Parallax

22 May, AD 337

Constantine dies in the white robes of a new Christian

The emperor who had favoured the Church for twenty-five years was baptised only on his deathbed, by a bishop whose theology his own council had condemned. He died at Pentecost, and his family began killing one another within weeks.

Near Nicomedia, Bithynia (Izmit, Turkey)

In the spring of 337 Constantine was about sixty-five and preparing for war. The Persian king Shapur II had been raiding the eastern frontier, and the emperor intended to lead the army against him in person, taking bishops along and, according to his biographer, a tent made in the shape of a church. He kept Easter in Constantinople, the city he had dedicated seven years before. Soon afterwards he fell ill.

He tried the hot baths of the capital and then crossed the Bosphorus to those at Helenopolis, the town he had named for his mother, where he prayed at the shrine of the martyr Lucian. He grew worse. Carried on towards Nicomedia, he stopped at an imperial villa in its suburbs, sent for the bishops, and told them that the time had come for the seal he had long desired. He had hoped, he said, to receive it in the river Jordan, but God had decided otherwise.

Constantine had presided over councils, built great churches in Rome and Jerusalem and called himself a servant of the Christian God, but he had never been baptised. That was not unusual. Baptism was held to wash away all earlier sin and could be received only once, so men whose office required them to shed blood often put it off until the end. The rite was performed by the local bishop, Eusebius of Nicomedia, a courtier and a long-standing sympathiser of the condemned priest Arius.

Afterwards, says Eusebius of Caesarea, whose Life of Constantine is the only detailed account, the emperor refused to touch the imperial purple again. He lay on a white couch in the white garments of the newly baptised, received his officers, who wept, and told them he was now truly alive. He died about noon on the feast of Pentecost, 22 May.

Soldiers laid the body in a golden coffin and carried it to Constantinople, where it lay in state on a high platform in the palace, attended by court officials who went on making the daily obeisances as though he were alive. No Augustus was on the spot to succeed him. His son Constantius hurried from Antioch and buried him in the mausoleum he had built at the Church of the Holy Apostles, among twelve monuments to the apostles, with himself as the thirteenth.

How it came to this

Constantine was born at Naissus in the Balkans, the son of an army officer, Constantius, who rose to be one of the four emperors of Diocletian’s college, and of Helena, a woman of low birth. When his father died at York in 306 the troops proclaimed the son. For eighteen years he fought his way through rivals. Before defeating Maxentius at the Milvian Bridge outside Rome in 312 he adopted a Christian sign for his army, and from then on he treated the Christian God as his protector. In 313 he and his colleague Licinius agreed to full toleration and the return of confiscated church property, ending the persecution begun in 303.

He defeated Licinius in 324 and ruled alone. Christians were then perhaps a tenth of the empire’s population. Constantine gave their clergy privileges and money, summoned the bishops to Nicaea in 325 to settle their quarrel over the nature of Christ, and founded a new capital on the Bosphorus. He did not ban the old cults. In 326 he had his eldest son Crispus and then his wife Fausta put to death, for reasons never made public.

How each side saw it

Eusebius and the Christian tradition

Eusebius of Caesarea, who knew the emperor and finished the Life of Constantine shortly after his death, presents a ruler chosen by God, a new Moses who delivered the Church from its persecutors and died at the very hour of Pentecost. The work is a panegyric and passes over Crispus and Fausta in silence. The Eastern Orthodox churches venerate Constantine as a saint and ‘equal of the apostles’, and keep his feast with his mother’s on 21 May. The Latin West has been more reserved about a man baptised by an Arian sympathiser; Jerome noted the fact sourly in his Chronicle.

The pagan tradition

The last pagan historians saw in Constantine the author of Rome’s decline. Zosimus, writing around 500 from the lost history of Eunapius, says that he turned to Christianity because, after killing his son and wife, he was told by the priests of the old gods that no rite could cleanse such guilt, while the Christians promised forgiveness for anything. Zosimus also blames him for stripping the frontiers of troops and for extravagance. His nephew, the emperor Julian, mocked him in a satire as a lover of luxury. The chronology of the conversion story is wrong by fourteen years, but it records how the change looked to those who lost by it.

The medieval papacy

Rome could not leave the first Christian emperor to an Arian bishop at Nicomedia. By the fifth century a legend told that Constantine had been a persecutor struck with leprosy and was cured and baptised in Rome by Pope Sylvester. On it was built the Donation of Constantine, a document forged in the eighth century in which the grateful emperor grants the pope authority over Rome and the western provinces. It was cited in papal claims for centuries until Lorenzo Valla showed in 1440, from its Latin, that it could not be genuine.

Modern historians

Jacob Burckhardt, in 1853, drew Constantine as an irreligious politician who used the Church for power, and dismissed Eusebius as a dishonest flatterer. Twentieth-century scholars such as Norman Baynes and Timothy Barnes, working from the emperor’s own letters and laws, concluded that his belief was sincere, if unsophisticated. H. A. Drake has stressed a ruler seeking consensus among Christians and pagans alike. The sun god remained on his coins for more than a decade after 312, which some read as caution and others as a faith that blended two loyalties.

