Parallax

28 May, 1358

The Jacquerie begins on the Oise

Villagers north of Paris killed nine noblemen in an afternoon. Within a fortnight thousands were under arms, more than a hundred castles had been attacked, and the nobility of northern France was riding to take a revenge far bloodier than the revolt.

Saint-Leu-d’Esserent, France

On 28 May 1358 men from several villages along the river Oise gathered at Saint-Leu-d’Esserent, a small town with a priory and stone quarries about thirty miles north of Paris. A party of noblemen was there, apparently to hold the river crossing for the regent of France. The villagers attacked them and killed nine, four knights and five squires. Nobody recorded what was said beforehand. The chroniclers agree only that the killing was sudden and that the news spread at once.

Within days the countryside of the Beauvaisis was in arms, and the movement ran on into Picardy, the plain north of Paris and the edges of Champagne and Normandy. Bands of villagers, sometimes hundreds strong, marched under banners and went from manor to manor. They burned houses, drove off or killed noble families, and in some places forced reluctant gentlemen to ride with them as captains. They chose a general leader, Guillaume Cale, a man from the village of Mello whom the chroniclers describe as well spoken and handsome, and who tried to keep order and to find allies.

He found one in Paris. Etienne Marcel, the provost of the merchants, had controlled the capital since February, when his followers had killed two royal marshals in front of the eighteen-year-old regent. Marcel sent townsmen out to help pull down castles around the city, though he later wrote that he deplored the killing.

On 9 June a force of Parisians and peasants entered Meaux, where the townspeople had laid out food for them in the streets. The regent’s wife, his infant daughter and some three hundred ladies were sheltering in a fortified market on a bend of the Marne. Two great lords riding home from a crusade in Prussia happened to be there, the Count of Foix and the Captal de Buch, who served opposite sides in the war with England. They charged out across the bridge with a few dozen mounted men. The crowd, packed in a narrow street, was cut to pieces, and the town was burned.

The next day, near Mello, Charles of Navarre faced Cale’s main army. He invited Cale to talks and seized him when he came; the leaderless force was ridden down. Cale was beheaded at Clermont, by some accounts after being crowned with a ring of red-hot iron. Then came what historians call the counter-Jacquerie. For weeks bands of nobles burned villages across the region and hanged or cut down peasants, with little regard for whether they had taken part.

How it came to this

France in 1358 had no king at home. John II had been captured by the English at Poitiers in September 1356, along with much of the nobility, and their ransoms fell on the tenants. Government passed to his teenage son Charles, who was short of money and at odds with the Estates General, with the Parisians under Marcel, and with his cousin Charles of Navarre, a claimant to the throne. A truce with England had left thousands of soldiers unpaid. They formed companies that seized castles and lived by ransoming the countryside. The plague of 1348-49 was only a decade past.

Country people had expected the nobility to protect them and had watched it lose a battle and then fail to defend the villages. In May 1358 the regent, preparing to blockade Paris, ordered local lords to put their castles in a state of defence and to hold the rivers, measures that meant fresh demands for labour and supplies. The name Jacques Bonhomme was the nobles’ own contemptuous word for the peasant, perhaps taken from the padded jacket, the jacque, that villagers wore as armour.

How each side saw it

The noble chroniclers

Jean le Bel of Liege, and Jean Froissart who copied him, wrote for aristocratic patrons and tell the revolt as a nightmare. Their rebels are ‘wicked people’ without leaders or reason, small and dark and badly armed, who meant to destroy all gentlefolk. They report rape, the murder of children and a knight roasted on a spit before his wife. Their relish for the slaughter at Meaux is undisguised: Froissart says the peasants were killed like animals and puts the dead there at more than seven thousand, a number no modern historian accepts.

Jean de Venette

The Carmelite friar Jean de Venette, born in a village near Compiegne and himself of peasant family, wrote the account closest to the rebels’ point of view. He condemns the killing of noble women and children as monstrous. But he explains it. The nobles, he says, had given the country no protection, and had oppressed the peasants and taken their goods as if they were enemies. He adds that the lords’ revenge did more damage to France than the English had, and that many of those killed in it were innocent.

The rebels, through their pardons

No Jacque left a statement of aims. What survives is several hundred letters of remission, royal pardons issued from August 1358, which summarise each petitioner’s story in the crown’s words. In them men claim to have been forced to join by their neighbours, name the manor they helped burn and list what they lost. Read against the grain, they show village assemblies, elected captains and a range of rural trades: the rebels included stonecutters, coopers, minor royal officials and a few priests. They rarely mention the atrocities the chroniclers describe.

Paris and Etienne Marcel

Marcel’s letters to the towns of Flanders, written that summer, present the rising as the fault of nobles who had failed the kingdom and were now plundering it. He admitted sending men to destroy fortresses that threatened the capital’s food supply, and insisted he had forbidden the murder of women and children. To the regent’s party he was the hidden hand behind the whole affair. He was killed at a city gate on 31 July 1358 by Parisians who believed he was about to let Navarre’s English mercenaries into the city.

