On 21 March 1152 a council of French bishops at Beaugency declared that the marriage of King Louis VII and Eleanor, duchess of Aquitaine, had never been valid, because the two were related within the degrees forbidden by the Church. They had been married for nearly fifteen years and had two daughters, who stayed with their father. Eleanor kept her duchy, a great wedge of south-western France running from the Loire to the Pyrenees, and set out for her capital at Poitiers.
The journey showed what a duchess without a husband was worth. According to a chronicle of Tours, Count Theobald of Blois tried to seize her as she passed, and she slipped away by night; further on, the seventeen-year-old Geoffrey of Anjou laid an ambush at a river crossing, and she took another road. Either man, by forcing a marriage, would have made himself duke of Aquitaine.
Safe in Poitiers, she sent word to Geoffrey’s elder brother. Henry was nineteen, already duke of Normandy and count of Anjou, and through his mother, the Empress Matilda, a claimant to the throne of England. He had been at the French court the previous August, when he and Eleanor would have seen each other. He came south at once, and on Whit Sunday, 18 May, they were married in Poitiers, quietly and without the display their rank would normally have required. No chronicler describes the ceremony. Eleanor was about twenty-eight.
The match broke every rule that had just been applied to her first marriage. Henry was more closely related to her than Louis had been. As vassals of the French crown, neither had the right to marry without the king’s consent, and Louis had certainly not consented to see half his kingdom pass to the Angevins. He summoned Henry to answer for it, was ignored, and invaded Normandy that summer with a coalition that included Henry’s brother Geoffrey and King Stephen’s son Eustace. Henry beat them off in a matter of weeks.
Within the year Eleanor had given birth to a son, which she had not managed in all her time with Louis. In 1153 Stephen recognised Henry as his heir, and in December 1154 the couple were crowned at Westminster. A single household now ruled from the Scottish border to the Pyrenees.
How it came to this
Eleanor inherited Aquitaine in 1137, at about thirteen, when her father Duke William X died on pilgrimage. Within months she was married to the heir to France, who became Louis VII almost at once. The court at Paris, shaped by the austere piety of men such as Abbot Suger and Bernard of Clairvaux, was a different world from the south, and the couple produced only a daughter in their first decade.
In 1147 Eleanor went with Louis on the Second Crusade. At Antioch she sided with her uncle, Prince Raymond, in a quarrel over strategy, and declared that she wished to stay there and that her marriage was unlawful because of kinship. Louis removed her by force. Gossip about her and Raymond followed her for the rest of her life. Pope Eugenius III tried to reconcile the pair on their way home, and a second daughter was born, but a king needed a son. By 1152 Louis’s advisers were ready to use the kinship argument she had raised first.