Parallax

24 November, 1859

On the Origin of Species goes on sale

Its author was wrapped in wet sheets at a Yorkshire spa, sick with nerves. His publisher had been advised that a book about pigeons would sell better. The whole printing was ordered by booksellers before it reached a shop.

London, England

The book that went on sale in London on Thursday 24 November 1859 was a green cloth volume of 502 pages, priced at fourteen shillings, with a title that ran to twenty-one words. John Murray of Albemarle Street had printed 1,250 copies. After the author’s copies and those sent for review were set aside, 1,170 were left, and at Murray’s trade sale two days earlier the booksellers had ordered more than that. The circulating library Mudie’s took five hundred. This is the fact behind the saying that it sold out on its first day.

Murray had not been sure of it. He had accepted the manuscript on the strength of the author’s name and the word of the geologist Charles Lyell, then sent it to a clerical adviser, Whitwell Elwin, who recommended that Mr Darwin publish instead his observations on pigeons, since everybody was interested in pigeons. Charles Darwin, who was fifty, kept the pigeons to the first chapter.

He was not in London. He was at Ilkley, on the edge of the Yorkshire moors, undergoing the cold-water cure for the vomiting, boils and exhaustion that overtook him whenever he was under strain. From there he sent out presentation copies with anxious letters, telling one friend that he would think the author deserved to be crucified.

The argument was built slowly from homely things: the varieties bred by gardeners and fanciers, the struggle of seedlings on a patch of ground, the instincts of bees and ants. Living things vary; more are born than can survive; those whose variations suit them best to their conditions leave more offspring; over immense time, this alone can make new species from old. He did not use the word evolution. About mankind he allowed himself one sentence, near the end: light would be thrown on the origin of man and his history.

The replies came within days. Thomas Huxley, who is said to have reproached himself for not having thought of it, wrote that he was sharpening his claws and beak in readiness. Darwin’s old teacher Adam Sedgwick wrote that he had read it with more pain than pleasure, admiring some parts and laughing at others until his sides were sore. The clergyman and novelist Charles Kingsley said it was just as noble a conception of God to believe that he created forms capable of self-development. Murray ordered a second printing of three thousand, which appeared in January.

How it came to this

Darwin had come home from his voyage round the world on HMS Beagle in 1836 with collections, among them the birds and tortoises of the Galapagos, that made him doubt that species were fixed. He opened a notebook on the question in 1837, and the following year, reading Malthus on population, saw how a struggle for existence could do the selecting. He wrote his theory out in 1842 and at more length in 1844, with instructions to his wife for publishing it if he died. Then he spent eight years on barnacles, and years more collecting evidence.

In June 1858 a letter arrived from the Malay Archipelago. Alfred Russel Wallace, a collector fourteen years his junior, had hit on the same idea during a fever and written it up in a short essay, which he asked Darwin to pass on if he thought it good. Darwin was appalled. His friends Lyell and Joseph Hooker arranged for extracts of Darwin’s unpublished writing and Wallace’s essay to be read together at the Linnean Society on 1 July. Neither man was there: Wallace was in New Guinea and had not been asked, and Darwin was burying his infant son. He wrote the Origin, which he called an abstract, in the next thirteen months.

How each side saw it

Alfred Russel Wallace

Wallace learned of the joint reading months after it happened and wrote that he was glad his essay had prompted Darwin to publish. He never claimed more: he called his own later book Darwinism and said the theory would have gone unnoticed for years had it rested on his paper alone. A few modern writers have argued that he was wronged, and even that Darwin received his letter earlier than he admitted and borrowed from it; the historian John van Wyhe’s reconstruction of the mail steamers finds the letter arrived when Darwin said. Wallace did part company with him over the human mind, which he thought natural selection could not explain.

Religious critics, and religious friends

Samuel Wilberforce, Bishop of Oxford, reviewing the book in the Quarterly Review, argued that it was bad science and that it contradicted the revealed relation of creation to its Creator. Sedgwick feared it would brutalise humanity by severing the moral from the physical. Others in the churches accepted it early: Kingsley, the future archbishop Frederick Temple, and in America the devout botanist Asa Gray, who thought variation itself might be guided. Rome never placed the Origin on its Index. Organised rejection on scriptural grounds belongs mainly to the twentieth century, and to some Protestant and later some Muslim movements.

Scientific opponents

The leading anatomist in Britain, Richard Owen, attacked the book anonymously in the Edinburgh Review; Louis Agassiz at Harvard held to the end that species were thoughts of God. More damaging were objections Darwin could not answer. The engineer Fleeming Jenkin showed that if inheritance blended parents’ traits, a favourable variation would be diluted away. The physicist William Thomson calculated that the Earth was far too young for so slow a process. By 1900 most naturalists accepted descent with modification but doubted natural selection was its cause. It was restored only when Mendel’s genetics was joined to it in the 1930s.

Those to whom the theory was applied

The subtitle’s ‘favoured races’ meant varieties of any organism, cabbages included, but the phrase and the idea were soon turned on people. Darwin’s cousin Francis Galton founded eugenics; writers and officials in Europe and America cited the struggle for existence to justify empire, the neglect of the poor and the expected disappearance of colonised peoples. Darwin himself came of an abolitionist family and loathed slavery, as Adrian Desmond and James Moore have stressed, yet in The Descent of Man he wrote calmly of ‘civilised races’ exterminating ‘savage’ ones. Descendants of those peoples have reason to read him with mixed feelings.

