The first search, on the afternoon of Monday 4 November 1605, found nothing alarming. The Earl of Suffolk, as Lord Chamberlain, walked through the ground-floor storeroom beneath the House of Lords and noticed a very large pile of firewood for so small a lodging, and a servant standing by it who said it belonged to his master, Thomas Percy. Suffolk reported back to the king. James I, whose father had been killed in a house blown up with gunpowder, ordered a second look.
Around midnight a Westminster magistrate, Sir Thomas Knyvett, returned with armed men. The servant was still there, dressed for travel in boots and spurs. Behind the faggots and billets were thirty-six barrels of powder. On the man were a watch, slow match and touchwood. He called himself John Johnson. Brought before the king in his bedchamber at about four in the morning, he was calm and unapologetic, and said that a dangerous disease required a desperate remedy. Asked by a Scottish courtier what he had intended, he is reported to have said that he meant to blow the Scots back to their mountains.
He was Guy Fawkes, a Yorkshireman of thirty-five who had fought for ten years in the Spanish army in Flanders and knew explosives. He was not the leader. The plot belonged to Robert Catesby, a charismatic Midlands gentleman who had concluded that English Catholics would get no relief from the new king. The plan was to destroy king, lords, bishops and commons at the state opening, seize the nine-year-old Princess Elizabeth from her household in Warwickshire and rule through her.
James authorised torture, ‘the gentler tortures first’. Fawkes held out for two days. His signatures before and after, preserved in the National Archives, show what the rack did to his hands. By then the others had fled north. A rising in the Midlands attracted almost nobody. On 8 November the sheriff of Worcestershire surrounded the remnant at Holbeche House in Staffordshire, where some had already been burned drying their own damp powder before a fire. Catesby and Percy were shot dead, by tradition with a single ball.
Eight survivors were tried in Westminster Hall on 27 January 1606 and convicted in a day. Four were hanged, drawn and quartered in St Paul’s Churchyard on the 30th and four, Fawkes last, in Old Palace Yard on the 31st, in sight of the building they had meant to destroy. Weak from torture, Fawkes had to be helped up the ladder, and broke his neck in the fall.
How it came to this
England had been officially Protestant since 1559. Under Elizabeth I it was treason to be a Catholic priest in England or to shelter one, and those who refused to attend their parish church, known as recusants, paid fines that could ruin a family. Papal support for Elizabeth’s overthrow, and the Spanish Armada, had made Catholicism look like disloyalty to many of their neighbours. Perhaps one English person in twenty was still Catholic in practice, concentrated among gentry households in the north and Midlands.
When James VI of Scotland inherited the throne in 1603, Catholics were hopeful. His mother was Mary, Queen of Scots, his wife had privately converted, and he had hinted at toleration. He did remit the fines for a time. But two minor plots in 1603, pressure from Parliament and his own dislike of papal claims brought the penalties back in 1604, and in August that year peace with Spain was signed without any protection for English Catholics. Catesby, who had already been fined heavily for his part in the Essex rising of 1601, had begun recruiting in May. The opening of Parliament was postponed several times because of plague, and the powder sat waiting for months.