Parallax

7 November, 1917

The Bolsheviks take Petrograd in a night

Trams ran, theatres were open and most of the city slept while armed detachments occupied the bridges, the telephone exchange and the state bank. The storming of the Winter Palace that the world remembers was filmed ten years later.

Petrograd, Russia

The seizure of power began as a quarrel about a printing press. In the small hours of 24 October 1917 by the Russian calendar, 6 November in the West, the Provisional Government sent military cadets to close two Bolshevik newspapers. The Military Revolutionary Committee of the Petrograd Soviet, run from the Smolny Institute by Leon Trotsky, sent soldiers to reopen them and announced that the Soviet was under attack. Through that day and the following night its units moved, with hardly a shot, to the railway stations, the bridges over the Neva, the power station, the post office and the telephone exchange. In most places the guards simply changed.

Lenin, in hiding in a flat on the Vyborg side, could not bear to wait. Late on the 24th he put on a wig and a bandage, crossed the city by tram and on foot past a government patrol that took him for a drunk, and arrived at Smolny to press his colleagues to finish it before the national Congress of Soviets met the next day. By the morning of the 25th, 7 November, the government held little more than the Winter Palace. At ten o’clock Lenin issued a proclamation announcing that it had been deposed, which was not yet true.

The prime minister, Alexander Kerensky, left at about eleven in an open touring car, followed by a vehicle borrowed from the American embassy flying its flag, to find loyal troops at the front. His ministers stayed in the palace, guarded by cadets, some Cossacks and a company of the Women’s Battalion, perhaps three thousand in all at the start and far fewer by evening as groups drifted away, hungry and unpaid.

At 9.40 that night the cruiser Aurora fired a blank from the river. Guns in the Peter and Paul Fortress then fired live shells, of which one or two struck the building. The Congress of Soviets opened at Smolny to the sound of them. Mensheviks and Socialist Revolutionaries denounced the rising as a conspiracy behind the back of the Congress and walked out, and Trotsky told them they were going where they belonged, into the dustbin of history.

There was no single assault. Red Guards and sailors filtered in through unlocked doors and windows and wandered the corridors until, at about ten past two in the morning, Vladimir Antonov-Ovseenko found the ministers sitting round a table in a small dining room and arrested them. A handful of people had been killed. The following evening the Congress approved decrees on peace and on land, and a government of People’s Commissars with Lenin at its head.

How it came to this

Nicholas II had abdicated in March 1917 after bread riots and a garrison mutiny in the capital. Authority then split between a Provisional Government of liberals and moderate socialists and the soviets, councils elected by workers and soldiers, which controlled the factories and regiments. The government kept Russia in the war, postponed land reform and put off elections to a Constituent Assembly. A summer offensive collapsed. In the cities bread rations fell and prices rose; in the countryside peasants began seizing estates; at the front soldiers deserted in hundreds of thousands.

The Bolsheviks, a small party in March, were the only major one that refused any part in the government and promised peace, land and all power to the soviets. Lenin returned from Swiss exile in April on a train provided by Germany. A premature rising in July sent him back into hiding. But when the army commander Kornilov moved on Petrograd in late August, Kerensky armed the workers to stop him, and the Bolsheviks took the credit. By September they held majorities in the Petrograd and Moscow soviets. On 10 October the party’s central committee voted, ten to two, for an armed rising.

How each side saw it

The Bolsheviks

In Trotsky’s History of the Russian Revolution and in Soviet accounts for seventy years, October was a proletarian revolution carried out by the masses through their own institutions, with the party as their instrument. The ease of the victory proved its legitimacy: the old order had no defenders because it represented no one. Lenin argued that waiting for a Constituent Assembly meant handing the country to generals. The decrees of the first day, giving land to the peasants and proposing an immediate peace, were what the majority of Russians wanted and what no other party had dared enact. John Reed’s eyewitness book, with a preface by Lenin, carried this version abroad.

The socialists who walked out

The Menshevik leader Julius Martov, and Nikolai Sukhanov, whose memoir is the fullest non-Bolshevik eyewitness record, had no love for Kerensky. Their charge was that one party had seized power by military conspiracy on the eve of a Congress that would have formed a broad socialist government peacefully, and that this made civil war certain. They pointed to the elections for the Constituent Assembly held three weeks later, in which the Bolsheviks won about a quarter of the vote and the Socialist Revolutionaries the largest share. The Assembly met for one day in January 1918 before it was dispersed by armed guards. Sukhanov later judged the walkout itself a fatal mistake.

Kerensky, the liberals and the Whites

Kerensky spent half a century in exile insisting that he had been betrayed from the right by Kornilov and from the left by a party financed by the German General Staff. Liberal Kadets and the officers who formed the White armies saw October as a coup by fanatics who exploited war-weariness and then signed away a third of European Russia’s population at Brest-Litovsk. That German money reached the Bolsheviks is documented; that it explains their success is not accepted by most historians. In emigre memory, and in much of today’s official Russia, 1917 is a national catastrophe that destroyed a great power.

Historians: coup or revolution

Richard Pipes argued that October was a classic coup d’etat, the capture of the state by a disciplined minority with no mandate, and the direct source of the dictatorship that followed. Alexander Rabinowitch, working from Petrograd’s factory and regimental records, showed that the party was open and quarrelsome in 1917 and that its programme had real majority support among the capital’s workers and soldiers. Orlando Figes describes both at once: a coup that succeeded because a social revolution was already under way. Since Soviet archives opened in 1991 the argument has moved from whether to how quickly popular support turned into one-party rule.

