Parallax

6 November, 1796

Catherine the Great dies, and her son buries her beside the husband she overthrew

The empress who had ruled Russia for thirty-four years collapsed in her dressing room and never spoke again. The date is the Russian one: in the rest of Europe it was already 17 November.

St Petersburg, Russia

Catherine II kept regular hours. On the morning of 5 November 1796 by the Russian calendar she rose at six in the Winter Palace, drank her strong coffee, and sat down to write as she had done almost every day of her reign. Some time after nine she went into the small closet off her dressing room. When she had not come out after an unusually long time her valet, Zakhar Zotov, opened the door and found her on the floor, her face dark, breathing in snores. She was sixty-seven. It took several men to carry her to the bedroom, and because they could not lift her on to the bed she was laid on a mattress on the floor.

Her Scottish physician, John Rogerson, bled her and applied blisters, and told the court it was a stroke and that there was no hope. Messengers rode the thirty miles to Gatchina, where her son Paul drilled his private regiments in Prussian uniforms and waited. He is said to have assumed, on seeing riders approach, that they had come to arrest him. He reached the palace that evening and set up in the room next to hers, so that officials summoned to see him had to walk past the dying empress.

Through the night and the following day Paul and the chancellor’s deputy, Alexander Bezborodko, went through her study and sealed her papers. Catherine lay unconscious for some thirty-six hours. She died at about a quarter to ten on the evening of 6 November without having regained speech. The oath to Paul I was administered in the palace chapel before midnight.

What Paul did next startled even those who knew how much he hated his mother’s memory. His father, Peter III, deposed by Catherine in 1762 and dead a week later in the custody of her supporters, had been buried without imperial honours in the Alexander Nevsky monastery. Paul had the coffin opened, placed a crown on it, since Peter had never been crowned in life, and brought it in procession to the Winter Palace. Alexei Orlov, who had been in charge at the house where Peter died, was made to walk behind the coffin carrying the crown.

The two coffins lay in state side by side under an inscription that gave their dates of birth and burial and implied a shared reign. On 5 December they were interred together in the cathedral of the Peter and Paul Fortress, a husband and wife separated, as the wits said, in life and united in death.

How it came to this

She was born Sophie of Anhalt-Zerbst in 1729, a minor German princess, and brought to Russia at fourteen to marry the heir to the throne. She converted to Orthodoxy, learned Russian thoroughly and endured an unhappy marriage of eighteen years. Six months after her husband became emperor in 1762, with the help of the Guards regiments and her lover Grigory Orlov, she deposed him. She had no hereditary claim. Her son Paul, then seven, did, and many had expected her to rule as regent. She took the throne herself.

Her reign extended the empire south to the Black Sea at the expense of the Ottomans, annexed Crimea in 1783, and, with Prussia and Austria, removed Poland from the map in three partitions. She corresponded with Voltaire and Diderot, bought the collections that founded the Hermitage, and had herself and Paul inoculated against smallpox in 1768 as an example to her subjects. She also confirmed the nobility’s privileges, extended serfdom into Ukraine and crushed the great rebellion of Pugachev in 1773-75. By the 1790s, alarmed by the French Revolution, she was censoring books she had once encouraged.

How each side saw it

Paul

Paul believed his mother had murdered his father, usurped his own inheritance and then kept him from any share in government for thirty-four years while her favourites ran the state. The double funeral was his statement of the true succession: Peter III, then himself. His first acts were to free the Polish leader Kosciuszko and the writer Radishchev, both imprisoned by Catherine, and in 1797 to issue a law fixing the succession by male primogeniture so that no ruler could again choose an heir or a consort seize the throne. His own letters and the memoirs of his circle present a wronged son; hers present him as unstable.

The serfs and their advocates

Roughly half of Russia’s peasants were the property of landlords, and under Catherine they lost the right to petition the sovereign against their owners, on pain of the knout and hard labour. They left almost no writing of their own. Their view reaches us through the manifestos issued in Pugachev’s name, which promised land and freedom and death to the nobles, and through Alexander Radishchev, a nobleman whose Journey from St Petersburg to Moscow in 1790 described serfs sold at auction. Catherine annotated her copy angrily, called him a rebel worse than Pugachev, and had him sentenced to death, commuted to Siberia.

Poles, and the peoples of the south

In Polish memory Catherine is the ruler who placed a former lover on the throne, used him, and then destroyed the state. The storming of the Warsaw suburb of Praga by Suvorov’s troops in November 1794, in which thousands of civilians were killed, ended the last resistance. For Crimean Tatars the annexation of 1783 began a long emigration to Ottoman lands, and the ‘New Russia’ that Potemkin colonised for her was built on territory emptied of Tatars, Nogais and the Zaporozhian Cossack host she abolished in 1775. Ukrainian historians date the loss of their remaining autonomy to her reign.

Gossip and the historians

Within months of her death French and German pamphlets were portraying a monster of appetite, and the tale that she died in an act with a horse, for which there is no evidence at all, has proved the most durable thing ever said about her. She did take a series of lovers, about a dozen over forty years, and rewarded them openly. Biographers such as Isabel de Madariaga and John T. Alexander argue that a male ruler’s mistresses would not have defined him in this way, and that the legend began as a means of belittling a woman who had won wars against France’s allies.

