Parallax

5 May, 1821

Napoleon dies on St Helena

The former emperor of the French died in a damp farmhouse on a rock in the South Atlantic, a prisoner of the British. His will accused them of murder, and the argument over what killed him has not stopped.

Longwood House, St Helena

By the spring of 1821 Napoleon Bonaparte had been on St Helena for five and a half years. The island lies in the South Atlantic nearly two thousand kilometres from the African coast, and the house the British had given him, Longwood, stood on a windy plateau where the walls sweated and the rats ran under the floors. He had arrived a stout, energetic man of forty-six who rode, gardened and dictated his campaigns for hours. Since the previous autumn he had been failing: pain below the ribs, vomiting, a horror of food.

From the middle of March he kept to his bed. He had little faith in his own physician, a young Corsican anatomist named Antommarchi, and for a long time refused to see a British one, since the governor would use the doctor as a spy. At the start of April he at last admitted Archibald Arnott, an army surgeon, who for weeks reported that the illness was largely in the mind.

In mid-April he spent several days dictating and copying out a will. It asks that his ashes rest on the banks of the Seine among the French people he had loved so well. It declares that he dies before his time, murdered by the English oligarchy and its hired assassin. It leaves money to his companions and old soldiers, and a bequest to a man who had tried to shoot the Duke of Wellington. On 3 May the Abbe Vignali gave him the last rites.

On the evening of 4 May a gale blew across the plateau. Through the next day he lay unconscious, the household standing round the camp bed he had used on campaign: General Bertrand with his wife and children, the Comte de Montholon, the valet Marchand, the doctors. At eleven minutes to six on 5 May, as the sunset gun sounded, he stopped breathing. He was fifty-one.

Antommarchi opened the body the following afternoon in the billiard room, watched by seven British medical men. They found a large ulcerated growth in the stomach near its outlet, with a perforation sealed off by the liver. On 9 May, grenadiers carried the coffins, four nested one inside another, down to a valley he had chosen, beside a spring under some willows. The garrison lined the route. The slab over the grave was left blank: the French wanted the single word Napoleon, and the governor would permit only Napoleon Bonaparte.

How it came to this

After Waterloo in June 1815 Napoleon abdicated for the second time and made for the Atlantic coast, hoping to reach America. Finding the port blockaded, he went aboard HMS Bellerophon and wrote to the Prince Regent asking for the hospitality of the British people. The allied governments had already seen him leave one island exile, Elba, and march on Paris. They chose instead a place from which escape was close to impossible. St Helena belonged to the East India Company; a garrison of more than two thousand soldiers and a naval squadron were sent to guard one man.

With him went a small court of volunteers who quarrelled among themselves and wrote everything down. Relations with the governor, Sir Hudson Lowe, broke down within months over money, the limits of his rides, censored letters and Lowe’s insistence on addressing him as General Bonaparte, since Britain had never recognised the imperial title. They met only a handful of times. Napoleon used the captivity as his last campaign. The conversations he held with the Comte de Las Cases, published in 1823, presented him as a son of the Revolution and friend of peoples, chained to a rock by kings.

How each side saw it

The British government and Hudson Lowe

To Lord Liverpool’s ministry he was a prisoner of war whose return in 1815 had cost tens of thousands more lives, and whom the peace of Europe required to be kept securely. Lowe’s instructions were strict and he followed them to the letter. He was savaged in a book by Napoleon’s dismissed Irish surgeon, Barry O’Meara, in 1822, never managed to clear his name, and died poor. A defence compiled from his papers by William Forsyth in 1853 argues that he was a conscientious officer given an impossible charge and a captive determined to provoke him.

The companions and the Bonapartist legend

Bertrand, Montholon, Marchand, Gourgaud and Las Cases all left journals or memoirs, and all describe a great man slowly destroyed by climate, confinement and petty insult. Their accounts differ on a good deal, including his last words: Montholon reported ‘France, the army, head of the army, Josephine’, while Bertrand’s diary notes only broken mutterings. The books made a martyr of him. In France of the 1820s and 1830s, under kings he had despised, veterans, songwriters and print-sellers kept the image of the little corporal alive, and it carried his nephew to power in 1848.

Haiti and the French Caribbean

In the former slave colonies he is remembered first for 1802. In that year his government restored slavery where the Revolution had abolished it, and sent an army to Saint-Domingue that seized Toussaint Louverture and shipped him to die in a fortress in the Jura. The war that followed killed tens of thousands and ended with the independence of Haiti in 1804. In Guadeloupe and Martinique, monuments to the empire have been contested for years. At the bicentenary of his death in 2021 President Macron called the restoration of slavery a mistake and a betrayal of the spirit of the Enlightenment.

The peoples he fought

Across Europe the memory is of invasion as much as of reform. Spain dates its modern nationhood from the rising against his armies; Russia calls 1812 the Patriotic War; German nationalism took shape in the campaigns of 1813. Estimates of the dead in the wars that bear his name run from about three million to more than five million, soldiers and civilians. Against that, the legal codes and administrative systems he imposed outlasted him in much of the continent, and in Poland and parts of Italy he is remembered as having briefly restored a nation.

