Parallax

29 May, 1431

Joan of Arc’s judges vote to hand her over

Five days after she had saved her life by signing a recantation, Joan was found in men’s clothes again. On 29 May some forty churchmen met in a chapel in Rouen and agreed what that meant.

Rouen, Normandy

On the morning of Tuesday 29 May 1431 Pierre Cauchon, Bishop of Beauvais, gathered about forty theologians, canon lawyers and abbots in the chapel of the archbishop’s palace at Rouen. He put one question to them. The prisoner known as Joan the Maid had abjured her errors the previous Thursday and been received back into the Church. She had now returned to them. What was to be done?

The facts were not in doubt. On 24 May, on a platform in the cemetery of Saint-Ouen, with the executioner’s cart waiting, Joan had put her mark to a paper renouncing her visions and promising to stop wearing men’s dress. She was sentenced to prison for life on bread and water. She had expected a church prison with women attendants. She was taken back instead to her cell in the castle, in leg irons, under English soldiers. By the weekend she was wearing tunic and hose again.

Cauchon went to the cell on Monday 28 May with several assessors and a notary. Joan said she had taken the clothes of her own will, that it was more fitting among men, and that the promises made to her, of mass and release from irons, had not been kept. Then she went further. Her voices, Saint Catherine and Saint Margaret, had told her that she had damned herself to save her life. Whatever she had said at Saint-Ouen, she said, was for fear of the fire. The notary wrote in the margin of his minute two Latin words: responsio mortifera, the fatal answer.

The assessors gave their opinions one by one the next day. The first to speak judged her relapsed. The Abbot of Fecamp agreed, adding that the paper she had signed should be read and explained to her once more. Nearly all the rest said they were of the abbot’s mind. The conclusion was unanimous in substance: she was a relapsed heretic and should be abandoned to the secular arm, with the customary request that it treat her gently. Cauchon thanked them and ordered her cited to appear at eight the next morning in the Old Market.

There, on 30 May, before a large crowd and several hundred English soldiers, a sermon was preached, the sentence was read, and she was passed to the royal bailiff, who by several later accounts pronounced no sentence of his own and simply told the executioner to do his duty. She asked for a cross, and died calling on the name of Jesus. She was about nineteen. Her ashes were thrown into the Seine.

How it came to this

France in 1429 had two kings. By a treaty of 1420 the crown was to pass to the English royal house, and the child Henry VI was acknowledged in Paris and the north, backed by the Duke of Burgundy. The disinherited Charles held the lands south of the Loire. Joan, a farmer’s daughter from Domremy on the eastern border, came to him that spring saying that voices from God had sent her. She rode with the army that relieved Orleans in May, and in July stood beside Charles at his coronation in Reims. An attack on Paris failed in September.

On 23 May 1430 she was pulled from her horse outside Compiegne by soldiers of John of Luxembourg, a Burgundian lord, who sold her to the English for ten thousand livres. Charles made no known attempt to ransom her. The English wanted her discredited as well as dead: if she was a heretic and a witch, then the coronation at Reims was the Devil’s work. The trial was therefore held as a church inquiry into her faith, under Cauchon, a bishop long in English service, and it opened at Rouen in January 1431.

How each side saw it

The judges and the University of Paris

To Cauchon and his assessors, most of them graduates of the University of Paris, the case was a serious matter of doctrine. An unlettered girl claimed direct commands from saints she could see and touch, refused to submit those claims to the judgment of the Church on earth, and wore men’s clothing in defiance of scripture. The university’s faculties examined twelve articles drawn from her answers and declared them false, superstitious and schismatic. The official record, which Cauchon had carefully prepared in Latin afterwards, presents every step as regular. Several assessors later testified that they had acted under fear of the English, a claim convenient in 1456.

Joan, in the trial record

Her own voice survives in the notaries’ minutes of her answers, taken down in French. She would not say what sign she had given the king. Asked if she was in God’s grace, she replied that if she was not, might God put her there, and if she was, might God keep her there. She insisted that her voices came from God and that she would answer to him first. On 28 May she said she would rather do her penance once and for all, by dying, than endure prison any longer, and that she had never understood herself to be denying her visions.

The English command

The Duke of Bedford, regent for Henry VI, and the Earl of Warwick, who held Rouen castle, paid for the trial and guarded the prisoner. In a circular sent to the princes of Europe in June 1431 in the young king’s name, her execution was announced as the just end of a false prophetess who had deceived simple people and shed Christian blood. Bedford wrote in 1434 that English reverses had begun with a ‘disciple and limb of the Fiend, called the Pucelle’. Witnesses in 1456 claimed that Warwick was angry when her recantation seemed likely to save her.

The court of 1456

After Charles VII took Rouen he ordered an inquiry, and in 1455-56 a papal commission reheard the case at the request of Joan’s mother, Isabelle Romee. More than a hundred witnesses were heard, including surviving assessors and her childhood neighbours. They described a prisoner threatened with rape, tricked into the male clothing by guards who took away her dress, and made to sign a paper far shorter than the abjuration in the record. On 7 July 1456 the original sentence was declared null. The verdict cleared Charles of owing his crown to a heretic. It did not blame the dead Cauchon’s superiors or the king’s own inaction.

