On 25 September 1789, the same day that Congress sent the states the amendments that became the Bill of Rights, the House of Representatives in New York heard a motion from Elias Boudinot of New Jersey. He wanted a joint committee to ask the President to recommend a day of public thanksgiving and prayer, so that the people could acknowledge the favours of Almighty God and, in particular, the chance to establish a constitution of government peaceably.
Not everyone liked the idea. Aedanus Burke of South Carolina said it was a mimicking of European customs, where thanksgivings were a kind of mockery. Thomas Tudor Tucker, also of South Carolina, objected that it was not the business of Congress, that religious matters belonged to the states, and that the people might prefer to wait until they had tried the constitution before giving thanks for it. The motion passed anyway, and the Senate agreed.
George Washington, five months into his presidency, signed the proclamation on 3 October. It named Thursday 26 November as a day to be devoted to the service of that great and glorious Being who is the beneficent Author of all the good that was, that is, or that will be. It gave thanks for divine care before independence, for the outcome of the war and for the peaceable way the constitution had been adopted, and asked God to pardon national transgressions and to make the government wise and just.
The language was carefully general. It named no church and no doctrine, and it recommended rather than commanded. Copies went out to the state governors, who were asked to pass it on, and newspapers up and down the coast printed it in full. In New York, which was then the capital, churches held services. Washington’s diary records that he went to St Paul’s Chapel, though the weather was stormy and few people came. Governors and clergy elsewhere observed the day or did not, as they chose.
It was not repeated as a regular event. Washington issued one more thanksgiving proclamation, in 1795, after the Whiskey Rebellion. John Adams called days of fasting and prayer. Thomas Jefferson refused to issue any proclamation, holding that the Constitution gave the federal government no authority over religious exercises. For seventy years after 1789 Thanksgiving remained a state holiday, strongest in New England, held on dates set by each governor.
How it came to this
Days of thanksgiving, and days of fasting, were an old Protestant practice, called by authorities in response to particular events: a victory, a good harvest, the end of a plague. The settlers of New England held them often. The occasion later remembered as the first Thanksgiving, in the autumn of 1621 at Plymouth, was described in a single paragraph by Edward Winslow: after the harvest the colonists held a celebration, and the Wampanoag leader Massasoit arrived with some ninety men, who stayed three days and brought five deer. Winslow did not call it a thanksgiving, and the Pilgrims would not have used the word for a feast.
During the Revolution the Continental Congress recommended several days of thanksgiving, the first of them on 18 December 1777 after the victory at Saratoga. Those recommendations had passed through Congress with little objection. In 1789 things were different. The new Constitution was barely in force, its religious clauses were being debated in the same session that drafted the First Amendment, and some members were wary of anything that looked like a national church.