Parallax

19 November, 1523

A Medici becomes Pope Clement VII

After seven weeks of deadlock the cardinals chose the ablest administrator among them. Eleven years later Rome had been sacked, Florence besieged by its own pope and England was leaving the Church.

Rome, Papal States

The conclave that followed the death of Pope Adrian VI opened on 1 October 1523 and went on for fifty days. The cardinals were locked in the Sistine Chapel in wooden cells, and as the weeks passed their food was cut back, according to the rule, to hurry them along. It made little difference. The college was split between those who looked to the Emperor Charles V and those who looked to Francis I of France, and inside the imperial party two men blocked each other.

One was Giulio de’ Medici, forty-five years old, cousin of the late Leo X and for a decade the man who had actually run the papal government. The other was Pompeo Colonna, head of a Roman baronial family that had hated the Medici for years. Giulio entered the conclave with a solid group of votes and no way of adding to it. Other names were tried and failed, among them Alessandro Farnese, who would have to wait eleven more years.

The break came when the French cardinals put forward a candidate Colonna liked even less. He went over to Medici, bringing his friends with him, and on the night of 18 to 19 November Giulio was elected. He took the name Clement. Rome was delighted: after the austere Dutchman Adrian, a Medici meant money, building and festivals. The imperial ambassador wrote home that the new pope was entirely the emperor’s creature.

He was nothing of the kind. Clement was serious, sober, hard-working and cultivated; he had commissioned Raphael’s Transfiguration and would set Michelangelo to work on the Medici tombs and the Laurentian Library. But he governed by weighing every option until events chose for him. Caught between Charles and Francis, he sided with each in turn. In 1526 he joined a league against the emperor. That September Colonna’s men raided the Vatican. On 6 May 1527 an unpaid, mutinous imperial army stormed Rome.

Clement ran along the covered passage to the Castel Sant’Angelo while most of his Swiss Guard died covering his escape. From the battlements he watched the city plundered for weeks. He was a prisoner for seven months, got away to Orvieto in disguise, and let his beard grow as a sign of mourning for the rest of his life. It was to this man, in that condition, that Henry VIII’s agents came asking for an annulment of the king’s marriage to the emperor’s aunt.

How it came to this

Giulio was born in 1478, a month after his father, Giuliano de’ Medici, was stabbed to death in Florence cathedral in the Pazzi conspiracy. His parents had not been married. He was brought up in the household of his uncle Lorenzo the Magnificent alongside Lorenzo’s son Giovanni, and when Giovanni became Pope Leo X in 1513 he had Giulio declared legitimate, made him a cardinal and gave him the vice-chancellorship, the chief office of the Curia. Giulio also governed Florence for the family, and did it well.

The Church he inherited was in trouble that Rome had not yet measured. Luther had been excommunicated in 1521 and much of Germany was following him; the short-lived Adrian VI had admitted that the sickness began in the Curia itself. Italy, meanwhile, had been a battlefield for French and Spanish armies since 1494. The Papal States lay between the emperor’s kingdom of Naples to the south and his claims in Lombardy to the north, and every pope feared being encircled. Clement’s shifts of alliance were attempts to keep the two great powers balanced. Neither forgave him.

How each side saw it

Francesco Guicciardini, the pope’s own lieutenant

The historian Guicciardini served Clement as governor and as commander of the papal army, and judged him in his History of Italy with the bitterness of a man who had watched from close by. He granted that Clement was intelligent, well informed and more hard-working than Leo. The fault, he wrote, was irresolution: the pope would reach a decision, then any small new consideration would reopen it, and he was timid and unwilling to spend money when action was needed. Guicciardini thought a man admirable as a second-in-command had proved unfit for the first place.

The imperial side and the Lutheran soldiers

Charles V professed grief at the sack and put his court into mourning, but his secretary Alfonso de Valdes wrote a dialogue arguing that the pope had brought it on himself by making war instead of tending souls, and that God had used the army to punish a corrupt Rome. Many of the German foot soldiers were Lutherans who needed no such argument. They paraded a mock pope through the streets, stabled horses in churches, and one scratched Luther’s name into a Raphael fresco in the Vatican, where it can still be seen.

Catherine of Aragon and Henry VIII

Catherine held that she was Henry’s lawful wife, that her first marriage to his brother had never been consummated, and that only Rome could judge the case. Her letters to the pope and to her nephew the emperor beg for a verdict, and she saw six years of delay as abandonment. Henry’s side held that a pope who was the emperor’s captive could not give free judgement, and that no pope could dispense from a prohibition in Leviticus in any case. Clement found for Catherine in March 1534, after Henry had already remarried.

The Florentine republicans

Florence drove out the Medici in 1527 on news of the sack and restored its republic. Two years later Clement made peace with the emperor, and part of the price was an imperial army to recover the city for his family. Florence held out for ten months in 1529-30, with Michelangelo directing its fortifications, before hunger forced a surrender. Republican historians such as Benedetto Varchi and Jacopo Nardi recorded a pope who turned on his birthplace the same soldiers who had sacked Rome. The Medici ruled Florence as dukes for the next two centuries.