What is disputed

First, the date: 6 November is Old Style, eleven days behind the Western calendar in that century, so most of Europe recorded her death on 17 November. Whether Catherine ordered or merely benefited from Peter III’s death in 1762 is unresolved; Alexei Orlov’s letter of confession survives only in a copy whose authenticity has been challenged. Contemporaries believed she had drawn up a will passing over Paul in favour of her grandson Alexander and that it was burned on the night she died; no such paper exists. Her own memoirs hint that Paul’s father was her lover Sergei Saltykov, which may be true or may be spite.

What followed

Paul reversed his mother’s policies with an energy that frightened the nobility, and was strangled in his bedroom by Guards officers in March 1801, the last of the palace coups that had put Catherine on the throne. His son Alexander I, raised by Catherine, promised to rule in the spirit of his grandmother. Paul’s succession law held until 1917, and Russia never again had a woman on the throne. Her annexations set frontiers that are fought over today: Odesa and Sevastopol are her foundations, and her statue in Odesa was taken down in 2022.

Read further

  • Isabel de Madariaga, Russia in the Age of Catherine the Great (1981)
  • John T. Alexander, Catherine the Great: Life and Legend (1989)
  • Simon Dixon, Catherine the Great (2009)
  • The Memoirs of Catherine the Great, translated by Mark Cruse and Hilde Hoogenboom (2005)
  • Roderick E. McGrew, Paul I of Russia, 1754-1801 (1992)

Same day, other years

1860

Lincoln wins with less than forty per cent

United StatesThe Americas

Abraham Lincoln, a former one-term congressman from Illinois, was elected sixteenth president in a contest among four candidates after the Democratic Party split over slavery. He took almost every free state and 180 electoral votes with just under 40 per cent of the popular vote, and his name did not appear on the ballot in ten Southern states. His party’s platform opposed the spread of slavery into the western territories but promised not to interfere with it where it existed. South Carolina called a convention within days and voted to leave the Union on 20 December. Six more states had followed before he took the oath in March 1861.

Seen from elsewhere. Secession conventions said plainly that the election of a president hostile to slavery was their reason for leaving. Abolitionists, including Frederick Douglass, thought Lincoln far too cautious. The four million enslaved people, who had no vote, are known to have followed the news closely; some slaveholders reported talk of freedom in the quarters.

1913

Gandhi leads two thousand strikers across a forbidden border

Volksrust, South AfricaAfrica

Indian labourers brought to Natal under indenture faced a three-pound annual tax if they stayed on as free workers, and a court ruling that year had declared marriages by Hindu, Muslim and Parsi rites invalid. Mohandas Gandhi, a lawyer who had spent twenty years in South Africa, called the coal miners of Newcastle out on strike and on 6 November set off with about 2,200 men, women and children to cross illegally into the Transvaal and court arrest. He was detained that day, bailed, and arrested twice more before the marchers were put on trains back to Natal. Strikes then spread to the sugar estates, where police shot several workers dead.

Seen from elsewhere. Smuts conceded most of the demands in 1914. Gandhi’s campaigns sought rights for Indians, not Africans, and his early writings used contemptuous language about Black South Africans, as the historians Ashwin Desai and Goolam Vahed have documented. African leaders such as John Dube were organising separately against the Natives Land Act of the same year.

1975

The Green March enters Western Sahara

Western SaharaAfrica

With Franco on his deathbed and Spain preparing to leave its desert colony, King Hassan II of Morocco called for volunteers to walk in and claim it. On 6 November some 350,000 unarmed Moroccans, carrying flags, portraits of the king and copies of the Quran, crossed the frontier and advanced a few miles before halting in front of Spanish lines. Three weeks earlier the International Court of Justice had found that historic ties between the territory and Morocco did not amount to sovereignty and that its people were entitled to self-determination. Spain agreed on 14 November to hand administration to Morocco and Mauritania. The referendum promised to the Sahrawis has never been held.

Seen from elsewhere. Morocco celebrates the march as the peaceful recovery of its southern provinces. The Polisario Front and Algeria call it an invasion, noting that Moroccan troops had already crossed further east. Tens of thousands of Sahrawis fled to camps near Tindouf in Algeria, where their descendants still live.

1985

Guerrillas storm Colombia’s Palace of Justice

Bogota, ColombiaThe Americas

Thirty-five members of the M-19 movement drove into the basement of the building that housed the Supreme Court, on the main square of the capital, and took about three hundred people hostage, announcing that they would put President Belisario Betancur on trial for betraying a truce. The army answered with armoured cars and rockets. Over twenty-seven hours the building burned. About a hundred people died, including eleven of the court’s twenty-five justices and its president, Alfonso Reyes Echandia, who had pleaded by telephone on live radio for the firing to stop. At least eleven others, most of them cafeteria workers, were seen leaving alive in military custody and were never seen again.

Seen from elsewhere. The army has maintained that it rescued hostages from terrorists. The Inter-American Court of Human Rights held the state responsible in 2014 for disappearances, torture and executions. A Colombian truth commission concluded that the drug trafficker Pablo Escobar financed the raid to destroy extradition files, which former M-19 members deny.

Also on 6 November