Parallax

1 June, 1879

The last Bonaparte heir dies in a Zulu ambush

The only son of Napoleon III went to Zululand in a British uniform to earn a soldier’s name. A torn saddle strap left him alone on foot in front of some forty Zulu fighters.

Tshotshosi valley, Zululand (now KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa)

On the morning of 1 June 1879 a small mounted patrol rode out ahead of the British army that was about to invade Zululand for the second time. Its task was to pick a camp site for the next day’s march. With it went Louis-Napoleon, the Prince Imperial of France, 23 years old, trained as a gunner at Woolwich and attached to the staff as an observer. Beside him rode Lieutenant Jahleel Carey of the 98th Regiment, six troopers of Bettington’s Horse and a Zulu guide. A promised escort of mounted Basotho failed to appear, and the party left without it.

Early in the afternoon they halted at a deserted homestead above the Tshotshosi river, a cluster of huts with tall grass and maize growing close to the walls. The ashes of a fire were still warm, and nobody posted a lookout. The men unsaddled, brewed coffee and rested for the better part of an hour while the prince sketched the country.

At about four o’clock the guide reported that he had seen a Zulu on the hill. The prince gave the order to mount. As the troopers swung into their saddles a volley crashed out of the grass at a few yards’ range and some forty men charged. The horses bolted. The prince’s grey, Percy, was a tall and nervous animal; he ran beside it, gripping the holster strap on the saddle to vault up, and the leather tore in his hand. He fell, the horse trod on his right arm, and it galloped off after the others.

He got up, took his revolver in his left hand and turned to face his pursuers in a dry watercourse. He fired and missed. The Zulus closed in with spears. When his body was found the next morning it bore seventeen or eighteen wounds, all of them in front. Two troopers and the guide had also been killed. Carey and the four other survivors had not stopped riding until they were well clear, and it was Carey who had to report to Lord Chelmsford’s camp that the heir of the Bonapartes had been left behind.

The body was carried to the coast and shipped to England, where Queen Victoria attended the funeral at Chislehurst. Carey was court-martialled for misbehaviour before the enemy and sentenced to be cashiered, a verdict set aside on review in London. He went back to his regiment, where few officers would speak to him, and died in India four years later. Disraeli, who had tried to stop the prince going at all, is reported to have remarked that the Zulus had defeated Britain’s generals, converted her bishops and now settled the fate of a great European dynasty.

How it came to this

Louis was born in the Tuileries in 1856, the only child of Napoleon III and the Spanish-born Empress Eugenie. He was fourteen when his father’s empire collapsed at Sedan, and he grew up in exile at Camden Place in Kent. When Napoleon III died in 1873 the Bonapartist party proclaimed the boy Napoleon IV. He passed out seventh in his class from the Royal Military Academy at Woolwich, but as a foreign pretender he could hold no British commission, and a claimant bearing that name was expected to have seen a battlefield.

The chance came in January 1879, when Britain invaded the independent Zulu kingdom of King Cetshwayo on a manufactured ultimatum and lost more than 1,300 men at Isandlwana within two weeks. Reinforcements were rushed out, among them many of the prince’s Woolwich friends. He begged to go. The government refused, the empress and the queen interceded with the Duke of Cambridge, and he sailed as a private spectator with a letter asking Chelmsford to look after him. Chelmsford placed him under Colonel Richard Harrison, who put him to work on maps and reconnaissance and tried, with limited success, to curb his taste for riding at any Zulu he saw.

How each side saw it

The Zulu men who fought him

The attackers belonged to several royal regiments, among them the iNgobamakhosi and uMbonambi, and were scouting an invading army that had already burned homesteads in the valley. They left no written record. What they said survives because British officers escorting the Empress Eugenie to the spot in 1880 questioned several of them through interpreters. They said they had no idea who the young man was, that he fought like a lion and never turned his back, and that a man named Xabanga struck first. The cut made in his abdomen was the customary rite to free a slain enemy’s spirit. Cetshwayo afterwards sent the prince’s sword back to the British.

French Bonapartists and republicans

For the Bonapartist party the news was a catastrophe: its only plausible candidate was dead in a British colonial war that was none of France’s business. Their newspapers asked why an Englishman had ridden away, and rumours spread that Queen Victoria’s government, or the Freemasons, or French republican agents had arranged for him to be abandoned. No evidence has ever supported any of it. Republicans privately regarded the death as the end of a danger to the young Third Republic. The prince’s will passed over his cousin Prince Napoleon in favour of that cousin’s son Victor, and the quarrel that followed split what remained of the movement.

Lieutenant Carey and the British army

Carey argued at his court martial that the prince, not he, had led the patrol, chosen the halting place and given the orders, and that once the volley came it was every man for himself in broken ground. Harrison’s instructions had left the question of command unclear. Most of the army judged him by a simpler standard: he had not looked back. Chelmsford’s staff, for their part, had allowed a pretender to a foreign throne to ride out with eight men into country known to be watched. The court’s sentence was quashed on a technicality, and the Empress herself asked that Carey not be punished further.

