Parallax

2 November, 1470

A king is born in hiding, and vanishes at twelve

Edward V was born in the sanctuary at Westminster while his father was a fugitive abroad. He reigned for less than three months, was never crowned, and nobody can prove what became of him.

Westminster, England

In the autumn of 1470 the queen of England was living on charity in the precincts of Westminster Abbey. Elizabeth Woodville had fled there from the Tower with her three small daughters when the Earl of Warwick invaded, restored the deposed Henry VI and drove her husband, Edward IV, across the North Sea to the Low Countries. The abbot, Thomas Millyng, gave her rooms. A London butcher is recorded as supplying meat on credit. On 2 November, attended by a midwife and a few women, she gave birth to her first son by the king. He was baptised in the abbey with little ceremony and named after a father who had not seen him and might never return.

The father did return. Edward IV landed in Yorkshire the following spring, destroyed Warwick at Barnet and the Lancastrians at Tewkesbury, and came to the sanctuary to collect his family. The baby was made Prince of Wales and at three was sent to Ludlow on the Welsh border, where he grew up under the supervision of his mother’s brother, Anthony Woodville, Earl Rivers, a soldier and scholar who followed a timetable the king had drawn up for the boy’s lessons, meals and bedtime.

He was still at Ludlow, aged twelve, when Edward IV died on 9 April 1483. Rivers set out with him for London and a coronation. At Stony Stratford on 30 April the party was intercepted by the late king’s brother, Richard, Duke of Gloucester, who arrested Rivers and the boy’s other attendants and took charge of his nephew. The queen went back into sanctuary at Westminster with her younger son.

Events then moved in weeks. Gloucester was named Protector. The young king was lodged in the Tower, the usual residence before a coronation. On 13 June Lord Hastings, the old king’s closest friend, was beheaded without trial. On 16 June the queen was persuaded to give up nine-year-old Richard, Duke of York, to join his brother. On 22 June a sermon at St Paul’s Cross announced that Edward IV had been contracted to another woman before he married Elizabeth, so that their children were bastards. On 26 June Gloucester took the throne as Richard III.

The Italian visitor Dominic Mancini, who left England in July, wrote that the two boys were withdrawn into the inner rooms of the Tower and seen more and more rarely behind the bars and windows, until they ceased to appear at all. The elder boy’s physician, he added, reported that the young king was making daily confession like a victim prepared for sacrifice, because he believed death was facing him. After the summer of 1483 there is no certain record of either child alive.

How it came to this

The Wars of the Roses were in their third decade. Edward IV, of the house of York, had taken the crown from the Lancastrian Henry VI in 1461 with the help of his cousin Warwick. In 1464 he secretly married Elizabeth Woodville, a widow about five years his senior with two sons and a large family of brothers and sisters. The match brought no foreign alliance, humiliated Warwick, who had been negotiating a French bride, and filled the court with Woodville relations who needed titles and heirs to marry.

Resentment of the Woodvilles outlived Warwick. When Edward IV died unexpectedly at forty, the question was who would control a king of twelve: his mother’s family, who had brought him up, or his father’s brother, who had governed the north loyally for a decade. English precedent for royal minorities was poor. Richard II and Henry VI had both come to the throne as children, and both had been deposed and killed. An earlier Duke of Gloucester who served as protector to a boy king had died in custody.

How each side saw it

The Tudor tradition

The account most people know was written under the dynasty that overthrew Richard. Thomas More’s History of King Richard III, composed about thirty years later, says that Sir James Tyrell arranged the murder on Richard’s orders and that two men, Miles Forest and John Dighton, smothered the boys in their beds and buried them at the foot of a stair. Polydore Vergil, Henry VII’s official historian, agrees on the guilt. Shakespeare turned it into theatre. Its defenders note that the story was already believed in 1483: the chancellor of France told the Estates General in January 1484 that the children had been killed and the crown given to their murderer.

Richard’s defenders

Since the seventeenth century, and through the Richard III Society since 1924, others have argued that the case is hearsay recorded by his enemies. Richard had the boys declared illegitimate by Parliament and so, on this view, had no need to kill them. Suspicion is directed instead at the Duke of Buckingham, who rebelled that autumn, or at Henry VII, whose claim required them dead. Philippa Langley, who led the search that found Richard’s grave, published documents in 2023 which she reads as showing that both boys survived and were the pretenders later known as Lambert Simnel and Perkin Warbeck. Most academic historians are not persuaded.

Elizabeth Woodville

The boys’ mother left no statement, and her actions have been read both ways. In 1483 she joined the plot to marry her eldest daughter to the exiled Henry Tudor, which makes sense only if she believed her sons were dead. Yet in March 1484 she came out of sanctuary and placed her daughters in Richard’s care, after he swore a public oath to protect them, and she wrote urging her surviving son by her first marriage to come home and make his peace. Either she had been reassured, or a woman with five daughters and no income had run out of choices.

