Parallax

28 November, 1290

Eleanor of Castile dies, and Edward I builds twelve crosses

The king marked every night’s halt of his wife’s funeral journey with a stone monument. Her subjects remembered a harder woman than the one on the crosses.

Harby, Nottinghamshire, England

In the autumn of 1290 Edward I was moving north towards Lincoln, with Scotland on his mind: the young heir to the Scottish throne, Margaret, the Maid of Norway, had died in September, and the succession was open. His queen, Eleanor of Castile, had been unwell for months, and the court’s household accounts show payments for her medicines. She was carried to a manor house at Harby, near Lincoln, owned by a local knight. Edward came to her there, and she died on the evening of 28 November, aged about forty-nine.

They had been married for thirty-six years, since a ceremony at the abbey of Las Huelgas in Burgos when she was about thirteen and he fifteen. She had borne him at least fourteen children, perhaps sixteen; only six outlived her, one of them the future Edward II, born at Caernarfon in 1284. She had gone with Edward on crusade, travelled with him to Gascony and Wales, and was almost always at his side. He was not a man given to gentle words, but in a letter to the abbot of Cluny soon afterwards he wrote of her as one whom living he had dearly cherished and whom dead he could not cease to love.

Her body was embalmed. Her entrails were buried in Lincoln Cathedral, and the rest of her made a slow progress south to London through the first half of December, resting each night at a town or abbey: Lincoln, Grantham, Stamford, Geddington, Hardingstone near Northampton, Stony Stratford, Woburn, Dunstable, St Albans, Waltham, Westcheap in the City of London and finally Charing, a village on the road to Westminster. She was buried in Westminster Abbey on 17 December. Her heart was taken to the Dominican friary in London.

Edward then ordered a stone cross to be raised at each of the twelve stopping places. Built over the next few years by the leading masons and sculptors of the day, among them Richard of Crundale, Michael of Canterbury and William of Ireland, they were tall, many-sided structures with statues of the queen set in canopied niches, and they asked passers-by to pray for her soul. Charing’s, of marble, was the most expensive.

Three of the crosses survive, at Geddington, Hardingstone and Waltham Cross, all much weathered and restored. The others were broken up, most of them by Puritan iconoclasts in the 1640s; the Charing cross was pulled down on Parliament’s order in 1647, and a statue of Charles I now stands near its site. The cross in front of Charing Cross station is a Victorian design of 1865, put up by the railway company.

How it came to this

Eleanor was the daughter of Ferdinand III of Castile and half-sister of Alfonso X. Her marriage to the heir of Henry III was part of a settlement that ended Castilian claims to Gascony, the English king’s lands in south-west France. In England she was a foreigner surrounded by foreigners, and the barons who rebelled against Henry III in the 1260s attacked the court’s Spanish and Savoyard connections. When Henry died in 1272 Edward and Eleanor were in the Holy Land; they returned to be crowned together in 1274.

As queen she was expected to support herself from her own lands, and she built a large estate quickly. Much of it came through the purchase of debts owed by landholders to Jewish moneylenders: the queen took over the bonds and, when the debtors could not pay, the land. The archbishop of Canterbury, John Pecham, wrote warning her that her conduct was causing scandal. The Jews themselves, heavily taxed by the crown, were expelled from England by Edward’s order in July 1290, four months before she died.

How each side saw it

Edward and the court

To Edward and his household she was a devoted companion, and the crosses, the Westminster tomb with William Torel’s gilt bronze effigy and the masses endowed for her soul made her memory into a public cult of royal grief. Chroniclers close to the court praised her piety and her patronage of the Dominicans. Edward never had another queen like her: when he remarried in 1299, to Margaret of France, it was a diplomatic match made to settle a war, though by all accounts a friendly one.

Her tenants and the chroniclers

Outside the court she had a hard reputation. The chronicler Walter of Guisborough preserves a verse that ran, in English translation, that the king would like to get our gold and the queen our lands to hold. Pecham’s letters accuse her officials of extortion. After her death Edward ordered an inquiry into complaints against her administrators, and her executors paid compensation to people found to have been wronged. The historian John Carmi Parsons, who studied her accounts, concludes that she was a capable, acquisitive estate manager whom many feared.

The Jewish communities of England

No Jewish writer recorded a view of Eleanor. What survives is the record of the Exchequer of the Jews and the queen’s own accounts, which show her acquiring debts owed to Jewish lenders, sometimes as gifts from the king, and turning them into estates. The same system of royal exploitation, combined with new taxes and accusations of coin-clipping that led to hundreds of executions in 1278-79, drove the community into poverty before the expulsion of 1290. Historians such as Robin Mundill see the queen as one beneficiary of that system.

