Parallax

5 November, 1605

A man with a lantern under the House of Lords

Around midnight a search party found a tall stranger guarding thirty-six barrels of gunpowder beneath the chamber where the king was to open Parliament. He gave his name as John Johnson.

Westminster, England

The first search, on the afternoon of Monday 4 November 1605, found nothing alarming. The Earl of Suffolk, as Lord Chamberlain, walked through the ground-floor storeroom beneath the House of Lords and noticed a very large pile of firewood for so small a lodging, and a servant standing by it who said it belonged to his master, Thomas Percy. Suffolk reported back to the king. James I, whose father had been killed in a house blown up with gunpowder, ordered a second look.

Around midnight a Westminster magistrate, Sir Thomas Knyvett, returned with armed men. The servant was still there, dressed for travel in boots and spurs. Behind the faggots and billets were thirty-six barrels of powder. On the man were a watch, slow match and touchwood. He called himself John Johnson. Brought before the king in his bedchamber at about four in the morning, he was calm and unapologetic, and said that a dangerous disease required a desperate remedy. Asked by a Scottish courtier what he had intended, he is reported to have said that he meant to blow the Scots back to their mountains.

He was Guy Fawkes, a Yorkshireman of thirty-five who had fought for ten years in the Spanish army in Flanders and knew explosives. He was not the leader. The plot belonged to Robert Catesby, a charismatic Midlands gentleman who had concluded that English Catholics would get no relief from the new king. The plan was to destroy king, lords, bishops and commons at the state opening, seize the nine-year-old Princess Elizabeth from her household in Warwickshire and rule through her.

James authorised torture, ‘the gentler tortures first’. Fawkes held out for two days. His signatures before and after, preserved in the National Archives, show what the rack did to his hands. By then the others had fled north. A rising in the Midlands attracted almost nobody. On 8 November the sheriff of Worcestershire surrounded the remnant at Holbeche House in Staffordshire, where some had already been burned drying their own damp powder before a fire. Catesby and Percy were shot dead, by tradition with a single ball.

Eight survivors were tried in Westminster Hall on 27 January 1606 and convicted in a day. Four were hanged, drawn and quartered in St Paul’s Churchyard on the 30th and four, Fawkes last, in Old Palace Yard on the 31st, in sight of the building they had meant to destroy. Weak from torture, Fawkes had to be helped up the ladder, and broke his neck in the fall.

How it came to this

England had been officially Protestant since 1559. Under Elizabeth I it was treason to be a Catholic priest in England or to shelter one, and those who refused to attend their parish church, known as recusants, paid fines that could ruin a family. Papal support for Elizabeth’s overthrow, and the Spanish Armada, had made Catholicism look like disloyalty to many of their neighbours. Perhaps one English person in twenty was still Catholic in practice, concentrated among gentry households in the north and Midlands.

When James VI of Scotland inherited the throne in 1603, Catholics were hopeful. His mother was Mary, Queen of Scots, his wife had privately converted, and he had hinted at toleration. He did remit the fines for a time. But two minor plots in 1603, pressure from Parliament and his own dislike of papal claims brought the penalties back in 1604, and in August that year peace with Spain was signed without any protection for English Catholics. Catesby, who had already been fined heavily for his part in the Essex rising of 1601, had begun recruiting in May. The opening of Parliament was postponed several times because of plague, and the powder sat waiting for months.

How each side saw it

The crown and Parliament

The official account, printed within weeks as the ‘King’s Book’, presented the discovery as a providential deliverance in which James himself had divined the meaning of an obscure warning letter. Sir Edward Coke, prosecuting, told the court that the plot’s true authors were the Jesuits. Parliament ordered an annual thanksgiving on 5 November, with a special service that remained in the prayer book until 1859, and passed laws in 1606 barring Catholics from the professions and requiring an oath denying the pope’s power to depose kings. For Protestant England the date became proof, renewed every year with bonfires, of what Catholics would do if they could.

English Catholics and the Jesuits

Most Catholics were horrified, and their leaders said so at once; the archpriest George Blackwell denounced the plot within days. The Jesuit superior Henry Garnet had learned of it in outline through the confession of another priest, believed himself bound by the seal, and tried to discourage violence without revealing what he knew. He was hanged in May 1606. The Jesuit John Gerard, who escaped abroad, wrote a narrative portraying the plotters as devout men driven to despair by persecution and insisting that no priest approved. For the community the consequence was two more centuries of legal exclusion for the act of thirteen men.

The plotters

Their own voices survive in confessions taken under duress or the threat of it, chiefly those of Fawkes and Thomas Wintour, and in a few letters. Sir Everard Digby wrote from the Tower that he would never have joined had he thought it a sin, and was astonished that fellow Catholics condemned it. Catesby reportedly justified the deaths of innocent peers by comparing them to bystanders killed in a just siege. They saw themselves as soldiers in a religious war already being waged against them by the state. At Holbeche, according to Wintour, Catesby kissed a gold crucifix and said he was ready to die.

The sceptics

Since the seventeenth century some Catholic writers have suspected that Robert Cecil, Earl of Salisbury, the king’s chief minister, knew of the plot early and let it ripen, or invented much of it, to justify repression. The Jesuit historian John Gerard, a namesake of the earlier priest, put the case in 1897, and Francis Edwards revived it in the twentieth century. Samuel Rawson Gardiner answered Gerard point by point the same year. Most historians now accept that the plot was real and that Cecil learned of it late, while allowing that he managed the revelation and the trials for maximum political effect.