What is disputed

Almost everything after June 1483. The birth date is usually given as 2 November 1470, though some older reference works say the 4th. The story of the earlier marriage contract, attributed by the French memoirist Commynes to Bishop Stillington, cannot be checked. Bones of two children found under a staircase in the Tower in 1674 were placed in Westminster Abbey as the princes; an examination in 1933 judged the ages consistent, but its methods are now thought weak, and requests for DNA testing have been refused. In 2021 Tim Thornton argued that More could have heard the tale from the sons of one of the alleged killers.

What followed

Richard III was killed at Bosworth in August 1485. Henry VII married the boys’ sister, Elizabeth of York, and repealed the act that had made her illegitimate, which also restored her brothers’ right had they lived. He spent years fighting pretenders who claimed to be one or other of them, and never produced the bodies or a public inquiry. Edward V is counted among English kings although he was never crowned. His sister’s descendants have held the throne ever since, and the argument over his uncle remains the liveliest in English medieval history.

Read further

  • Dominic Mancini, The Usurpation of Richard III, edited by C. A. J. Armstrong (1969)
  • Thomas More, The History of King Richard III
  • Charles Ross, Richard III (1981)
  • Rosemary Horrox, Richard III: A Study of Service (1989)
  • A. J. Pollard, Richard III and the Princes in the Tower (1991)

Same day, other years

1917

Britain promises a Jewish national home in Palestine

London and PalestineMiddle East

In a letter of a single sentence of substance, the foreign secretary Arthur Balfour told Lord Rothschild that the British government viewed with favour the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, on the understanding that nothing should prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities. British troops were then fighting their way towards Jerusalem. The declaration owed much to the lobbying of Chaim Weizmann and to hopes of rallying Jewish opinion in America and Russia to the Allied cause. Written into the League of Nations mandate in 1922, it shaped thirty years of British rule and the conflict that has followed.

Seen from elsewhere. Arabs, about nine-tenths of Palestine’s people in 1917, were not consulted and were named only as ‘non-Jewish communities’ with no political rights mentioned; Palestinians mark the date as a day of mourning. Britain had made overlapping wartime promises to the Sharif of Mecca and to France. Edwin Montagu, the one Jewish cabinet minister, opposed the declaration.

1920

Election day massacre at Ocoee

Ocoee, Florida, United StatesThe Americas

When Black citizens of this small citrus town near Orlando tried to vote in the presidential election, they were turned away. One of them, Mose Norman, went to seek legal advice and came back. That evening a white crowd, some of them deputised, surrounded the house of his friend July Perry. After an exchange of gunfire in which two white men died, the mob burned the Black district of northern Ocoee, including its churches and lodge. Perry was taken from jail and lynched. The number of Black dead is unknown; estimates run from a handful to more than fifty. The survivors fled, and their land was sold.

Seen from elsewhere. Local white accounts at the time described a riot begun by armed Black men. Walter White of the NAACP, investigating undercover, reported a planned effort to stop Black voting. Ocoee had almost no Black residents for half a century afterwards. The city issued a formal apology in 2018.

1930

Haile Selassie is crowned in Addis Ababa

Addis Ababa, EthiopiaAfrica

Ras Tafari Makonnen, regent of Ethiopia since 1916, was crowned emperor in St George’s Cathedral under the name Haile Selassie, Power of the Trinity. He had the capital paved and lit for the occasion and invited the world: a British royal duke, a French marshal and an Italian prince attended, and newsreels carried the ceremony abroad. Ethiopia was then one of only two African states not under European rule. In Jamaica, preachers such as Leonard Howell read the crowning of a Black king with the titles King of Kings and Lion of Judah as the fulfilment of scripture, and the Rastafari movement took his former name.

Seen from elsewhere. Haile Selassie was a devout Orthodox Christian and did not accept the divinity Rastafari attributed to him. Inside Ethiopia critics saw a centralising autocrat; his 1931 constitution kept power in his hands, and slavery was not finally abolished until 1942. He was deposed by soldiers in 1974 after a concealed famine.

1963

Ngo Dinh Diem is shot in the back of an armoured car

Saigon, South VietnamAsia

South Vietnam’s president and his brother and adviser Ngo Dinh Nhu had slipped out of the besieged palace during the coup that began on 1 November and taken refuge in a church in the Chinese quarter of Cholon. On the morning of All Souls’ Day they telephoned the generals and surrendered. An armoured personnel carrier was sent to collect them. When it arrived at headquarters both men were dead, shot and stabbed with their hands tied. The plotters first announced suicide. Washington had been told the coup was coming and had signalled that it would not object. A string of short-lived military governments followed.

Seen from elsewhere. Buddhists, whose protests Diem’s forces had met with raids on pagodas, and many Saigon residents celebrated. Vietnamese Catholics mourned him, and historians such as Edward Miller and Mark Moyar argue he was an independent nationalist, not an American puppet. Kennedy was reported to be shaken; Lyndon Johnson later called American complicity a grave mistake.

Also on 2 November