Parallax

15 November, 1684

The Hall of Mirrors is shown to the court

Seventy-three metres of glass, gilt and painted victories, built so that a king could walk every day beneath his own apotheosis. The men who made it and the countries shown defeated on its ceiling saw it rather differently.

Versailles, France

When the court of Louis XIV came back to Versailles from its autumn stay at Fontainebleau in mid-November 1684, the scaffolding had gone from the long room on the garden side of the palace. The Grande Galerie, as it was then called, had been six years in the making. It ran the whole width of the central block, linking the king’s apartments to the queen’s: seventy-three metres long and more than twelve high, with seventeen tall windows looking west over the gardens and, facing them, seventeen arches filled with mirrors.

There were 357 panes, and they were the room’s first boast. Until the 1660s only Venice could make mirror glass of any size, and guarded the secret with its laws. Louis’s minister Jean-Baptiste Colbert had bribed workmen away from Murano and set up a royal manufactory in Paris. Every mirror in the gallery was French, and was meant to be understood as a victory of French industry.

The second boast was overhead. Charles Le Brun, the king’s first painter, had proposed a ceiling on the labours of Hercules, and before that one on Apollo. After the Peace of Nijmegen in 1678 the council chose something bolder: the king himself, in Roman armour and a full wig, in thirty scenes of his own reign since 1661. He crosses the Rhine, takes Ghent in six days, and governs alone, while figures of Holland, Spain and Germany cower or submit. The explanatory inscriptions were later rewritten in French by Racine and Boileau.

It was furnished in solid silver: tables, candle stands and tubs for orange trees, lit at night by thousands of candles doubled in the glass. But the gallery was above all a corridor. The king passed through it each morning on his way to mass, and anyone decently dressed could stand there and try to catch his eye or hand him a petition. On great days a throne was set up at the far end. The Doge of Genoa, whose city the French fleet had bombarded, came there in May 1685 to apologise in person; asked what he found most remarkable at Versailles, he is reported by Voltaire to have answered, ‘To see myself here.’ Ambassadors from Siam climbed the dais in 1686.

The silver lasted five years. In 1689, with France at war against most of Europe, Louis sent it all to the mint.

How it came to this

Versailles began as a hunting lodge built by Louis XIII on poor, marshy ground twenty kilometres from Paris. His son started enlarging it in 1661, the year he took government into his own hands, using the architect, painter and gardener who had just made a too-splendid house for his finance minister, Nicolas Fouquet, whom he had arrested. Colbert protested in writing that the money would be better spent on the Louvre. The king, who had been driven from Paris as a boy during the civil wars of the Fronde, never liked the city.

In May 1682 the court and the ministries moved to Versailles for good. Several thousand people lived in the palace and many more in the town, the great nobles among them, drawn from their provinces to compete for lodgings and for the right to hand the king his shirt. Jules Hardouin-Mansart, architect from 1678, built the gallery over an open terrace left by his predecessor. Building never stopped: in 1685 the diarist Dangeau counted 36,000 men at work on the palace, the park and an aqueduct meant to bring water for the fountains.

How each side saw it

The Duke of Saint-Simon

The most famous account of Versailles from inside was written by a man who loathed it. Saint-Simon, a duke and peer who lived at court from the 1690s, called the site the saddest and most barren of places, without view, wood or water, chosen so that the king could tyrannise over nature. In his memoirs the palace is a device for ruining the old nobility: lured into attendance, bankrupted by display, set against one another over trifles of etiquette while real power went to middle-class ministers. Historians value him as a witness and discount him as a partisan of his own caste.

The labourers and the taxpayers

The masons, glaziers, soldiers and peasants who built Versailles left no testimony of their own. Their conditions are glimpsed in the royal building accounts, which record payments to the injured and to widows, and in a letter of Madame de Sévigné in October 1678 reporting that cartloads of dead workmen were taken away every night. Fever from the stagnant ground killed many more on the aqueduct works in the 1680s, a project then abandoned. The money came from a peasantry that in 1693-94 suffered a famine in which well over a million people died.

The nations on the ceiling

To foreign visitors the paintings were an insult set in gold. The Dutch, shown as a humbled woman, and the German princes, whose lands across the Rhine French armies laid waste in 1689, took Versailles as the image of the power they were fighting, even as they copied its architecture at home. The memory lasted. In January 1871, with Paris under siege, the German princes proclaimed the King of Prussia German Emperor in this room. In June 1919 the victorious Allies made German delegates sign the peace treaty at a table placed on the same spot.

Modern historians

The older picture, drawn from Saint-Simon, was of a gilded cage in which an absolute king tamed his nobles. Norbert Elias turned it into a theory of how court manners civilised a warrior class. Peter Burke described the whole enterprise as the deliberate manufacture of a royal image by committees of artists and writers. More recent work, by Roger Mettam and William Beik among others, argues that the great nobility came to Versailles willingly, because that was where offices, pensions and marriages were to be had, and that the king ruled with them far more than over them.

