Parallax

23 May, 1498

Savonarola is hanged and burned in Florence

For four years a Dominican friar had ruled the conscience of the richest city in Italy and defied a Borgia pope. He died in the square where his followers had burned their mirrors and playing cards, and his ashes were thrown into the river so that nobody could keep them.

Piazza della Signoria, Florence, Italy

On the morning of 23 May 1498 three friars were led out of the Palazzo della Signoria on to a raised walkway that ran across the square to a scaffold. Girolamo Savonarola, prior of San Marco, was forty-five. With him were Fra Domenico da Pescia, his most devoted lieutenant, and Fra Silvestro Maruffi, a visionary whose trances he had trusted.

The ceremony had three stages. First a bishop stripped them of their Dominican habits and degraded them from the priesthood. His early biographers report that the bishop, flustered, declared Savonarola separated from the Church militant and the Church triumphant, and that the friar corrected him: from the Church militant only, the other was not in his power. Next the papal commissioners pronounced them heretics and schismatics and handed them to the secular arm. Finally the city’s magistrates passed sentence of death.

They were hanged one at a time from a tall gibbet shaped, to the unease of the crowd, something like a cross, Savonarola last. The pyre beneath was then lit. Some in the square jeered; a man is said to have shouted that the prophet should now work a miracle. Boys threw stones at the bodies as they burned. Luca Landucci, an apothecary who had believed in the friar, wrote in his diary that the remains were carted to the Ponte Vecchio and tipped into the Arno, down to the last handful of ash, so that no relic should be found. Women were nonetheless seen collecting floating cinders.

The fall had been quick. On 7 April a Franciscan challenge to an ordeal by fire, which Fra Domenico had eagerly accepted, drew the whole city to the square and ended, after hours of wrangling and a cloudburst, with nobody walking through the flames. The crowd felt cheated and blamed Savonarola. The next evening a mob stormed San Marco. He was arrested, and over the following weeks examined under the strappado, the rope that hoists a man by his wrists tied behind his back.

Under torture he signed a confession that his prophecies had not come from God and that he had sought worldly glory. He withdrew it, and confessed again. When the text was read out publicly, Landucci recorded that his soul was grieved to see such an edifice fall.

How it came to this

Savonarola, born in Ferrara in 1452, came to Florence as a Dominican teacher and by 1491 was prior of San Marco and the most compelling preacher in the city. His sermons announced that the Church would be scourged and renewed, and soon. When Charles VIII of France invaded Italy in 1494 and the Medici, who had managed Florence for sixty years, were driven out, it seemed that he had foretold it. He met the French king, helped to spare the city a sack, and became the moral authority behind a new republic with a broad Great Council.

He preached that Florence would be the new Jerusalem, with Christ as its king. Bands of boys went from house to house collecting dice, wigs, cosmetics, carnival masks and indecent pictures, which were burned in ‘bonfires of vanities’ at carnival in 1497 and 1498. He also denounced the corruption of Rome under Pope Alexander VI, ignored a summons, was forbidden to preach, and in May 1497 was excommunicated. In February 1498 he went back into the pulpit and began writing to princes to urge a council that would depose the pope.

How each side saw it

His followers, the Piagnoni

To the ‘weepers’, as their enemies called them, Savonarola was a prophet and martyr killed by a corrupt pope and a rigged tribunal. They held that the notary had falsified the confession. Friars of San Marco preserved his writings and scraps of relics, and medals with his image circulated within years. Saints of the next century, Philip Neri and Catherine de’ Ricci among them, venerated him privately. His supporters returned to power in the last Florentine republic of 1527-30, which again proclaimed Christ king. In 1997 the archdiocese of Florence opened an inquiry with a view to his beatification.

Pope Alexander VI and Rome

The papal case was about obedience more than doctrine. A friar had refused a summons to Rome, resisted the reorganisation of his convent, preached while excommunicated, and called on kings to summon a council against the reigning pope, all while keeping Florence loyal to the French invader whom the pope’s Italian league was trying to expel. Alexander threatened the city with interdict, which would have exposed Florentine merchants’ goods to seizure everywhere. Later Catholic judgement has been divided: some of his sermons were placed on the Index in 1559, but his teaching was never formally condemned as heretical.

His Florentine opponents

The Arrabbiati, the ‘enraged’, and the young bloods who called themselves the Compagnacci resented a city where friars and children policed dress and amusements, and where policy was made from the pulpit. They pointed to the costs: Pisa lost, trade endangered, Florence isolated in Italy. Many also remembered that in 1497 five prominent citizens accused of plotting a Medici return were executed without the right of appeal that Savonarola himself had championed. Machiavelli, who heard him preach, drew the cool moral in The Prince that unarmed prophets come to grief when the people stop believing.

Protestants and their critics

Martin Luther had the meditation on the psalm Miserere that Savonarola wrote in prison printed at Wittenberg in 1523, with a preface claiming him as a witness to justification by faith. Protestant tradition placed him among the forerunners of the Reformation, and his statue sits at the foot of the Luther monument in Worms. Catholic scholars reply that he was an orthodox follower of Thomas Aquinas who attacked the morals of the papal court and never its doctrines, the sacraments or the authority of the office itself.

