Parallax

8 May, 1884

Harry Truman is born in a Missouri farm town

The son of a mule trader, with no college degree and a failed shop behind him, he became president by accident at sixty and within four months had ordered the use of the atomic bomb.

Lamar, Missouri, United States

Harry Truman was born on 8 May 1884 in a small white frame house in Lamar, a farm town in south-western Missouri. His father, John Truman, dealt in horses and mules and used the lot across the street as a yard. The baby was named Harry after an uncle. The middle initial S stood for nothing: it was a way of honouring both grandfathers, Anderson Shipp Truman and Solomon Young, without choosing between them.

The family moved several times and settled in Independence, near Kansas City. Harry was a short-sighted boy in thick glasses who was kept out of rough games, read history and practised the piano before school. There was no money for college after his father lost everything speculating in grain. He worked as a railway timekeeper and a bank clerk, and then for eleven years ran his grandmother’s farm at Grandview, ploughing behind a team.

The First World War took him to France as captain of an artillery battery of unruly Kansas City Irishmen, who to his surprise came to like him. Back home he married Bess Wallace and opened a men’s clothing shop with an army friend. It failed in the slump of 1921-22, and he spent fifteen years paying off the debts. Politics was what remained. The Kansas City machine of Tom Pendergast, a famously corrupt organisation, needed a clean candidate with a war record for a county office, and later for the Senate, where he arrived in 1935 to be called the senator from Pendergast. He made his name during the next war running a committee that exposed waste in arms contracts.

In 1944 party leaders who thought Vice-President Henry Wallace too radical put Truman on the ticket in his place. He was vice-president for eighty-two days and saw Franklin Roosevelt alone twice. On the afternoon of 12 April 1945 he was summoned to the White House, where Eleanor Roosevelt told him the president was dead. He asked what he could do for her. By his own account she answered that it was he who was in trouble now.

He learned the full details of the atomic bomb project only after taking the oath. On 8 May 1945, his sixty-first birthday, he announced Germany’s surrender to the nation by radio. Three months later, on his authority, American aircraft destroyed Hiroshima and Nagasaki. He always said that the decision had cost him no sleep.

How it came to this

Missouri had been a slave state that stayed in the Union, and its western border was fought over by irregulars on both sides before and during the Civil War. Truman’s people were Southern in sympathy. All four of his grandparents had come from Kentucky and had owned slaves. In 1863 a Union general ordered the rural population of several border counties out of their homes, and his mother, then a child, was among those turned out. She never forgave it. Visiting the White House as an old woman, she is said to have refused to sleep in Lincoln’s bed.

The country he was born into was still largely one of farms and small towns, and its government was small. By the time he reached the presidency the United States had been through the Depression and the New Deal, was the richest and most heavily armed state on earth, and was about to become the only one with nuclear weapons. Roosevelt, ill and secretive, had told his vice-president almost nothing about the war, the bomb, or what he had agreed with Stalin and Churchill at Yalta.

How each side saw it

Survivors of Hiroshima and Nagasaki

The two bombs killed, by the usual estimates, between 110,000 and 210,000 people by the end of 1945, the great majority civilians, among them many thousands of Korean forced labourers. The survivors, known as hibakusha, have recorded their testimony for eight decades and have campaigned for abolition of nuclear weapons; their organisation, Nihon Hidankyo, received the Nobel Peace Prize in 2024. Many of them hold that no military purpose could justify the attacks, and note that Truman spoke of Hiroshima as a military base. No serving American president visited the city until Barack Obama in 2016, and none has apologised.

The Soviet Union

Moscow had reason to distrust him from the start. In June 1941, as a senator, Truman had told a reporter that if Germany was winning America ought to help Russia and if Russia was winning it ought to help Germany, and so let them kill as many as possible. As president he cut off wartime aid abruptly, announced in 1947 a doctrine of supporting governments against communist pressure, and built the Western alliance. Soviet histories, and some later Russian ones, make him the principal author of the Cold War and regard the bombs as a warning addressed to Stalin.

Black Americans

Truman used racial slurs in private letters all his life, and in the 1920s had dealings with the Ku Klux Klan in Jackson County whose extent is disputed. Yet as president, shaken by attacks on returning Black servicemen such as the blinding of Sergeant Isaac Woodard by a police chief in 1946, he appointed a civil rights committee, became the first president to address the NAACP, and in July 1948 ordered an end to segregation in the armed forces. The labour leader A. Philip Randolph had threatened a campaign of draft resistance. Southern Democrats walked out of the party, and Black voters helped re-elect him.

His American contemporaries and later opinion

Many who knew Roosevelt thought his successor a small man out of his depth, and the press wrote off his chances in 1948 until the morning after the vote. The stalemate in Korea, his dismissal of General Douglas MacArthur in 1951 and scandals among his associates pushed his approval in the polls to the lowest then recorded. He went home to Independence by train with no pension. His standing rose after his death, and polls of historians now tend to place him in the first ten presidents, a judgment some consider as overdone as the earlier contempt.

