On the morning of 23 May 1498 three friars were led out of the Palazzo della Signoria on to a raised walkway that ran across the square to a scaffold. Girolamo Savonarola, prior of San Marco, was forty-five. With him were Fra Domenico da Pescia, his most devoted lieutenant, and Fra Silvestro Maruffi, a visionary whose trances he had trusted.
The ceremony had three stages. First a bishop stripped them of their Dominican habits and degraded them from the priesthood. His early biographers report that the bishop, flustered, declared Savonarola separated from the Church militant and the Church triumphant, and that the friar corrected him: from the Church militant only, the other was not in his power. Next the papal commissioners pronounced them heretics and schismatics and handed them to the secular arm. Finally the city’s magistrates passed sentence of death.
They were hanged one at a time from a tall gibbet shaped, to the unease of the crowd, something like a cross, Savonarola last. The pyre beneath was then lit. Some in the square jeered; a man is said to have shouted that the prophet should now work a miracle. Boys threw stones at the bodies as they burned. Luca Landucci, an apothecary who had believed in the friar, wrote in his diary that the remains were carted to the Ponte Vecchio and tipped into the Arno, down to the last handful of ash, so that no relic should be found. Women were nonetheless seen collecting floating cinders.
The fall had been quick. On 7 April a Franciscan challenge to an ordeal by fire, which Fra Domenico had eagerly accepted, drew the whole city to the square and ended, after hours of wrangling and a cloudburst, with nobody walking through the flames. The crowd felt cheated and blamed Savonarola. The next evening a mob stormed San Marco. He was arrested, and over the following weeks examined under the strappado, the rope that hoists a man by his wrists tied behind his back.
Under torture he signed a confession that his prophecies had not come from God and that he had sought worldly glory. He withdrew it, and confessed again. When the text was read out publicly, Landucci recorded that his soul was grieved to see such an edifice fall.
How it came to this
Savonarola, born in Ferrara in 1452, came to Florence as a Dominican teacher and by 1491 was prior of San Marco and the most compelling preacher in the city. His sermons announced that the Church would be scourged and renewed, and soon. When Charles VIII of France invaded Italy in 1494 and the Medici, who had managed Florence for sixty years, were driven out, it seemed that he had foretold it. He met the French king, helped to spare the city a sack, and became the moral authority behind a new republic with a broad Great Council.
He preached that Florence would be the new Jerusalem, with Christ as its king. Bands of boys went from house to house collecting dice, wigs, cosmetics, carnival masks and indecent pictures, which were burned in ‘bonfires of vanities’ at carnival in 1497 and 1498. He also denounced the corruption of Rome under Pope Alexander VI, ignored a summons, was forbidden to preach, and in May 1497 was excommunicated. In February 1498 he went back into the pulpit and began writing to princes to urge a council that would depose the pope.