Parallax

11 November, 1918

The guns stop at eleven

The armistice was signed in a railway carriage a little after five in the morning. The fighting went on for six more hours, and nearly three thousand men died in them.

Forest of Compiègne, France

The German delegation crossed the French lines on the evening of 7 November 1918 in a column of cars flying white flags, with a bugler on the running board of the first. They were driven through the wreckage of the front and put on a train with drawn blinds. When it stopped next morning they were in a clearing in the forest of Compiègne, alongside a second train: the mobile headquarters of Marshal Ferdinand Foch, supreme commander of the Allied armies.

The delegation was led by a civilian, Matthias Erzberger, a Catholic Centre Party politician who had argued for a negotiated peace since 1917. The German high command had asked for the armistice and then made sure that no senior general would put his name to it. Foch received them in a converted dining car. He asked what they wanted, declined to call the meeting a negotiation, and had the terms read aloud. Germany was to evacuate France, Belgium and Alsace-Lorraine within fifteen days, hand over 5,000 guns, 25,000 machine guns, 1,700 aircraft, 5,000 locomotives and all its submarines, and accept Allied garrisons on the Rhine. The naval blockade would continue. They had seventy-two hours. Erzberger asked for a ceasefire while they considered. Foch refused.

During those three days Germany changed regime. The Kaiser’s abdication was announced on 9 November and a republic proclaimed in Berlin. On the evening of the 10th a message from the new chancellor, Friedrich Ebert, authorised signature, and Field Marshal Hindenburg advised it. The delegates won small changes, fewer machine guns among them, on the argument that the government would need them against revolution. They signed a few minutes after five on the morning of the 11th; the document records the time as five o’clock. Erzberger read a protest ending with the words that a people of seventy million suffers but does not die. Foch said ‘Très bien’ and the two sides parted without shaking hands.

The ceasefire was set for eleven, to give time for the order to reach every unit. Some commanders let the morning pass quietly. Others attacked. American divisions were sent across the Meuse under fire; one general later explained an assault on the town of Stenay by the need for bathing facilities. Henry Gunther of Baltimore, a sergeant reduced to private, charged a German machine-gun post near Chaumont-devant-Damvillers and was shot at 10.59. A Canadian, George Price, had been killed by a sniper two minutes earlier, and a French runner, Augustin Trébuchon, at about 10.45.

At eleven the firing stopped along four hundred miles of front. Men who were there mostly remembered the silence, and an absence of cheering in the line that contrasted with the crowds in London, Paris and New York.

How it came to this

The war on the Western Front had been deadlocked for more than three years when Russia’s collapse allowed Germany to move its eastern armies west. General Erich Ludendorff’s offensives in the spring of 1918 gained more ground than any attack since 1914 and cost nearly a million casualties without breaking the Allies. From July, and decisively from the British victory at Amiens on 8 August, the Allied armies, now reinforced by two million Americans, drove the Germans back in a continuous advance.

Germany’s allies fell away in turn: Bulgaria at the end of September, the Ottoman Empire on 30 October, Austria-Hungary on 3 November. On 29 September Ludendorff told the Kaiser that an armistice must be sought at once, and insisted that the request come from a new civilian government answerable to parliament. The approach was made to the American president, Woodrow Wilson, on the basis of his Fourteen Points. While notes were exchanged, sailors of the High Seas Fleet mutinied at Kiel rather than sail on a last sortie, and workers’ and soldiers’ councils took over German cities one after another.

How each side saw it

The German army and the nationalist right

Because the front was still on foreign soil when the firing stopped, and because a civilian signed, it was possible to claim the army had never been beaten. Hindenburg told a parliamentary inquiry in November 1919 that it had been stabbed in the back, attributing the phrase to an English general. The men who signed were named the November criminals. Erzberger was shot dead by members of a nationalist murder squad while walking in the Black Forest in August 1921. Ludendorff’s own demand for an immediate armistice, recorded in the staff papers of September 1918, was left out of the story.

Pershing and those who wanted to fight on

General John Pershing, commanding the American armies, wrote to the Allied Supreme War Council at the end of October urging that no armistice be granted and that the war continue until Germany surrendered unconditionally. He thought an army that marched home in formation would not believe itself defeated. Foch answered that the terms gave the Allies everything a victory would, and that he would not spend one more life for a result already in hand. Foch himself came to think the later peace too lenient; the remark that it was an armistice for twenty years is widely attributed to him.

German civilians under the blockade

Article 26 of the armistice kept the Allied naval blockade in force. Food was not allowed into Germany in quantity until March 1919, and the blockade was lifted only after the peace treaty was signed in the summer. German health officials attributed some three quarters of a million civilian deaths to hunger during the war; later demographers, including Jay Winter, arrive at lower figures but agree the excess mortality was severe. For many Germans this, more than the terms read out in the carriage, was the proof that the armistice had been a continuation of war by other means.

Africa and the east, where the war did not end

In East Africa the German commander Paul von Lettow-Vorbeck did not hear of the armistice for two days and surrendered at Abercorn, in what is now Zambia, on 25 November. The campaign had been carried on the backs of conscripted African porters, of whom around 100,000 on the British side alone are estimated to have died, mostly of disease and hunger. They left almost no written record. In eastern and central Europe, as the historian Robert Gerwarth has argued, 1918 marked a change of wars, not an end: fighting in Russia, Poland, Hungary, Ireland and Anatolia continued into the 1920s.