What is disputed

The cause of death. The doctors of 1821 concluded it was a cancerous stomach, the disease that killed his father. In 1961 the Swedish dentist Sten Forshufvud argued from the valet Marchand’s newly published memoirs, and from arsenic found in preserved hairs, that he had been slowly poisoned; Ben Weider later named Montholon as the culprit. Critics answer that arsenic was everywhere in the period, in medicines, hair preparations and the green wallpaper at Longwood. Italian physicists reported in 2008 that hairs from his boyhood, and from his son and Josephine, held similar levels. A 2007 pathology study found the autopsy consistent with advanced gastric cancer. His last words and the authenticity of the death masks are also contested.

What followed

In 1840 the government of King Louis-Philippe obtained British consent to bring the body home. The grave was opened that October in the presence of men who had buried him, and the remains were found well preserved. A frigate carried them to France, and on 15 December, in bitter cold, the coffin passed under the Arc de Triomphe to the Invalides, where it lies in a tomb completed in 1861. Longwood and the empty grave have been French state property since 1858. France still argues at every anniversary over whether to commemorate him, celebrate him or neither.

Read further

  • Emmanuel de Las Cases, Le Memorial de Sainte-Helene (1823)
  • Andrew Roberts, Napoleon the Great (2014)
  • Philip Dwyer, Napoleon: Passion, Death and Resurrection, 1815-1840 (2018)
  • Ben Weider and David Hapgood, The Murder of Napoleon (1982)
  • Thierry Lentz and Jean Mace, La mort de Napoleon: mythes, legendes et mysteres (2009)

Same day, other years

1260

Kublai is proclaimed Great Khan

Kaiping (Shangdu), Inner MongoliaAsia

The Great Khan Mongke had died the previous summer while campaigning in Sichuan. His brother Kublai, who commanded the Mongol armies in north China, did not wait for an assembly in the Mongolian homeland. He gathered his own supporters at Kaiping, the city he had built on the edge of the steppe and which Europeans later knew as Xanadu, and had himself acclaimed. The date usually given is 5 May 1260. A month later his youngest brother, Ariq Boke, was proclaimed at a rival assembly in Mongolia. Four years of civil war followed. Kublai won, founded the Yuan dynasty and in 1279 completed the conquest of China.

Seen from elsewhere. To many Mongol nobles Kublai’s assembly was irregular: held outside the homeland and without all the family’s branches. Ariq Boke stood for a steppe-centred empire against a brother who had gone over to Chinese ways. The surviving accounts were written for the winners, and the western khanates never fully accepted Kublai’s authority.

1862

A Mexican army stops the French at Puebla

Puebla, MexicoThe Americas

Mexico’s government under Benito Juarez, bankrupt after a civil war, had suspended payment of its foreign debts, and Napoleon III used the default as the occasion to send an army. On the road to the capital about six thousand French troops under the Comte de Lorencez attacked the forts of Loreto and Guadalupe above Puebla. General Ignacio Zaragoza’s smaller and poorly armed force, which included Indigenous militia from the nearby sierra, threw back three assaults. Zaragoza telegraphed that the national arms had covered themselves in glory. France sent reinforcements, took Puebla the next year and installed the Austrian archduke Maximilian as emperor. He was shot by a republican firing squad in 1867.

Seen from elsewhere. Mexican conservatives and much of the Church had invited the intervention, seeing Juarez’s laws against church property as an attack on religion and a monarchy as the cure for forty years of disorder. The anniversary is a modest holiday in Mexico outside Puebla; its large celebration began among Mexicans in California in the 1860s.

1936

Italian troops enter Addis Ababa

Addis Ababa, EthiopiaAfrica

Seven months after Mussolini’s armies invaded Ethiopia from Eritrea and Somalia, a motorised column under Marshal Pietro Badoglio drove into the capital. Emperor Haile Selassie had left by train for Djibouti three days earlier, and the city had been looted and burned in the interval. That evening Mussolini told a vast crowd in Rome that the war was over, and on 9 May he proclaimed an Italian empire. The conquest had been won with aircraft, artillery and mustard gas, which Italy had bound itself by treaty not to use. In June Haile Selassie went to Geneva and told the League of Nations that its own survival was at stake.

Seen from elsewhere. For most Italians it was the regime’s most popular hour, and the Italian state denied using gas until 1996. Ethiopians hold that the war never ended: resistance fighters known as the Patriots fought on through an occupation marked by mass reprisals, and the emperor re-entered his capital five years later to the day, on 5 May 1941.

1981

Bobby Sands dies on hunger strike

Maze Prison, Northern IrelandEurope

Bobby Sands, a 27-year-old member of the Provisional IRA serving fourteen years for possession of firearms, died in the prison hospital on the sixty-sixth day without food. He had begun the fast on 1 March to demand that republican prisoners be treated as political prisoners and not as ordinary criminals: their own clothes, no prison work, free association. In April, while starving, he was elected to the Westminster parliament for Fermanagh and South Tyrone with more than thirty thousand votes. Some hundred thousand people followed his coffin in Belfast. Nine more prisoners died before the strike was called off in October.

Seen from elsewhere. Margaret Thatcher told the Commons that Sands was a convicted criminal who chose to take his own life, a choice his organisation had not allowed many of its victims. Unionists and relatives of people killed by the IRA agreed. For republicans he is a martyr, and the election showed Sinn Fein a road into politics.

Also on 5 May