What is disputed

The date is Old Style; the rest of Catholic Europe called it 15 November. Who wrote the anonymous letter that warned the Catholic Lord Monteagle to stay away is unknown: Francis Tresham, his brother-in-law and the last recruit, is the usual suspect, and some think Monteagle and Cecil concocted it. The story of a tunnel dug from a neighbouring house rests on confessions alone, and no trace was ever found. Some reports said the powder had decayed and would not have fired, though modern estimates suggest that sound powder in that quantity would have destroyed the chamber. Fawkes’s quoted replies come from letters by courtiers, not from a transcript.

What followed

Bonfire Night was kept by law until 1859 and by custom ever since, though for most of its history the figure burned was the pope, not Fawkes. The anti-Catholic laws were dismantled between 1778 and 1829. The cellars of Parliament are still ceremonially searched by the Yeomen of the Guard before each state opening. In the twentieth century the meaning turned again: the stylised Fawkes mask from the comic and film V for Vendetta became a worldwide emblem of protest against governments, which would have surprised a man who wanted to install a Catholic monarchy.

Read further

  • Antonia Fraser, The Gunpowder Plot: Terror and Faith in 1605 (1996)
  • Mark Nicholls, Investigating Gunpowder Plot (1991)
  • James Sharpe, Remember, Remember the Fifth of November: Guy Fawkes and the Gunpowder Plot (2005)
  • Samuel Rawson Gardiner, What Gunpowder Plot Was (1897)
  • John Gerard, What Was the Gunpowder Plot? The Traditional Story Tested by Original Evidence (1897)

Same day, other years

1556

An arrow at Panipat decides who rules northern India

Panipat, IndiaAsia

The Mughal emperor Humayun had died in January after a fall on his library stairs, leaving a thirteen-year-old heir, Akbar, and a shaky hold on Delhi. In October the city was taken by Hemu, a Hindu of modest origins who had risen to be chief minister and general of the Afghan Sur dynasty and who now had himself proclaimed king with the ancient title Vikramaditya. The armies met on the plain of Panipat, north of Delhi. Hemu, directing his far larger force from an elephant, was winning when an arrow struck him in the eye. His troops, seeing the howdah empty, broke. He was brought unconscious before Akbar and beheaded.

Seen from elsewhere. Mughal chronicles belittle Hemu as an upstart shopkeeper and disagree on who struck the blow: Abu’l-Fazl says Akbar refused and the regent Bairam Khan did it. Hindu nationalist writers honour him as the last Hindu ruler of Delhi, though his army and his cause were largely Afghan.

1872

Susan B. Anthony casts a ballot

Rochester, New York, United StatesThe Americas

Having talked the registrars of her ward into enrolling her four days earlier, Anthony and fourteen other women voted in the presidential election on the argument that the new Fourteenth Amendment made them citizens and citizens could vote. She wrote to her friend Elizabeth Cady Stanton that she had gone and done it. Two weeks later a federal marshal arrested her at home. At her trial in June 1873 the judge, Ward Hunt, refused to let her testify, directed the jury to convict and read an opinion he had written beforehand. He fined her 100 dollars. She told him she would never pay a dollar of it, and never did.

Seen from elsewhere. The Supreme Court ruled in 1875 that citizenship did not confer the vote. Black suffragists such as Frances Harper had clashed with Anthony when she opposed enfranchising Black men before white women, sometimes in racist terms. The amendment of 1920 that bears her name left most Black women in the South unable to vote until 1965.

1881

The invasion of Parihaka

Parihaka, Taranaki, New ZealandOceania

Parihaka was the largest Maori settlement in the country, founded on land the colonial government had declared confiscated after the wars of the 1860s. Its leaders, Te Whiti o Rongomai and Tohu Kakahi, taught resistance without weapons: when surveyors marked out the land for settlers, their followers ploughed it up and rebuilt fences, and went to prison in hundreds. At dawn on 5 November about 1,600 armed constables and volunteers led by the Native Minister, John Bryce, marched in. They were met by children singing and by more than two thousand people sitting silently on the marae. The two leaders were arrested and held without trial. The village was pulled down and its people dispersed.

Seen from elsewhere. The government and most settler newspapers described a fanatical movement obstructing lawful settlement, and Bryce barred reporters, some of whom hid and wrote what they saw. Taranaki tribes recorded looting and the rape of women. In 2017 the Crown apologised formally at Parihaka for the invasion and the imprisonments.

1945

Riots against the Jews of Tripoli

Tripoli, LibyaAfrica

Jews had lived on the Libyan coast since antiquity and were a substantial minority in Tripoli. The former Italian colony was under British military administration when, on the evening of 4 November and through the following three days, crowds attacked the Jewish quarter of the city and Jewish families in nearby towns including Zanzur, Zawia and Qusabat. More than 130 Jews were killed, among them many children, and synagogues, homes and shops were burned. British troops were not ordered to intervene effectively until the third day. A second outbreak in 1948 met organised Jewish self-defence. By 1951 the great majority of Libya’s 38,000 Jews had left for Israel.

Seen from elsewhere. The community’s leaders blamed British officers for standing back; the administration’s report cited economic hardship, nationalist agitation and rumour. Muslim notables condemned the violence and some neighbours hid Jewish families. Libyan and Israeli historians differ on how far the events reflected tensions over Palestine or local causes.

Also on 5 November