Parallax

10 May, 1508

A sculptor is paid to paint a ceiling

Michelangelo did not want the Sistine Chapel job, said painting was not his trade, and suspected his rivals of arranging it so that he would fail. On 10 May 1508 he took the first 500 ducats anyway.

Rome, Papal States

The note is in his own hand. On 10 May 1508, it says, ‘I, Michelangelo, sculptor,’ have received from Pope Julius II five hundred ducats on account for painting the vault of the chapel of Pope Sixtus, ‘on which I begin work today’. He was thirty-three. He had made the Pieta in St Peter’s and the David in Florence, and he had painted almost nothing in fresco since his apprenticeship. Calling himself a sculptor in a painting contract was a statement of grievance.

The work he wanted to be doing was the pope’s tomb, a free-standing monument with some forty marble figures that Julius had commissioned in 1505 and then stopped paying for. Michelangelo had left Rome in a fury in 1506 and been brought to heel in Bologna some months later. Now he was offered three thousand ducats to decorate the ceiling of the chapel built by the pope’s uncle, a shallow barrel vault more than twenty metres above the floor, then painted blue with gold stars.

The first plan was modest: twelve apostles in the spandrels and ornament in between. Michelangelo later wrote that he told the pope it would turn out ‘a poor thing’, and that Julius then let him do as he liked. What he did was cover the whole vault with nine scenes from Genesis, from the separation of light and darkness to the drunkenness of Noah, framed by prophets, sibyls, the ancestors of Christ and twenty seated nude youths: more than three hundred figures.

He sent to Florence for assistants who knew fresco, among them his old friend Francesco Granacci. He rejected a hanging scaffold designed by the papal architect Bramante, which would have left holes in the vault, and built a stepped platform on brackets set into the walls so that services could continue below. The first scene he painted, the Flood, bloomed with mould and had to be partly redone. He worked standing, head tipped back, and described the result in a comic sonnet to a friend: beard to heaven, paint dripping on his face, his body bent like a Syrian bow. ‘I am not in a good place,’ it ends, ‘and I am no painter.’

Money stopped for months in 1510-11 while Julius was away at war. The pope, old and impatient, climbed the ladders to ask when it would be finished; the early biographers have him threatening to throw the artist off the scaffold. The first half was shown in August 1511. The whole ceiling was unveiled on 31 October 1512, the eve of All Saints. Julius died less than four months later.

How it came to this

The Sistine Chapel was built in the 1470s for Pope Sixtus IV as the pope’s private chapel and the place where cardinals elect his successor. Its walls had been frescoed in the 1480s by the leading painters of the day, among them Botticelli, Perugino and Ghirlandaio, in whose workshop the young Michelangelo had briefly trained. Cracks had opened in the vault in 1504, and the repairs left it disfigured.

Sixtus’s nephew, Giuliano della Rovere, became pope as Julius II in 1503. He led armies in person to recover papal territory, began the demolition of the thousand-year-old basilica of St Peter so that Bramante could build a new one, and set Raphael to paint his apartments. The money came from the revenues of the Papal States, from the sale of offices and from indulgences, the last of which would within a decade give Martin Luther his opening. Rome under Julius was a building site and a court where artists competed, sometimes viciously, for one man’s favour.

How each side saw it

Michelangelo, in his letters and through Condivi

In letters to his father from the scaffold he complains that the work does not go forward, that it is hard, and that it is ‘not my profession’. Decades later he told his pupil Ascanio Condivi, whose biography of 1553 is close to an authorised account, that Bramante and other rivals had urged the commission on the pope in order to pull him away from sculpture and see him compared unfavourably with Raphael. In this version the ceiling is a trap he turned into a triumph, and the unfinished tomb is the tragedy of his life.

Bramante, as reported at the time

Bramante left no account of his own. But a letter to Michelangelo from the mason Piero Rosselli, dated 10 May 1506, reports a supper conversation at which Bramante told the pope that Michelangelo did not want the chapel job and probably lacked the courage for it, since he had little practice in painting figures seen from below. Rosselli says he contradicted him. On this evidence, which is contemporary where Condivi’s is not, Bramante was arguing against giving Michelangelo the ceiling, not scheming to land him with it.

Critics of papal Rome

Not everyone who saw the ceiling admired what it stood for. Luther, who visited Rome as a friar in the winter of 1510-11 while the scaffold was up, later remembered the city as a place where everything was for sale. Erasmus mocked the warrior pope in a satire that has Julius turned away from heaven’s gate. According to Vasari, the austere Dutch pope Adrian VI, elected in 1522, disliked the nude figures and spoke of the chapel as a bathhouse; later in the century draperies were painted over parts of Michelangelo’s Last Judgement on the altar wall.

