Parallax

13 May, 1888

Brazil abolishes slavery in two sentences

The last country in the Americas to end slavery did it on a Sunday afternoon with a law of two articles. By then the people it freed had been walking off the plantations for a year.

Rio de Janeiro, Empire of Brazil

The law that Princess Isabel signed in the Paco Imperial in Rio de Janeiro on Sunday 13 May 1888 is one of the shortest ever to change a country. Article one: slavery is declared extinct in Brazil from the date of this law. Article two: all provisions to the contrary are revoked. She was thirty-one and was governing as regent while her father, the Emperor Pedro II, lay ill in Europe. She used a gold pen bought by public subscription. Outside, a crowd of thousands filled the square, and the city celebrated for days.

The bill had been before parliament for less than a week. The Conservative cabinet of Joao Alfredo Correia de Oliveira brought it to the Chamber of Deputies on 8 May; it passed there two days later by 83 votes to 9 and cleared the Senate on the morning of the thirteenth. It offered the owners no compensation and the freed no land, wages or schooling. Something over 700,000 people were still held as property by the last official count, a year earlier, out of a population of about fourteen million.

The speed reflected what was happening in the coffee country. Through 1887 enslaved workers in the province of Sao Paulo had been leaving the estates in groups of dozens and hundreds, guided by networks of abolitionists such as Antonio Bento’s caifazes down the mountain roads to the port of Santos, where a settlement of fugitives at Jabaquara held several thousand people. Railway workers hid them on trains. In October 1887 the army’s officers, through their club, asked the regent not to use soldiers to hunt runaways. Planters began freeing their workforces on condition that they stay through the harvest. The institution was collapsing, and parliament legislated to keep up.

Behind the flights lay two decades of campaigning. The lawyer Luis Gama, himself sold into slavery as a child, won freedom for hundreds in the courts. The journalist Jose do Patrocinio, the engineer Andre Reboucas and the deputy Joaquim Nabuco built a national movement with newspapers, theatre benefits and public meetings. In the northern province of Ceara, raftsmen led by Francisco Jose do Nascimento refused from 1881 to ferry captives to the ships, and the province declared itself free in 1884.

A story told ever since has the Baron of Cotegipe, the chief opponent of the law in the Senate, saying to the princess as he kissed her hand that she had redeemed a race and lost a throne. Eighteen months later, on 15 November 1889, the army deposed her father and the imperial family sailed into exile.

How it came to this

Brazil took in more enslaved Africans than any other country: about 4.9 million people were landed there between the sixteenth century and the 1850s, roughly forty-five per cent of all those who survived the Atlantic crossing. They and their descendants cut the sugar of the north-east, dug the gold of Minas Gerais and, in the nineteenth century, planted the coffee that became the empire’s chief export. Slavery was not confined to plantations; it ran through every town, trade and household.

Independence in 1822 changed nothing. The transatlantic trade was banned by treaty in 1831, a law so widely ignored that it gave Portuguese the phrase ‘for the English to see’, and was only truly stopped in 1850 under British naval pressure. A law of 1871 declared children born to enslaved mothers free, though bound to the mother’s owner until twenty-one. Another in 1885 freed those over sixty. Each was presented as the final concession. By the 1880s Brazil stood alone in the hemisphere, after abolition in the United States in 1865 and in Cuba in 1886.

How each side saw it

The enslaved and the freed

Very few of those freed in 1888 left writing of their own; historians such as Sidney Chalhoub and Maria Helena Machado have recovered their actions from police files, court cases and plantation letters, which show people bargaining, suing, fleeing and occasionally killing overseers. Many freedpeople revered the princess, and a Black Guard was formed in Rio to defend her. Since the 1970s, however, Brazil’s Black movement has called 13 May a false abolition, a freedom granted on paper without land or rights, and has chosen to commemorate 20 November, the death of Zumbi of Palmares, instead.

The planters

Coffee growers of the Paraiba valley, heavily mortgaged with their workers as collateral, regarded uncompensated abolition as confiscation of legally acquired property by the Crown they had sustained. Cotegipe told the Senate that the law would ruin agriculture and that the monarchy would not survive it. Petitions for indemnity reached parliament through 1888 and were refused. Many such men went over to the republican cause and were mocked as ‘republicans of 14 May’. Planters in western Sao Paulo, already turning to subsidised Italian immigrants, took the change more calmly.

The abolitionists

Nabuco had argued in O Abolicionismo in 1883 that slavery had corrupted every Brazilian institution and that ending it would be the beginning, not the end, of the work. Reboucas wanted what he called rural democracy: the break-up of great estates and plots for the freed, with schools. Patrocinio knelt to kiss the princess’s hand. Within two years Reboucas had followed the imperial family into exile and Nabuco was writing that the movement had been abandoned at the moment of its victory, its second half never attempted.

The monarchist and Catholic tradition

For Isabel’s admirers she is the Redeemer, a devout woman who had long favoured abolition, sheltered fugitives’ supporters at her palace in Petropolis, and signed knowing what it might cost her family. Pope Leo XIII sent her the Golden Rose that year. Her father, told the news on his sickbed in Milan, is reported to have wept and called his people great. In this account the law was an act of conscience by the Crown, and the republic that followed was the revenge of the slaveholders.

