Parallax

21 November, 1783

Two men leave the ground and are not tied to it

A science teacher and an army officer stood in a wicker gallery under a paper-lined balloon, feeding straw to an open fire, and drifted across Paris for twenty-five minutes. The king had wanted to send convicts.

Paris, France

The balloon stood in the garden of the Chateau de la Muette, on the western edge of Paris, where the royal children lived. It was about seventy feet tall, made of cloth lined with paper, painted blue and decorated in gold with fleurs-de-lis, the signs of the zodiac and the king’s monogram. Under its open neck hung an iron brazier, and around the neck ran a wicker gallery where two men could stand on opposite sides to keep it level.

The men were Jean-Francois Pilatre de Rozier, twenty-nine, who taught physics and chemistry to fashionable Paris, and Francois Laurent, marquis d’Arlandes, an infantry major. A first attempt that morning, 21 November 1783, ended when the wind dragged the balloon against a garden walk and tore it. Seamstresses mended it in under two hours. At six minutes to two in the afternoon the ropes were let go.

D’Arlandes wrote an account a week later, and it is the first description of flight by someone who did it. He was so absorbed in the view of the river and the silent crowd that Pilatre called across to him that he was doing nothing and they were hardly rising. He forked on more straw. Over the Seine he heard a crack from above and saw holes burning in the fabric near the base, and cords parting. He put the fire out with a wet sponge they had brought for the purpose.

They crossed the city at a height of perhaps three thousand feet, passing south of the centre, with the towers of Saint-Sulpice sliding by. Pilatre wanted to go on; d’Arlandes, looking at the scorched cloth, wanted to come down. They let the fire sink and landed between two windmills on the Butte-aux-Cailles, some five and a half miles from where they had started. The envelope collapsed over Pilatre, who crawled out in his shirt, having taken off his coat to work. The coat, according to one report, was torn up by the crowd for souvenirs.

Among those who watched the ascent was Benjamin Franklin, the American envoy, from his terrace at Passy. He signed the official certificate of the flight that evening, along with members of the Academy of Sciences, and wrote to the Royal Society in London that he could not see where this would end.

How it came to this

The balloon was the work of two brothers from Annonay in the south, Joseph and Etienne Montgolfier, sons of a paper manufacturer. Joseph, the dreamer of the pair, had noticed that heated air trapped in a bag would lift it; he thought the fire released a special light gas and burned damp straw and wool to make as much smoke as possible. They flew a large unmanned globe in public at Annonay on 4 June 1783. Etienne then went to Paris, where, with the wallpaper maker Jean-Baptiste Reveillon, he built a balloon that carried a sheep, a duck and a cockerel aloft at Versailles on 19 September before the court.

The animals survived, which settled whether the upper air could be breathed. Louis XVI proposed that the first human passengers should be two condemned prisoners. Pilatre objected that the honour should not go to criminals, and with d’Arlandes’s connections at court the king was talked round. In October Pilatre made a series of ascents on a tether to learn how to manage the fire. Meanwhile the physicist Jacques Charles was preparing a rival balloon filled with the newly isolated gas, hydrogen.

How each side saw it

Jacques Charles and the hydrogen party

To Charles and his backers the Montgolfiers’ fire balloon was a crude device that worked for reasons its inventors misunderstood. He had flown an unmanned hydrogen balloon from the Champ de Mars in August, and ten days after Pilatre’s flight, on 1 December, he and Nicolas-Louis Robert rose from the Tuileries before an enormous crowd and travelled more than twenty miles. Their craft had a valve, ballast, a net and a suspended basket: every element of the gas balloon for the next century. Charles is said to have remarked that the Montgolfiers had shown the way and he had made it practicable.

The villagers of Gonesse

When Charles’s unmanned balloon came down in a field at Gonesse in August 1783, the villagers, who had been told nothing, took it for a monster, or a fallen moon. They attacked it with pitchforks and stones, and tied the remains to a horse’s tail. The episode is known only from Parisian newspapers and prints that found it funny. The government issued a printed notice to the public explaining that such globes were harmless machines of taffeta or paper and might one day be useful. It is a reminder that almost nobody outside a few towns knew what was happening.

The sceptics in London

Sir Joseph Banks, president of the Royal Society, received Franklin’s reports politely and declined to commit the Society’s funds, hoping, he wrote, that English philosophers would not be carried away by the French craze. Horace Walpole wished that these new meteors would remain playthings and not be turned into engines of destruction. When someone asked what use a balloon was, Franklin is supposed to have replied by asking what use was a new-born baby. The remark is reported at second hand and seems to date from the hydrogen trial that August, not from this flight.

Portuguese and Brazilian tradition

In Lisbon and in Brazil the first aeronaut is Bartolomeu de Gusmao, a priest born at Santos, who in August 1709 demonstrated a small hot-air balloon indoors before King Joao V; it rose to the ceiling and scorched the hangings. Contemporary accounts confirm the model, though not the bird-shaped passenger craft of later engravings. Chinese writers point further back still, to paper sky lanterns in use many centuries earlier. Neither claim involves a person leaving the ground, but both show that what happened in 1783 was the scaling up of something already seen.