What is disputed

The exact minute of signing is uncertain; accounts give between 5.10 and 5.20, and the text was backdated to five. Joseph Persico counted about 2,700 dead and nearly 11,000 total casualties on all sides on the last morning, figures others consider approximate. Whether the final attacks were justified was examined by a committee of the United States Congress in 1919-20, which reached no agreed verdict. The identity of the ‘last man killed’ depends on nationality and on records that were sometimes altered: Trébuchon’s grave, like those of other Frenchmen who fell that morning, is dated 10 November.

What followed

The armistice was renewed three times until the Treaty of Versailles took effect in January 1920. Britain first kept two minutes’ silence on 11 November 1919, and the date is still observed across the Commonwealth, in France and Belgium, and as Veterans Day in the United States. Poland marks it as the day independence was regained. On 22 June 1940 Hitler had the same carriage brought back to the same clearing to receive France’s surrender. It was taken to Germany and destroyed in 1945.

Read further

  • Joseph E. Persico, Eleventh Month, Eleventh Day, Eleventh Hour: Armistice Day, 1918 (2004)
  • David Stevenson, With Our Backs to the Wall: Victory and Defeat in 1918 (2011)
  • Bullitt Lowry, Armistice 1918 (1996)
  • Matthias Erzberger, Erlebnisse im Weltkrieg (1920)
  • Robert Gerwarth, The Vanquished: Why the First World War Failed to End, 1917-1923 (2016)

Same day, other years

1831

Nat Turner is hanged

Jerusalem, Southampton County, Virginia, United StatesThe Americas

Nat Turner was an enslaved preacher who believed that signs in the sky had called him to fight. On the night of 21 August 1831 he and a handful of companions began killing white families in Southampton County, Virginia, gathering some sixty or seventy followers as they went. About fifty-five white men, women and children were dead before militia scattered the band two days later. Turner hid in the woods for two months. He was tried on 5 November and hanged on the 11th. In the panic that followed the rising, militia and mobs killed Black people across the region, most of whom had no part in it; estimates run from several dozen to two hundred.

Seen from elsewhere. Almost all that is known of Turner’s mind comes from the ‘Confessions’ taken down in his cell by a white lawyer, Thomas Gray, who sold them as a pamphlet; how far the voice is Turner’s is disputed. White Virginia briefly debated ending slavery, then tightened it, banning Black preaching and literacy. Black tradition remembered him as a prophet.

1855

An earthquake wrecks Edo

Edo (Tokyo), JapanAsia

At about ten at night on 11 November 1855 an earthquake of roughly magnitude 7 struck directly beneath Edo, the shogun’s capital and one of the largest cities in the world. The low-lying eastern districts built on reclaimed land collapsed, and fires burned until morning. Between 7,000 and 10,000 people died. Within days the city was flooded with anonymous woodblock prints of the giant catfish that folklore held responsible for earthquakes. Some showed townspeople beating the fish. Others showed it forcing the rich to cough up gold coins, while carpenters and plasterers, suddenly in demand, drank its health.

Seen from elsewhere. The shogunate treated the prints as sedition and banned them within two months. Coming two years after Commodore Perry’s warships had forced Japan open, the disaster was widely read as a sign that the order of things was out of joint, and the prints’ talk of ‘world renewal’ anticipated the language of the upheavals that ended Tokugawa rule in 1868.

1965

Rhodesia declares itself independent

Salisbury (Harare), RhodesiaAfrica

At eleven in the morning on Armistice Day 1965 the government of Ian Smith announced that the self-governing British colony of Rhodesia was independent. The proclamation borrowed phrases from the American declaration of 1776. Britain had refused independence without progress towards majority rule; Rhodesia’s roughly 220,000 white residents were about one in twenty of the population and controlled parliament through a restricted franchise. The British prime minister, Harold Wilson, ruled out the use of force and relied on sanctions, which South Africa and Portugal helped Rhodesia evade. A guerrilla war followed in which at least 20,000 people died. Majority rule and recognised independence, as Zimbabwe, came in 1980.

Seen from elsewhere. Smith and his supporters said they were defending competent government and their own homes against the chaos they saw to the north, and pointed to Rhodesians’ service in two world wars. African nationalist leaders, most of them in detention that day, called it a settler rebellion, and asked why Britain used troops against colonial revolts elsewhere but not against white ones.

1975

The Governor-General dismisses Gough Whitlam

Canberra, AustraliaOceania

For four weeks the opposition majority in the Australian Senate, led by Malcolm Fraser, had refused to pass the budget of Gough Whitlam’s Labor government, hoping to force an election. On 11 November 1975 Whitlam went to the Governor-General, Sir John Kerr, to request an election for half the Senate. Kerr instead handed him a letter withdrawing his commission as prime minister, and swore in Fraser as caretaker within the hour. No elected Australian government had been removed by the Crown’s representative since federation. On the steps of Parliament House Whitlam told the crowd that nothing would save the Governor-General. Fraser won the election in December by a landslide.

Seen from elsewhere. Kerr held that a government which cannot obtain supply must resign or go to the people, and he had the private advice of the Chief Justice. Labor called it an ambush by a man who had concealed his intentions. Palace correspondence released in 2020 showed Kerr had discussed his powers with the Queen’s private secretary but had not told her beforehand.

Also on 11 November