Parallax

4 November, 1942

Rommel’s line breaks at El Alamein

After twelve days of attrition in the Egyptian desert, and a day lost to an order from Hitler to stand and die, the Axis army in Africa began a retreat that did not stop for 1,500 miles.

El Alamein, Egypt

By the night of 2 November 1942 Field Marshal Erwin Rommel knew the battle was lost. His army had been under attack for ten days on a forty-mile front between the Mediterranean and the impassable Qattara Depression. He had about thirty-five German tanks still running, almost no fuel, and Italian infantry divisions with no vehicles to carry them out. That evening he signalled Berlin that he was pulling back to Fuka, sixty miles west, and the first units began to move.

The answer arrived early in the afternoon of 3 November. Hitler forbade any withdrawal. The troops were to hold where they stood, and Rommel was told he could show them no other road than the one leading to victory or death. Rommel, who had built his reputation on ignoring orders he thought foolish, obeyed this one. He halted the retreat for almost twenty-four hours and later called it the decision he most regretted.

On the other side Lieutenant-General Bernard Montgomery was grinding forward on a plan he had revised more than once. His opening assault on 23 October, behind the fire of nearly nine hundred guns, had not broken through the minefields as intended. The Australians had spent a week pulling German reserves north towards the coast road. On 2 November a second blow, codenamed Supercharge, went in further south. The 9th Armoured Brigade was sent against the anti-tank screen at dawn, with Montgomery’s acceptance that it might be wiped out, and lost some seventy of its ninety-four tanks.

The sacrifice opened the way. Before dawn on 4 November Indian and Highland infantry cut a gap south of Tel el Aqqaqir, and British armour drove through into open desert. The Italian Ariete armoured division, in obsolete tanks, fought until it was surrounded and destroyed. General Wilhelm von Thoma, commander of the Afrika Korps, was captured beside a burning tank and dined that night with Montgomery. In the afternoon Rommel ordered the retreat on his own authority. Hitler’s permission came the next day.

The Germans took what transport there was. Tens of thousands of Italians in the southern sector, including the paratroopers of the Folgore division, were left on foot without water and surrendered over the following days. Eighth Army counted some 13,500 killed, wounded and missing. Axis losses are harder to fix, but around 30,000 prisoners were taken. In Britain, on 15 November, church bells that had been silent since 1940, reserved as an invasion warning, were rung for a victory.

How it came to this

The war in the desert had swung back and forth across Libya for two years, each side advancing until it outran its supplies. In June 1942 Rommel took Tobruk with 33,000 prisoners and chased Eighth Army into Egypt. General Claude Auchinleck stopped him in July at the Alamein position, the last defensible line before Alexandria and the Suez Canal, in a series of costly actions now called the first battle. Churchill, impatient for an offensive, replaced Auchinleck in August. The intended commander of Eighth Army, William Gott, was shot down and killed on his way to take up the post, and Montgomery was sent instead.

Time favoured the British. Montgomery repelled Rommel’s last attack at Alam Halfa at the start of September and then refused to move until he had overwhelming strength: roughly 195,000 men against 105,000 and more than a thousand tanks against about five hundred, including new American Shermans. Codebreakers at Bletchley Park were reading Axis signals, and submarines and aircraft from Malta were sinking the tankers Rommel depended on. Rommel himself was on sick leave in Austria when the attack began. His deputy, Georg Stumme, died of a heart attack on the first morning.

How each side saw it

Rommel and the German command

In the papers edited after his death by Basil Liddell Hart, Rommel presents Alamein as a battle decided before it started, by petrol and by air power. He blames the Italian supreme command and the German staff in Rome for convoys that never arrived, and Hitler for an order that cost him a day and much of his infantry. He was scathing about Montgomery’s caution in pursuit. Some German officers and later historians have answered that Rommel created his own supply crisis by driving into Egypt in the first place, against the advice of Kesselring, with Malta still unsubdued behind him.

The Italians

Italians were the majority of the Axis army at Alamein and have been its least heard voice. British wartime propaganda and German memoirs both treated them as a liability. Italian accounts, such as Paolo Caccia Dominioni’s memoir of the battle, describe ill-equipped men who held their ground and were then abandoned when the Germans took the lorries. The stand of the Folgore and the destruction of the Ariete are commemorated on the battlefield, where an Italian inscription says that luck was lacking, not valour. Rommel himself wrote that the Italian soldier was let down by his equipment and his leaders.

Montgomery’s critics

Montgomery’s memoirs claimed the battle went according to plan and implied he had inherited an army preparing to retreat. Auchinleck and his staff officer Eric Dorman-Smith disputed this bitterly, and threatened legal action. In The Desert Generals in 1960 Correlli Barnett argued that Auchinleck had already saved Egypt in July and that the October battle was an unnecessary set piece fought for prestige four days before Allied landings in Rommel’s rear. Montgomery’s defenders reply that the army’s confidence was badly shaken in August 1942 and that he restored it by methods suited to the troops he had.

The Commonwealth armies and Egypt

The Eighth Army was ‘British’ only in the imperial sense. Australians, New Zealanders, South Africans and Indians did much of the infantry fighting, alongside Greek, Free French and Polish units; the Australian 9th Division alone took about a fifth of the army’s casualties. Their national histories each tell the battle as their own. Egypt, on whose soil it was fought, was formally neutral and occupied under treaty, and some Egyptian nationalists, including the young officer Anwar Sadat, had hoped for a British defeat. Millions of mines laid in 1942 remain in the western desert and still kill and maim Bedouin and farm workers.

