Parallax

18 May, 1152

Eleanor of Aquitaine marries Henry of Anjou

Eight weeks after the king of France let her go, the richest heiress in Europe married his most dangerous vassal, a man about ten years her junior, without asking anyone’s leave.

Poitiers, Aquitaine (France)

On 21 March 1152 a council of French bishops at Beaugency declared that the marriage of King Louis VII and Eleanor, duchess of Aquitaine, had never been valid, because the two were related within the degrees forbidden by the Church. They had been married for nearly fifteen years and had two daughters, who stayed with their father. Eleanor kept her duchy, a great wedge of south-western France running from the Loire to the Pyrenees, and set out for her capital at Poitiers.

The journey showed what a duchess without a husband was worth. According to a chronicle of Tours, Count Theobald of Blois tried to seize her as she passed, and she slipped away by night; further on, the seventeen-year-old Geoffrey of Anjou laid an ambush at a river crossing, and she took another road. Either man, by forcing a marriage, would have made himself duke of Aquitaine.

Safe in Poitiers, she sent word to Geoffrey’s elder brother. Henry was nineteen, already duke of Normandy and count of Anjou, and through his mother, the Empress Matilda, a claimant to the throne of England. He had been at the French court the previous August, when he and Eleanor would have seen each other. He came south at once, and on Whit Sunday, 18 May, they were married in Poitiers, quietly and without the display their rank would normally have required. No chronicler describes the ceremony. Eleanor was about twenty-eight.

The match broke every rule that had just been applied to her first marriage. Henry was more closely related to her than Louis had been. As vassals of the French crown, neither had the right to marry without the king’s consent, and Louis had certainly not consented to see half his kingdom pass to the Angevins. He summoned Henry to answer for it, was ignored, and invaded Normandy that summer with a coalition that included Henry’s brother Geoffrey and King Stephen’s son Eustace. Henry beat them off in a matter of weeks.

Within the year Eleanor had given birth to a son, which she had not managed in all her time with Louis. In 1153 Stephen recognised Henry as his heir, and in December 1154 the couple were crowned at Westminster. A single household now ruled from the Scottish border to the Pyrenees.

How it came to this

Eleanor inherited Aquitaine in 1137, at about thirteen, when her father Duke William X died on pilgrimage. Within months she was married to the heir to France, who became Louis VII almost at once. The court at Paris, shaped by the austere piety of men such as Abbot Suger and Bernard of Clairvaux, was a different world from the south, and the couple produced only a daughter in their first decade.

In 1147 Eleanor went with Louis on the Second Crusade. At Antioch she sided with her uncle, Prince Raymond, in a quarrel over strategy, and declared that she wished to stay there and that her marriage was unlawful because of kinship. Louis removed her by force. Gossip about her and Raymond followed her for the rest of her life. Pope Eugenius III tried to reconcile the pair on their way home, and a second daughter was born, but a king needed a son. By 1152 Louis’s advisers were ready to use the kinship argument she had raised first.

How each side saw it

Louis VII and the French court

For the Capetians the remarriage was both an insult and a strategic disaster. Louis had given up Aquitaine in the expectation that a male heir from a new wife would outweigh the loss, and that Eleanor’s next husband would be chosen with his agreement. Instead his former wife’s lands were joined to Normandy and Anjou, encircling the small royal domain round Paris. French chroniclers treated the marriage as a breach of the fealty Henry owed. The Capetian response, sustained for half a century, was to work on the Angevin family’s quarrels until Louis’s son Philip Augustus took Normandy and Anjou in 1204.

The clerical chroniclers

Almost everything written about Eleanor in her own century comes from churchmen who disapproved of her. William of Newburgh says she pressed for the annulment, complaining that she had married a monk and not a king. John of Salisbury, who was at the papal court, gives the sober account of Antioch. Walter Map and Gerald of Wales, writing later and with grudges against Henry’s family, add that she had slept with Henry’s father. None of them was present at Poitiers, and none shows much interest in what she herself wanted. Her own voice survives mainly in charters.

Aquitaine

For the barons and towns of the south, the question was who would rule them and how closely. Eleanor’s first acts after the annulment were charters issued in her own name as duchess, some cancelling grants Louis had made. Her marriage replaced a distant Parisian overlord with an energetic Angevin one, and the nobles of Poitou and the Limousin rebelled against Henry and later against their son Richard repeatedly. Troubadour verse of the period praises her, but the duchy’s loyalty was to its own dynasty, of which she was the last direct heir, and not to either of her husbands.

Modern historians

Recent biographers such as Ralph Turner and Jean Flori read the marriage as a calculated alliance between two people who each needed the other: she a protector strong enough to keep her duchy intact, he the resources to win England. Michael Evans has shown how much of the familiar Eleanor, the adulteress, the patron of ‘courts of love’, the poisoner of Henry’s mistress Rosamund, was added by later centuries. Historians of women point out that her freedom of action in 1152 was real but brief, and that it depended on choosing a husband quickly.