What is disputed

Was it a spontaneous outburst of misery, as Simeon Luce argued in 1859, or an organised movement tied to the Parisian revolution? Raymond Cazelles stressed the artisans and officials among the rebels; Justine Firnhaber-Baker’s recent study finds deliberate military planning and a good deal of local improvisation. The atrocity stories rest almost wholly on Jean le Bel and cannot be confirmed from legal records, which name only a few dozen noble victims. Figures of twenty thousand peasants killed in the reprisals come from the same chroniclers. The date of 28 May is the usual one, though some sources place the first violence a few days earlier.

What followed

The crown pardoned both sides in August, in general terms, and lawsuits over burned manors ran on for years. The regent, who became Charles V in 1364, rebuilt royal authority and taxation, and northern France saw no rural rising on this scale again before 1789. The word jacquerie entered French, and then English, as the general term for a peasant revolt. Nineteenth-century writers, from Michelet to the socialists, made Jacques Bonhomme an ancestor of the Revolution, while conservatives quoted Froissart. Each reading says as much about its own century as about 1358.

Read further

  • Justine Firnhaber-Baker, The Jacquerie of 1358: A French Peasants’ Revolt (2021)
  • Jean de Venette, The Chronicle of Jean de Venette, translated by Jean Birdsall (1953)
  • Jean Froissart, Chronicles, translated by Geoffrey Brereton (1968)
  • Jonathan Sumption, The Hundred Years War, Volume 2: Trial by Fire (1999)
  • Samuel K. Cohn, Lust for Liberty: The Politics of Social Revolt in Medieval Europe, 1200-1425 (2006)

Same day, other years

585 BC

An eclipse stops a battle in Anatolia

Near the river Halys, AnatoliaMiddle East

Herodotus says that the Lydians under Alyattes and the Medes under Cyaxares had been at war for five years when, during a battle in the sixth, day turned suddenly to night. Both armies stopped fighting and their kings made peace, sealed by a marriage, with the river Halys as the frontier. He adds that Thales of Miletus had told the Ionians beforehand of the year in which it would happen. Astronomers calculating backwards find a total eclipse of the sun crossing Anatolia late in the day on 28 May 585 BC. If the identification is right, it is the earliest battle in history that can be dated to the day.

Seen from elsewhere. Many scholars doubt it. No method known in Thales’s time could predict where a solar eclipse would be visible, so the forecast may be a later legend attached to a famous name. Others question whether the battle belongs to 585 at all, proposing a different eclipse or a different reading of the Median king list.

1830

Andrew Jackson signs the Indian Removal Act

Washington, DC, United StatesThe Americas

The act President Jackson signed on 28 May 1830 authorised him to negotiate with Native nations living east of the Mississippi for the exchange of their lands for territory in the west. It had passed the House by only five votes after weeks of debate. In form it provided for voluntary treaties. In practice the following decade saw the Choctaw, Creek, Chickasaw, Seminole and Cherokee nations, and many northern peoples, moved under pressure or by force, some sixty thousand people or more from the south-east alone. On the Cherokee removal of 1838-39 an estimated four thousand died in the stockades and on the road.

Seen from elsewhere. Jackson told Congress the policy was generous and would save the tribes from extinction. The Cherokee, who had a written constitution and a newspaper, fought it in the Supreme Court and won in 1832, to no effect. Their chief John Ross gathered thousands of signatures against a removal treaty signed by a small unauthorised faction. Opponents in Congress called the act a breach of national faith.

1871

The last barricade of the Paris Commune falls

Paris, FranceEurope

The Commune, the revolutionary city government that had held Paris since March, ended on Sunday 28 May 1871 when the last barricades in the working-class districts of Belleville were taken by the army of the national government at Versailles. It was the seventh day of street fighting. The troops had entered from the west on 21 May and worked eastward, shooting prisoners as they went. On the 27th they fought among the tombs of Pere Lachaise cemetery and executed 147 captives against its wall. Behind the retreating Communards the Tuileries palace and the city hall burned. About forty thousand people were arrested, and thousands were later deported to New Caledonia.

Seen from elsewhere. The Versailles government saw an insurrection in wartime that had shot its hostages, including the Archbishop of Paris, and set fire to the capital. The left remembered a massacre. The number killed in the week was long put at twenty to thirty thousand; Robert Tombs has argued from burial records for six to seven and a half thousand, which other historians contest.

1991

Rebel forces enter Addis Ababa

Addis Ababa, EthiopiaAfrica

Tanks of the Ethiopian People’s Revolutionary Democratic Front rolled into Addis Ababa at dawn on 28 May 1991 and took the presidential palace after a few hours’ fighting. It was the end of the Derg, the military regime that had overthrown Haile Selassie in 1974 and ruled through the Red Terror, forced resettlement and the famine of 1983-85. Its leader, Mengistu Haile Mariam, had flown to Zimbabwe a week earlier. The Front was a coalition built around the Tigrayan guerrilla movement of Meles Zenawi, who governed Ethiopia until his death in 2012. Eritrean fighters had taken Asmara four days before, and Eritrea voted for independence in 1993.

Seen from elsewhere. Many in the capital feared a northern army with Marxist roots, and crowds protested against the American mediator who had endorsed its entry. The federal system of ethnic regions that the victors introduced is seen by supporters as recognition of Ethiopia’s peoples and by critics as the root of later wars. Mengistu, convicted of genocide in his absence, remains in Zimbabwe.

Also on 28 May