What is disputed

Why she resumed male dress is the central question. The 1431 record has her say she chose it; witnesses twenty-five years later said her woman’s clothes had been removed, or that she had been assaulted and wanted protection. Both sets of testimony were shaped by the court that took them. The paper she signed at Saint-Ouen was, by several accounts, a few lines long, while the abjuration in the official record runs to some fifty. Daniel Hobbins and others argue that the trial followed inquisitorial procedure more closely than its reputation suggests; the lack of a church prison and of any secular sentence remain hard to defend.

What followed

The war went on for twenty-two years and ended with the English expelled from everywhere but Calais. Joan was largely a regional memory, kept up at Orleans, until the nineteenth century, when the publication of the trial records by Jules Quicherat in the 1840s made her a national figure claimed by republicans, monarchists and Catholics at once. The Church beatified her in 1909 and canonised her in 1920. Since then she has been invoked by the French Resistance and by Vichy, by the far right and by feminists, each citing the same documents.

Read further

  • Daniel Hobbins, The Trial of Joan of Arc (2005)
  • Regine Pernoud, Joan of Arc: By Herself and Her Witnesses (1964)
  • Craig Taylor, Joan of Arc: La Pucelle (2006)
  • Helen Castor, Joan of Arc: A History (2014)
  • Jules Quicherat (ed.), Proces de condamnation et de rehabilitation de Jeanne d’Arc (1841-49)

Same day, other years

1453

Constantinople falls to Mehmed II

ConstantinopleEurope

The Ottoman sultan Mehmed II, aged twenty-one, had besieged Constantinople since early April with an army many times larger than the seven or eight thousand defenders, and with cannon that had been battering the fifth-century land walls for weeks. The final assault began in the dark hours of Tuesday 29 May 1453. After the Genoese commander Giovanni Giustiniani was wounded and carried from the wall, Janissaries broke through near the gate of St Romanus. The last emperor, Constantine XI, died in the fighting and his body was never certainly identified. The city was given over to sack, and that afternoon Mehmed rode to Hagia Sophia and had it made a mosque.

Seen from elsewhere. For Greeks it was the end of the Roman empire, and Tuesday is still held unlucky. Turks celebrate the Conquest as a founding moment. Mehmed took the title Caesar of Rome, resettled the city with Muslims, Christians and Jews, and installed a new Orthodox patriarch. Ottoman and Greek writers give very different accounts of how long and how savage the sack was.

1919

An eclipse tests Einstein’s theory

Principe, Gulf of Guinea, and Sobral, BrazilAfrica

Einstein’s general theory of relativity predicted that light from distant stars would bend as it passed the sun by twice the amount Newtonian physics allowed. The only way to check was to photograph stars near the sun during a total eclipse. On 29 May 1919 two British expeditions did so: Arthur Eddington on the island of Principe off West Africa, where cloud cleared just in time, and a second team at Sobral in northern Brazil. In November the results were announced in London as confirming Einstein. A German theory had been vindicated by British astronomers within months of the war’s end, and Einstein became famous overnight.

Seen from elsewhere. Critics have long said Eddington, a convinced relativist, got the answer he wanted by setting aside one set of Sobral plates that favoured Newton. Later reanalysis, notably by Daniel Kennefick, supports the original judgment that those plates were faulty. Principe itself was a Portuguese plantation colony whose cocoa estates, one of which housed the observers, had been notorious for forced labour.

1953

Tenzing and Hillary reach the summit of Everest

Mount Everest, Nepal and TibetAsia

At about half past eleven on the morning of 29 May 1953, Tenzing Norgay, a Sherpa who had been on six earlier Everest expeditions, and Edmund Hillary, a beekeeper from New Zealand, stood on the highest point on Earth. They were the second summit pair of a large British expedition led by John Hunt, which depended on some 350 porters and more than thirty Sherpa climbers. They stayed about fifteen minutes. Hillary photographed Tenzing holding up his ice axe with four flags; Tenzing buried sweets in the snow as an offering. The news reached London in a coded telegram in time for the morning of Elizabeth II’s coronation.

Seen from elsewhere. Crowds in Kathmandu and India hailed Tenzing as the first man up and pressed him to say so; he later wrote that Hillary stepped up first and that they had climbed as a team. Hillary and Hunt were knighted while Tenzing received a lesser medal. To Sherpas and Tibetans the mountain is Chomolungma, and climbing it was not, traditionally, something to be done.

1969

Workers and students take over Cordoba

Cordoba, ArgentinaThe Americas

Cordoba was Argentina’s car-making city, and in May 1969 its unions were angry at the military government of General Juan Carlos Ongania over wage freezes and the loss of the Saturday half-day. On 29 May car workers and power workers, led by Elpidio Torres and Agustin Tosco, marched on the centre and were joined by university students. After police shot a worker dead, the crowd drove the police out, built barricades and burned foreign-owned businesses and an officers’ club. For about a day the protesters held most of the city. The army retook it by the following evening. The dead numbered at least fourteen, and possibly several times that.

Seen from elsewhere. The government blamed organised subversion and jailed Tosco and Torres. Ongania never recovered and was removed by fellow officers in 1970. The left remembers the Cordobazo as the moment the dictatorship was shown to be beatable; others see in it the beginning of the cycle of guerrilla war and state terror that consumed Argentina in the 1970s.

Also on 29 May