Parallax

6 May, 1527

An unpaid army sacks Rome

The troops of a Catholic emperor, many of them Lutherans and none of them paid, went over the walls of the pope’s city in a morning fog. Their commander was dead within minutes, and nobody could stop what came next.

Rome

On the evening of 5 May 1527 an army of about twenty thousand men camped outside the walls of Rome. It belonged in name to the emperor Charles V. In fact it belonged to nobody. The German foot soldiers, the Spanish infantry and the Italian companies had not been paid for months; they had marched the length of Italy in rain, eating what they could take, and they had no siege guns. Their commander, Charles, Duke of Bourbon, once Constable of France and now a renegade in the emperor’s service, had lost the power to turn them. Rome was the only pay on offer.

They attacked at dawn on the 6th, against the walls between the Vatican hill and the Janiculum. A thick mist off the Tiber blinded the defenders’ cannon. Bourbon, wearing a white cloak over his armour so that his men could see him, was setting a ladder against the wall when a shot from an arquebus struck him. He was carried to a nearby chapel and died. The goldsmith Benvenuto Cellini, who was on the ramparts, later claimed the shot as his own.

The loss removed the last restraint. The attackers were over the wall within the hour. Of the pope’s Swiss Guard, 147 died around the obelisk and on the steps of St Peter’s, buying time for the remainder to hurry Clement VII along the covered passage that runs from the Vatican to Castel Sant’Angelo. He got in as the portcullis was falling. By nightfall the imperial troops had crossed the Ponte Sisto into the main city.

What followed lasted for days without check and for months in slower form. Houses were ransomed room by room, and their owners tortured to reveal hidden money. Patients in the hospital of Santo Spirito were killed. Convents were broken open. Churches were stripped and tombs rifled for rings, including those of popes. German soldiers who were followers of Luther dressed in cardinals’ robes, held a mock conclave under the castle walls and acclaimed Luther pope. One scratched the reformer’s name across a fresco by Raphael in the papal apartments, where it can still be seen. Cardinals who had supported the emperor were held to ransom with the others.

Clement surrendered in early June, agreeing to pay four hundred thousand ducats and hand over fortresses. Plague broke out in the summer among the unburied dead. The army did not march out until February 1528, by which time the city had lost most of its people to death or flight.

How it came to this

Since 1494 France and the Habsburg rulers of Spain and the Empire had fought over Italy, with the Italian states shifting between them. In 1525 Charles V’s army destroyed the French at Pavia and captured King Francis I. The victory was too complete for the pope’s comfort. Clement VII, a Medici, feared an emperor who held both Naples and Milan, and in 1526 he joined France, Venice and Florence in the League of Cognac against him. Charles regarded this as betrayal by the Church’s own head.

The army that reached Rome was assembled from two parts. Georg von Frundsberg, a veteran German captain with Lutheran sympathies, raised some twelve thousand landsknechts largely on his own credit and brought them over the Alps in the winter of 1526. They joined Bourbon, who had quarrelled with Francis I over an inheritance and gone over to the emperor in 1523, and the Spanish garrison of Milan. No money came. In March 1527 the troops mutinied; Frundsberg, trying to face them down, suffered a stroke. From then on the soldiers led and their officers followed, south towards the richest target in Italy.

How each side saw it

The emperor’s court

Charles V was in Spain and learned of the sack weeks later. He put on mourning and wrote to other rulers that it had happened against his will. He did not, however, give up the advantage of holding the pope. His Latin secretary, Alfonso de Valdes, wrote a dialogue in which a young courtier persuades an archdeacon that the emperor was blameless and that God had allowed the disaster to punish a warlike pope and a corrupt clergy. The papal nuncio, Baldassare Castiglione, demanded the book be suppressed. The argument that Rome brought it on itself became the official imperial line.

The landsknechts

The German soldiers left few statements but some plain ones. The captain Sebastian Schertlin recorded in his memoir that they took the city by storm, killed thousands, plundered the churches and burned a good part of the town, and he lists his share of the proceeds without embarrassment. To men raised on Luther’s pamphlets Rome was the seat of Antichrist, and mocking its rites was a form of preaching. They also saw themselves as creditors collecting a debt that their employer had failed to pay. Luther himself wrote that Christ was reigning in such a way that the emperor who persecuted Luther for the pope was destroying the pope for Luther.

Romans and the papal court

The fullest accounts come from the victims’ side. Luigi Guicciardini, a Florentine official, wrote a narrative soon afterwards that blames the pope’s indecision and the cowardice of his commanders as much as the invaders. His brother Francesco, the historian, was the pope’s lieutenant with the League’s army, which stood off and did nothing. Humanists who lost their libraries and friends, such as Pierio Valeriano, wrote of the end of a golden age. Many churchmen, among them Giles of Viterbo, accepted the disaster as a judgment on the worldliness of the Roman court and a summons to reform.

France and the memory of Bourbon

In French tradition Bourbon is the great traitor, the Constable who took arms against his king and died under excommunication at the gates of Rome. His own view was that the crown had robbed him: after his wife’s death the king’s mother, Louise of Savoy, laid claim to his vast lands, and the courts were moving against him when he fled. His soldiers thought enough of him to carry his body away with them to Gaeta. Francis I confiscated the Bourbon inheritance, removing the last great independent fief from the kingdom.

