Parallax

24 May, 1626

The Dutch ‘buy’ Manhattan

The most famous property deal in American history rests on one sentence in a letter written in Amsterdam. It gives a price, sixty guilders, and nothing else: no date, no deed, no list of goods, and no word from the people who are supposed to have sold.

Manhattan, New Netherland (New York)

Peter Minuit stepped ashore at the mouth of the Hudson on 4 May 1626. He was a Protestant of Walloon family from Wesel on the Rhine, in middle age, and he had been in the Dutch West India Company’s small colony of New Netherland once before. He found it in trouble. The settlers were scattered in handfuls from the Delaware to the upper Hudson, the provisional director Willem Verhulst was hated and soon to be sent home, and at Fort Orange, far upriver, the commander had just got himself and three of his men killed by joining a Mahican war party against the Mohawks.

The council chose Minuit to take charge. He decided to gather the colonists in one defensible place, and the place was the southern tip of the long island the local people called Mannahatta. It had a superb harbour, it commanded the river that brought down the beaver pelts, and an engineer, Cryn Fredericks, was already staking out a fort there.

The Company’s instructions were explicit that land must not be taken from the Indians by force or trickery but acquired with their consent, by payment. At some point that spring or summer, Minuit or his predecessor made such an arrangement with a group of the Munsee-speaking Lenape who lived, hunted and planted on and around the island.

What we know of it comes from a letter dated 5 November 1626. Pieter Schaghen, a delegate of the Dutch parliament to the Company, reported that the ship Arms of Amsterdam had arrived from New Netherland, having sailed on 23 September. The colonists, he wrote, were in good heart; their women had borne children there; and ‘they have purchased the Island Manhattes from the Indians for the value of 60 guilders’, an area he gave as 11,000 morgens. He went on to list the cargo: 7,246 beaver skins, otter, mink and oak timber.

That is all. The payment would have been in goods, as in the surviving deed for Staten Island of 1630, which lists kettles, axes, hoes, cloth and awls. The beads and trinkets of legend were added by nineteenth-century storytellers, as was the figure of twenty-four dollars, a conversion made by a New York historian in the 1840s. By the end of 1626 some 270 Europeans were living in thirty bark-roofed houses round the unfinished Fort Amsterdam, and the Lenape were still living on the rest of the island.

How it came to this

Henry Hudson, an Englishman sailing for the Dutch, entered the river that bears his name in 1609, and Dutch traders followed for furs. The West India Company, chartered in 1621 chiefly to make war on Spain in the Atlantic, sent the first families of settlers in 1624, many of them French-speaking Walloon refugees. The colony was a commercial outpost, wedged between English Virginia and the new English settlement at Plymouth, and England denied that the Dutch had any right to be there.

The country round the harbour was Lenapehoking, the homeland of the Lenape, who lived in autonomous bands from the Delaware valley to the lower Hudson. They farmed maize, beans and squash, fished and hunted, and moved between sites with the seasons. Land was held by communities and its use could be granted to others, often in exchange for gifts and with the expectation of a continuing relationship. Nothing in their practice corresponded to the permanent transfer of exclusive ownership that a Dutch notary understood by a sale.

How each side saw it

The Lenape

The Lenape left no written record of 1626, and no Dutch writer set down what they said. The earliest Lenape tradition of the coming of the Dutch was recorded by the Moravian missionary John Heckewelder around 1800. It tells of strangers who asked for only as much land as a bullock’s hide would cover, then cut the hide into a thin strip and enclosed a large tract. The story is an old folk motif, but its meaning is plain. Present-day Lenape nations, now in Oklahoma, Wisconsin and Ontario, say their ancestors agreed to share the island and accepted gifts as allies, and did not sell their home.

The West India Company

For the Company, purchase was a matter of law and prudence. Its instructions to Verhulst in 1625 required that Indian claims be extinguished by agreement and that the transaction be recorded in a signed contract, because such a document could be shown to rival Europeans. Dutch jurists, Hugo Grotius among them, held that native peoples were true owners of their lands, which implied that title had to come from them and not from a royal charter or a papal grant. Sixty guilders in goods, a few months of a skilled workman’s wages, seemed to the directors a proper and economical way to secure it.

England

The English crown recognised neither party to the bargain. It claimed the whole coast by right of prior discovery, and regarded the Dutch as squatters and Indian deeds as worthless against a royal patent. English envoys said so to the Dutch government repeatedly from the 1620s. In 1664 Charles II granted the territory to his brother James, duke of York, and sent four frigates to take it. Peter Stuyvesant surrendered without a shot. In English eyes New York was not conquered from a lawful owner but recovered from intruders.

Modern historians

Scholars of New Netherland such as Jaap Jacobs, Paul Otto and Russell Shorto reject both the old comic tale of gullible natives and the simple charge of fraud. The Lenape, they argue, struck what looked to them like a good arrangement: useful metal goods and cloth, and an armed trading partner, in return for letting newcomers use land they themselves went on using. The injustice came later, when the Dutch and then the English enforced their own reading of the paper with fences, courts and soldiers. Surviving deeds show Lenape leaders ‘selling’ the same tracts more than once over the following decades, which suggests they understood such grants as renewable.

