Parallax

18 November, 1095

The council that launched the First Crusade assembles

Some three hundred churchmen met at Clermont to discuss clerical discipline and a king’s adultery. Nine days later the pope walked out to a field and said something, nobody is sure exactly what, that sent tens of thousands of people to Jerusalem.

Clermont, Auvergne, France

Pope Urban II opened his council at Clermont on 18 November 1095. He was a Frenchman, born Odo of Chatillon, once prior of the great abbey of Cluny, and he had spent the summer and autumn travelling through southern France consecrating altars and gathering support. About three hundred bishops and abbots came, most of them from France; the chronicler Fulcher of Chartres gives 310.

For more than a week they dealt with ordinary business. They renewed decrees against the buying of church offices and against married priests. They extended the Truce of God, which forbade fighting on certain days. They excommunicated King Philip I of France, who had put aside his wife and taken the wife of the Count of Anjou. None of this would have been remembered.

On Tuesday 27 November it was announced that the pope would speak in public. The crowd was too large for the cathedral, so a platform was set up in a field outside the eastern gate. Urban spoke of the Christians of the East, of the Turks who had overrun Asia Minor, and, according to most later reports, of Jerusalem. He called on the fighting men of the West to stop killing one another and go to their aid, and he offered a spiritual reward: the council’s own decree says that whoever went to Jerusalem out of devotion alone, not for honour or money, to free the Church of God, could count the journey in place of all penance.

The response looks arranged. Adhemar, Bishop of Le Puy, came forward at once, knelt and asked leave to go; Urban named him his legate. People in the crowd cut strips of cloth into crosses and sewed them to their shoulders. One account has them shouting ‘God wills it’. The next day envoys arrived from Raymond, Count of Toulouse, the richest lord in the south, announcing that he would lead an army; he had almost certainly been consulted beforehand.

The council closed on 28 November. Urban spent the next eight months on the road, preaching at Limoges, Angers, Tours and Nimes, and writing to those he could not reach. He fixed the departure for 15 August 1096, the feast of the Assumption. By then crowds he had never intended to summon were already on the march.

How it came to this

The request had come from Constantinople. In March 1095, at a council in Piacenza, envoys of the Byzantine emperor Alexios I Komnenos asked the pope for help in recruiting western soldiers. Since the defeat at Manzikert in 1071 the Seljuk Turks had taken most of Asia Minor, the empire’s heartland, and Alexios had long hired Frankish and Norman mercenaries. Jerusalem itself had been under Muslim rule since 638; pilgrims still went, though the wars between Seljuks and the Fatimids of Egypt in the 1070s had made the journey dangerous.

Urban had reasons of his own. The papacy was fighting the German emperor Henry IV over who appointed bishops, and an imperial antipope held part of Rome. Helping the eastern Christians offered a chance to heal the breach between the Latin and Greek churches, open since 1054, and to show that the pope, not the emperor, led Christendom. The reforming Church had also spent decades trying to restrain the violence of the knightly class at home, and had already blessed wars against Muslim rulers in Spain and Sicily.

How each side saw it

The Byzantine court

Alexios wanted a few thousand disciplined soldiers under his own command. What arrived were whole armies with their own princes, including his old enemy Bohemond the Norman. His daughter Anna Komnene, writing the Alexiad some fifty years later, describes the westerners as brave, greedy and impossible to trust, and treats the movement as something that fell on the empire from outside; she does not mention that her father had asked for help. Alexios made the leaders swear to return any imperial territory they recovered. When they kept Antioch for themselves, Byzantines concluded that they had been right about them.

The Jews of the Rhineland

In the spring of 1096, before the main armies left, bands of crusaders under Count Emicho of Flonheim and others attacked the Jewish communities of Speyer, Worms, Mainz and Cologne, offering baptism or death. Some bishops tried to shelter them and failed. Three Hebrew narratives survive, known by the names of Solomon bar Simson, Eliezer bar Nathan and the Mainz Anonymous. They record that the attackers asked why they should travel so far to fight God’s enemies while leaving others at home, and that many Jews killed their children and themselves rather than convert. The dead are still commemorated in the Ashkenazi liturgy.

Muslim writers

No Muslim source reports Urban’s sermon. The Syrian chronicler Ibn al-Qalanisi, a contemporary, records the Franks’ arrival as a sudden calamity, and many at first took them for another Byzantine mercenary force. The fullest explanation comes from Ibn al-Athir, writing in Mosul more than a century later, who set the invasion alongside the Christian capture of Toledo in 1085 and the Norman conquest of Sicily as one western advance. In Damascus in 1105 the jurist al-Sulami preached that the Franks had succeeded because Muslim rulers were divided and had neglected their duty. For decades few listened.

The western chroniclers

To the men who wrote it up in the West, Clermont was the moment God moved his people. Robert the Monk called the expedition the greatest event since the Creation and the Crucifixion. Guibert of Nogent titled his history The Deeds of God through the Franks. In their telling the knights, who had been damning themselves by fighting fellow Christians, had been offered a new road to salvation that did not require them to become monks. This is the tradition that passed into European memory, and it was written by clerics who knew that Jerusalem had fallen.