What is disputed

Numbers are uncertain. Contemporary estimates of the dead range from about four thousand to more than twelve thousand, and a census taken shortly before the sack counted some fifty-five thousand inhabitants, of whom perhaps a fifth remained a year later. Who shot Bourbon cannot be known: Cellini’s memoir is boastful and several others were credited. How far Charles V intended an attack on Rome, as opposed to pressure on the pope, is argued. So is the old claim, set out by Andre Chastel, that the sack ended the Renaissance in Rome; others stress how quickly artists and patrons returned.

What followed

Clement made peace with Charles and crowned him emperor at Bologna in 1530, the last time a pope performed that ceremony. A pope in the emperor’s power could not grant Henry VIII an annulment from Catherine of Aragon, who was Charles’s aunt, and England broke with Rome within a few years. The shock strengthened those in the Church who wanted reform and a council, which met at Trent from 1545. The Swiss Guard still swears in its recruits each year on 6 May.

Read further

  • Luigi Guicciardini, The Sack of Rome, translated by James H. McGregor (1993)
  • Judith Hook, The Sack of Rome, 1527 (1972)
  • Andre Chastel, The Sack of Rome, 1527 (1983)
  • Benvenuto Cellini, Autobiography, translated by George Bull (1956)
  • Kenneth Gouwens, Remembering the Renaissance: Humanist Narratives of the Sack of Rome (1998)

Same day, other years

1536

Manco Inca’s army attacks Spanish-held Cuzco

Cuzco, PeruThe Americas

Manco Inca had been crowned in 1533 as a ruler the Spaniards thought they could manage. After the Pizarro brothers imprisoned him, extorted gold and took his wife, he escaped and raised the highlands. His forces, which Spanish writers put at over a hundred thousand, surrounded about 190 Spaniards and several thousand of their Andean allies in the old Inca capital. On 6 May they attacked, setting the thatched roofs alight with heated sling-stones and fighting street by street. The Spaniards held two buildings on the main square. They broke out to storm the fortress of Sacsayhuaman, where Juan Pizarro was killed. The siege went on for some ten months before Manco withdrew to the forests of Vilcabamba.

Seen from elsewhere. Manco’s son Titu Cusi Yupanqui dictated an account in 1570, a rare Inca voice, which says his father rose because of abuse and broken promises. Spanish chroniclers credited their survival to Saint James and the Virgin. Canari, Chachapoya and rival Inca nobles fought for the Spaniards, so the siege was also a war among Andeans.

1542

Francis Xavier lands at Goa

Goa, IndiaAsia

Thirteen months after leaving Lisbon, the Navarrese priest Francis Xavier, one of the first seven members of the Society of Jesus, stepped ashore in the capital of Portugal’s Asian empire with a commission from the pope and the king. He spent the next ten years in almost constant motion: among the pearl-fishing villages of the southern Indian coast, at Malacca, in the Moluccas and, from 1549, in Japan, where he founded a mission that grew to hundreds of thousands of converts within a few decades. He died in 1552 on an island off the Chinese coast, waiting for a boat to the mainland. His body lies in Goa.

Seen from elsewhere. In a letter of 1545 Xavier urged the king of Portugal to set up the Inquisition in Goa. Established in 1560, it tried converts accused of keeping Hindu, Jewish or Muslim practices and lasted until 1812, while temples were demolished. Goan Catholics venerate him as their patron; some Hindu groups object to public honours for him.

1882

The United States bars Chinese labourers

Washington, DC, United StatesThe Americas

President Chester Arthur signed the Chinese Exclusion Act, which suspended the immigration of Chinese labourers for ten years and forbade any court to make a Chinese person a citizen. It was the first American law to shut out a group by nationality. About 105,000 Chinese then lived in the country, well under one per cent of the population; many had come to work the gold fields and to build the western half of the transcontinental railway. The ban was renewed in 1892 and made permanent in 1902. It was repealed in 1943, when China was a wartime ally, and replaced with a quota of 105 immigrants a year.

Seen from elsewhere. Western labour leaders argued that Chinese workers undercut wages; a few opponents, such as Senator George Hoar, called the act racial discrimination written into law. Chinese residents fought it in the courts, winning the 1898 ruling that children born in the United States are citizens. Congress passed resolutions of regret in 2011 and 2012.

1916

Ottoman authorities hang Arab nationalists in two cities

Beirut and DamascusMiddle East

On the orders of Cemal Pasha, the Ottoman governor of Syria and commander of the Fourth Army, twenty-one men were hanged at dawn: fourteen in Beirut’s Burj Square and seven in Marjeh Square in Damascus. They were journalists, lawyers, officers and notables, Muslim and Christian, convicted by a military court at Aley of conspiring with France and Britain to detach the Arab provinces from the empire. Eleven others had been hanged the previous August. Much of the evidence came from papers left behind in the French consulates. The executions took place while famine was killing many thousands in Mount Lebanon. Both squares were later renamed for the martyrs.

Seen from elsewhere. Cemal published a defence arguing that the men had committed treason in wartime, and the seized papers did show contacts with France. Arab memory calls him the Blood-shedder, and the hangings helped push Sharif Hussein of Mecca into revolt a month later. Historians note that most Arab subjects nonetheless stayed loyal to the empire until its collapse.

Also on 6 May