Parallax

12 November, 1948

Seven death sentences in Tokyo

After two and a half years, eleven judges sentenced Japan’s wartime leaders one at a time. One judge would have acquitted them all, and the man in whose name they had acted was never in the dock.

Ichigaya, Tokyo, Japan

The courtroom was the auditorium of the former Army Ministry at Ichigaya, the building from which much of the war had been directed. On the afternoon of 12 November 1948 the president of the International Military Tribunal for the Far East, Sir William Webb of Australia, finished reading a judgment that had taken seven court days to deliver. The dock was then cleared. The twenty-five defendants were brought back singly, in alphabetical order, to stand between two American military policemen, put on headphones and hear their sentences in translation.

Seven were condemned to death by hanging. General Tojo Hideki, prime minister when Pearl Harbor was attacked, listened, nodded and took off the headphones. The others were five more generals, Doihara Kenji, Itagaki Seishiro, Kimura Heitaro, Matsui Iwane and Muto Akira, and one civilian, the former prime minister and foreign minister Hirota Koki. Sixteen men received life imprisonment. Two diplomats received fixed terms: Togo Shigenori twenty years and Shigemitsu Mamoru seven. No one was acquitted. The whole procedure took less than half an hour.

Tojo had made the tribunal’s task easier than his lawyers wished. He had shot himself in the chest when American officers came to arrest him in September 1945, survived, and decided to use the witness box to take responsibility for the war while denying that it was a crime. He said Japan had fought in self-defence against economic strangulation. He slipped once, telling the court that no Japanese subject would act against the emperor’s will, which implied that the emperor had willed the war. The prosecution, which was as anxious as the defence to keep Hirohito out of the case, had him correct it a week later.

Hirota’s sentence shocked many in the room, the Dutch judge among them. He had not commanded troops. He was convicted of taking part in the planning of aggression and of failing, as foreign minister in 1937-38, to press the cabinet to stop the atrocities at Nanjing that his own ministry had reported to him. The vote on his death is said to have been six to five. Matsui, the general in command at Nanjing, was acquitted of every charge of aggression and condemned solely for failing to control his army.

General Douglas MacArthur confirmed every sentence. An appeal to the United States Supreme Court was refused on the ground that the tribunal was not an American court. The seven were hanged at Sugamo Prison shortly after midnight on 23 December 1948 and cremated, and the American authorities disposed of the ashes in secret so that there would be no grave.

How it came to this

The Allies had declared at Potsdam in July 1945 that stern justice would be meted out to war criminals, and Japan accepted those terms on surrender. In January 1946 MacArthur, as Supreme Commander, issued a charter for a tribunal modelled on the one sitting at Nuremberg. Eleven countries each supplied a judge: the United States, the Soviet Union, Britain, China, France, the Netherlands, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, India and the Philippines. The chief prosecutor was an American, Joseph Keenan.

Twenty-eight men were indicted as ‘Class A’ suspects, accused chiefly of crimes against peace: planning and waging aggressive war from the seizure of Manchuria in 1931 onwards. Two died during the trial and one was found unfit to plead. The court sat from May 1946, heard 419 witnesses and received more than four thousand exhibits. Separately, Allied military courts across Asia tried some 5,700 Japanese for conventional war crimes against prisoners and civilians and executed more than 900. Emperor Hirohito was neither charged nor called as a witness, a decision taken by MacArthur and Washington on the reasoning that the occupation needed him.

How each side saw it

Justice Radhabinod Pal and the charge of victors’ justice

The Indian judge wrote a dissent longer than the judgment and would have acquitted every defendant on every count. Aggressive war, he argued, had not been a crime in international law when these men acted, so the charge was retroactive; the judges all came from the victor nations; and powers that held colonies in Asia and had used atomic bombs were poorly placed to try others. Pal did not deny that atrocities such as Nanjing occurred. His opinion was suppressed in occupied Japan and published there in 1952. Japanese nationalists have honoured him since, with a monument at the Yasukuni Shrine, in ways that some scholars think misread an anti-colonial argument as an exoneration.

China, the Philippines and the occupied countries

For the countries Japan invaded the tribunal did too little. The Philippine judge, Delfin Jaranilla, a survivor of the Bataan death march, wrote that the sentences were too lenient. The court found that more than 200,000 civilians and prisoners were killed at Nanjing; China’s own tribunal there put the figure at over 300,000. Whole categories of crime went largely unexamined: the forced prostitution of women across the empire, the army’s biological warfare unit in Manchuria, whose officers the United States shielded in exchange for their data, and the colonial rule of Korea and Taiwan, neither of which had a judge on the bench.

The defendants and their families

The accused mostly argued that they had served a lawful government in a war forced on Japan by Western encirclement, and that there had been no conspiracy, only a succession of quarrelling cabinets. Tojo accepted responsibility for defeat, which he owed to the emperor and the nation, but not criminal guilt. Hirota declined to testify at all and is said to have forbidden his family to plead for him; a petition for clemency nonetheless gathered many thousands of signatures in Japan. In 1978 the priests of Yasukuni quietly enshrined fourteen Class A defendants, including the seven hanged, among the country’s war dead.

The judges who disagreed among themselves

Five of the eleven judges wrote separately. Webb, the president, observed that the leader of the crime, though available for trial, had been granted immunity, and that this should weigh in sentencing. The French judge, Henri Bernard, said the emperor was a principal author of the war and that the proceedings were procedurally defective. The Dutch judge, Bert Röling, would have acquitted Hirota and four others, and spent much of his later career arguing that the trial, for all its faults, had helped establish that leaders can be held personally accountable for war.