What is disputed

Some lists date the election to 18 November, since the decisive votes came that night; the formal election and proclamation were on the 19th. Clement’s reputation has been argued over since Ranke called him the most ill-fated of popes: recent scholars, including the contributors to Gouwens and Reiss’s collection, stress how little room he had. On the English divorce, J. J. Scarisbrick argued that Henry’s case was weak in canon law whatever the politics; others think a free pope would have found a way. Estimates of the dead in the sack run from about 6,000 to over 12,000. It is also unsettled whether Alessandro de’ Medici, first duke of Florence, was Clement’s own son.

What followed

Clement died in September 1534, having crowned Charles V at Bologna and married his young cousin Catherine de’ Medici to a son of the French king. Weeks later the English Parliament declared Henry supreme head of the Church of England. He had refused throughout to call the general council that reformers and the emperor demanded, fearing it would judge him; the Council of Trent finally met under his successor in 1545, by which time the division of western Christendom was beyond repair. Shortly before his death he commissioned Michelangelo to paint the Last Judgement on the Sistine Chapel’s altar wall.

Read further

  • Francesco Guicciardini, The History of Italy, translated by Sidney Alexander (1969)
  • Judith Hook, The Sack of Rome, 1527 (1972)
  • Kenneth Gouwens and Sheryl E. Reiss (eds), The Pontificate of Clement VII: History, Politics, Culture (2005)
  • Andre Chastel, The Sack of Rome, 1527 (1983)
  • J. J. Scarisbrick, Henry VIII (1968)

Same day, other years

1863

Lincoln speaks for two minutes at Gettysburg

Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, United StatesThe Americas

Four and a half months after the battle, a cemetery for the Union dead was dedicated on the field. The main address was given by Edward Everett, the most admired orator in the country, who spoke from memory for two hours. President Lincoln had been asked to add ‘a few appropriate remarks’. He spoke about 270 words, saying that the nation had been founded on the proposition that all men are created equal and that the war would decide whether such a nation could last. It was over before a photographer could get a clear picture. Everett wrote to him next day that he wished he had come as near the point in two hours.

Seen from elsewhere. The Democratic Chicago Times called the speech silly, flat and dishwatery, and charged that Lincoln had misrepresented a Constitution which says nothing of equality. Five manuscript copies survive and differ: the two earliest lack the words ‘under God’. The story that he wrote it on an envelope on the train is a legend.

1941

HMAS Sydney is lost with every man aboard

Off Shark Bay, Western AustraliaOceania

The Australian light cruiser Sydney, returning to Fremantle, sighted a merchant ship that identified herself as the Dutch freighter Straat Malakka. She was the German raider Kormoran, armed with hidden guns and torpedoes. For reasons never established, Captain Joseph Burnett brought the Sydney to within about a mile. When challenged for a secret call sign the Kormoran dropped her disguise and opened fire. In half an hour both ships were crippled. The Kormoran was scuttled; 318 of her crew of nearly 400 were rescued. The Sydney drifted away burning and vanished with all 645 men, the worst loss in Australian naval history.

Seen from elsewhere. Because the only witnesses were German, many Australians refused for decades to believe their account, suspecting a Japanese submarine, a false surrender or the shooting of survivors. The wrecks were found in 2008, and a judicial inquiry in 2009 concluded that the German version was substantially true.

1977

Sadat lands in Israel

Ben Gurion Airport and JerusalemMiddle East

Ten days earlier the Egyptian president, Anwar Sadat, had told his parliament that he would go to the ends of the earth, even to the Knesset, for peace. Israel’s prime minister, Menachem Begin, sent an invitation. On the evening of Saturday 19 November Sadat’s aircraft landed near Tel Aviv, and the leader of the largest Arab state, which had fought Israel four times, walked down the steps to shake hands with Golda Meir, Moshe Dayan and Ariel Sharon. He prayed at al-Aqsa and addressed the Knesset the next day. The Camp David accords followed in 1978, a peace treaty in 1979, and Sinai was returned to Egypt by 1982.

Seen from elsewhere. Much of the Arab world called it treason. Syria declared a day of mourning, Sadat’s own foreign minister resigned, and Egypt was suspended from the Arab League. Palestinians saw a separate peace that removed Egypt’s army from the balance and left their own question unresolved. Sadat was assassinated by Egyptian Islamist soldiers in October 1981.

1984

The San Juanico gas explosions

San Juan Ixhuatepec, MexicoThe Americas

Before six in the morning a pipe ruptured at a liquefied petroleum gas depot run by the state oil company Pemex on the northern edge of Mexico City. A cloud of gas spread over the yard and the houses crowded against its fence, found a flame, and ignited. Over the next hour and a half the storage tanks exploded one after another, throwing fireballs and fragments of steel across the neighbourhood. People were burned in their beds. The official count was about five hundred dead and several thousand injured; much of the surrounding settlement was levelled. It remains among the deadliest industrial accidents in the Americas.

Seen from elsewhere. Pemex at first pointed to a neighbouring private gas company. Residents and independent investigators have always held that the true toll was far higher than the official one, because many bodies were destroyed, and that compensation was meagre and no senior official was held to account.

Also on 19 November