What is disputed

The trial record is unreliable: the notary, Ser Ceccone, was accused at the time of altering the confession, and words obtained by torture prove little either way. Historians still divide on whether Savonarola believed his own prophecies to the end; Donald Weinstein thought he did. The story that he refused absolution to the dying Lorenzo de’ Medici is contradicted by an eyewitness. The tale that Botticelli burned his own paintings on the bonfires comes from Vasari decades later and is unproven. Nineteenth-century liberals such as Pasquale Villari made him a champion of republican liberty, a reading later scholars find one-sided.

What followed

The republic he had helped to shape survived him by fourteen years, until the Medici returned with Spanish troops in 1512. Five days after the execution the young Niccolo Machiavelli was put forward for the chancery post in which he learned his politics. The questions Savonarola raised about a worldly papacy were asked again, far more dangerously, by Luther within twenty years. A round plaque in the pavement of the Piazza della Signoria marks the place of the pyre, and each 23 May Florentines scatter flowers on it.

Read further

  • Donald Weinstein, Savonarola: The Rise and Fall of a Renaissance Prophet (2011)
  • Lauro Martines, Scourge and Fire: Savonarola and Renaissance Italy (2006)
  • Luca Landucci, A Florentine Diary from 1450 to 1516, translated by Alice de Rosen Jervis (1927)
  • Roberto Ridolfi, The Life of Girolamo Savonarola (1959)
  • Pasquale Villari, Life and Times of Girolamo Savonarola (1888)

Same day, other years

1618

Two governors are thrown from a window in Prague

Prague Castle, Bohemia (Czech Republic)Europe

A party of Protestant noblemen led by Count Thurn climbed to the Bohemian chancellery in Prague Castle and confronted the Catholic regents who governed for the Habsburg king. They accused two of them, Vilem Slavata and Jaroslav Martinic, of violating the Letter of Majesty of 1609, which guaranteed Protestant worship, after churches at Broumov and Hrob were closed or demolished. After a shouted trial lasting minutes, both men and their secretary, Philipp Fabricius, were pushed out of a window some twenty metres above the castle ditch. All three survived and got away. The rebels set up their own government, and the war that followed lasted thirty years.

Seen from elsewhere. Catholics said the Virgin Mary or angels had caught the falling men. Protestants said they landed on a dung heap, a detail that appears only in later tellings; the sloping bank and heavy cloaks are likelier explanations. The emperor ennobled Fabricius with a title meaning ‘of the high fall’.

1844

A young merchant of Shiraz declares himself the Bab

Shiraz, Persia (Iran)Middle East

On the evening of 22 May, which by Islamic reckoning already belonged to the next day, a twenty-four-year-old merchant named Sayyid Ali Muhammad told a travelling scholar, Mulla Husayn, that he was the Bab, the ‘Gate’ to the hidden Imam whose return Shia Muslims await. He later claimed to be that promised figure himself and to bring a new revelation. Within a few years his movement had spread across Persia and alarmed both clergy and crown. The Bab was shot by a firing squad in Tabriz in 1850. One of his followers, later known as Baha’u’llah, founded the Baha’i Faith, which dates its calendar from this night.

Seen from elsewhere. Shia jurists judged the claim apostasy, and the Qajar state, facing armed Babi risings and an attempt on the shah’s life in 1852, killed thousands of believers. The Islamic Republic of Iran does not recognise Baha’is as a religious minority; more than two hundred have been executed since 1979 and they are barred from universities.

1951

Tibetan delegates sign the Seventeen Point Agreement

Beijing, ChinaAsia

Seven months after the People’s Liberation Army destroyed the small Tibetan force at Chamdo, a delegation from Lhasa led by Ngapoi Ngawang Jigme, the governor who had surrendered there, signed an agreement in Beijing ‘on measures for the peaceful liberation of Tibet’. It stated that Tibet was returning to the family of the Chinese motherland. In exchange Beijing promised regional autonomy and undertook not to alter the existing political system, the position of the Dalai Lama or the monasteries. Chinese troops entered Lhasa that autumn. The Dalai Lama, then fifteen, heard the terms on the radio. His government telegraphed its acceptance in October.

Seen from elsewhere. China treats the document as the lawful basis of its sovereignty and celebrates the date. The Tibetan government in exile says the delegates had no authority to sign, did so under threat of further invasion, and used seals made for them in Beijing. The Dalai Lama repudiated the agreement in 1959 after fleeing to India.

1960

Ben-Gurion announces that Eichmann is in Israel

Jerusalem, IsraelMiddle East

In a statement of two sentences to a stunned Knesset, Prime Minister David Ben-Gurion said that Adolf Eichmann, one of the chief organisers of the deportation of Europe’s Jews to the death camps, had been found by the Israeli security services, was under arrest in Israel and would be tried there. Agents of the Mossad had seized him twelve days earlier on a street in a suburb of Buenos Aires, where he had lived since 1950 as Ricardo Klement, and flown him out drugged on an El Al airliner. The trial in Jerusalem in 1961 heard more than a hundred survivors. Eichmann was hanged in 1962.

Seen from elsewhere. Argentina protested at the violation of its sovereignty, and the UN Security Council asked Israel to make reparation; the two states settled the matter within months. Critics, including some Jewish jurists, questioned a trial of a kidnapped man under a retroactive law. Hannah Arendt’s portrait of a thoughtless bureaucrat has been challenged by historians who find a convinced Nazi.

Also on 23 May