Parallax

9 May, 1892

Zita, the empress who never abdicated

Born in a Tuscan villa to a duke without a duchy, she reigned for two years over an empire at war, tried to end that war through her brothers, and then outlived her throne by seventy years.

Villa Pianore, near Viareggio, Italy

The child born at the Villa Pianore on 9 May 1892 was the seventeenth of the twenty-four children of Robert, Duke of Parma, who had lost his duchy to Italian unification when he was eleven. The family was not poor, whatever is sometimes said: Robert had inherited the chateau of Chambord and kept another great house at Schwarzau in Lower Austria, and his children moved between them by private train. Zita grew up speaking Italian, French, German and Portuguese, was schooled by nuns in Bavaria and on the Isle of Wight, and for a time thought of taking the veil herself.

In October 1911, at Schwarzau, she married Archduke Charles of Austria, a great-nephew of the Emperor Franz Joseph and then second in line to the throne. Three years later the heir, Franz Ferdinand, was shot dead at Sarajevo. Franz Joseph died in November 1916, in the third year of the war that followed, and Charles, aged twenty-nine, became Emperor of Austria and King of Hungary. Zita was twenty-four. On 30 December she sat beside him in Budapest as he was crowned with the crown of St Stephen.

Both were convinced that the monarchy could not survive a long war. In the spring of 1917 Zita’s brothers Sixtus and Xavier, who were serving as officers in the Belgian army, were brought secretly to the palace at Laxenburg. They left with a letter in Charles’s hand, dated 24 March, promising to support what he called France’s just claims to Alsace-Lorraine. The approach came to nothing, since Italy’s claims on Austrian territory could not be squared with it. A year later the French prime minister, Clemenceau, published the letter. Charles denied it, was not believed, and had to travel to German headquarters at Spa to bind his army more tightly to Germany’s. In Vienna and Berlin the empress was now spoken of as ‘the Italian woman’ who had betrayed the alliance.

On 11 November 1918, at Schonbrunn, ministers put before Charles a statement renouncing any part in the affairs of state. By her own later account Zita protested that a sovereign could be deposed but could never abdicate. He signed, in pencil, a text that carefully avoided the word. In March 1919 a British officer, Edward Lisle Strutt, escorted the family by train into Switzerland.

Twice in 1921 Charles tried to recover the Hungarian throne. On the second attempt Zita, pregnant, flew with him in a small aeroplane to western Hungary. The regent, Admiral Horthy, who governed in the king’s name, met them with troops outside Budapest. The Allies sent the couple by British warship to Madeira, where Charles died of pneumonia on 1 April 1922, aged thirty-four. Zita gave birth to their eighth child two months later. She wore black for the rest of her life, was allowed back into Austria only in 1982, and died in Switzerland in March 1989, aged ninety-six.

How it came to this

The House of Bourbon-Parma was a junior branch of the Spanish Bourbons, descended from Louis XIV of France through his grandson Philip V of Spain. It ruled the small duchy of Parma, with interruptions, from 1748 until 1859, when the duchy was swept into the new Italy. Robert, the last reigning duke, spent the rest of his life as a wealthy exile with strong Catholic and legitimist loyalties, and married his children into the Catholic dynasties of Europe.

The Habsburg monarchy that Zita married into held about fifty million people of eleven recognised nationalities under one elderly emperor. Since 1867 it had been divided into an Austrian and a Hungarian half with separate parliaments and a common army and foreign policy. By 1916 it was dependent on German military help, its cities were hungry, and Czech, South Slav and Polish politicians in exile were persuading the Allies that it should be broken up. Charles came to the throne promising reform and peace and had less than two years to attempt either.

How each side saw it

Zita, in her own recollections

Zita gave long interviews late in life to the Austrian writer Erich Feigl and the British journalist Gordon Brook-Shepherd. In them the peace approach of 1917 is the one honest attempt by any ruler to stop the slaughter, wrecked by Italian demands and by the vanity of the foreign minister, Count Czernin, whose boastful speech provoked Clemenceau into publishing the letter. She held that her husband had never abdicated and that their eldest son Otto was therefore the rightful emperor. She presented the Hungarian ventures as the keeping of a coronation oath, not as adventures.

The German alliance and Austrian German nationalists

To the German high command and to German nationalist opinion in Austria, the Sixtus letter was an offer to give away German territory behind an ally’s back while German soldiers were holding the Austrian front. Newspapers and pamphlets in 1918 blamed the empress’s foreign birth and her brothers in an enemy uniform, and rumours circulated that she had passed military secrets to Italy. No evidence for that has ever been produced. Czernin, in his memoirs, portrayed the emperor as well-meaning but weak, and steered by his wife’s family.

The Austrian Republic and the successor states

The Social Democrat Karl Renner, first chancellor of the republic, held that the dynasty had led its peoples into a catastrophic war and had forfeited any claim on them. The Habsburg Law of April 1919 banished Charles for good and other members of the family unless they renounced their claims, and it confiscated the crown properties. Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia and Romania treated the restoration attempts of 1921 as a threat to their existence and mobilised troops. For Tomas Masaryk and other national leaders, Charles’s manifesto of October 1918 offering a federal Austria had come years too late.