What is disputed

The date of 24 May has no documentary basis; it is a tradition, and the transaction can be placed only between Minuit’s arrival on 4 May and the ship’s departure on 23 September. Some historians think Verhulst concluded it before Minuit took over. Which Lenape band took part is unknown: an old story says the Canarsee of Brooklyn sold an island that was not theirs, but nothing supports it. No deed has been found. The 24 dollars is a nineteenth-century exchange-rate calculation, and attempts to state the price in modern money give answers from a few hundred dollars to many thousands.

What followed

Relations soured as the colony grew. In February 1643 Director Willem Kieft sent soldiers to massacre Lenape refugees camped at Pavonia and on Manhattan itself, killing about 120 men, women and children and beginning a war that emptied much of the region. Disease, war and further land cessions pushed the Lenape west in stages over two centuries. The wall the Dutch built across the island in 1653 gave its name to Wall Street. The purchase story became a national joke about a shrewd bargain, which is one reason historians and Lenape people keep returning to what was actually agreed.

Read further

  • Russell Shorto, The Island at the Center of the World (2004)
  • Paul Otto, The Dutch-Munsee Encounter in America (2006)
  • Jaap Jacobs, New Netherland: A Dutch Colony in Seventeenth-Century America (2005)
  • Robert S. Grumet, The Munsee Indians: A History (2009)
  • Edwin G. Burrows and Mike Wallace, Gotham: A History of New York City to 1898 (1999)

Same day, other years

1543

Copernicus dies as his book comes off the press

Frombork (Frauenburg), Royal Prussia, PolandEurope

Nicolaus Copernicus, a canon of the cathedral chapter of Warmia on the Baltic, died at seventy after a stroke. For some thirty years he had been working out a system in which the earth turns daily on its axis and travels yearly round the sun, and for most of that time he had declined to publish it. A young Lutheran mathematician, Georg Joachim Rheticus, finally talked him round and carried the manuscript to a printer in Nuremberg. According to a letter from his friend Bishop Tiedemann Giese, the finished copy of On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres reached Copernicus on the day he died.

Seen from elsewhere. The printed book opened with an unsigned preface, slipped in by the Lutheran theologian Andreas Osiander, telling readers the theory was only a calculating device. Giese was furious. Luther is reported to have scoffed at the idea in 1539. Rome took little notice until Galileo’s time, and placed the book on the Index in 1616, seventy-three years after its author’s death.

1822

Sucre wins Quito on the slopes of a volcano

Pichincha, Quito (Ecuador)The Americas

Antonio Jose de Sucre, Bolivar’s ablest general and twenty-seven years old, led about 3,000 men by night up the flank of the Pichincha volcano to get behind the Spanish defences of Quito. His army was drawn from much of the continent: Colombians and Venezuelans, a Peruvian division sent by San Martin, Argentines, and a battalion of British and Irish volunteers. At about 3,500 metres, in thin air and broken ground, they met the royalist force climbing to stop them. The fight lasted the morning. The Spanish commander, Melchor Aymerich, capitulated the next day, and the old Audiencia of Quito joined Bolivar’s Gran Colombia.

Seen from elsewhere. Most of the royalist rank and file were born in the Americas, and many Andean communities had no reason to prefer creole landowners to a distant king. The tribute paid by Indigenous people continued in independent Ecuador until 1857. The port of Guayaquil, which had wanted to govern itself, was annexed by Bolivar weeks later.

1915

The Allies accuse the Ottoman government of ‘crimes against humanity’

London, Paris and PetrogradMiddle East

As reports arrived of the deportation and killing of Armenians across Anatolia, Britain, France and Russia issued a joint declaration. In view of what it called new crimes of Turkey ‘against humanity and civilization’, it said, the Allied governments would hold personally responsible all members of the Ottoman government and those of its agents implicated in the massacres. The Russian draft had spoken of crimes against Christianity; the wording was broadened at French and British insistence. It was the first time states had used the phrase in a formal accusation against another government. The deportations continued. Estimates of Armenian deaths between 1915 and 1917 range from about 600,000 to 1.5 million.

Seen from elsewhere. The Ottoman government replied that it was exercising its sovereign right to defend itself against a revolutionary movement aided by its enemies, and blamed the Allies. Turkey still rejects the term genocide while acknowledging mass deaths during wartime relocation. Ottoman courts martial in 1919-20 condemned the chief organisers in their absence; the international trial the declaration promised never took place.

1993

Eritrea declares independence

Asmara, EritreaAfrica

Two years to the day after its fighters entered Asmara, the Eritrean People’s Liberation Front proclaimed an independent state, following a UN-observed referendum in April in which 99.8 per cent of voters chose separation from Ethiopia. Eritrea had been an Italian colony from 1890 and under British administration from 1941; the United Nations federated it with Ethiopia in 1952, and Emperor Haile Selassie annexed it outright in 1962. The war that followed lasted thirty years, outlived the emperor, and ended when Eritrean and Ethiopian rebel movements together brought down the military regime of Mengistu Haile Mariam. The Front’s leader, Isaias Afwerki, became president.

Seen from elsewhere. Ethiopia’s new government accepted the loss of its coastline, a decision many Ethiopians resented. A border war in 1998-2000 killed tens of thousands. Eritrea has held no national election since independence, its constitution has never been put into force, and a UN inquiry in 2016 accused its government of crimes against humanity, which it denies.

Also on 24 May