What is disputed

The famous story that Eleanor sucked the poison from Edward’s wound after an assassin stabbed him at Acre in 1272 first appears in an Italian chronicle written decades later; Walter of Guisborough says she was led away weeping while a surgeon cut out the infected flesh. Her age at marriage was once given as nine or ten, but her birth is now placed around 1241. The number of her children ranges from fourteen to sixteen. Older books describe her as a gentle moderating influence on Edward; Parsons and Sara Cockerill, who largely defends her, agree that the evidence is thinner than the legend.

What followed

The Eleanor crosses inspired a long line of memorial crosses, including the Victorian Martyrs’ Memorial in Oxford, and they made Charing Cross the point from which distances from London were measured. Edward went on to intervene in Scotland, beginning the wars of independence in 1296. The expulsion of 1290 was not reversed until Jews were readmitted under Cromwell in the 1650s. Eleanor’s reputation swung from saintly queen in Victorian books to grasping foreigner and back towards a more balanced picture, built from her household accounts.

Read further

  • John Carmi Parsons, Eleanor of Castile: Queen and Society in Thirteenth-Century England (1995)
  • Sara Cockerill, Eleanor of Castile: The Shadow Queen (2014)
  • Marc Morris, A Great and Terrible King: Edward I and the Forging of Britain (2008)
  • Michael Prestwich, Edward I (1988)
  • Robin R. Mundill, England’s Jewish Solution: Experiment and Expulsion, 1262-1290 (1998)

Same day, other years

1520

Magellan’s ships reach the Pacific

Strait of Magellan, now ChileThe Americas

After more than five weeks threading the channels at the tip of South America, three ships of Ferdinand Magellan’s Spanish fleet came out into an open ocean that he named the Pacific for its calm. A fourth, the San Antonio, had deserted and sailed back to Spain. The crossing that followed took more than three months without fresh food; men ate leather and sawdust and died of scurvy. Magellan was killed in the Philippines in April 1521, and only one ship, under Juan Sebastian Elcano, completed the voyage round the world.

Seen from elsewhere. The fires the sailors saw along the southern shore gave Tierra del Fuego its name; the Selk’nam, Kawesqar and Yaghan peoples who lit them left no account of the ships. In the Philippines Magellan is remembered chiefly through Lapulapu, the chief of Mactan whose warriors killed him, now honoured as a national hero.

1893

New Zealand’s women vote in a national election

New ZealandOceania

Ten weeks after the Electoral Act of 1893 became law, women voted for the first time in a general election in a self-governing country. About 109,000 women had enrolled, and some 90,000 of them voted in the European electorates on 28 November. The campaign had been led by Kate Sheppard and the Women’s Christian Temperance Union, who had presented petitions with nearly 32,000 signatures, a huge share of the adult female population. Women could vote but could not yet stand for Parliament; that right came only in 1919, and the first woman MP was elected in 1933.

Seen from elsewhere. Maori women voted in the separate Maori electorates on 20 December. Maori women had also campaigned for the right to vote and speak in their own Kotahitanga parliament. Opponents, including the premier Richard Seddon, had tried to defeat the bill, and the liquor trade feared that women would vote for prohibition.

1943

The Big Three meet in Tehran

Tehran, IranMiddle East

Stalin, Roosevelt and Churchill met together for the first time, in the Soviet embassy in the capital of a country their armies had occupied since 1941. Over four days they agreed that Britain and the United States would invade northern France in May 1944, that the Soviet Union would join the war against Japan after Germany’s defeat, and, in outline, that Poland’s borders would be moved westward. Roosevelt stayed in the Soviet compound, on Soviet advice about German assassins, where his rooms were almost certainly bugged. Sergo Beria, son of the Soviet security chief, later wrote that he had been set to listen in.

Seen from elsewhere. Iran’s young shah received the leaders as a host in his own occupied capital and obtained a declaration promising Iran’s independence after the war. The Polish government in exile was not told what had been decided about its borders. Churchill later complained that he had been outvoted by the other two.

1975

East Timor declares independence

Dili, East TimorAsia

As Portugal abandoned its colonial empire after the 1974 revolution, a short civil war in Portuguese Timor left the left-leaning Fretilin movement in control. Facing Indonesian border incursions, Fretilin proclaimed the Democratic Republic of East Timor in Dili. Nine days later, on 7 December, Indonesia invaded by sea and air, landing paratroops and marines in Dili. The occupation that followed lasted twenty-four years. The country’s truth commission later counted at least 102,800 deaths from killing, hunger and disease caused by the conflict, and its upper estimate was about 180,000, in a population of some 650,000.

Seen from elsewhere. Indonesia presented the invasion as a response to a communist threat and an invitation from Timorese parties, and annexed the territory in 1976. The United States and Australia, informed in advance, did not object. The United Nations never recognised the annexation, and East Timor became independent in 2002 after a referendum.

Also on 28 November