What is disputed

Why Darwin waited twenty years is argued. The long-standard view, put most forcefully by Desmond and Moore, is that he feared the scandal; John van Wyhe has argued that there was no delay at all, only other work he meant to finish first. ‘Sold out on the first day’ means oversubscribed by the trade, not bought by readers. Huxley’s celebrated self-reproach comes from his recollection decades later. The exchange between Huxley and Wilberforce at Oxford in June 1860, about apes and grandmothers, was not recorded at the time, and the surviving accounts disagree about what was said and who came off better.

What followed

Six editions appeared in Darwin’s lifetime, each revised to meet critics; the phrase ‘survival of the fittest’, borrowed from Herbert Spencer, entered in the fifth. He addressed human origins directly in 1871. When he died in 1882 he was buried in Westminster Abbey, a few feet from Newton. The theory, fused with genetics and then with molecular biology, is the organising principle of the life sciences. The argument about teaching it has never quite ended, from the Tennessee trial of a schoolteacher in 1925 to an American federal court ruling on ‘intelligent design’ in 2005.

Read further

  • Charles Darwin, On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection (1859)
  • Janet Browne, Charles Darwin: The Power of Place (2002)
  • Adrian Desmond and James Moore, Darwin (1991)
  • Peter J. Bowler, Evolution: The History of an Idea (1984)
  • John van Wyhe, Dispelling the Darkness: Voyage in the Malay Archipelago and the Discovery of Evolution by Wallace and Darwin (2013)

Same day, other years

1642

Abel Tasman sights the island that will bear his name

West coast of TasmaniaOceania

The Dutch East India Company had sent Abel Tasman from Batavia with two small ships to find out what lay south and east of the known coasts of New Holland, and whether there was anything to trade. On the afternoon of 24 November 1642 his lookouts saw high land to the east. He named it Anthony van Diemen’s Land, after the governor-general who had sent him. Bad weather kept him off the coast for a week. On 3 December the ship’s carpenter swam through the surf to plant a flag. The landing party heard voices and saw smoke and notched trees, but met no one, and Tasman sailed on to New Zealand.

Seen from elsewhere. The Palawa had lived on the island for some forty thousand years; what they made of the ships is not recorded. British settlement from 1803 and the war of the 1820s reduced a population of several thousand to a few hundred exiles within thirty years. Their descendants are today’s Tasmanian Aboriginal community, who call the island lutruwita.

1922

Erskine Childers is shot by the Irish Free State

Dublin, IrelandEurope

Childers was English-born, a former clerk of the House of Commons and the author of a famous spy novel, The Riddle of the Sands. He had converted to the Irish cause, run guns into Howth on his yacht in 1914, and served as secretary to the delegation that negotiated the treaty of 1921, which he then opposed. In the civil war he wrote propaganda for the anti-Treaty side. Free State troops arrested him on 10 November carrying a small pistol that had been a gift from Michael Collins. Possession of a firearm was now a capital offence. He was shot at Beggars Bush Barracks at dawn on 24 November, having shaken hands with each of the firing party.

Seen from elsewhere. The Free State government believed, wrongly, that he was directing the republican campaign, and held that a new state fighting for its life had to enforce its law. Republicans called it judicial murder, carried out while his appeal was still before the courts. His son, whom he asked to forgive those responsible, became President of Ireland in 1973.

1965

Mobutu takes power in the Congo

Leopoldville (Kinshasa), CongoAfrica

Five years after independence from Belgium the Congo had been through the murder of its first prime minister, Patrice Lumumba, two secessions, a rebellion that held half the country, and now a deadlock between President Joseph Kasavubu and the prime minister he had dismissed, Moise Tshombe. On the night of 24 November the army commander, Joseph-Desire Mobutu, gathered his senior officers, and by morning the radio announced that he had assumed the presidency for five years. No shot was fired. He stayed for thirty-two, renamed the country Zaire, and amassed a personal fortune counted in billions of dollars while its roads, mines and hospitals decayed. He was driven out in 1997.

Seen from elsewhere. At the time many Congolese welcomed an end to paralysis, and Washington and Brussels were content: Mobutu had been close to the CIA since 1960, and its station chief later wrote that he knew of the coup in advance. Followers of Lumumba saw the triumph of the officer who had delivered their leader to his killers.

2012

The Tazreen garment factory fire

Ashulia, near Dhaka, BangladeshAsia

The fire started in the evening among bales of yarn and fabric stored on the open ground floor of the Tazreen Fashions building, where more than a thousand people were working overtime on the floors above. Survivors said that when the alarm sounded, supervisors told them it was a drill and to go back to their machines. The staircases all led down into the burning ground floor; there were no outside fire escapes and the windows were barred. At least 112 people died, some after jumping from upper storeys. Labels and paperwork found in the ruins linked the factory to well-known American and European retailers.

Seen from elsewhere. Several brands said their orders had been subcontracted to Tazreen without their knowledge. Officials at first spoke of sabotage. Labour groups replied that buyers’ prices and deadlines made such buildings inevitable and that inspections had already rated the factory unsafe. Five months later the collapse of the Rana Plaza building nearby killed more than 1,100 garment workers.

Also on 24 November