What is disputed

The date depends on the calendar, 25 October in Russia and 7 November in the West; the Soviet state kept the old name and celebrated in November. The image of crowds charging the palace gates comes from a staged re-enactment in 1920 and Eisenstein’s film October of 1927, each of which caused more damage than the event. Deaths at the palace are usually put at five or six. Rumours of mass rape of the women soldiers were investigated by the city council and found to be greatly exaggerated, though assaults were reported. In Moscow, by contrast, a week of street fighting killed several hundred.

What followed

The new government made peace with Germany in March 1918 and fought a civil war until 1921-22 in which, with famine and epidemic, something between seven and ten million people died. The tsar and his family were shot in July 1918. The state founded that night became the Soviet Union in 1922 and lasted until 1991, and its example shaped revolutions and counter-revolutions from China to Cuba. Russia stopped marking 7 November as a public holiday in 2005, replacing it with a Day of National Unity on the 4th that commemorates the expulsion of Polish forces from Moscow in 1612.

Read further

  • Alexander Rabinowitch, The Bolsheviks Come to Power: The Revolution of 1917 in Petrograd (1976)
  • Richard Pipes, The Russian Revolution (1990)
  • Orlando Figes, A People’s Tragedy: The Russian Revolution, 1891-1924 (1996)
  • N. N. Sukhanov, The Russian Revolution 1917: A Personal Record, edited by Joel Carmichael (1955)
  • Leon Trotsky, The History of the Russian Revolution (1932)

Same day, other years

1775

A royal governor offers freedom to the enslaved

Off Norfolk, VirginiaThe Americas

Driven from his capital and living aboard a ship in the Elizabeth River, the Earl of Dunmore, Virginia’s last royal governor, signed a proclamation declaring martial law and promising freedom to ‘all indented servants, Negroes, or others’ belonging to rebels who were able and willing to bear arms for the king. Within weeks several hundred men, some with their families, had reached British lines by canoe and on foot. Dunmore formed them into a unit called the Ethiopian Regiment. Most died of smallpox in crowded camps over the following year. The survivors sailed with him in 1776, among the first of many thousands who sought freedom with the British.

Seen from elsewhere. Dunmore owned slaves himself and freed none of his own, nor those of loyalists. Virginia’s patriots called the proclamation an incitement to massacre, and it pushed many waverers towards independence; the Declaration’s complaint of ‘domestic insurrections’ refers to it. For the enslaved, the revolution’s liberty lay on the other side.

1907

Jesus Garcia drives a burning dynamite train out of town

Nacozari, Sonora, MexicoThe Americas

Nacozari was a copper town in the Sonoran mountains owned by an American company. On the afternoon of 7 November sparks from a locomotive set fire to hay on a wagon loaded with dynamite as the train stood near the centre of the settlement. The engine driver, Jesus Garcia Corona, twenty-five years old, told his crew to jump and opened the throttle up the grade towards the mine. The train had gone about six kilometres when it exploded, killing him and about a dozen people at a trackside camp. The town itself was untouched. It was renamed Nacozari de Garcia, and Mexico’s railway workers keep 7 November as their day.

Seen from elsewhere. The celebration of Garcia as the ‘hero of Nacozari’ has tended to pass over the company’s part: accounts of the accident say the explosives were loaded directly behind the engine, against practice. Mexican writers after the Revolution made him a symbol of the worker’s worth under foreign owners, a meaning the mine’s managers did not share.

1918

A ship brings influenza to Samoa

Apia, Western SamoaOceania

The steamer Talune arrived from Auckland with sick passengers aboard and was allowed to dock without quarantine by the New Zealand military administration that had held the former German colony since 1914. Within a week the pandemic strain of influenza was throughout the islands of Upolu and Savai’i. Whole villages were too ill to gather food or bury their dead. In about two months some 8,500 people died, more than a fifth of the population, among the highest death rates recorded anywhere in the pandemic. Forty miles away in American Samoa, the naval governor imposed a strict quarantine and the territory did not record a single death.

Seen from elsewhere. The administrator, Colonel Robert Logan, declined an American offer of medical help and broke off radio contact; he blamed circumstances. A New Zealand royal commission in 1919 found the administration at fault. Samoans’ anger fed the Mau independence movement of the 1920s. New Zealand’s prime minister apologised formally in 2002.

1987

Tunisia’s president is declared unfit by his doctors

Tunis, TunisiaAfrica

Habib Bourguiba had led Tunisia to independence from France in 1956, given women rights unmatched in the Arab world and made himself president for life. By 1987 he was in his mid-eighties, erratic, and demanding the retrial and execution of Islamist leaders whom a court had declined to hang. In the early hours of 7 November his recently appointed prime minister, the former security chief Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, had seven doctors sign a statement that the president was incapable of governing and took over under the constitution’s provision for incapacity. No shot was fired. Bourguiba lived under guard in his home town of Monastir until his death in 2000.

Seen from elsewhere. Most Tunisians, including the Islamists reprieved by it, welcomed what was called ‘the Change’, and Ben Ali promised pluralism and an end to life presidencies. He then ruled for twenty-three years through rigged elections and a pervasive police, until the uprising of January 2011 drove him to Saudi Arabia.

Also on 7 November