What is disputed

The battle is variously dated to end on 4 November, when the line broke and the retreat was ordered, or on 11 November, when the last Axis troops left Egypt. Whether it was necessary, given the Anglo-American landings in Morocco and Algeria on 8 November, has been argued since Barnett. Churchill’s remark that before Alamein there was never a victory and after it never a defeat was hedged in his own memoirs with the words ‘it may almost be said’, and ignores earlier successes. Historians also dispute how much credit belongs to Ultra intelligence and to the air force, and why the pursuit failed to trap Rommel.

What followed

Rommel retreated across Libya into Tunisia, where the Axis armies, caught between Eighth Army and the forces landed in Operation Torch, surrendered in May 1943 with about a quarter of a million prisoners. Alamein was the last major land victory won by British and Commonwealth forces without American troops, which is part of why it holds its place in British memory. It made Montgomery a public figure and a difficult ally. For the wider war it mattered less than Stalingrad, where the Soviet counter-offensive began a fortnight later against far larger German forces.

Read further

  • Niall Barr, Pendulum of War: The Three Battles of El Alamein (2004)
  • Correlli Barnett, The Desert Generals (1960)
  • B. H. Liddell Hart (editor), The Rommel Papers (1953)
  • Stephen Bungay, Alamein (2002)
  • Jonathan Fennell, Combat and Morale in the North African Campaign: The Eighth Army and the Path to El Alamein (2011)

Same day, other years

1780

Tupac Amaru II seizes a Spanish governor

Tinta province, near Cuzco, PeruThe Americas

Jose Gabriel Condorcanqui was a mule-train owner and hereditary chief of three villages south of Cuzco who claimed descent from the last Inca ruler and used his name. On 4 November, after a dinner for the king of Spain’s name day, he ambushed the local governor, Antonio de Arriaga, a man hated for forcing overpriced goods on Indian communities. Six days later Arriaga was hanged in the square at Tungasuca before thousands. The revolt that followed, directed in large part by Condorcanqui’s wife Micaela Bastidas, spread across the southern Andes and merged with risings in what is now Bolivia. Perhaps 100,000 people died before it was put down.

Seen from elsewhere. He first claimed to act in the king’s name against bad officials, and historians dispute whether he sought reform or independence. Creoles who might have joined were frightened off by the killing of Europeans. After his execution in 1781 Spain banned Inca dress, titles and plays. Peru’s military government of the 1970s made him a national emblem.

1922

A step cut in the rock leads to Tutankhamun

Valley of the Kings, Luxor, EgyptAfrica

Howard Carter had dug in the Valley of the Kings for years on Lord Carnarvon’s money and was in what both men understood to be his final season. On the morning of 4 November his Egyptian workmen, clearing beneath the remains of ancient labourers’ huts, uncovered a step. By the next evening a staircase led down to a sealed doorway. Carter filled it in and cabled Carnarvon in England. On 26 November, with a candle at a hole in a second door, he saw the antechamber of the only largely intact royal burial ever found in the valley. Clearing the tomb’s more than five thousand objects took ten years.

Seen from elsewhere. Egypt had become nominally independent that February, and Carnarvon’s sale of exclusive coverage to The Times enraged the Egyptian press. The government locked Carter out in 1924 and kept every object in the country. The foreman Ahmed Gerigar and the workmen are barely named in the record, and letters suggest Carter removed items privately.

1956

Soviet tanks return to Budapest

Budapest, HungaryEurope

For five days Hungarians believed they had won. A rising that began with a student march on 23 October had forced Soviet troops out of the capital, and the reform communist Imre Nagy had announced a multi-party government and withdrawal from the Warsaw Pact. Before dawn on 4 November more than a thousand Soviet tanks entered Budapest. Nagy broadcast that his government was at its post, then took refuge in the Yugoslav embassy. Workers and teenagers fought for about a week in districts such as Csepel and the Corvin Passage. Some 2,500 Hungarians and about 700 Soviet soldiers were killed, and 200,000 people fled to the West. Nagy was hanged in 1958.

Seen from elsewhere. Moscow and the government it installed under Janos Kadar called the rising a counter-revolution led by fascists, pointing to the lynching of secret policemen. Soviet leaders also feared the bloc unravelling while the West was distracted by Suez. Many Hungarians blamed Radio Free Europe for implying that help would come.

1979

Students seize the American embassy in Tehran

Tehran, IranMiddle East

Nine months after the fall of the shah, several hundred students calling themselves followers of the Imam’s line climbed the gates of the United States embassy and took its staff prisoner. They had planned a sit-in of a few days. Ayatollah Khomeini endorsed the occupation, the moderate provisional government resigned within two days, and the seizure became a siege. Women and Black staff were released early; fifty-two Americans were held for 444 days, through a failed rescue mission in which eight servicemen died, and freed minutes after Ronald Reagan was sworn in as president in January 1981. The two countries have had no diplomatic relations since.

Seen from elsewhere. The students called the embassy a den of spies and feared a repeat of 1953, when a coup organised from that building restored the shah; his admission to America for medical treatment was the trigger. Washington and the International Court of Justice called it a plain breach of diplomatic immunity. Several of the hostage-takers later became reformist critics of the state.

Also on 4 November