Parallax

20 November, 1910

Tolstoy dies at a railway station

The most famous writer alive walked out of his own house at 82 and died ten days later in a stationmaster’s bedroom, with the world’s press camped on the platform.

Astapovo, Ryazan province, Russia

Before dawn on 28 October 1910 by the Russian calendar, Leo Tolstoy woke his doctor, Dushan Makovitsky, and told him they were leaving. He had heard his wife going through the papers in his study during the night, and it was the last thing he was prepared to put up with. He left her a letter saying he could no longer live in the luxury that surrounded him and was doing what old men of his age commonly did, withdrawing from the world to spend his last days in solitude and quiet. Then he took a carriage to the nearest station in the dark.

He had no settled plan. He went first to the Optina monastery, then to the convent at Shamordino where his sister Maria was a nun, and thought of renting a peasant hut nearby. When he learned that his family knew where he was, he moved on, heading south in a crowded third-class carriage with Makovitsky and his daughter Alexandra. On the train he developed a high fever. They got him off at Astapovo, a small junction few people had heard of, and the stationmaster, Ivan Ozolin, gave up his own house.

What followed was one of the first deaths to be covered as live news. Reporters, photographers and a Pathe film crew arrived within days. The telegraph office at the station sent out bulletins on his pulse and temperature. Police agents and a provincial governor came to watch the crowd. Tolstoy’s wife, Sofia Andreevna, arrived by special train and was kept out of the sickroom by her own children and by his disciple Vladimir Chertkov, on the grounds that the sight of her might kill him. The cameras caught her standing on tiptoe at the window, trying to see in.

Pneumonia had set in. He drifted in and out of consciousness, dictating thoughts and at one point telling those around him that there were a great many people in the world besides Leo Tolstoy and they should not all be looking at him. Sofia was let in only when he was no longer conscious. He died at five past six on the morning of 7 November, which was 20 November in the calendar used in the rest of Europe.

He was buried two days later at Yasnaya Polyana, in the wood where, as a boy, his brother Nikolai had told him a green stick was buried with the secret of universal happiness written on it. Several thousand people followed the coffin. There was no priest and no cross, which made it the first public funeral of its kind for a famous Russian.

How it came to this

By 1910 Tolstoy had been two people for thirty years. One was the author of War and Peace and Anna Karenina, a count with an estate of some 4,000 acres. The other was a religious teacher who, after a crisis around 1880, rejected the Orthodox Church, the state, private property, violence of every kind, and most of his own fiction. His later books were banned in Russia and read across the world. Gandhi, then a lawyer in South Africa, corresponded with him in his last year and named a commune Tolstoy Farm.

At home the two lives could not be reconciled. Sofia had borne thirteen children, copied his manuscripts by hand and ran the estate and the publishing income that kept the family. He wanted to give his copyrights to the public. In the summer of 1910 he signed a secret will, in a forest, that effectively placed his works in Chertkov’s hands. Sofia suspected it and searched for it. Her diary and his for those months record the same quarrels from opposite ends of the same house.

How each side saw it

Sofia Andreevna Tolstaya

In her diaries and her memoir My Life, Sofia describes forty-eight years of service to a husband who preached love of humanity and showed little to her. She saw Chertkov as an intruder who had stolen her husband and her children’s inheritance, and the secret will as a betrayal carried out behind her back. On learning that Tolstoy had gone she threw herself into the estate pond. Her own account of Astapovo is of a wife barred from her dying husband by people who had known him a fraction of the time she had.

Chertkov and the Tolstoyans

For Vladimir Chertkov and the followers who shared Tolstoy’s beliefs, the flight was the act the old man had owed his conscience for decades, and the family home was the obstacle. Chertkov’s own account of the last days presents Sofia as hysterical and controlling, and himself as the guardian of a teacher’s wishes. The will, in this view, protected works that belonged to everyone from heirs who wanted to sell them. Modern biographers tend to find both him and Sofia sincere and both, at times, ruthless.

The Orthodox Church

The Holy Synod had declared in 1901 that Tolstoy had fallen away from the Church, a notice widely understood as excommunication. He replied in print that it was true he rejected its teaching. When he fell ill the Synod sent Elder Varsonofy from Optina to Astapovo in the hope of a reconciliation; the family did not admit him and Tolstoy was not told he was there. Church burial rites were refused. Requests to lift the 1901 decision have been declined since, most recently in 2001, on the grounds that only the man himself could have asked.

The Tsarist state and its opponents

The government treated the death as a public order problem. Gendarmes reported from the station, special trains to the funeral were restricted, and memorial meetings were watched. Students and workers in several cities demonstrated anyway, some with calls to abolish the death penalty in his memory. Lenin, who had called Tolstoy a mirror of the Russian revolution in 1908, wrote that the liberals mourning him ignored what he had actually said about property and power, while his doctrine of non-resistance was useless to those trying to change them.

