 150,000 and are guesses. Lindbergh’s own accounts differ: a hurried book of 1927 is matter-of-fact, while The Spirit of St. Louis, written a quarter of a century later, adds the phantoms and much inner drama. The common statement that he was the first to fly the Atlantic is wrong by eight years; dozens of people had crossed by air before him. Earhart’s skill as a pilot, as against her courage, was questioned by some contemporaries.

What followed

Investment poured into American aviation, and passenger numbers on US airlines rose many times over in the three years after the flight. Lindbergh surveyed routes for the new airlines. In 1932 his infant son was kidnapped and killed, a case that ended with the execution of Bruno Hauptmann and drove the family abroad. Earhart disappeared over the Pacific in 1937. The Spirit of St. Louis hangs in the Smithsonian in Washington. From 2003 it emerged that Lindbergh had secretly fathered children with three women in Germany.

Read further

  • Charles A. Lindbergh, The Spirit of St. Louis (1953)
  • A. Scott Berg, Lindbergh (1998)
  • Amelia Earhart, The Fun of It (1932)
  • Joe Jackson, Atlantic Fever: Lindbergh, His Competitors, and the Race to Cross the Atlantic (2012)
  • Susan Butler, East to the Dawn: The Life of Amelia Earhart (1997)

Same day, other years

1871

The army enters Paris and the Bloody Week begins

Paris, FranceEurope

On a Sunday afternoon, while a concert was being given in the Tuileries gardens, troops of the national government at Versailles found a gate in the south-western wall of Paris unguarded and came through it. For two months the city had been ruled by the Commune, a radical municipal government elected after France’s defeat by Prussia. The fighting that followed went street by street and barricade by barricade for seven days. The retreating Communards shot hostages, among them the archbishop of Paris, and set fire to the Tuileries palace and the city hall. The army shot prisoners in batches, in parks, barracks and cemeteries.

Seen from elsewhere. The Versailles government held that it was putting down an armed insurrection against an elected national assembly. The left, following Marx, saw the first workers’ government drowned in blood. The number killed by the army was long given as 20,000 or more; the historian Robert Tombs has argued from burial records for about 7,000, a revision others dispute.

1879

The Esmeralda goes down at Iquique

Iquique, Peru (now Chile)The Americas

Six weeks into the War of the Pacific, fought by Chile against Peru and Bolivia over the nitrate deserts of the Atacama, the Peruvian ironclad Huascar caught an old wooden Chilean corvette blockading the port of Iquique. The Esmeralda’s captain, Arturo Prat, refused to strike his flag. When the Huascar rammed, he leapt on to its deck sword in hand, followed by only one or two men, and was shot down. The corvette sank at the third ramming with its colours flying. The same morning Peru’s other large ironclad, the Independencia, ran on to a reef while chasing a Chilean schooner and was lost.

Seen from elsewhere. Chile keeps the day as a national holiday for a defeat that roused the country to enlist. Peru honours the Huascar’s commander, Miguel Grau, who picked up the Chilean survivors and sent Prat’s sword and letters to his widow. The war cost Peru its southern provinces and Bolivia its coastline, which Bolivia has never ceased to claim.

1991

Rajiv Gandhi is killed by a suicide bomber

Sriperumbudur, Tamil Nadu, IndiaAsia

The former prime minister of India, campaigning to return to office, arrived late in the evening at an election rally near Madras. As he walked through the crowd, a young woman stepped forward with a sandalwood garland, bent as if to touch his feet, and detonated explosives strapped under her dress. Gandhi, aged forty-six, and at least fourteen others died. A photographer’s camera, found intact beside his body, held pictures of the killers. Investigators traced the plot to the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam, the Sri Lankan separatist army that Indian troops, sent by Gandhi as peacekeepers in 1987, had ended up fighting.

Seen from elsewhere. The Tigers denied responsibility for years. In 2006 their chief negotiator, Anton Balasingham, called the killing a monumental tragedy that the movement deeply regretted. In Tamil Nadu a long campaign argued that several of those convicted were minor figures harshly treated; the last of them were freed by the Supreme Court in 2022, over the objections of Gandhi’s party.

1998

Suharto resigns after thirty-two years

Jakarta, IndonesiaAsia

In a short televised statement at the presidential palace, the general who had ruled Indonesia since the mid-1960s announced that he was stepping down and handed over to his vice-president, B. J. Habibie. The Asian financial crisis had wrecked the currency and sent food and fuel prices soaring. On 12 May security forces shot dead four students at Trisakti University in Jakarta. Three days of rioting followed in which more than a thousand people died, many trapped in burning shopping centres, and ethnic Chinese Indonesians were singled out for attack, including many reported rapes. Students occupied the parliament building, and Suharto’s ministers and generals deserted him.

Seen from elsewhere. Admirers credit Suharto with three decades of growth that lifted tens of millions out of poverty. His rule began with the killing of at least half a million alleged communists in 1965-66 and included the occupation of East Timor. He was never tried for corruption or abuses, on grounds of ill health, and who organised the May riots has not been established in court.

Also on 21 May