What is disputed

The flight’s length is given as anything from twenty to twenty-eight minutes and its distance from five to nine miles, depending on whether the straight line or the track is measured. Pilatre had already been aloft on a rope in October, so he alone has a claim to be the first human airborne; 21 November is the first free flight. There are stories, impossible to confirm, that Etienne Montgolfier made a secret tethered ascent first and was forbidden by his father to fly again. Credit between the brothers is still argued: Joseph had the idea, Etienne built the machines. Franklin’s baby remark is not securely attested.

What followed

Hydrogen won. Jean-Pierre Blanchard and the American John Jeffries crossed the Channel in a gas balloon in January 1785. Pilatre, trying to cross the other way that June in a craft combining a hydrogen balloon with a fire beneath it, was killed with his companion Pierre Romain when it burst over the French coast: the first deaths in an aircraft. The French army used a tethered balloon to observe the enemy at Fleurus in 1794. Hot-air balloons were largely forgotten until propane burners revived them in the 1960s. In French they are still called montgolfieres.

Read further

  • Charles Coulston Gillispie, The Montgolfier Brothers and the Invention of Aviation, 1783-1784 (1983)
  • Richard Holmes, Falling Upwards: How We Took to the Air (2013)
  • Barthelemy Faujas de Saint-Fond, Description des experiences de la machine aerostatique de MM. de Montgolfier (1783)
  • L. T. C. Rolt, The Aeronauts: A History of Ballooning, 1783-1903 (1966)
  • Mi Gyung Kim, The Imagined Empire: Balloon Enlightenments in Revolutionary Europe (2016)

Same day, other years

1620

The Mayflower Compact is signed

Cape Cod, North AmericaThe Americas

After sixty-six days at sea the Mayflower anchored inside the hook of Cape Cod, well north of the territory her passengers had permission to settle. Some of those aboard who were not members of the separatist congregation said that, outside the patent, nobody had authority over them. Before anyone went ashore, forty-one of the adult men signed a short agreement to combine into a ‘civil body politic’ and obey such laws as it should make. The date was 11 November by the English calendar of the time, 21 November by the modern one. The original is lost; the text survives in a pamphlet of 1622 and in William Bradford’s history.

Seen from elsewhere. The Wampanoag, on whose land they settled, had lost most of their people to an epidemic brought by earlier European ships. Within days the newcomers had taken stored corn and opened graves. Many Wampanoag keep the American Thanksgiving as a Day of Mourning. Historians also note that the Compact, later hailed as a seed of democracy, professed loyalty to King James and excluded women.

1894

Port Arthur falls and its people are killed

Lushun (Port Arthur), ChinaAsia

Port Arthur, at the tip of the Liaodong peninsula, was the fortified base of China’s northern fleet and was expected to hold for months. Japan’s Second Army took it in a single day, 21 November 1894. Entering the town, soldiers found the mutilated heads and bodies of Japanese prisoners displayed. Over the following three or four days they killed surrendered soldiers and townspeople, including women and children. Western correspondents who were present, among them James Creelman of the New York World and Thomas Cowen of The Times, reported it, and the story appeared just as Japan was seeking equal treaties with the Western powers.

Seen from elsewhere. Japan’s foreign minister, Mutsu Munemitsu, replied that the dead were mostly soldiers who had put on civilian clothes, and that the reports were exaggerated; no one was punished. Chinese accounts, and the memorial at the site, give about 20,000 dead. Japanese and some Western historians have argued for between 2,000 and 6,000.

1920

Bloody Sunday in Dublin

Dublin, IrelandEurope

Early in the morning, squads directed by Michael Collins went to addresses across Dublin and shot men they believed to be British intelligence officers, some in front of their wives. Fourteen died that day and another later. In the afternoon a mixed force of police, Auxiliaries and soldiers drove to Croke Park, where several thousand people were watching Dublin play Tipperary at Gaelic football, to search the crowd. Firing began almost at once and lasted about ninety seconds. Fourteen civilians were killed or fatally hurt, among them a Tipperary player, Michael Hogan, and three schoolboys. That night two senior IRA officers and a civilian were killed in custody in Dublin Castle.

Seen from elsewhere. Dublin Castle announced that its forces had been fired on first from the crowd. A military court of inquiry, whose findings were kept closed for decades, concluded that the shooting was unauthorised and excessive. On the other side of the ledger, several of the men killed that morning had no proven connection with intelligence work.

1962

China declares a ceasefire in its war with India

The Himalayan frontierAsia

For a month Chinese forces had been driving the Indian army back at both ends of a disputed mountain border. In the east they had overrun the passes at Se La and Bomdi La and stood at the edge of the Assam plain; the town of Tezpur was being evacuated, and Jawaharlal Nehru had written to President Kennedy asking for American aircraft. Then Beijing announced that from midnight on 21 November its troops would cease fire and pull back twenty kilometres behind the line they had held before the fighting. India had lost about 1,400 dead and nearly 4,000 prisoners. China kept the Aksai Chin plateau in the west.

Seen from elsewhere. India remembers an unprovoked attack by a neighbour it had befriended. China calls it a counter-attack in self-defence, provoked by Indian posts pushed forward into territory that Beijing claimed, along a boundary drawn by British officials in 1914 which no Chinese government accepted. India’s own official inquiry, the Henderson Brooks report, has never been formally released.

Also on 21 November