The conclave that followed the death of Pope Adrian VI opened on 1 October 1523 and went on for fifty days. The cardinals were locked in the Sistine Chapel in wooden cells, and as the weeks passed their food was cut back, according to the rule, to hurry them along. It made little difference. The college was split between those who looked to the Emperor Charles V and those who looked to Francis I of France, and inside the imperial party two men blocked each other.
One was Giulio de’ Medici, forty-five years old, cousin of the late Leo X and for a decade the man who had actually run the papal government. The other was Pompeo Colonna, head of a Roman baronial family that had hated the Medici for years. Giulio entered the conclave with a solid group of votes and no way of adding to it. Other names were tried and failed, among them Alessandro Farnese, who would have to wait eleven more years.
The break came when the French cardinals put forward a candidate Colonna liked even less. He went over to Medici, bringing his friends with him, and on the night of 18 to 19 November Giulio was elected. He took the name Clement. Rome was delighted: after the austere Dutchman Adrian, a Medici meant money, building and festivals. The imperial ambassador wrote home that the new pope was entirely the emperor’s creature.
He was nothing of the kind. Clement was serious, sober, hard-working and cultivated; he had commissioned Raphael’s Transfiguration and would set Michelangelo to work on the Medici tombs and the Laurentian Library. But he governed by weighing every option until events chose for him. Caught between Charles and Francis, he sided with each in turn. In 1526 he joined a league against the emperor. That September Colonna’s men raided the Vatican. On 6 May 1527 an unpaid, mutinous imperial army stormed Rome.
Clement ran along the covered passage to the Castel Sant’Angelo while most of his Swiss Guard died covering his escape. From the battlements he watched the city plundered for weeks. He was a prisoner for seven months, got away to Orvieto in disguise, and let his beard grow as a sign of mourning for the rest of his life. It was to this man, in that condition, that Henry VIII’s agents came asking for an annulment of the king’s marriage to the emperor’s aunt.
How it came to this
Giulio was born in 1478, a month after his father, Giuliano de’ Medici, was stabbed to death in Florence cathedral in the Pazzi conspiracy. His parents had not been married. He was brought up in the household of his uncle Lorenzo the Magnificent alongside Lorenzo’s son Giovanni, and when Giovanni became Pope Leo X in 1513 he had Giulio declared legitimate, made him a cardinal and gave him the vice-chancellorship, the chief office of the Curia. Giulio also governed Florence for the family, and did it well.
The Church he inherited was in trouble that Rome had not yet measured. Luther had been excommunicated in 1521 and much of Germany was following him; the short-lived Adrian VI had admitted that the sickness began in the Curia itself. Italy, meanwhile, had been a battlefield for French and Spanish armies since 1494. The Papal States lay between the emperor’s kingdom of Naples to the south and his claims in Lombardy to the north, and every pope feared being encircled. Clement’s shifts of alliance were attempts to keep the two great powers balanced. Neither forgave him.