Parallax

26 November, 1789

The new republic gives thanks, by presidential request

Washington’s first national Thanksgiving was meant to bless a seven-month-old constitution. Congress argued about whether he had any business asking.

New York City, United States

On 25 September 1789, the same day that Congress sent the states the amendments that became the Bill of Rights, the House of Representatives in New York heard a motion from Elias Boudinot of New Jersey. He wanted a joint committee to ask the President to recommend a day of public thanksgiving and prayer, so that the people could acknowledge the favours of Almighty God and, in particular, the chance to establish a constitution of government peaceably.

Not everyone liked the idea. Aedanus Burke of South Carolina said it was a mimicking of European customs, where thanksgivings were a kind of mockery. Thomas Tudor Tucker, also of South Carolina, objected that it was not the business of Congress, that religious matters belonged to the states, and that the people might prefer to wait until they had tried the constitution before giving thanks for it. The motion passed anyway, and the Senate agreed.

George Washington, five months into his presidency, signed the proclamation on 3 October. It named Thursday 26 November as a day to be devoted to the service of that great and glorious Being who is the beneficent Author of all the good that was, that is, or that will be. It gave thanks for divine care before independence, for the outcome of the war and for the peaceable way the constitution had been adopted, and asked God to pardon national transgressions and to make the government wise and just.

The language was carefully general. It named no church and no doctrine, and it recommended rather than commanded. Copies went out to the state governors, who were asked to pass it on, and newspapers up and down the coast printed it in full. In New York, which was then the capital, churches held services. Washington’s diary records that he went to St Paul’s Chapel, though the weather was stormy and few people came. Governors and clergy elsewhere observed the day or did not, as they chose.

It was not repeated as a regular event. Washington issued one more thanksgiving proclamation, in 1795, after the Whiskey Rebellion. John Adams called days of fasting and prayer. Thomas Jefferson refused to issue any proclamation, holding that the Constitution gave the federal government no authority over religious exercises. For seventy years after 1789 Thanksgiving remained a state holiday, strongest in New England, held on dates set by each governor.

How it came to this

Days of thanksgiving, and days of fasting, were an old Protestant practice, called by authorities in response to particular events: a victory, a good harvest, the end of a plague. The settlers of New England held them often. The occasion later remembered as the first Thanksgiving, in the autumn of 1621 at Plymouth, was described in a single paragraph by Edward Winslow: after the harvest the colonists held a celebration, and the Wampanoag leader Massasoit arrived with some ninety men, who stayed three days and brought five deer. Winslow did not call it a thanksgiving, and the Pilgrims would not have used the word for a feast.

During the Revolution the Continental Congress recommended several days of thanksgiving, the first of them on 18 December 1777 after the victory at Saratoga. Those recommendations had passed through Congress with little objection. In 1789 things were different. The new Constitution was barely in force, its religious clauses were being debated in the same session that drafted the First Amendment, and some members were wary of anything that looked like a national church.

How each side saw it

The Wampanoag

For the Wampanoag, the story attached to Thanksgiving begins with an alliance made under pressure. Massasoit’s people had been devastated by an epidemic between 1616 and 1619 and saw advantage in a pact with the newcomers against the Narragansett. Within fifty years that relationship ended in King Philip’s War, the death or enslavement of thousands and the loss of most Wampanoag land. In 1970, when Wamsutta Frank James was invited to speak at Plymouth’s anniversary celebrations and then told his text was unacceptable, Native activists began the National Day of Mourning, held on Cole’s Hill every Thanksgiving since.

Opponents in Congress

Burke and Tucker were not irreligious men. Their objection, recorded in the Annals of Congress, was about federal power and European habit. A national government that told citizens when to pray was, to them, the first step towards the established churches they had left behind, and it intruded on matters reserved to the states. Their view lost the vote in 1789, but it became the position of Jefferson as president and of a strong tradition in American constitutional thought about the separation of church and state.

Sarah Josepha Hale and the reformers

The holiday as Americans know it owes more to Sarah Josepha Hale than to Washington. As editor of Godey’s Lady’s Book she campaigned from the 1840s for one national Thanksgiving, writing editorials and letters to governors and presidents. She presented it as a domestic festival of family, home and table, and as a bond that might hold North and South together. After the war began she argued it would unite a divided nation. Lincoln proclaimed a national day in 1863, setting the last Thursday of November, which that year fell on 26 November.