What is disputed

Historians differ over how far Zita directed her husband. Wartime gossip made her the real ruler; Brook-Shepherd and most later biographers see a close partnership in which she was the firmer character. Whether the 1917 approach ever had a chance is also argued: Manfried Rauchensteiner and others judge it amateur diplomacy that ignored Italy, while admirers call it a lost opportunity. The words she is said to have spoken at Schonbrunn in November 1918 rest on her own recollection decades later. Her claim in the 1980s that Crown Prince Rudolf was murdered at Mayerling in 1889 is rejected by nearly all scholars.

What followed

Otto von Habsburg renounced his claim in 1961, returned to Austria and sat for twenty years in the European Parliament. Zita herself never renounced anything; an Austrian court ruled in 1982 that as a Habsburg by marriage she did not need to. Her funeral in Vienna on 1 April 1989, the anniversary of Charles’s death, used the old imperial ritual and drew large crowds. The Catholic Church beatified Charles in 2004 and opened a cause for Zita in 2009, decisions welcomed by monarchists and criticised by those who recall the use of poison gas by his armies.

Read further

  • Gordon Brook-Shepherd, The Last Empress: The Life and Times of Zita of Austria-Hungary, 1892-1989 (1991)
  • Gordon Brook-Shepherd, The Last Habsburg (1968)
  • Manfried Rauchensteiner, The First World War and the End of the Habsburg Monarchy, 1914-1918 (2014)
  • Pieter M. Judson, The Habsburg Empire: A New History (2016)

Same day, other years

1927

Canberra’s Parliament opens, with two uninvited elders

Canberra, AustraliaOceania

The Duke of York, later George VI, opened the provisional Parliament House in Australia’s new capital on 9 May 1927, the anniversary of the first federal parliament’s opening in Melbourne in 1901. Dame Nellie Melba sang the anthem before a crowd of thousands on what had lately been sheep paddocks. Among them were two Wiradjuri elders, Jimmy Clements and John Noble, who had walked for days from the Brungle mission station to be there. A policeman told Clements, barefoot and in old clothes, to move on. People in the crowd objected, he stayed, and the next day he was among those presented to the royal visitors.

Seen from elsewhere. Newspapers at the time reported that Clements claimed a sovereign right to the land the capital stood on. Aboriginal people were then excluded from the census by the constitution and most could not vote in federal elections until 1962. His presence is now often cited as the first recorded Aboriginal protest at Parliament.

1936

Mussolini proclaims an empire in Ethiopia

Rome, Italy, and Addis Ababa, EthiopiaAfrica

Italian troops under Marshal Badoglio had entered Addis Ababa on 5 May, seven months after invading from Eritrea and Somalia. On the evening of 9 May Mussolini announced from the balcony of the Palazzo Venezia that Ethiopia was annexed and that King Victor Emmanuel III was now its emperor. The conquest had been won with aircraft, artillery and mustard gas, which Italy had bound itself by treaty in 1925 not to use. Emperor Haile Selassie had left for exile days earlier, and on 30 June he stood before the League of Nations in Geneva to ask what help a small state could now expect.

Seen from elsewhere. Ethiopians speak of a five-year occupation, not a conquest: the Patriots, the Arbegnoch, fought on in the highlands until 1941, and thousands of civilians were killed in Addis Ababa in the reprisals of February 1937. Italian governments denied the use of gas until 1996. Ethiopia’s post-war figure of some 760,000 dead cannot be verified.

1945

Victory Day on Moscow time

Berlin, Germany, and Moscow, Soviet UnionEurope

Germany’s surrender had been signed at Reims on 7 May, but Stalin insisted that it be ratified in the conquered capital before his own commander. Late on 8 May, in an army engineering school at Karlshorst in Berlin, Field Marshal Keitel signed again in front of Marshal Zhukov and Allied representatives. The fighting was to stop at one minute past eleven that night by Central European time. In Moscow it was already 9 May, and the announcement was read on the radio in the small hours. The Soviet Union had lost some 27 million people, by the estimate now generally used.

Seen from elsewhere. Western Europe marks 8 May. In Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and much of Poland the date also recalls the start of four decades of Soviet control, and Ukraine moved its commemoration to 8 May in 2023. Russian governments treat challenges to the 9 May narrative as an insult to the dead.

1960

The contraceptive pill is cleared for sale

Washington, D.C., United StatesThe Americas

On 9 May 1960 the United States Food and Drug Administration announced that it would approve Enovid, made by G. D. Searle, as an oral contraceptive. The drug was the work of the biologist Gregory Pincus, his colleague Min Chueh Chang and the Catholic gynaecologist John Rock, paid for largely by the heiress Katharine McCormick at the urging of the birth control campaigner Margaret Sanger. Within five years several million American women were taking it. No earlier medicine had been designed for healthy people to take daily for years, and none had so quickly altered the terms of marriage, work and family size.

Seen from elsewhere. The large trials were run from 1956 among poor women in Puerto Rico, at doses far higher than later ones, without the standards of consent now required; reports of side effects were discounted and three deaths went uninvestigated. The Catholic Church condemned artificial contraception in 1968. Many women then and since have called the pill the foundation of their independence.

Also on 9 May