What is disputed

The council opened on 18 November, but the famous sermon was given on the 27th; popular books often merge the two. No text of the speech exists. Five versions were written down, by Fulcher of Chartres, Robert the Monk, Baldric of Dol, Guibert of Nogent and William of Malmesbury, all after Jerusalem fell in 1099, and they differ; the cry of ‘God wills it’ appears in only some. Historians disagree on whether Urban aimed at Jerusalem from the start, as H. E. J. Cowdrey argued from his letters, or chiefly at aid for Byzantium, as Carl Erdmann held. Peter Frankopan has stressed Alexios’s part; Jonathan Riley-Smith argued that most crusaders went from piety and at ruinous cost, not for land.

What followed

The first to leave were the unarmed followers of the preacher Peter the Hermit, most of whom were killed in Asia Minor in 1096. The princes’ armies took Antioch in 1098 and stormed Jerusalem on 15 July 1099, killing a large part of its Muslim and Jewish population. Urban died two weeks later, before the news reached Rome. Latin states survived on the Syrian coast until 1291. The idea outlived them: ‘crusade’ is still a word of praise in some mouths and an accusation in others, and what was said in that field is argued over as if it had happened last year.

Read further

  • Jonathan Riley-Smith, The First Crusade and the Idea of Crusading (1986)
  • Thomas Asbridge, The First Crusade: A New History (2004)
  • Peter Frankopan, The First Crusade: The Call from the East (2012)
  • Carole Hillenbrand, The Crusades: Islamic Perspectives (1999)
  • Robert Chazan, European Jewry and the First Crusade (1987)

Same day, other years

1803

The battle that made Haiti

Vertieres, Saint-DomingueThe Americas

Napoleon had sent an army in 1802 to retake France’s richest colony and, as became clear, to restore slavery there. Yellow fever and a general rising destroyed it. On 18 November 1803 the ‘indigenous army’ of Jean-Jacques Dessalines attacked the forts covering the last French stronghold, Cap-Francais. The officer Francois Capois led charge after charge at Vertieres; his horse was killed under him and he went on on foot. By nightfall the French position was lost. General Rochambeau agreed the next day to evacuate, and his ships sailed straight into a British blockade. On 1 January 1804 Dessalines declared the independence of Haiti.

Seen from elsewhere. France long explained the defeat by fever alone, and Vertieres was absent from French school histories, as the historian Jean-Pierre Le Glaunec has shown. Rochambeau’s campaign had included mass drownings and the use of dogs. In 1804 Dessalines ordered the killing of most remaining French colonists, and in 1825 France made Haiti pay an indemnity for its freedom.

1910

Black Friday outside Parliament

London, EnglandEurope

A bill that would have given the vote to about a million women had passed its second reading, and the prime minister, H. H. Asquith, announced an election without finding time for it. Some three hundred members of the Women’s Social and Political Union walked to Parliament Square in small groups to protest. For six hours police, and men in the crowd, pushed them back, struck them and in many cases assaulted them sexually. One hundred and fifteen women and four men were arrested; the Home Secretary, Winston Churchill, had the charges dropped next day. Two women died in the following weeks, and the WSPU turned to breaking windows.

Seen from elsewhere. The police maintained they had used only the force needed to keep the approach to Parliament clear. A memorandum compiled by Henry Brailsford and Jessie Murray from 135 statements said otherwise and asked for a public inquiry, which Churchill refused. Opponents of the suffragettes held that women who set out to be arrested had invited rough handling.

1949

Police shoot coal miners at Enugu

Iva Valley, Enugu, NigeriaAfrica

The miners at the government-owned Iva Valley colliery in eastern Nigeria were on a go-slow over back pay they believed they were owed. The colonial authorities, nervous of militant nationalists, decided to remove the mine’s store of explosives and sent armed police to do it. Miners gathered around the magazine, singing and waving sticks and tools. A British police officer, F. S. Philip, gave the order to fire. Twenty-one miners were killed and about fifty wounded, many shot in the back. Riots followed in Aba, Port Harcourt, Onitsha and Calabar, and rival nationalist parties briefly made common cause.

Seen from elsewhere. Officials said the police had been about to be overwhelmed. The Fitzgerald Commission sent from London found that the officer had made an error of judgement and that a labour dispute had been wrongly treated as a political one, while also blaming the union’s leader. In Nigeria the dead are remembered as martyrs of independence.

1978

Jonestown

Port Kaituma, GuyanaThe Americas

The Peoples Temple, a California congregation led by Jim Jones, had moved about a thousand members, most of them African American, to a farm settlement in the Guyanese jungle. A United States congressman, Leo Ryan, flew in to investigate complaints from relatives. As he left with a group of defectors on 18 November, Temple gunmen opened fire at the airstrip, killing Ryan, three journalists and one defector. That evening Jones gathered his followers and told them to drink a fruit drink mixed with cyanide. Nine hundred and nine people died at the settlement, about a third of them children. Jones was found shot through the head.

Seen from elsewhere. Jones called it ‘revolutionary suicide’. Survivors and relatives of the dead reject the word: the children were given the poison by adults, armed guards ringed the pavilion, and some bodies showed injection marks. They also object to the flippant phrase about ‘drinking the Kool-Aid’. For Guyanese it remains an American tragedy enacted on their soil.

Also on 18 November