Parallax

9 November, 1799

Brumaire: the coup that nearly failed

A thirty-year-old general set out to take power by parliamentary vote, lost his nerve in front of the deputies, and was rescued by his younger brother and a column of grenadiers.

Paris and Saint-Cloud, France

On the morning of 18 Brumaire in the Year VIII of the Republic, 9 November 1799, the upper chamber of the French legislature, the Council of Ancients, was summoned at an unusually early hour, and the members thought likely to object were not told. Those present were informed that a Jacobin plot threatened the Republic. They voted to move both chambers out of Paris to the palace of Saint-Cloud the next day and to give General Napoleon Bonaparte command of the troops in the capital. All of this was legal. That was the point of the plan.

The plan belonged less to Bonaparte than to Emmanuel Sieyès, one of the five Directors who governed France, who wanted a stronger executive and had been looking for what he called a sword. Bonaparte, back from Egypt for barely three weeks, was the sword available. By the afternoon Sieyès and his colleague Roger Ducos had resigned, a third Director, Paul Barras, had been talked into resigning by Talleyrand, and the remaining two were under guard in the Luxembourg palace. The executive had ceased to exist without a shot.

The second day went wrong. At Saint-Cloud on 19 Brumaire the rooms were not ready, and for hours deputies stood about comparing notes and noticing that nobody could describe the plot. When the lower house, the Council of Five Hundred, finally met in the Orangery, its members insisted on swearing loyalty to the constitution one by one. Bonaparte lost patience. He addressed the Ancients first and did it badly, rambling about the god of war and the god of fortune. Then he walked into the Five Hundred with an escort of grenadiers.

Soldiers on the floor of the chamber were an outrage, and the deputies reacted as one. They shouted ‘Outlaw him!’ and ‘Down with the dictator!’, the cry that had destroyed Robespierre. Bonaparte was seized by the collar, shaken and pushed, and his grenadiers had to pull him out. Witnesses describe him pale and barely coherent. The chamber’s president was his brother Lucien, aged twenty-four. Lucien refused to put the motion of outlawry to the vote, left the chair, mounted a horse in the courtyard and told the guard that the assembly was being terrorised by a handful of deputies with daggers, in English pay. He held a sword to his brother’s chest and swore to run him through if he ever harmed French liberty.

It worked. Joachim Murat led the grenadiers into the Orangery with drums beating, and the deputies left by the doors and, according to most accounts, the windows. That night a few dozen of them were rounded up to give the proceedings a vote. They abolished the Directory and named three provisional consuls: Bonaparte, Sieyès and Ducos. Within six weeks a new constitution had made Bonaparte First Consul and left Sieyès with a pension and an estate.

How it came to this

The Directory had ruled France since 1795 under a constitution designed to prevent both a king and a second Terror. It did so by annulling elections whenever they went against it: against royalists in 1797, against Jacobins in 1798. By 1799 it was at war with a second coalition of Austria, Russia and Britain, its paper money was worthless, parts of the west and south were in armed revolt and a forced loan had frightened property owners. Many who had done well out of the Revolution wanted its gains made safe by someone strong.

Bonaparte had made his name in Italy in 1796-97 and then taken an army to Egypt, where Nelson destroyed his fleet. In August 1799 he left that army behind and sailed for France, landing in October to cheering crowds who knew of his victories and little of his failures. The military emergency that had seemed to justify a rescue was in fact already passing: Masséna had beaten the Russians at Zurich in September and an Anglo-Russian landing in Holland had been defeated.

How each side saw it

The deputies of the Five Hundred

For the republicans in the Orangery this was not the rescue of a failing state but the dispersal of an elected legislature by armed men. They had been asked to believe in a conspiracy for which no evidence was ever produced, and their demand that every member renew his oath to the constitution was, in their eyes, the proper answer. After the coup about sixty deputies were struck from the rolls and a number were listed for deportation, though the sentence was not carried out. Their version survives in protests and later memoirs, and it shaped the republican tradition that treated Brumaire as the original military crime against the Republic.

The Bonapartist account

The official story, issued within hours, was that the general had gone unarmed among the deputies and been attacked with daggers, and that a grenadier named Thomé had taken a blow meant for him. Thomé was given a pension and a kiss from Josephine for a torn sleeve. In this telling the army did not overthrow the law but saved a nation from a faction, and the proof offered was the calm that followed and the lack of anyone willing to fight for the Directory. The proclamation of December 1799 put it in a sentence: the Revolution was fixed to the principles that began it, and it was finished.

Royalists and the exiled court

Royalists inside and outside France hoped Bonaparte would play the part General Monck had played in England in 1660 and hand the throne back to its owner. The pretender, the future Louis XVIII, wrote to him from exile in 1800 offering to let him name his own reward. Bonaparte’s reply, that the king would have to walk over a hundred thousand corpses to return, ended that hope. For the legitimist tradition Brumaire therefore changed nothing essential: one usurping regime had replaced another, and the man in charge was simply more dangerous because he was more able.

The liberal circle around Sieyès, Constant and Madame de Staël

Many of those who helped plan the coup thought they were strengthening representative government, not ending it. Sieyès drafted a constitution of balanced powers with a largely ceremonial head of state, and Bonaparte dismantled it clause by clause in a few evenings of argument. Benjamin Constant, appointed to the new Tribunate, was warning against arbitrary rule within weeks and was purged in 1802. Germaine de Staël, in whose salon the plotters had been welcome, was later exiled. Their writings are the main source for the view that Brumaire was a liberal project captured by its instrument.

