Parallax

20 May, 1498

Vasco da Gama anchors off Calicut

Ten months out of Lisbon, three small Portuguese ships reached the pepper coast of India. The first words spoken to them ashore, by a Tunisian who knew Spanish, were a curse and a question: what brought you here?

Calicut (Kozhikode), Malabar coast, India

Vasco da Gama left Lisbon on 8 July 1497 with four vessels and about 170 men. He swung far out into the Atlantic to pick up the westerlies, rounded the Cape of Good Hope in November, and worked up the east coast of Africa through a chain of Muslim trading cities whose rulers received him with suspicion at Mozambique and Mombasa and with calculated friendship at Malindi. There the sultan lent him a pilot who knew the monsoon. With the wind behind them the ships crossed the Arabian Sea in twenty-three days, sighted the mountains of India on 18 May 1498, and on the 20th anchored a few miles north of Calicut.

Da Gama sent ashore one of the convicts carried for dangerous errands. The man was taken to two merchants from Tunis, who greeted him in Castilian. The anonymous journal kept on the voyage records the exchange: ‘May the Devil take you! What brought you here?’ He answered that they had come to seek Christians and spices.

Calicut was the richest port of the Malabar coast, ruled by a Hindu king known as the Samudri Raja, or Zamorin, and thronged with Arab, Persian, Gujarati and local Muslim traders who carried its pepper and ginger to the Red Sea. The Portuguese, expecting to find the Christians of legend, took the Hindus for them. On the way to the palace they knelt in a temple, supposing an image of a goddess to be the Virgin, though one of them muttered that if these were devils he was worshipping the true God.

The audience on 28 May began well and soured the next day, when da Gama laid out his presents for the king: striped cloth, hats, strings of coral, wash-basins, sugar, oil and honey. The Zamorin’s officials laughed, saying the poorest merchant from Mecca gave more, and that a king should send gold. Da Gama claimed the goods were his own and not his sovereign’s.

Three months of mutual distrust followed. The Portuguese could sell little, quarrelled over customs duties, and believed the Muslim merchants were plotting against them. Each side detained men of the other. Da Gama sailed at the end of August with a modest cargo of spices and several captives. The return crossing against the monsoon took three months and scurvy killed so many that one ship had to be burned for want of hands. Two ships and some fifty-five men reached Portugal in the summer of 1499.

How it came to this

For most of the fifteenth century Portuguese ships had been feeling their way down the Atlantic coast of Africa, trading in gold and enslaved people and looking for a sea road to the East. Spices reached Europe through Muslim hands, by way of the Red Sea, Mamluk Egypt and Venice, and the Portuguese crown wanted both the profit and a Christian ally in the legendary Prester John. Bartolomeu Dias rounded the southern tip of Africa in 1488. King Manuel I, who came to the throne in 1495, chose da Gama, a minor nobleman in his late twenties or thirties, to finish the work.

The ocean he entered was not empty. A trading system centuries old linked East Africa, Arabia, India, the Malay world and China by the rhythm of the monsoon winds. It was largely in Muslim hands, though Hindus, Jews, Christians and others took part, and its ports generally lived by welcoming whoever came to buy. Chinese treasure fleets under Zheng He had called at Calicut early in the century. No power had tried to control the sea itself by force.

How each side saw it

The Zamorin’s court

No account of the visit from the Zamorin’s own court is known to survive, and what he said and thought comes to us through the Portuguese journal, whose author understood neither the language nor the religion. Read against the grain, it shows a ruler behaving as the lord of a free port should: he received the strangers, allowed them to trade, required them to pay duties like anyone else, and saw nothing in their goods or gifts to justify special treatment. His letter to King Manuel, as the journal gives it, offered cinnamon, cloves, ginger and pepper in exchange for gold, silver, coral and scarlet cloth.

The Muslim merchants of Malabar

The fullest Malabar Muslim account is the Tuhfat al-Mujahidin of Zainuddin Makhdum, written in Arabic some eighty years later. It describes the Portuguese as intruders who arrived as traders and quickly turned to seizing ships, burning mosques and killing pilgrims, and it calls on Muslim rulers to fight them. The merchants of 1498 were right to fear for their livelihood: on his second voyage, in 1502, da Gama demanded that the Zamorin expel every Muslim from Calicut, and burned a pilgrim ship returning from Mecca with several hundred people on board, as a Portuguese eyewitness, Tome Lopes, recorded.

The Portuguese crown

To Manuel I the voyage was a providential triumph. He wrote at once to Ferdinand and Isabella of Spain announcing the discovery of India and its Christians, and added to his titles ‘Lord of the Conquest, Navigation and Commerce of Ethiopia, Arabia, Persia and India’. Portuguese tradition, crowned by Camoes’s epic The Lusiads in 1572, made da Gama a national hero who opened the world’s seas by courage and seamanship. The navigational achievement was real: the Atlantic loop he sailed was the longest passage out of sight of land that any European ship had yet made.

Modern Asian historians

The Indian diplomat and historian K. M. Panikkar named the four and a half centuries from 1498 to 1945 the ‘Vasco da Gama epoch’ of Western maritime dominance over Asia. Sanjay Subrahmanyam has taken apart both the Portuguese heroic legend and the idea of an instant revolution, showing a violent, improvising captain and an Asian trade that long outweighed anything the Portuguese carried. When Portugal proposed joint celebrations of the five-hundredth anniversary in 1998, there were protests in Kerala and Goa and the Indian government stayed away.

