On the evening of Wednesday 23 November 1407, Louis, Duke of Orleans, the only brother of King Charles VI, was at supper with Queen Isabeau at her private residence, the Hotel Barbette in the Marais. She had given birth thirteen days earlier to a son who lived only a few hours, and the duke had come to keep her company. At about eight o’clock one of the king’s valets, Thomas Courteheuse, arrived to say that the king wanted his brother at once.
The message was false. Louis set off down the rue Vieille-du-Temple on a mule, bareheaded, singing, with a handful of attendants and torchbearers. Opposite a house with the sign of the Image of Our Lady, fifteen or more armed men ran out of the dark. He called out that he was the Duke of Orleans; they answered that he was the one they wanted. A blow from an axe took off the hand that held the reins. They dragged him down and split his skull. A young page from his household threw himself across the body and was killed too.
A shoemaker’s wife, Jacquette Griffard, saw it from an upper window, where she was hanging out a cloth and looking for her husband, and screamed murder. One of the men shouted at her to be quiet. They set fire to the house they had been hiding in, scattered iron caltrops behind them to lame pursuing horses, and ran.
The provost of Paris, Guillaume de Tignonville, sealed the city gates and took statements through the night. The trail led him towards the Hotel d’Artois, the Paris house of the king’s cousin John, Duke of Burgundy. When he asked the royal council for leave to search the princes’ residences, the game was up. John had walked in the funeral procession in black, holding a corner of the pall and, it was said, weeping. On 25 November he took aside two of the older princes and told them that, tempted by the devil, he had had it done. Next morning he rode out of Paris for Flanders, not stopping until he was across his own frontier.
He did not stay away. In February 1408 he came back with an escort of soldiers, to cheers from Parisians, and on 8 March a Sorbonne theologian in his pay, Jean Petit, spoke for four hours before the court. His argument was that Louis had been a tyrant who plotted against the king’s life by sorcery and poison, and that killing a tyrant was lawful and meritorious. The king, in one of his calmer intervals, signed a pardon.
How it came to this
Charles VI had gone mad in 1392, attacking his own escort in a forest near Le Mans, and for the rest of his life he passed in and out of episodes in which he did not know his wife or believed he was made of glass. Whoever controlled the council during his absences controlled the taxes of the richest kingdom in Europe. At first that was his uncle Philip, Duke of Burgundy. As Louis of Orleans grew up he contested it, and after Philip’s death in 1404 the quarrel passed to Philip’s son John, later called the Fearless.
By 1407 Louis was winning. He sat with the queen at the head of the government, drew huge sums from the treasury and was cutting off the payments on which Burgundy’s finances depended. The two men differed on war with England and on which pope to back in the papal schism. Louis was clever and pious in bursts, a notorious gambler and seducer, and hated in Paris for the taxes levied in the king’s name. John, plain in dress and manner, posed as the enemy of those taxes. Three days before the killing they had taken communion together and sworn friendship.