What is disputed

The date marks the first payment and Michelangelo’s own statement that work began, but the old plaster had first to be hacked off and renewed, a job Rosselli was paid for through that summer; brushes probably did not touch the vault before the autumn or winter of 1508. The image of the artist lying on his back comes from a misreading of an early biography. Vasari’s claim that he dismissed his helpers and painted alone is contradicted by payment records studied by William Wallace. Who devised the theological scheme is unknown. The cleaning of 1980-94 remains contested: James Beck argued that it stripped away Michelangelo’s own finishing touches, the Vatican restorers that it removed only soot and later glue.

What followed

The ceiling changed what painters thought the human body could express, and Raphael altered his own style after seeing the first half. Michelangelo went back to the tomb, which shrank through forty years of renegotiation to a wall monument with a single great figure, the Moses. He returned to the chapel in 1536 to paint the Last Judgement. Some six million people now pass beneath the vault each year, and every papal conclave since 1878 has met under it.

Read further

  • Ascanio Condivi, The Life of Michelangelo (1553)
  • Giorgio Vasari, Lives of the Artists (1550, enlarged 1568)
  • William E. Wallace, Michelangelo: The Artist, the Man and His Times (2010)
  • Ross King, Michelangelo and the Pope’s Ceiling (2002)
  • Michael Hirst, Michelangelo: The Achievement of Fame, 1475-1534 (2011)

Same day, other years

1857

The rising at Meerut

Meerut, North-Western Provinces, IndiaAsia

On 9 May eighty-five troopers of the 3rd Bengal Light Cavalry, who had refused to handle cartridges they believed were greased with cow and pig fat, were stripped of their uniforms on the parade ground at Meerut, put in irons and sentenced to ten years’ hard labour. The following evening, a Sunday, the Indian regiments of the garrison rose, freed the prisoners and killed some fifty British officers, civilians, women and children. Then they rode through the night to Delhi, forty miles away, and next morning called on the aged Mughal emperor, Bahadur Shah Zafar, to lead them. Within weeks British authority across much of northern India had collapsed.

Seen from elsewhere. British writers called it the Sepoy Mutiny; V. D. Savarkar in 1909 named it India’s First War of Independence, and R. C. Majumdar later doubted it was either national or a war of independence. The cartridges were a spark: annexations, land settlements and fear of forced conversion lay behind it. British reprisals killed many times the number of Europeans who died.

1869

The last spike of the transcontinental railroad

Promontory Summit, Utah Territory, United StatesThe Americas

On 10 May 1869 the rails of the Central Pacific, built east from Sacramento, met those of the Union Pacific, built west from Omaha, on a sagebrush plateau north of the Great Salt Lake. Leland Stanford tapped a ceremonial golden spike into a laurelwood tie, a telegrapher sent the single word ‘Done’, and bells rang in cities on both coasts. A journey that had taken months by wagon or by sea now took about a week. The Central Pacific’s line through the Sierra Nevada had been cut largely by Chinese labourers, who made up most of its workforce of well over ten thousand.

Seen from elsewhere. The Chinese workers were paid less than white crews, struck for equal terms in 1867 and are all but invisible in the famous photograph of the day; Congress barred Chinese labour immigration in 1882. For the Lakota, Cheyenne, Pawnee, Shoshone and other nations, the railroad brought soldiers, settlers and hide hunters, and the near-extermination of the bison within fifteen years.

1933

Students burn books in Berlin

Berlin, GermanyEurope

On the night of 10 May 1933, in the square beside the Berlin opera house, members of the German Student Union threw some twenty thousand books on to a bonfire while the new propaganda minister, Joseph Goebbels, announced the end of an age of ‘Jewish intellectualism’. Similar fires burned in more than thirty university towns. The works were those of Marx, Freud, Heinrich Mann, Remarque, Einstein and many others, along with the looted library of Magnus Hirschfeld’s Institute for Sexual Science. The novelist Erich Kastner stood in the crowd and heard his own name read out as his books went into the flames.

Seen from elsewhere. The burnings were planned by student organisations, not ordered from above, and many professors attended in their gowns. The writer Oskar Maria Graf, finding himself left off the list, publicly demanded to be burned too. Heine’s line that those who burn books end by burning people, now set in the square, was written in 1821 about the burning of the Quran in Spain.

1994

Mandela is sworn in

Pretoria, South AfricaAfrica

Nelson Mandela took the oath as president of South Africa on 10 May 1994 in the amphitheatre of the Union Buildings in Pretoria, the seat of the governments that had imprisoned him for twenty-seven years. The country’s first election open to all races had been held two weeks earlier. Thabo Mbeki and the last apartheid president, F. W. de Klerk, were sworn in as his deputies, and military jets flown by white officers saluted him overhead. ‘Never, never and never again,’ he told the crowd and the largest gathering of foreign leaders the country had seen, ‘shall it be that this beautiful land will again experience the oppression of one by another.’

Seen from elsewhere. The transition was not bloodless: political violence killed some fourteen thousand people between 1990 and 1994, and white extremists set off bombs during election week. A later generation of South African critics argues that the negotiated settlement delivered the vote but left land and wealth largely where apartheid had put them.

Also on 10 May