What is disputed

The pilot from Malindi is often named as the great Arab navigator Ahmad ibn Majid. The identification rests on a later Meccan chronicler and is rejected by most specialists; the Portuguese sources describe a Gujarati. The landing place is disputed between Kappad, where a monument stands, and nearby Pantalayini. The author of the voyage journal is unknown, though Alvaro Velho is the usual guess. The often-repeated claim that the cargo repaid the cost sixty times over has no firm documentary basis. And ‘discovery’ describes only the European view of a route into waters that others had sailed for a thousand years.

What followed

A second fleet under Cabral bombarded Calicut in 1500. Within fifteen years the Portuguese had seized Goa, Malacca and Hormuz and were requiring Asian ships to buy passes or be sunk, a claim to own the sea that was new to the Indian Ocean. They never controlled the spice trade, but they showed that armed ships could force their way into it, and the Dutch, English and French followed. Da Gama died at Cochin in 1524 as viceroy. Portuguese rule in Goa lasted until India took it by force in 1961.

Read further

  • A Journal of the First Voyage of Vasco da Gama, 1497-1499, translated by E. G. Ravenstein (1898)
  • Sanjay Subrahmanyam, The Career and Legend of Vasco da Gama (1997)
  • K. M. Panikkar, Asia and Western Dominance (1953)
  • Zainuddin Makhdum, Tuhfat al-Mujahidin
  • M. N. Pearson, The Portuguese in India (1987)

Same day, other years

AD 325

The Council of Nicaea opens

Nicaea, Bithynia (Iznik, Turkey)Middle East

The emperor Constantine, newly master of the whole Roman world, summoned the bishops of the Church at public expense to settle a dispute that had begun in Alexandria. The priest Arius taught that the Son of God was created by the Father and was therefore not eternal in the same sense. Some 250 to 300 bishops attended, nearly all from the Greek East. Under the emperor’s eye they adopted a creed declaring the Son ‘of one substance’ with the Father, set a common rule for the date of Easter, and issued twenty canons on church order. Arius and two bishops who would not sign were exiled.

Seen from elsewhere. The opening date of 20 May comes from the fifth-century historian Socrates; other evidence points to June. The council did not end the argument. Constantine recalled Arius within a few years, and versions of his teaching held the imperial court for decades and the Gothic kingdoms for centuries. Contrary to a common belief, Nicaea did not decide which books belong in the Bible.

1802

Bonaparte’s law restores slavery in the French colonies

Paris, France, and the French CaribbeanThe Americas

The French Republic had abolished slavery in 1794, pushed by the great rising of the enslaved in Saint-Domingue. On 30 Floreal Year X, a day after the law founding the Legion of Honour, the legislature passed a short act for First Consul Bonaparte: slavery would be maintained in the colonies returned by Britain under the Peace of Amiens, such as Martinique, where abolition had never been applied, and the slave trade would resume. Secret instructions went further. In Guadeloupe an expedition under General Richepance re-enslaved the population by force that summer. The officer Louis Delgres and several hundred followers blew themselves up at Matouba sooner than surrender.

Seen from elsewhere. Bonaparte’s defenders note that the law’s wording preserved slavery only where it still existed and that he acted under pressure from planters and merchants. News from Guadeloupe convinced the Black generals of Saint-Domingue that the same was planned for them; they destroyed the French army and declared Haiti independent in 1804. France abolished slavery again in 1848.

1902

The Cuban flag is raised over Havana

Havana, CubaThe Americas

At noon the American military governor, Leonard Wood, handed power to Tomas Estrada Palma, first president of the Republic of Cuba, and the United States flag came down from the Morro castle. Cubans had fought Spain for independence on and off since 1868. The United States intervened in 1898, defeated Spain in a few months, and then occupied the island for more than three years. The price of withdrawal was the Platt Amendment, which the Cuban constitutional convention accepted by a narrow vote in 1901: it gave Washington the right to intervene to preserve order and to lease naval stations, one of which was Guantanamo Bay.

Seen from elsewhere. American officials pointed to the roads, schools and the defeat of yellow fever that the occupation left behind. Many Cuban veterans felt cheated of the victory. US troops returned in 1906. Since the revolution of 1959 the Cuban state has dismissed the 1902 republic as a neo-colony and does not celebrate the date; Cuban exiles in Florida do.

2002

East Timor becomes independent

Dili, East Timor (Timor-Leste)Asia

At midnight the United Nations flag was lowered in Dili and the half-island of East Timor became the first new state of the century, with the former guerrilla leader Xanana Gusmao as president. A Portuguese colony for four centuries, it had been invaded by Indonesia in December 1975, days after declaring independence. Timor’s own truth commission later estimated that at least 102,800 people died from killing, hunger and illness during the twenty-four-year occupation, from a population of well under a million. In a UN-run ballot in 1999, 78.5 per cent voted to separate. Militias backed by the Indonesian army then burned much of the territory before an Australian-led force arrived.

Seen from elsewhere. Indonesia had presented the 1976 annexation as integration requested by the Timorese, and the United States and Australia, wary of the left-wing Fretilin party, acquiesced. Indonesian courts acquitted or freed every officer tried over 1999. A joint commission in 2008 accepted that Indonesian institutions bore responsibility, and both governments chose reconciliation over prosecution.

Also on 20 May