What is disputed

The 1621 event’s date is unknown: Winslow’s letter puts it after the harvest, so sometime between late September and early November. The number of English survivors is usually given as about fifty. Popular accounts, including the book this site uses as an index, say the 1777 day was in October and that Roosevelt moved the holiday to the fourth Thursday; the 1777 day was in December, and Roosevelt in 1939 moved it to the second-to-last Thursday. Congress fixed the fourth Thursday by law in December 1941. Whether Washington’s proclamation was a religious act or a civic one is still argued in court cases about public prayer.

What followed

Hale’s campaign succeeded in 1863, and every president since has proclaimed the holiday. In 1939 Franklin Roosevelt brought it forward a week to lengthen the Christmas shopping season after retailers asked; about half the states refused to follow, and for two years the country had two Thanksgivings. Washington’s 1789 text is still quoted in arguments over the role of religion in American public life, by those who see a Christian nation and by those who point out what it carefully left out.

Read further

  • Edward Winslow and William Bradford, Mourt’s Relation (1622)
  • William Bradford, Of Plymouth Plantation
  • David J. Silverman, This Land Is Their Land: The Wampanoag Indians, Plymouth Colony, and the Troubled History of Thanksgiving (2019)
  • Diana Karter Appelbaum, Thanksgiving: An American Holiday, An American History (1984)
  • Annals of Congress, House of Representatives, 25 September 1789

Same day, other years

1161

The Song navy stops the Jin at the Yangtze

Caishi, on the Yangtze, ChinaAsia

The Jurchen emperor of the Jin, Wanyan Liang, had invaded Southern Song China intending to unite the whole country under his rule. At Caishi he tried to ferry his army across the Yangtze. Yu Yunwen, a civil official who happened to be there to deliver supplies, took command of the demoralised defenders and sent the Song river fleet against the crossing. Paddle-wheel warships, driven by men on treadmills, and gunpowder bombs thrown by catapult broke up the Jin boats. Within three weeks Wanyan Liang had been murdered by his own officers.

Seen from elsewhere. Jin sources blamed the defeat on Wanyan Liang’s tyranny, which had already provoked a rebellion that placed a rival emperor on the throne. Modern historians differ on how large the Jin force at the crossing really was; the Song figures may be inflated, and the battle’s fame rests partly on its use of gunpowder weapons.

1922

Carter looks into Tutankhamun’s tomb

Valley of the Kings, EgyptAfrica

Howard Carter had spent five fruitless seasons in the Valley of the Kings, paid for by Lord Carnarvon. In early November his workmen found a step cut into the rock, and on 26 November, with Carnarvon, his daughter Lady Evelyn Herbert and the engineer Arthur Callender beside him, Carter made a hole in the sealed inner doorway and held up a candle. Carnarvon asked whether he could see anything. Carter’s later published account gives his answer as yes, wonderful things. The antechamber was packed with gilded furniture, chariots and statues.

Seen from elsewhere. Carter’s own notebook records a shorter reply, and the famous phrase was polished for publication. Egyptian officials resented the exclusive deal Carnarvon sold to The Times, and in 1924 the government locked Carter out. Egypt kept the whole contents, overturning the custom of dividing finds, and most of the treasure stayed in Cairo.

1939

Shells fall on Mainila

Mainila, Karelian Isthmus, Soviet UnionEurope

Moscow announced that Finnish artillery had shelled the Soviet border village of Mainila, killing four Red Army soldiers and wounding nine. Finland had been refusing Soviet demands to move its border away from Leningrad and to lease a naval base. The Finnish government replied that its own guards had observed the shells landing on the Soviet side, and proposed a joint investigation. Moscow refused, renounced its non-aggression treaty with Finland, and on 30 November the Red Army invaded, beginning the Winter War. The League of Nations expelled the Soviet Union for the attack in December.

Seen from elsewhere. Soviet histories maintained for fifty years that Finland fired first. Finnish artillery had in fact been withdrawn out of range. Documents released after 1991 and accounts by former Soviet officials point to the shelling being staged by the NKVD, though Russian writers still dispute it.

1949

India adopts its constitution

New Delhi, IndiaAsia

After almost three years of debate, the Constituent Assembly of India adopted the longest written national constitution in the world. Its drafting committee was chaired by B. R. Ambedkar, a jurist and economist born into a Dalit family, who in his closing speech warned that India was entering a life of contradictions: political equality alongside social and economic inequality. The constitution abolished untouchability, guaranteed fundamental rights and created a parliamentary republic. It came into force on 26 January 1950, and since 2015 26 November has been marked nationally as Constitution Day.

Seen from elsewhere. The assembly was elected indirectly by provincial legislatures on a limited franchise, and critics on the left and right, then and since, argued that it did not represent the country. Hindu nationalists objected to its secularism; others argued that it preserved too much of the colonial Government of India Act of 1935.

Also on 26 November