What is disputed

The bomb decision remains the argument. The traditional case, made by Truman and Henry Stimson and defended by historians such as Richard Frank, is that it ended the war quickly and avoided an invasion of Japan. Gar Alperovitz and others have argued that Japan was close to surrender and that the bombs were aimed partly at impressing the Soviet Union. Tsuyoshi Hasegawa holds that the Soviet declaration of war weighed more with Tokyo than Hiroshima did. Truman’s later claim that an invasion would have cost half a million American lives exceeds the estimates his planners gave him in June 1945, as Barton Bernstein showed. His story of dressing down Molotov in April 1945 is not borne out by official notes.

What followed

Truman served until January 1953. The institutions set up under him, among them the Marshall Plan, NATO, the Central Intelligence Agency and the National Security Council, shaped American foreign policy for the rest of the century, as did the precedent of fighting a war in Korea without a declaration by Congress. He recognised the state of Israel minutes after its proclamation in 1948, against the advice of his secretary of state. He died in Kansas City on 26 December 1972, aged eighty-eight. Missouri keeps his birthday as a state holiday.

Read further

  • David McCullough, Truman (1992)
  • Alonzo L. Hamby, Man of the People: A Life of Harry S. Truman (1995)
  • Harry S. Truman, Memoirs, Volume 1: Year of Decisions (1955)
  • Tsuyoshi Hasegawa, Racing the Enemy: Stalin, Truman, and the Surrender of Japan (2005)
  • Gar Alperovitz, The Decision to Use the Atomic Bomb (1995)

Same day, other years

1794

Lavoisier goes to the guillotine

Paris, FranceEurope

Antoine Lavoisier, who had named oxygen, shown that matter is conserved in chemical reactions and helped design the metric system, was tried in the morning with twenty-seven other former tax farmers and beheaded the same afternoon on the Place de la Revolution. He was fifty. His father-in-law died a few minutes before him. The men had been shareholders in the General Farm, the private company that collected the old monarchy’s taxes on salt, tobacco and goods entering Paris, and were convicted of defrauding the nation. The mathematician Lagrange is reported to have said that it took only a moment to cut off that head, and a hundred years might not produce another like it.

Seen from elsewhere. To the revolutionaries he died as a financier, not a scientist. The Farm was among the most hated institutions of the old order, and Lavoisier had promoted the customs wall around Paris. The remark attributed to the judge, that the Republic had no need of scholars, is probably a later invention. His widow and collaborator, Marie-Anne, recovered his papers and published them.

1902

Mount Pelee destroys Saint-Pierre

Saint-Pierre, MartiniqueThe Americas

A few minutes before eight in the morning a cloud of superheated gas and ash burst from the side of Mount Pelee and rolled down over Saint-Pierre, the commercial capital of the French colony of Martinique. The town of stone warehouses, theatres and rum distilleries was destroyed in about two minutes, and ships at anchor burned. Some 28,000 to 30,000 people died. Two men within the town are known for certain to have lived, one of them a prisoner, Ludger Sylbaris, in a thick-walled cell. The volcano had been throwing out ash for a fortnight, and a mudflow had killed workers at a sugar mill three days earlier. The governor, who had come with his wife to calm the population, died with them.

Seen from elsewhere. It has long been said that officials kept people in town for an election due that Sunday. Historians accept that an official commission gave false reassurance, but point out that the kind of eruption that struck was unknown to science, and that country people were fleeing into Saint-Pierre for safety. Blame was coloured by the island’s bitter politics of race.

1945

A victory parade in Setif ends in massacre

Setif and Guelma, AlgeriaAfrica

On the day Europe celebrated Germany’s surrender, several thousand Algerian Muslims marched in the market town of Setif, some carrying banners calling for independence and the release of the nationalist leader Messali Hadj. Police tried to seize a flag and shot a young man, Bouzid Saal. Rioting spread through the surrounding countryside, and about a hundred European settlers were killed over the following days. The French response lasted for weeks: army sweeps, bombing of villages from the air, shelling from a cruiser offshore, and summary executions by settler militias around Guelma. The number of Algerians killed is put at anywhere from a few thousand to 45,000.

Seen from elsewhere. French authorities described the restoration of order after the murder of settlers, and gave about 1,500 dead; the Algerian state uses 45,000; many historians suggest between 6,000 and 20,000. Algerians, many of whose sons had fought for France, date the road to the war of 1954 from this day. France’s ambassador called it an inexcusable tragedy in 2005.

1963

Shots are fired at a Buddhist crowd in Hue

Hue, South VietnamAsia

On the Buddha’s birthday, the government of President Ngo Dinh Diem, a Catholic ruling a largely Buddhist country, enforced a ban on flying religious flags, days after Vatican flags had been displayed in the same city for the anniversary of his brother, the archbishop. That evening a crowd gathered at the radio station in Hue to protest when a monk’s broadcast was cancelled. Troops and police moved in with armoured cars; there were explosions and gunfire; eight or nine people died, several of them children. The protests that followed, including the public self-immolation of the monk Thich Quang Duc in June, turned Washington against Diem. He was overthrown and murdered by his own generals in November.

Seen from elsewhere. Diem’s government insisted that a Viet Cong explosive had caused the deaths and that communists were steering the movement, a view a few American writers shared. Witnesses and doctors blamed the security forces. The officer in charge, Dang Sy, was convicted after the coup and maintained that his men had used only concussion grenades.

Also on 8 May