What is disputed

The vision before the Milvian Bridge exists in two versions, a dream in Lactantius and a cross of light in the sky in Eusebius, and may reflect a solar halo seen in Gaul in 310, as Peter Weiss has argued. The so-called Edict of Milan was neither an edict nor issued at Milan; the text we have is a letter of Licinius. Constantine did not make Christianity the state religion, which was the work of Theodosius in 380. Why Crispus and Fausta died is unknown. So is who ordered the massacre of his relatives in 337: Julian blamed Constantius II.

What followed

For more than three months the empire was governed in a dead man’s name. Then the army killed nearly every male descendant of Constantine’s half-brothers, sparing two small boys, and on 9 September his three sons became emperors. They fought each other; Constantius II outlived the rest. One of the spared boys, Julian, tried as emperor to restore the old gods and failed. The Senate at Rome enrolled Constantine among the gods in the traditional way. His capital remained the seat of Roman emperors until 1453, and the partnership of throne and altar that he began shaped European government for far longer.

Read further

  • Eusebius, Life of Constantine, translated by Averil Cameron and Stuart G. Hall (1999)
  • Timothy D. Barnes, Constantine and Eusebius (1981)
  • H. A. Drake, Constantine and the Bishops: The Politics of Intolerance (2000)
  • Zosimus, New History, translated by Ronald T. Ridley (1982)
  • Jacob Burckhardt, The Age of Constantine the Great (1853)

Same day, other years

1455

The first battle of St Albans

St Albans, Hertfordshire, EnglandEurope

Richard, duke of York, shut out of power at the court of the feeble Henry VI, marched south with his Neville allies, the earls of Salisbury and Warwick, and found the king and his chief minister, the duke of Somerset, in the market town of St Albans with a smaller force. After a morning of failed talks the Yorkists attacked the barricaded streets. Warwick’s men broke in through back gardens and houses, and the fight was over in less than an hour. Somerset was cut down outside an inn, and the earl of Northumberland and Lord Clifford died with him. The king, grazed in the neck by an arrow, was found sheltering in a tanner’s house.

Seen from elsewhere. York knelt to Henry and insisted he had come only to remove evil counsellors; Parliament obligingly blamed the dead Somerset. The sons of the men killed wanted blood, and got it. Whether this skirmish ‘began’ the Wars of the Roses is a matter of convention: some historians start in 1459, and the name itself is a later invention.

1960

The strongest earthquake ever recorded strikes Chile

Valdivia, ChileThe Americas

At about ten past three on a Sunday afternoon, a day after a severe shock at Concepcion, the seabed off southern Chile ruptured along a line some thousand kilometres long. The earthquake, of magnitude 9.5, lasted about ten minutes. Parts of the coast sank by two metres, and waves up to twenty-five metres high swept away fishing villages. The tsunami crossed the Pacific to kill sixty-one people at Hilo in Hawaii and more than a hundred in Japan, twenty-two hours later. Estimates of the dead in Chile run from about 1,600 to several thousand, and some two million people lost their homes. Engineers and labourers dug for weeks to drain a lake dammed by landslides above Valdivia.

Seen from elsewhere. At Lago Budi on the coast, a Mapuche community, on the instruction of a machi or ritual specialist, sacrificed a small boy to the sea to stop the waves. Those responsible were arrested and later released; the court held that they had acted without free will, driven by fear and ancestral belief. The case is still debated in Chile.

1987

Police take the men of Hashimpura to the canal

Meerut, Uttar Pradesh, IndiaAsia

During weeks of Hindu-Muslim rioting in the city of Meerut, men of the Provincial Armed Constabulary, a state paramilitary police force, rounded up Muslim residents of the Hashimpura neighbourhood. After dark they loaded more than forty of the younger men into a yellow police lorry, drove them to an irrigation canal outside the city, shot them one by one and threw the bodies into the water, then repeated the process at a second canal. A handful survived by feigning death and reached a police station. A district police chief, Vibhuti Narain Rai, recorded their statements that night. Charges were not filed for nine years.

Seen from elsewhere. The accused constables denied everything, and in 2015 a trial court acquitted all sixteen for want of proof of identity. In 2018 the Delhi High Court reversed the verdict and sentenced them to life, calling the crime a targeted killing of members of a minority. Survivors note that no senior officer was ever charged.

1990

North and South Yemen unite

Aden and Sana’a, YemenMiddle East

In Aden, the flag of a single Republic of Yemen was raised by Ali Abdullah Saleh, the army officer who had ruled the north since 1978, with the southern leader Ali Salim al-Beidh at his side as vice-president. The north, the Yemen Arab Republic, had been a conservative, tribal state since the fall of its imams in 1962. The south, a British colony and protectorate until 1967, had become the Arab world’s only Marxist state, and was bankrupt now that Soviet aid had stopped. Oil found near the shared border gave both a reason to merge. Sana’a became the capital of a country of some twelve million people.

Seen from elsewhere. Many southerners soon felt they had been annexed, not united. Their leaders tried to secede in 1994 and were crushed in a short war. A southern movement has demanded separation since 2007 and has at times controlled Aden. The north celebrates 22 May as Unity Day; for separatists it marks the start of an occupation.

Also on 22 May