What is disputed

No dagger was ever produced, and most historians treat the story as invented on the spot; the scratches on Bonaparte’s face may have been his own doing. Whether he fainted outside the Orangery rests on hostile memoirs. The plebiscite on the new constitution was announced as about three million votes to 1,562, but Claude Langlois showed that Lucien Bonaparte, as interior minister, roughly doubled the yes vote. Historians also divide on the larger question. Some, following the republican tradition, see the end of the Revolution; others, such as Isser Woloch and Thierry Lentz, stress how many revolutionaries joined the new regime and how much of their work it preserved.

What followed

Bonaparte became consul for life in 1802 and emperor in 1804. The Consulate gave France the prefects, the Bank of France, the Concordat with Rome and the Civil Code, and it gave Europe fifteen years of war. The word Brumaire entered political language as the name for a soldier’s seizure of a tired republic. Karl Marx used it for the title of his essay on Louis-Napoleon’s coup of 1851, where he remarked that history repeats itself, first as tragedy and then as farce.

Read further

  • Thierry Lentz, Le 18 Brumaire (1997)
  • Isser Woloch, Napoleon and His Collaborators: The Making of a Dictatorship (2001)
  • Malcolm Crook, Napoleon Comes to Power: Democracy and Dictatorship in Revolutionary France, 1795-1804 (1998)
  • Patrice Gueniffey, Bonaparte: 1769-1802 (2013)
  • Karl Marx, The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (1852)

Same day, other years

1867

The last shogun hands back his mandate

Kyoto, JapanAsia

Tokugawa Yoshinobu, fifteenth shogun of a line that had governed Japan since 1603, submitted a memorial to the imperial court on 9 November 1867 returning the authority of government to the emperor. He had announced the decision to the assembled representatives of the great domains at Nijo Castle the day before, and the court accepted it the day after. The idea came from the domain of Tosa, which hoped to avoid civil war. Yoshinobu was no simple loser: he expected to remain the largest landholder in Japan and to preside over a council of lords under a boy emperor of fifteen.

Seen from elsewhere. The domains of Satsuma and Choshu wanted the Tokugawa house broken, not rearranged. They obtained a secret imperial order to attack it, whose authenticity is doubted, seized the palace in January 1868 and proclaimed direct imperial rule. Northern domains loyal to the shogun fought on until 1869, and their descendants long remembered the Restoration as a conquest.

1938

The November pogrom

Germany and AustriaEurope

On the night of 9 November 1938, after a German diplomat shot in Paris by a seventeen-year-old Polish Jew, Herschel Grynszpan, died of his wounds, Nazi party formations attacked Jewish communities across the Reich. Joseph Goebbels gave the signal in a speech to party veterans in Munich. Well over a thousand synagogues and prayer rooms were burned or wrecked and some 7,500 shops smashed. The official death toll was 91; counting suicides and deaths in custody, historians put it in the high hundreds or more. About 30,000 Jewish men were sent to Dachau, Buchenwald and Sachsenhausen, and the Jewish community was then fined a billion marks for the damage.

Seen from elsewhere. The regime presented the violence as the spontaneous anger of the people, a claim its own orders to police and fire brigades contradict. The familiar name, Kristallnacht, is avoided by many Germans as a euphemism that turns murder into broken glass. How far ordinary Germans approved, joined in or disapproved in silence is still argued from police and exile reports.

1953

Cambodia becomes independent

Phnom Penh, CambodiaAsia

French troops handed over their last commands in Phnom Penh on 9 November 1953, ending ninety years of protectorate. The date is Cambodia’s national day. King Norodom Sihanouk, whom the French had put on the throne in 1941 as a pliable eighteen-year-old, had spent the year on what he called a royal crusade, touring Paris, Washington and Ottawa and then withdrawing to the north-west and refusing to return to his capital until France gave way. France, losing a war next door in Vietnam, could not afford a second one. Sihanouk dominated the country’s politics for the next seventeen years.

Seen from elsewhere. The armed Khmer Issarak and the communists who fought alongside the Viet Minh held that their guerrilla war, not the king’s diplomacy, had forced France out, and that Sihanouk had taken the credit and the state. The Democratic Party, which had won elections, made a similar complaint about a monarch who had dissolved parliament to rule himself.

1989

The Berlin Wall opens by mistake

Berlin, GermanyEurope

At a dull evening press conference on 9 November 1989 the East German Politburo spokesman Günter Schabowski read out a new travel regulation he had not studied. Asked when it took effect, he shuffled his papers and said immediately, without delay. It was meant to start the next day, with visas. West German television reported that the border was open, and thousands of East Berliners went to the crossings to see. At Bornholmer Strasse, shortly before midnight, an officer named Harald Jäger, without orders and afraid of a crush, raised the barrier. The Wall had stood since 1961, and at least 140 people had died at it.

Seen from elsewhere. Many of the East German dissidents whose marches had brought the regime down wanted a reformed socialist state, not absorption by the West, and felt overtaken. Britain’s Margaret Thatcher and France’s François Mitterrand privately feared a larger Germany. Because the date is also that of the 1938 pogrom, Germany chose 3 October for its national holiday.

Also on 9 November