What is disputed

Whether the trial was law or politics has been argued since Pal. Richard Minear’s ‘Victors’ Justice’ (1971) set out the case against it; Yuma Totani and others have since defended much of its fact-finding on atrocities while accepting flaws in the conspiracy charge. The six-to-five vote on Hirota comes from Röling’s recollections, not from any official record, since the judges’ deliberations were secret. The extent of Hirohito’s responsibility remains contested between historians such as Herbert Bix, who see an active commander, and those who see a constitutional monarch carried along by his generals.

What followed

On the day after the hangings the occupation released the remaining Class A suspects without trial. One of them, Kishi Nobusuke, became prime minister in 1957. Japan accepted the tribunal’s judgments in the San Francisco peace treaty of 1951, and the surviving prisoners were paroled by 1958; Shigemitsu returned as foreign minister. Visits by Japanese prime ministers to Yasukuni still draw formal protests from China and South Korea. The principles applied at Nuremberg and Tokyo underlie the international criminal courts created since the 1990s.

Read further

  • Richard H. Minear, Victors’ Justice: The Tokyo War Crimes Trial (1971)
  • Yuma Totani, The Tokyo War Crimes Trial: The Pursuit of Justice in the Wake of World War II (2008)
  • Neil Boister and Robert Cryer, The Tokyo International Military Tribunal: A Reappraisal (2008)
  • John W. Dower, Embracing Defeat: Japan in the Wake of World War II (1999)
  • Gary J. Bass, Judgement at Tokyo: World War II on Trial and the Making of Modern Asia (2023)

Same day, other years

1035

Cnut dies at Shaftesbury

Shaftesbury, EnglandEurope

Cnut, son of the Danish king Swein Forkbeard, conquered England in 1016 after a year of war against Edmund Ironside, and went on to rule Denmark, Norway and part of Sweden as well: a North Sea empire held together by ships and silver. He began with killings and a tax of more than 80,000 pounds to pay off his fleet, then governed for nearly twenty years as a law-giving Christian king, married his predecessor’s widow, Emma of Normandy, and made a pilgrimage to Rome. He died on 12 November 1035, aged about forty, and was buried at Winchester. His empire did not outlast his sons, both dead by 1042.

Seen from elsewhere. The tale of Cnut and the tide first appears a century later in Henry of Huntingdon, where it shows a pious king rebuking flatterers, not a vain one commanding the sea. English and Danish writers praised him. Norwegian tradition did not: he drove out Olaf Haraldsson, later a saint, and the rule of Cnut’s son and consort there was remembered as oppression.

1893

A line is drawn through the Pashtun lands

Kabul, AfghanistanAsia

On 12 November 1893 Sir Mortimer Durand, foreign secretary of British India, and Abdur Rahman Khan, Amir of Afghanistan, signed a short agreement in Kabul fixing the limit of their respective spheres. The line ran for some 2,600 kilometres from the Pamirs to Persia, across mountains inhabited by Pashtun and Baloch tribes whom neither government controlled and none of whom were consulted. The Amir’s British subsidy was raised by half. Surveyors marked the line on the ground over the next few years, sometimes through the middle of a village or a tribe’s grazing. It is today the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Seen from elsewhere. Pakistan regards it as an international frontier inherited in 1947. No Afghan government, royal, communist, republican or Taliban, has formally accepted that. Afghans argue the Amir signed under pressure and marked only zones of influence. A common belief that the agreement expired after a hundred years has no basis in its text.

1956

Killings at Rafah

Rafah, Gaza StripMiddle East

Israel occupied the Gaza Strip in the first days of November 1956 during the Suez war. On 12 November its soldiers carried out a screening operation in the town and refugee camp of Rafah to find Egyptian soldiers and Palestinian fighters, ordering men of military age to gather at a school. The director of the United Nations relief agency for Palestine refugees, Henry Labouisse, reported to the General Assembly that 111 people were killed in Rafah that day, most of them refugees, and that a similar operation at Khan Yunis nine days earlier had left 275 dead. Israel withdrew from Gaza under American pressure in March 1957.

Seen from elsewhere. Israel said its troops had met resistance and that a crowd had panicked and run. Survivors interviewed decades later, notably for Joe Sacco’s book ‘Footnotes in Gaza’, described men shot in the streets as they hurried to the assembly point. The UN report itself noted that the accounts conflicted. No findings of an inquiry were published.

1991

Soldiers open fire at the Santa Cruz cemetery

Dili, East TimorAsia

Indonesia had invaded the former Portuguese colony of East Timor in 1975. On 12 November 1991 several thousand people walked from a memorial mass in Dili to the Santa Cruz cemetery, to the grave of Sebastião Gomes, a young independence supporter shot by troops two weeks earlier. Some unfurled banners. At the cemetery gates Indonesian soldiers fired into the crowd without warning. Timorese investigators later compiled a list of 271 dead and about 250 missing. A British cameraman, Max Stahl, filmed from among the graves and buried his tapes before he was arrested. Broadcast worldwide, the footage ended years of international indifference. East Timor voted for independence in 1999.

Seen from elsewhere. The army said its men had been provoked; an officer had been stabbed on the route. Indonesia’s own inquiry first gave nineteen dead and then about fifty. A few junior soldiers received short sentences for indiscipline, while Timorese who organised the march were jailed for up to life.

Also on 12 November