What is disputed

Who commanded the patrol has never been settled; Carey held the commission but the prince appears to have given the orders, and the staff’s written instructions were ambiguous. The count of wounds is given as seventeen or eighteen in different medical reports. The story that the saddle strap failed because it was made of cheap paper-backed leather is a later embellishment; the saddlery, which survives, was simply worn. The sword he carried is often said to have been Napoleon I’s from Austerlitz, which historians such as Ian Knight doubt. Disraeli’s remark is reported at second hand and its exact wording varies.

What followed

The British army went on to burn Cetshwayo’s capital at Ulundi on 4 July, and the Zulu kingdom was broken into thirteen chiefdoms and then annexed. In France, Bonapartism never recovered as a serious political force; the Third Republic survived until 1940. Eugenie travelled to Zululand in 1880 to spend the anniversary night at the place where her son died, and built an abbey at Farnborough in Hampshire where he lies beside his father. A stone cross paid for by Queen Victoria still stands at the site, in a region where the war is remembered chiefly as the loss of Zulu independence.

Read further

  • Ian Knight, With His Face to the Foe: The Life and Death of Louis Napoleon, the Prince Imperial, Zululand 1879 (2001)
  • Donald R. Morris, The Washing of the Spears (1965)
  • John Laband, Rope of Sand: The Rise and Fall of the Zulu Kingdom in the Nineteenth Century (1995)
  • Saul David, Zulu: The Heroism and Tragedy of the Zulu War of 1879 (2004)

Same day, other years

1868

The Navajo sign their way home

Fort Sumner, New Mexico TerritoryThe Americas

In 1863-64 the United States Army under Kit Carson burned the crops and orchards of the Navajo, or Dine, and marched the survivors some 300 miles to Bosque Redondo, a guarded reservation on the Pecos river. The march is remembered as the Long Walk. More than 8,000 people were held there on alkaline water and failed harvests, and perhaps a quarter of them died. On 1 June 1868 Navajo leaders, with Barboncito as their chief spokesman, signed a treaty with General William Sherman that let them return to a reservation inside their own country. It is one of the few cases in which a removed nation negotiated its way back to its homeland.

Seen from elsewhere. Sherman had first proposed sending the Navajo to Indian Territory in present-day Oklahoma; Barboncito’s recorded reply was that his people would go nowhere but their own land. Washington agreed largely because the camp had become too expensive. In Dine memory the place is Hweeldi, the place of suffering, and the treaty is honoured as the founding document of Navajo sovereignty.

1921

Greenwood burns in Tulsa

Tulsa, Oklahoma, United StatesThe Americas

Greenwood was a prosperous Black district of Tulsa, with its own hotels, newspapers, doctors and theatres. On 31 May 1921 a young Black man, Dick Rowland, was arrested after an encounter with a white lift operator, and a crowd gathered at the courthouse expecting a lynching. Armed Black veterans came to protect him, shots were fired, and overnight and through the morning of 1 June thousands of white Tulsans, some deputised by the police, looted and burned some thirty-five blocks. Aircraft circled overhead. About 10,000 people were left homeless and thousands were interned. A state commission in 2001 put the dead at somewhere between 75 and 300.

Seen from elsewhere. The city’s white press and officials called it a ‘negro uprising’ and a riot, a label that let insurers refuse every claim. No one was convicted. The event was left out of Oklahoma schoolbooks for decades and survivors’ accounts were the main record. Searches for mass graves began in 2020; in 2024 the state’s supreme court dismissed the last survivors’ claim for reparations.

1941

The Farhud in Baghdad

Baghdad, IraqMiddle East

Baghdad’s Jewish community was one of the oldest in the world and made up roughly a quarter of the city. On 1 June 1941, during the festival of Shavuot, the pro-Axis government of Rashid Ali al-Gaylani had just fled after a brief war with Britain, and the city was without authority. Soldiers of the defeated army, police and civilians attacked Jews in the streets and in their homes. Over two days about 180 Jews were killed, on the most commonly cited count, with hundreds injured and many houses and shops looted, before the returning regent ordered troops to fire on the rioters. The name Farhud means violent dispossession.

Seen from elsewhere. An Iraqi government inquiry blamed German propaganda and nationalist officers. British forces were camped outside the city and did not enter, a delay that many survivors held against the ambassador. Many Muslims sheltered Jewish neighbours. Historians disagree on whether the Farhud began the end of Iraqi Jewry, or was an exception in a long coexistence that the events of 1948-51 destroyed.

2001

A royal family is shot dead at dinner

Narayanhiti Palace, Kathmandu, NepalAsia

On the evening of 1 June 2001 the royal family of Nepal gathered for its regular Friday dinner. Within minutes King Birendra, Queen Aishwarya, their younger son, their daughter and five other relatives had been shot dead. Crown Prince Dipendra was found with a bullet wound to the head and, in a coma, was proclaimed king; he died three days later. An official inquiry led by the chief justice and the speaker of parliament concluded within a week that Dipendra, drunk and angry that his parents opposed the woman he wished to marry, had carried out the killings himself with automatic weapons and then shot himself. The king’s brother Gyanendra took the throne.

Seen from elsewhere. Many Nepalis have never accepted the finding. They point out that Gyanendra was away from Kathmandu that night, that his own son survived unhurt, that no post-mortems were carried out before the cremations and that the inquiry lasted days. No evidence of a plot has been produced. The monarchy lost its standing and was abolished in 2008.

Also on 1 June