What is disputed

The date of 15 November 1684 is the one commonly given for the gallery’s completion and first showing to the court, but there was no ceremony of opening in the modern sense, and the decoration was finished in stages. The total cost of Versailles is uncertain: the surviving accounts suggest something under 100 million livres across the reign, which critics then and since have thought an underestimate. The story that Venice had defecting glassworkers poisoned is old and unproven. The figure of 36,000 workers comes from Dangeau and includes troops digging the aqueduct, not the palace alone.

What followed

The court stayed until 6 October 1789, when a crowd from Paris brought the royal family back to the city. The furniture was auctioned during the Revolution and the palace was spared by being turned into a museum ‘to all the glories of France’ in the 1830s. The gallery was restored between 2004 and 2007 and is now walked through by several million visitors a year, which makes it, as it was designed to be, the most looked-at room in France.

Read further

  • Peter Burke, The Fabrication of Louis XIV (1992)
  • Louis de Rouvroy, duc de Saint-Simon, Mémoires
  • Tony Spawforth, Versailles: A Biography of a Palace (2008)
  • Guy Walton, Louis XIV’s Versailles (1986)
  • Norbert Elias, The Court Society (1969)

Same day, other years

1884

The Berlin Conference opens

Berlin, GermanyAfrica

On 15 November 1884 delegates of fourteen states, twelve European plus the United States and the Ottoman Empire, met in Bismarck’s official residence in Berlin under a large map of Africa. No African ruler was invited. The agenda was trade and navigation on the Congo and Niger rivers and the rules by which a power could claim a stretch of coast. The General Act, signed the following February, required ‘effective occupation’ and notice to the other signatories, and the conference recognised the private Congo venture of King Leopold II of the Belgians as a state. Within twenty-five years almost the whole continent was under European flags.

Seen from elsewhere. Historians caution that the conference did not itself carve up Africa; most borders were set afterwards in two-power treaties, and the scramble had already begun. Its importance was in agreeing that Africans had no standing in the matter. Leopold’s Congo, approved as a free-trade and humanitarian project, became a system of forced labour that killed millions.

1889

Brazil’s emperor is overthrown

Rio de Janeiro, BrazilThe Americas

On the morning of 15 November 1889 Marshal Deodoro da Fonseca, ill and until recently a monarchist, led troops to the war ministry in Rio de Janeiro to depose the cabinet. By evening the officers and republican politicians around him had gone further and declared the empire at an end. Pedro II, who had reigned since childhood in 1831 and was personally respected, made no resistance and sailed into exile with his family two days later; he died in a Paris hotel in 1891. The monarchy had lost the planters by abolishing slavery without compensation eighteen months before, and the army by neglect.

Seen from elsewhere. A republican journalist, Aristides Lobo, wrote that the people watched dumbfounded, taking it for a parade. Monarchists called it a barracks coup with no popular mandate. Many freed Black Brazilians credited abolition to Princess Isabel, and some had organised to defend the throne; the republic gave them neither land nor schooling.

1908

The Empress Dowager Cixi dies

Beijing, ChinaAsia

Cixi entered the Forbidden City as a low-ranking concubine, bore the Xianfeng Emperor his only son, and after a palace coup in 1861 ruled China from behind a screen for most of the next forty-seven years, through two child emperors. She died on 15 November 1908, aged seventy-two, one day after her nephew, the Guangxu Emperor, whom she had kept confined since crushing his reform programme in 1898. On her deathbed she named a two-year-old, Puyi, as his successor. The dynasty fell just over three years later. Tests on the emperor’s remains published in 2008 found arsenic at lethal levels.

Seen from elsewhere. Who poisoned him is unproven; she is the leading suspect. Her reputation as a reactionary monster owes much to a diary forged by the Englishman Edmund Backhouse. Revisionists, notably Jung Chang, present a moderniser who after 1901 abolished the examination system and promised a constitution. Most specialists place her between the two portraits.

1988

The Palestinian declaration of independence

Algiers, AlgeriaMiddle East

In the early hours of 15 November 1988, at a meeting of the Palestine National Council in Algiers, Yasser Arafat read out a declaration proclaiming the State of Palestine with Jerusalem as its capital. The text was written by the poet Mahmoud Darwish. It came eleven months into the uprising in the occupied territories, and three months after Jordan gave up its claim to the West Bank. By citing the United Nations partition resolution of 1947, and in an accompanying statement accepting Security Council Resolution 242, the PLO implied for the first time that the state would exist beside Israel and not in place of it. Scores of countries recognised it within weeks.

Seen from elsewhere. Israel’s government dismissed the declaration as a manoeuvre by an organisation it classed as terrorist, and noted that the state controlled no territory. Hamas and some PLO factions rejected the implied acceptance of partition. The United States opened talks with the PLO a month later, after Arafat renounced terrorism in explicit terms.

Also on 15 November