What is disputed

Where he was going is not known; the Caucasus, Bulgaria and a Tolstoyan colony have all been suggested, and he may not have decided. Whether keeping Sofia from the room was a medical precaution or Chertkov’s last move in a long contest is argued in every biography. The Optina visit before his illness has been read by Orthodox writers as a sign that he wanted to return to the Church and by secular biographers as a call on his sister’s neighbourhood. The date itself depends on the calendar: 7 November in Russia, 20 November in the West.

What followed

Sofia fought the will, lost, and was granted a state pension by Nicholas II; she stayed at Yasnaya Polyana until her death in 1919, saying near the end that she had lived with Leo Nikolaevich for forty-eight years and never found out what kind of man he was. Astapovo was renamed Lev Tolstoy in 1918. The station clock is kept stopped at 6.05. The Soviet state made the novelist a national monument and persecuted the Tolstoyans who took his later teaching seriously.

Read further

  • Rosamund Bartlett, Tolstoy: A Russian Life (2010)
  • William Nickell, The Death of Tolstoy: Russia on the Eve, Astapovo Station, 1910 (2010)
  • Sofia Tolstaya, The Diaries of Sofia Tolstoy, translated by Cathy Porter (2009)
  • Pal Kolsto, Heretical Orthodoxy: Lev Tolstoi and the Russian Orthodox Church (2022)
  • V. I. Lenin, ‘L. N. Tolstoy’ (1910)

Same day, other years

1695

Zumbi of Palmares is killed

Serra Dois Irmaos, BrazilThe Americas

Palmares was a federation of settlements founded by people who had escaped slavery on the sugar plantations of north-eastern Brazil. It lasted most of the seventeenth century and at its height may have held more than ten thousand people. After its capital fell to a Portuguese colonial force in 1694, its last leader, Zumbi, fought on for more than a year until he was betrayed, ambushed and killed. His head was displayed in Recife to prove that he was not immortal.

Seen from elsewhere. Colonial reports called him a rebel chief. Since 1978 Black Brazilians have marked 20 November as Black Consciousness Day in deliberate preference to 13 May, the date of abolition by royal decree; it became a national holiday in 2024. Almost everything known about Zumbi comes from his enemies’ documents, and historians dispute how far Palmares itself kept captives.

1910

The Mexican Revolution is called for six in the evening

MexicoThe Americas

Francisco Madero, a landowner who had been jailed for running against the dictator Porfirio Diaz, issued a plan from exile naming Sunday 20 November, at 6 pm, as the hour for Mexicans to rise. Almost nobody did on the day, and Madero went back across the border. But risings spread in Chihuahua and Morelos over the following weeks under Pascual Orozco, Pancho Villa and Emiliano Zapata, and Diaz resigned in May 1911. The fighting that followed lasted a decade and killed, by most estimates, more than a million people.

Seen from elsewhere. Madero wanted clean elections; Zapata’s villagers wanted their land back, and turned on Madero within months of his victory. Whether the Revolution was one event or several incompatible ones under a shared name is the central argument of its history.

1945

The Nuremberg trial opens

Nuremberg, GermanyEurope

Twenty-one leaders of Nazi Germany took their seats in the dock of the Palace of Justice before judges from the United States, the Soviet Union, Britain and France. The charges included crimes against peace, war crimes and a category newly defined in the tribunal’s charter, crimes against humanity. The proceedings ran for almost a year and relied largely on the regime’s own documents. Twelve defendants were sentenced to death, three were acquitted.

Seen from elsewhere. The defence, and some Allied jurists, objected that the court applied law made after the fact and tried only the defeated. Soviet judges sat in judgment on aggressive war six years after the Soviet invasion of Poland and Finland, and Soviet prosecutors tried to blame Germany for the Katyn massacre. Defenders reply that the alternative on offer in 1945 was summary execution.

1979

Armed men seize the Grand Mosque in Mecca

Mecca, Saudi ArabiaMiddle East

At dawn prayers on the first day of the Islamic year 1400, several hundred followers of Juhayman al-Otaybi took over Islam’s holiest site, chained the gates and announced that one of their number was the Mahdi, the awaited redeemer. They held it for two weeks. Saudi forces, having obtained a ruling from senior clerics permitting the use of arms inside the sanctuary, retook it at a cost officially put at 255 dead, including pilgrims, troops and militants. Sixty-three of the captured men were publicly beheaded.

Seen from elsewhere. Juhayman’s group saw the Saudi royal family as corrupt and illegitimate. Iran’s new leader blamed the United States, and mobs burned the American embassy in Islamabad. Independent estimates of the dead run much higher than the official figure, and the role of French advisers is still described differently in Riyadh and Paris.

Also on 20 November