What is disputed

The central argument is over who ended slavery. An older historiography credited the princess and parliament; Robert Conrad, Emilia Viotti da Costa and later Angela Alonso and Maria Helena Machado give the weight to mass flight and to an organised abolitionist movement, with the law ratifying an accomplished fact. Cotegipe’s remark survives in several wordings and may have been polished afterwards. How far abolition caused the fall of the monarchy is debated, since the army and the republicans had other grievances. The number freed is uncertain because registration was already breaking down.

What followed

Nothing was done for the freed. Governments subsidised European immigration instead, and former slaves were left to sharecropping, domestic service and the hillsides of the cities. In December 1890 the finance minister, Rui Barbosa, ordered the treasury’s slave registers burned, by his account to defeat the owners’ claims for compensation; the order also destroyed evidence of families’ origins. Brazil today has the largest population of African descent outside Africa, and the gap in income, schooling and exposure to violence between Black and white Brazilians remains the country’s central social fact.

Read further

  • Robert Conrad, The Destruction of Brazilian Slavery, 1850-1888 (1972)
  • Emilia Viotti da Costa, Da senzala a colonia (1966)
  • Joaquim Nabuco, O Abolicionismo (1883)
  • Angela Alonso, The Last Abolition: The Brazilian Antislavery Movement, 1868-1888 (2021)
  • Sidney Chalhoub, Visoes da liberdade (1990)

Same day, other years

1787

The First Fleet sails for Botany Bay

Portsmouth, EnglandOceania

Eleven ships left the anchorage off Portsmouth before dawn on 13 May 1787 under Captain Arthur Phillip: two naval vessels, three store ships and six transports carrying some 750 to 780 convicted men, women and a few children, with marines, officers and their families. Britain’s gaols and prison hulks had been overflowing since the American colonies stopped taking transported felons. Most of those aboard had been sentenced for theft. After eight months and more than fifteen thousand miles, by way of Tenerife, Rio de Janeiro and the Cape, the fleet reached Botany Bay in January 1788 and moved a few days later to Sydney Cove.

Seen from elsewhere. The land was home to the Eora and their neighbours, who were neither consulted nor offered a treaty. An epidemic, probably smallpox, killed a great part of the Sydney people in 1789; its origin is still argued. Many Aboriginal Australians mark 26 January, the landing date, as Invasion Day or a day of mourning.

1846

The United States declares war on Mexico

Washington, D.C., United StatesThe Americas

On 13 May 1846 President James Polk signed the act of Congress declaring that a state of war existed with Mexico. Two days earlier he had told Congress that Mexican troops had ‘shed American blood upon the American soil’, after cavalry clashed on 25 April with a patrol he had sent into the strip between the Nueces and the Rio Grande, which both countries claimed. The House voted 174 to 14 and the Senate 40 to 2. American armies took Monterrey, Veracruz and, in September 1847, Mexico City. By the treaty of 1848 Mexico gave up California, New Mexico and its claim to Texas, about half its territory.

Seen from elsewhere. Mexico remembers the war as the North American intervention, an invasion to seize land, and honours the cadets who died defending Chapultepec. The young congressman Abraham Lincoln demanded to know the exact spot where blood was shed, and Ulysses Grant, who fought in it, called it one of the most unjust wars a stronger nation ever waged on a weaker.

1917

Three children report a vision at Fatima

Cova da Iria, Fatima, PortugalEurope

On 13 May 1917 three children minding sheep near the village of Fatima, Lucia dos Santos, aged ten, and her cousins Francisco and Jacinta Marto, nine and seven, said that a lady brighter than the sun had appeared above a small oak and asked them to return on the thirteenth of each month. Word spread, and by 13 October a crowd of tens of thousands stood in the rain, many of whom reported that the sun seemed to spin and plunge. Portugal’s anticlerical republic was hostile, and in August a local official briefly detained the children. Francisco and Jacinta died in the influenza pandemic; Lucia became a nun and lived until 2005.

Seen from elsewhere. The Church declared the visions worthy of belief in 1930 and canonised the two younger children in 2017. Sceptics note that the three ‘secrets’ are known only from memoirs Lucia wrote from 1935 onwards, and attribute the October reports to staring at the sun and to expectation. Witnesses in the crowd did not all see the same thing, and some saw nothing.

1969

The 13 May riots in Kuala Lumpur

Kuala Lumpur, MalaysiaAsia

Three days after a general election in which the ruling Alliance lost ground to mainly Chinese opposition parties, and after noisy opposition victory parades through the capital, supporters of the main Malay party gathered on the evening of 13 May 1969 at the residence of the chief minister of Selangor for a counter-procession. Fighting broke out and spread through the city, with killing, arson and looting over several days. The official count was 196 dead, most of them Chinese. A state of emergency was declared, parliament was suspended for nearly two years and the country was run by a council under the deputy prime minister, Abdul Razak.

Seen from elsewhere. The official report blamed opposition provocation and communist agitators. Foreign diplomats and journalists at the time put the dead far higher, and Kua Kia Soong argued in 2007 from British records that the violence was used by a faction in the ruling party to remove the prime minister, Tunku Abdul Rahman. Discussion of the event in Malaysia remains constrained.

Also on 13 May