What is disputed

Her year of birth is given as 1122 or 1124; the later date, argued by Andrew Lewis, is now more often preferred. Whether she or Louis’s counsellors drove the annulment is not settled, and nor is the suggestion that she and Henry reached an understanding in Paris in 1151. The story of an affair with Henry’s father rests on hostile gossip written decades later. The romantic passion that popular histories attach to the wedding has no contemporary evidence behind it: the sources record a date, a place and the political consequences, and nothing else.

What followed

Eleanor bore Henry eight children, among them the future kings Richard I and John. In 1173 she backed her sons’ rebellion against their father, was caught, and spent some fifteen years in confinement in England. Released on Henry’s death in 1189, she governed for Richard while he was on crusade and in captivity, and was still travelling on royal business in her late seventies. She died in 1204 and lies at Fontevraud. The claim of English kings to her duchy kept the two crowns at odds until the end of the Hundred Years War in 1453.

Read further

  • Ralph V. Turner, Eleanor of Aquitaine: Queen of France, Queen of England (2009)
  • Jean Flori, Eleanor of Aquitaine: Queen and Rebel (2007)
  • Bonnie Wheeler and John Carmi Parsons (eds), Eleanor of Aquitaine: Lord and Lady (2003)
  • W. L. Warren, Henry II (1973)
  • Michael R. Evans, Inventing Eleanor: The Medieval and Post-Medieval Image of Eleanor of Aquitaine (2014)

Same day, other years

1291

Acre falls to the Mamluks

Acre, Kingdom of Jerusalem (Israel)Middle East

After six weeks of bombardment by one of the largest siege trains the medieval world had seen, the army of the Mamluk sultan al-Ashraf Khalil broke through the walls of Acre at dawn. The port was the last major city of the crusader kingdom founded in 1099. The master of the Temple, William of Beaujeu, was killed at the breach. Those who could not fight their way to the overcrowded ships were killed or enslaved, and the Templars’ fortified compound by the sea held out for ten more days before it collapsed on defenders and attackers alike. The remaining Frankish towns on the coast were given up within weeks.

Seen from elsewhere. Arabic writers, among them Abu al-Fida, who served in the besieging army, presented the conquest as the completion of Saladin’s work and as repayment for Richard I’s massacre of the Muslim garrison of Acre a century earlier. The immediate cause they give is the killing of Muslim traders in the city in 1290 by newly arrived Italian crusaders.

1944

The Crimean Tatars are deported

Crimea, Soviet UnionEurope

Before dawn, troops of the Soviet security police under Lavrenty Beria began knocking on doors across Crimea, which the Red Army had retaken from the Germans a few weeks earlier. Families were given minutes to pack and were loaded into sealed goods wagons. In three days the entire Crimean Tatar population, about 190,000 people by the police’s own count, was sent to Uzbekistan and the Urals, accused as a nation of collaborating with the occupier. Men serving in the Red Army were removed from their units and sent after them. Many died on the trains and many more in the first years of exile, from hunger and disease.

Seen from elsewhere. Soviet records put deaths at roughly a fifth of the deportees; a survey by Tatar activists in the 1960s claimed nearly half. Some Tatars had served in German-raised battalions, as had members of every occupied nationality. A decree of 1967 withdrew the blanket accusation but return was barred until 1989. Ukraine and several other states call the deportation genocide; Russia does not.

1974

India explodes a nuclear device

Pokhran, Rajasthan, IndiaAsia

A plutonium device was detonated in a shaft under the Thar desert, and Prime Minister Indira Gandhi’s government announced that India had carried out a ‘peaceful nuclear explosion’. The test, later nicknamed Smiling Buddha, made India the first state outside the five permanent members of the UN Security Council to demonstrate a nuclear explosive. The plutonium came from a research reactor supplied by Canada and moderated with American heavy water, both provided for civil use. India put the yield at about twelve kilotons; outside analysts have suggested considerably less. India did not test again until 1998.

Seen from elsewhere. Canada suspended nuclear cooperation, and the supplier states formed a group to tighten export rules. India replied that the Non-Proliferation Treaty froze a world of nuclear haves and have-nots, and pointed to China’s bomb of 1964. In Pakistan, where a weapons programme had begun in 1972, the test was taken as a direct threat and the effort was speeded up.

1980

Paratroopers attack students in Gwangju

Gwangju, South KoreaAsia

The day after General Chun Doo-hwan extended martial law across South Korea, closed the universities and arrested opposition leaders including Kim Dae-jung, students gathered at the gate of Chonnam National University. Special forces troops set on them, and on bystanders, with clubs and bayonets. Over the next days the city rose: taxi and bus drivers led convoys against the army lines, citizens seized weapons from police stations, and on 21 May, after soldiers fired into a crowd, the troops withdrew. Gwangju governed itself for five days. The army retook it before dawn on 27 May.

Seen from elsewhere. Chun’s government called the rising a riot stirred up by communists and by Kim Dae-jung, who was sentenced to death and later reprieved. Official counts give about 200 dead; bereaved families have long said the real number is far higher. Chun was convicted in 1996. Claims that North Korean agents led the uprising have been rejected by successive inquiries.

Also on 18 May