Parallax

16 November, 1272

Henry III dies at Westminster

He had been king since he was nine, been his own barons’ prisoner, and rebuilt Westminster Abbey around the saint he loved. He died in his palace beside it, not, as is sometimes said, locked in the Tower.

Palace of Westminster, England

Henry III of England died at the Palace of Westminster on the evening of 16 November 1272. He was sixty-five and had been king for fifty-six years. His last days were noisy. The citizens of London were disputing the election of a mayor, and a London chronicle records that the crowd came out to Westminster shouting for its candidate, Walter Hervey, so that the clamour reached the chamber where the king lay.

He was buried four days later in the abbey church next door, which he had spent a quarter of a century and a fortune rebuilding in the new French style. They laid him before the high altar in the grave from which he had himself, three years earlier, lifted the body of Edward the Confessor into a golden shrine. Henry had named his eldest son after that saint. At the graveside the Earl of Gloucester and the other magnates swore allegiance to the absent heir.

The heir was in Sicily, on his way home from crusade, and did not reach England for nearly two years. Nothing happened. A council governed in his name, and Edward I’s reign was dated from the day of the funeral. It was the first time since the Norman Conquest that a king had succeeded without hurrying to be crowned, and it says something for the kingdom the old man left.

It had not always seemed likely. Henry was crowned at Gloucester in October 1216 with a plain gold circlet, because his father, King John, had died in the middle of a civil war with a French prince holding London. Regents won the war for him and reissued Magna Carta in his name. As a grown ruler he was devout, open-handed, fond of his wife and children, and a poor judge of what he could afford. He lost a campaign in Poitou. He promised the pope an impossible sum to make his second son King of Sicily.

In 1258 the barons came to him in armour and imposed a council to govern with him. The scheme collapsed into war. At Lewes in 1264 his brother-in-law Simon de Montfort captured him, and for fifteen months ruled England with the king as a kept figurehead. At Evesham in August 1265, where Montfort was killed, Henry was on the field in borrowed armour among his captors, wounded by his own side, and is said by the chroniclers to have saved himself by shouting who he was. That, and not any stay in the Tower, was his captivity.

How it came to this

Henry inherited a diminished crown. His grandfather Henry II had ruled from Scotland to the Pyrenees; John lost Normandy and Anjou to the French king in 1204 and was forced by his barons in 1215 to seal Magna Carta. Henry never accepted the loss of the family lands, and paid for failed attempts to recover them, until in the Treaty of Paris of 1259 he gave up his claims and did homage to Louis IX of France for Gascony, which was all that remained.

At home the charter, confirmed in its final form in 1225 in return for a tax, set the terms of politics: the king was expected to take counsel and ask consent for extraordinary taxation, in assemblies that from the 1230s were being called parliaments. Henry’s reliance on his wife’s Savoyard uncles and his own Lusignan half-brothers, all foreigners in English eyes, and the debts of the Sicilian scheme, turned grumbling into the reform movement of 1258. Its programme, the Provisions of Oxford, placed the king under an elected council, something no English monarch had yet been asked to bear.

How each side saw it

The Montfortians

For the reformers the issue was whether a king could be bound by law and by the counsel of his subjects. The ‘Song of Lewes’, a Latin poem written by a supporter after the victory of 1264, argues that the king is beneath the law and that the community of the realm should correct him. Montfort’s parliament of January 1265 summoned representatives of the towns as well as knights of the shires. After he was killed and mutilated at Evesham, pilgrims reported miracles at his grave, and the royal settlement of 1266 had to forbid anyone to call him a saint.

The Jews of England

England’s Jews were legally the king’s property, and Henry taxed them until the community was ruined; the chronicler Matthew Paris records their leader, Elias of London, begging in 1254 for leave to quit the country. In 1255, after a boy’s body was found in a well at Lincoln, Henry personally accepted the accusation of ritual murder and had some nineteen Jews hanged, the first time a king gave the blood libel the force of law. Montfort’s followers massacred Jews in London and elsewhere in 1264. Their experience is known almost wholly from royal records and Christian chronicles. Edward I expelled them all in 1290.

The Welsh

Seen from Gwynedd, Henry’s reign ended in a Welsh success. Early on he had kept the heir of Llywelyn the Great as a hostage in the Tower of London, where the prisoner fell to his death in 1244 trying to climb down a rope of knotted sheets. But the English civil war let that man’s son, Llywelyn ap Gruffudd, unite most of native Wales, and by the Treaty of Montgomery in 1267 Henry recognised him as Prince of Wales, the only time the English crown conceded the title to a Welsh ruler. The Welsh chronicle ‘Brut y Tywysogion’ records it. Edward I destroyed the principality within sixteen years.

Historians, then and now

Contemporaries were hard on him. Matthew Paris, the monk of St Albans who knew him and drew him, thought him grasping and easily led, and Dante placed him among the negligent rulers in Purgatory as ‘the king of the simple life’. Victorian constitutional historians treated him as the foil to the hero Montfort. The modern biographies, above all David Carpenter’s, are kinder: they describe a pious, peaceable man who gave England twenty-four years without civil war after 1234, presided over the growth of parliament and the common law, and left the abbey that has crowned his successors.

