Parallax

23 November, 1407

The king’s brother is hacked to death in a Paris street

Louis of Orleans was called out by a false message and cut down by masked men a few yards from the queen’s door. Two days later his cousin admitted ordering it, and then had a theologian explain why it was a good deed.

Paris, France

On the evening of Wednesday 23 November 1407, Louis, Duke of Orleans, the only brother of King Charles VI, was at supper with Queen Isabeau at her private residence, the Hotel Barbette in the Marais. She had given birth thirteen days earlier to a son who lived only a few hours, and the duke had come to keep her company. At about eight o’clock one of the king’s valets, Thomas Courteheuse, arrived to say that the king wanted his brother at once.

The message was false. Louis set off down the rue Vieille-du-Temple on a mule, bareheaded, singing, with a handful of attendants and torchbearers. Opposite a house with the sign of the Image of Our Lady, fifteen or more armed men ran out of the dark. He called out that he was the Duke of Orleans; they answered that he was the one they wanted. A blow from an axe took off the hand that held the reins. They dragged him down and split his skull. A young page from his household threw himself across the body and was killed too.

A shoemaker’s wife, Jacquette Griffard, saw it from an upper window, where she was hanging out a cloth and looking for her husband, and screamed murder. One of the men shouted at her to be quiet. They set fire to the house they had been hiding in, scattered iron caltrops behind them to lame pursuing horses, and ran.

The provost of Paris, Guillaume de Tignonville, sealed the city gates and took statements through the night. The trail led him towards the Hotel d’Artois, the Paris house of the king’s cousin John, Duke of Burgundy. When he asked the royal council for leave to search the princes’ residences, the game was up. John had walked in the funeral procession in black, holding a corner of the pall and, it was said, weeping. On 25 November he took aside two of the older princes and told them that, tempted by the devil, he had had it done. Next morning he rode out of Paris for Flanders, not stopping until he was across his own frontier.

He did not stay away. In February 1408 he came back with an escort of soldiers, to cheers from Parisians, and on 8 March a Sorbonne theologian in his pay, Jean Petit, spoke for four hours before the court. His argument was that Louis had been a tyrant who plotted against the king’s life by sorcery and poison, and that killing a tyrant was lawful and meritorious. The king, in one of his calmer intervals, signed a pardon.

How it came to this

Charles VI had gone mad in 1392, attacking his own escort in a forest near Le Mans, and for the rest of his life he passed in and out of episodes in which he did not know his wife or believed he was made of glass. Whoever controlled the council during his absences controlled the taxes of the richest kingdom in Europe. At first that was his uncle Philip, Duke of Burgundy. As Louis of Orleans grew up he contested it, and after Philip’s death in 1404 the quarrel passed to Philip’s son John, later called the Fearless.

By 1407 Louis was winning. He sat with the queen at the head of the government, drew huge sums from the treasury and was cutting off the payments on which Burgundy’s finances depended. The two men differed on war with England and on which pope to back in the papal schism. Louis was clever and pious in bursts, a notorious gambler and seducer, and hated in Paris for the taxes levied in the king’s name. John, plain in dress and manner, posed as the enemy of those taxes. Three days before the killing they had taken communion together and sworn friendship.

How each side saw it

The Burgundian case

Jean Petit’s Justification, copied and circulated in presentation manuscripts, is the Burgundian account in full. Louis had coveted the crown, bewitched the king with the help of an apostate monk, tried to poison the dauphin and bled the people with taxes for his own pleasures. To strike him down without waiting for forms of law, which a prince so powerful could evade, was a service to the king. Many Parisians, who had no love for Orleans, agreed. The chronicler Enguerrand de Monstrelet, who wrote from within Burgundian lands, preserves the speech at length.

Valentina Visconti and the house of Orleans

The widow came to Paris in mourning with her children and knelt before the king to demand justice. In September 1408 her advocate, the Abbot of Cerisy, answered Petit point by point before the court: there had been no tyranny and no sorcery, only a murder by ambush of a man the killer had embraced days before. Valentina died that December; her adopted motto was that nothing mattered to her any more. Her eldest son Charles, the poet, was fourteen. The party that formed around him took its name from his father-in-law, the Count of Armagnac.

Queen Isabeau

The tale that Isabeau was Louis’s lover, and even that she had a hand in his death, is the one most people have heard. No contemporary accuses her of the murder; she fled Paris in fear afterwards. Hints of scandal about her and the duke appear in a hostile sermon and pamphlet of 1405-06, and the story grew after 1420, when she signed the treaty that disinherited her son in favour of the English king. Historians including Rachel Gibbons and Tracy Adams have argued that the adultery is a product of Burgundian propaganda and later invention, not evidence.

The Church

Jean Gerson, chancellor of the University of Paris, spent years trying to have Petit’s doctrine condemned, arguing that it licensed any subject to murder any ruler he chose to call a tyrant. A Paris synod condemned it in 1414. At the Council of Constance the following year the Burgundians lobbied hard, and the fathers would go no further than a general decree against tyrannicide by private persons that named neither Petit nor the duke. Gerson, having made an enemy of Burgundy, never dared return to Paris.

