Parallax

7 May, 1915

A single torpedo sinks the Lusitania

The fastest liner on the Atlantic went down in eighteen minutes within sight of Ireland, taking nearly twelve hundred people with her. Germany called her a legitimate target, Britain called it murder, and both were hiding something.

Off the Old Head of Kinsale, Ireland

The Cunard liner Lusitania left New York for Liverpool on 1 May 1915 with close to two thousand people aboard. That morning several New York newspapers carried a notice from the Imperial German Embassy, in some cases printed beside Cunard’s own advertisement, reminding travellers that a state of war existed and that British ships in the waters around the British Isles were liable to destruction. Few passengers changed their plans. The ship was the pride of the British merchant fleet and could outrun any submarine afloat.

Six days later she was approaching the south coast of Ireland. To save coal, one of her four boiler rooms had been shut down for months, which cut her top speed, and Captain William Turner had slowed further that morning in fog. The Admiralty had signalled that submarines were active in the area. One of them, U-20 under Kapitanleutnant Walther Schwieger, had sunk three vessels there in two days and was low on fuel and torpedoes, about to turn for home.

At ten past two in the afternoon, in bright sunshine about eleven miles off the Old Head of Kinsale, Schwieger fired one torpedo from some seven hundred metres. It struck the starboard side below the bridge. Seconds later a second and heavier explosion shook the ship from within. She listed so sharply that the boats on one side swung inboard and those on the other hung too far out to reach. Power failed, trapping people in the lifts. Of forty-eight lifeboats only six got away in good order. Schwieger noted in his war diary that there was great confusion on board and that he could not have fired a second torpedo into such a crowd of people trying to save themselves.

The Lusitania sank in eighteen minutes. Fishing boats and tugs from Kinsale, Courtmacsherry and Queenstown took hours to arrive, and the water was cold enough to kill within that time. Of about 1,960 people aboard, close to 1,200 died, including 128 citizens of the neutral United States and most of the children and infants. The millionaire Alfred Vanderbilt and the theatre producer Charles Frohman were among them. Captain Turner was washed off the bridge and survived.

Bodies came ashore along the Irish coast for weeks. Well over a hundred victims, many of them never identified, were buried in mass graves outside Queenstown, now Cobh.

How it came to this

At the outbreak of war in 1914 Britain used its navy to cut Germany off from overseas trade, declaring the North Sea a war zone and treating food as contraband. Germans called it a hunger blockade aimed at civilians. In February 1915 Germany answered by declaring the seas around the British Isles a war zone in which enemy merchant ships would be sunk without warning. The older rules of war required a raider to stop a merchantman and see the crew to safety first. A submarine that surfaced to do so could be rammed or shot at, and British masters had been told to try.

The Lusitania had been built in 1907 with a government loan on the understanding that she could be taken up as an armed cruiser in wartime, and naval reference books listed her as such. In 1915 she was carrying no guns. Her cargo did include about 4.2 million rifle cartridges, some 1,250 cases of shrapnel shells and a quantity of fuses, all recorded on the manifest and legal under American law. To the German navy that made her a munitions carrier. To her passengers she was the Atlantic ferry.

How each side saw it

The German government and navy

Berlin’s position was that the ship was a British naval auxiliary carrying ammunition to kill German soldiers, that travellers had been publicly warned, and that Britain was sheltering war cargo behind civilians while starving German children with its blockade. German newspapers hailed a success. A Munich medallist, Karl Goetz, struck a satirical medal showing Death selling Cunard tickets; British propagandists copied it in the hundreds of thousands as proof of German gloating. Privately the chancellor and the foreign office were alarmed, and within months the Kaiser ordered that large passenger liners should not be attacked.

The British government and Admiralty

Britain presented the sinking as the deliberate murder of civilians and made it central to recruiting. Lord Mersey’s official inquiry blamed Germany alone and held that two torpedoes had struck, which helped keep attention away from the cargo. Behind the scenes Admiralty officials tried to fix responsibility on Captain Turner for ignoring instructions to zigzag and keep to mid-channel. The Admiralty’s code-breakers had been tracking U-20, and no escort was provided; how much of that was known to those who could have acted on it was not disclosed to the inquiry.

The United States

American opinion was outraged, and divided over what to do. Theodore Roosevelt called it piracy and demanded action. President Wilson said three days later that there was such a thing as a man being too proud to fight, and sent Germany a series of notes insisting on the right of Americans to travel in safety. His secretary of state, William Jennings Bryan, thought the notes one-sided, since Britain was also breaking the rules and passengers should not ride on ships carrying munitions. He resigned in June. German-Americans and Irish-Americans largely shared Bryan’s view.

Survivors and the people of the coast

The coroner at Kinsale, John Horgan, opened an inquest the next day, heard survivors and the captain, and had his jury return a verdict of wilful murder against the submarine’s officers, the German emperor and his government, before an Admiralty message arrived to stop the proceedings. Survivors’ testimony is full of anger at the failure of the boats and at how long help took. Many lost whole families. In the days afterwards mobs in Liverpool, London and other cities wrecked shops with German names, and the government began interning German men.