What is disputed

The book has Henry dying ‘incarcerated in the Tower’. No source supports this; he died at Westminster, a free man and reigning king, as the chronicles and the record of his burial show. Its verdict that he was cowardly and senile is also harsher than the evidence. His reign of fifty-six years was the longest in English history until George III, and has since been passed by Victoria and Elizabeth II as well. The words he is supposed to have cried at Evesham vary between chronicles and may be embroidery. Whether Montfort was a principled reformer or an ambitious magnate remains an open argument.

What followed

Edward I kept the lesson of his father’s reign: he legislated in parliament and summoned the commons to grant his taxes, and he conquered Wales and nearly Scotland with the money. The Statute of Marlborough of 1267, which made parts of the reformers’ programme permanent, contains the oldest English statute law still in force. Henry’s body was moved in 1290 to the tomb of Italian mosaic work where it still lies, under a gilt-bronze effigy. His heart was sent, as he had promised, to the family abbey of Fontevraud in Anjou.

Read further

  • David Carpenter, Henry III: The Rise to Power and Personal Rule, 1207-1258 (2020)
  • David Carpenter, Henry III: Reform, Rebellion, Civil War, Settlement, 1258-1272 (2023)
  • J. R. Maddicott, Simon de Montfort (1994)
  • F. M. Powicke, King Henry III and the Lord Edward (1947)
  • Matthew Paris, Chronica Majora

Same day, other years

1532

Atahualpa is seized at Cajamarca

Cajamarca, PeruThe Americas

Atahualpa had just won a civil war for the Inca empire when he agreed to meet a party of strangers in the highland town of Cajamarca. He came on the afternoon of 16 November 1532, carried on a litter, with several thousand attendants who were unarmed or nearly so. Francisco Pizarro had 168 men, hidden in the buildings round the square with horses and a few small guns. A friar, Vicente de Valverde, addressed the Inca through an interpreter and handed him a book of prayers, which Atahualpa examined and threw down. The Spaniards charged. Thousands were killed in two hours, none of them Spanish. Atahualpa was taken alive, ransomed for a roomful of gold, and garrotted the following July.

Seen from elsewhere. Spanish eyewitnesses claimed they forestalled an ambush. The account dictated in 1570 by the Inca ruler Titu Cusi Yupanqui says his people came in peace and were cut down like sheep. Supporters of Atahualpa’s defeated brother, and subject peoples such as the Cañari, at first welcomed the newcomers as allies.

1632

Gustavus Adolphus is killed at Lützen

Lützen, Saxony, GermanyEurope

Gustavus Adolphus, who had come to the Swedish throne at sixteen in 1611, landed in Germany in 1630 and in two years turned the Thirty Years’ War against the Catholic emperor. On 16 November 1632 by the new calendar, 6 November by the one Sweden used, he attacked the imperial army of Albrecht von Wallenstein in fog near Lützen, south-west of Leipzig. Leading a cavalry charge, short-sighted and without armour because of an old wound, he became separated from his men, was shot several times and stripped where he lay. His army, told he was dead, fought on and held the field at nightfall. He was thirty-seven. His heir, Christina, was five.

Seen from elsewhere. Protestant Europe mourned a deliverer, and Sweden still marks 6 November with a pastry bearing his profile. In Catholic Bavaria and the Rhineland his soldiers were remembered for plunder and torture. Wallenstein also claimed the victory. A rumour that the king was shot by a German prince in his own escort has never been substantiated.

1885

Louis Riel is hanged

Regina, CanadaThe Americas

Louis Riel led the Métis, the French-speaking Catholic people of mixed Indigenous and European descent on the Canadian prairies, in two resistances to the extension of Ottawa’s rule over their lands. The first, at Red River in 1869-70, won the creation of the province of Manitoba; during it his provisional government shot an Ontario Protestant, Thomas Scott. The second, in Saskatchewan in 1885, was crushed by troops sent west on the new railway. Riel surrendered and was tried for high treason at Regina before a jury of six English-speaking Protestants. He rejected his lawyers’ plea of insanity. The jury convicted and recommended mercy. He was hanged on 16 November 1885.

Seen from elsewhere. English Ontario saw a rebel and Scott’s murderer; French Quebec saw one of its own killed for his language and faith, and turned against the governing Conservatives for generations. Eleven days later eight Cree and Assiniboine men were hanged together at Battleford. Canada’s Parliament recognised Riel as a founder of Manitoba in 1992.

1989

Six Jesuits and two women are murdered in San Salvador

San Salvador, El SalvadorThe Americas

Before dawn on 16 November 1989, during a guerrilla offensive in the capital, soldiers of the Salvadoran army’s Atlacatl Battalion entered the campus of the Central American University. They took six Jesuit priests from their beds and shot them on the lawn: the rector, Ignacio Ellacuría, and Ignacio Martín-Baró, Segundo Montes, Amando López, Juan Ramón Moreno and Joaquín López y López. They also killed the housekeeper, Elba Ramos, and her sixteen-year-old daughter Celina, so as to leave no witnesses, and scrawled a sign blaming the rebels. The priests had been pressing for a negotiated end to a civil war that had by then cost some 70,000 lives. Peace was signed in 1992.

Seen from elsewhere. The army and much of the Salvadoran right regarded the university as the brains of the insurgency. The high command denied involvement; a UN truth commission in 1993 found that it had given the order. A colonel and a lieutenant were convicted and then amnestied. A Spanish court jailed a former vice-minister, Inocente Montano, in 2020.

Also on 16 November