What is disputed

The love affair between Louis and the queen is the chief dispute, and the weight of recent scholarship is against it; the claim that she sent him to his death has no support. Sources give the number of attackers as anything from eight to eighteen. John’s motive is argued: Bernard Guenee and Richard Vaughan stress money and power, since Louis was strangling Burgundy’s income, while a later story, found in Thomas Basin, has Louis boasting of seducing John’s wife. Whether the sorcery charges were believed by those who made them cannot be known. The leader of the killers, Raoul d’Anquetonville, had a private grudge, having lost a royal office through the duke.

What followed

The murder split France into Armagnacs and Burgundians, and the two factions fought each other while Henry V of England invaded. Neither was whole-heartedly at Agincourt in 1415. In 1419 John the Fearless was himself cut down on the bridge at Montereau during a parley with the dauphin, and his son allied with the English, making possible the treaty of 1420 that gave France’s crown to Henry. A century later a monk at Dijon, showing John’s broken skull to King Francis I, is said to have told him that this was the hole through which the English entered France.

Read further

  • Bernard Guenee, Un meurtre, une societe: L’assassinat du duc d’Orleans, 23 novembre 1407 (1992)
  • Richard Vaughan, John the Fearless: The Growth of Burgundian Power (1966)
  • Tracy Adams, The Life and Afterlife of Isabeau of Bavaria (2010)
  • Eric Jager, Blood Royal: A True Tale of Crime and Detection in Medieval Paris (2014)
  • Enguerrand de Monstrelet, Chronicles, translated by Thomas Johnes

Same day, other years

1248

Seville surrenders to Castile

Seville, al-AndalusEurope

Seville had been the capital of Muslim Spain under the Almohads and was probably the largest city in the peninsula. Ferdinand III of Castile besieged it for some sixteen months. The turning point came in May 1248, when ships brought round from the northern coast under Ramon Bonifaz broke the bridge of boats that linked the city to its supplies across the Guadalquivir. Starved, Seville capitulated on 23 November. The terms gave its Muslim inhabitants a month to leave with what they could carry. Ferdinand entered in December; the great mosque became a cathedral, keeping its minaret, now the Giralda.

Seen from elsewhere. The city was emptied: tens of thousands went to Granada or North Africa, though figures of 300,000 are too high. The emir of Granada had been obliged to send horsemen to help the besiegers. The poet al-Rundi’s lament for the lost cities of al-Andalus, written soon after, is still recited. ‘Reconquest’ is itself a term many historians now question.

1733

Enslaved Akwamu seize the island of St John

Coral Bay, St John, Danish West IndiesThe Americas

St John was a small Danish sugar island where the enslaved outnumbered the free by about five to one. Many were Akwamu, from a Gold Coast state recently defeated in war, and some had been people of rank there. A year of drought, hurricane and hunger was followed by a new slave code of extreme harshness. Before dawn on 23 November a group carrying bundles of firewood were admitted to the fort at Coral Bay; cane knives were hidden in the wood. They killed most of the garrison and fired the cannon as a signal. The rebels held most of the island for six months, until French troops from Martinique hunted them down.

Seen from elsewhere. The rebels left no testimony; the record is the planters’. Many killed themselves rather than be taken. Historians such as Ray Kea have argued that the Akwamu leaders meant to run the estates themselves with other Africans as their labourers. In the Virgin Islands today the rising is commemorated as a fight for freedom.

1946

French warships shell Haiphong

Haiphong, VietnamAsia

France had returned to Indochina after the Japanese surrender and had recognised Ho Chi Minh’s republic, in March 1946, as a ‘free state’ within a French union. Talks on what that meant had stalled. A quarrel over who collected customs in the port of Haiphong led to shooting on 20 November. Three days later, on orders from the French commander in Saigon to teach the Vietnamese a severe lesson, the local garrison issued a two-hour ultimatum and then bombarded the Vietnamese and Chinese quarters with naval guns, artillery and aircraft. Full-scale war began in Hanoi on 19 December and lasted until Dien Bien Phu, in 1954.

Seen from elsewhere. The French command said Viet Minh forces had fired first and that it had to secure the port. The death toll is disputed: a French admiral later spoke of 6,000, the Vietnamese of 20,000, while the historian Stein Tonnesson, who argues that officials in Saigon provoked the break deliberately, thinks the real number was much lower.

1974

Ethiopia’s new rulers shoot sixty prisoners

Addis Ababa, EthiopiaAfrica

The military committee known as the Derg had deposed Emperor Haile Selassie in September 1974 and promised a revolution without bloodshed. On 23 November its chairman, General Aman Andom, who opposed both a military solution in Eritrea and the killing of detainees, was shot dead at his house after a gun battle with troops sent to arrest him. That night some sixty prisoners were taken from their cells in Addis Ababa and executed without trial. They included two former prime ministers, the emperor’s grandson, nobles, generals and ministers. Ethiopians heard it on the radio next morning. The power in the committee was now Major Mengistu Haile Mariam.

Seen from elsewhere. The Derg announced a ‘political decision’ against men it held responsible for corruption and for hiding the famine in Wollo; some student radicals had been demanding exactly that. Mengistu, convicted of genocide in his absence in 2006, has maintained from exile that decisions were collective. Eritreans remember Aman’s death as the end of any negotiated settlement.

Also on 23 November