What is disputed

The second explosion has been blamed on the munitions, on coal dust in empty bunkers and on a burst boiler or steam line; most recent studies favour the last, and divers have found no sign that the cargo detonated. Whether the Admiralty deliberately left the ship exposed to bring America into the war was argued by Colin Simpson in 1972 and entertained by the intelligence historian Patrick Beesly; Thomas Bailey and Paul Ryan, and later Diana Preston, found negligence and no plot. Churchill had written that February of the value of attracting neutral shipping in the hope of embroiling the United States with Germany. The death toll is given as between 1,195 and 1,201.

What followed

The sinking did not bring the United States into the war, which it joined almost two years later, in April 1917, after Germany resumed unrestricted submarine attacks and offered Mexico an alliance. It did fix an image of Germany in American minds that made that decision easier. Schwieger died when his next boat was lost with all hands in 1917. The wreck lies in about ninety metres of water. The question it raised, when a ship carrying both civilians and war material may be attacked, has not been resolved by any later law of war.

Read further

  • Thomas A. Bailey and Paul B. Ryan, The Lusitania Disaster (1975)
  • Diana Preston, Wilful Murder: The Sinking of the Lusitania (2002)
  • Colin Simpson, Lusitania (1972)
  • Patrick Beesly, Room 40: British Naval Intelligence 1914-18 (1982)
  • Erik Larson, Dead Wake: The Last Crossing of the Lusitania (2015)

Same day, other years

1763

Pontiac tries to take Fort Detroit by surprise

Detroit, Great Lakes regionThe Americas

The Odawa leader Pontiac entered the British fort at Detroit with several hundred men for what was announced as a council. According to the accounts of the garrison they carried shortened muskets under their blankets and were to strike at a signal. The commander, Major Henry Gladwin, had been warned, by whom is not known, and had his soldiers standing armed. Pontiac gave no signal and withdrew. Two days later he began a siege that lasted until autumn, while warriors of a dozen nations captured eight other British posts from the Great Lakes to the Ohio country. The rising led London to issue the Proclamation of 1763, closing the lands beyond the Appalachians to settlement.

Seen from elsewhere. The peoples of the region held that France, lately defeated, had never owned their country and could not hand it to Britain, whose general Amherst had also ended customary gifts of powder. Amherst discussed spreading smallpox by infected blankets, and blankets from a smallpox hospital were given out at Fort Pitt. Historians differ on how far Pontiac directed the wider war.

1824

Beethoven’s Ninth Symphony is heard for the first time

Vienna, AustriaEurope

At the Karntnertor Theatre, an orchestra and chorus that had managed only two full rehearsals gave the first performance of a symphony with a sung finale, a setting of Schiller’s ode To Joy. Beethoven, who had not appeared at a concert in twelve years and could hear almost nothing, stood by the conductor Michael Umlauf, turning pages and beating time; the players had been told to follow Umlauf. When the audience broke into applause the composer was still facing the orchestra, and the contralto Caroline Unger turned him round to see it. Accounts differ on whether this was after the scherzo or at the end. The takings, after expenses, were small.

Seen from elsewhere. Early critics were split, and the composer Louis Spohr thought the choral finale tasteless. The work has since been claimed by nearly everyone: it was played for Hitler’s birthday and at the fall of the Berlin Wall, served as the anthem of white-ruled Rhodesia, and is now the anthem of the European Union.

1954

The French garrison at Dien Bien Phu is overrun

Dien Bien Phu, VietnamAsia

After a siege of fifty-six days, the Viet Minh under General Vo Nguyen Giap overran the last positions of the fortified camp that France had built in a remote valley near the Laotian border to draw them into open battle. The French command had assumed that heavy guns could not be brought through the mountains. Tens of thousands of porters hauled them there, piece by piece, and dug them into the slopes above the airstrip. Some eleven thousand defenders were marched into captivity: Frenchmen, Foreign Legionnaires, North and West Africans, Vietnamese and Tai. Fewer than half came back. The Geneva conference took up Indochina the next day and in July divided Vietnam at the seventeenth parallel.

Seen from elsewhere. Vietnam celebrates a victory that showed a colonised people could defeat a European army, and Algerian nationalists took the lesson within months. French veterans blamed the politicians and a flawed plan. The United States, which was paying most of the war’s cost, weighed air strikes and declined. Viet Minh losses were far heavier than the garrison’s.

1999

NATO bombs hit the Chinese embassy in Belgrade

Belgrade, YugoslaviaEurope

Six weeks into NATO’s air campaign against Yugoslavia over Kosovo, an American B-2 bomber dropped five satellite-guided bombs on the Chinese embassy in Belgrade shortly before midnight. Three Chinese journalists were killed, Shao Yunhuan, Xu Xinghu and Zhu Ying, and about twenty people were injured. Washington said the intended target was a Yugoslav arms procurement agency a few hundred metres away and that the CIA, which had nominated it, had used an out-of-date map. President Clinton apologised. The United States later paid compensation to the families and for the building, and the CIA dismissed one officer.

Seen from elsewhere. China has never accepted that it was an accident; crowds besieged American missions in Beijing and other cities for days. Two European newspapers reported that the embassy was struck deliberately because it was relaying Yugoslav military signals, which NATO denied. The campaign itself had no mandate from the UN Security Council.

Also on 7 May