Parallax

25 November, 1741

Peter the Great’s daughter takes the throne by night

With a few hundred grenadiers and not a shot fired, Elizabeth Petrovna arrested a baby emperor and his mother in their beds and woke up ruler of Russia.

St Petersburg, Russia

Late on the night of 24 November 1741, by the Russian calendar, the Tsarevna Elizabeth Petrovna prayed before an icon in her house and then set off by sledge for the barracks of the Preobrazhensky Guards. With her went her physician, the Frenchman Armand Lestocq, her chamberlain Mikhail Vorontsov and a handful of household men. She was thirty-one, the last surviving child of Peter the Great, and for ten years she had been kept at the edge of a court that did not trust her.

The Guards knew her. She had spent years cultivating the grenadiers of the regiment, standing godmother to their children and drinking their health, and they disliked the German ministers who ran the government in the name of the infant emperor. In the guardroom she asked them to follow her. Roughly three hundred did, swearing on a cross, and marched with her through the snow towards the Winter Palace. A story told later has the soldiers lifting her and carrying her the last stretch because she could not keep up.

The sentries at the palace let them in. Elizabeth went to the bedroom of the regent, Anna Leopoldovna, and woke her; Anna and her husband, Prince Anthony Ulrich of Brunswick, were taken under guard. The emperor, Ivan VI, fifteen months old, was carried out by a soldier. Tradition has Elizabeth taking him in her arms and saying that the child was not to blame. At the same hour detachments went to the houses of the vice-chancellor Andrei Ostermann, Field Marshal Burkhard von Munnich and other ministers and arrested them. Nobody was killed.

By morning on 25 November Elizabeth was back in her own palace receiving the oaths of the Senate, the Synod and the regiments. A short manifesto announced that she had taken her father’s throne at the request of her loyal subjects, and a longer one soon followed setting out her claim by birth and by the will of her mother, Catherine I. The grenadiers who had marched with her became a new unit, the Leib Company, with Elizabeth herself as its captain; its men were made nobles and given land.

The losers paid more slowly. Ostermann and Munnich were tried and taken to the scaffold in January 1742, where their death sentences were commuted at the last moment to exile in Siberia. The Brunswick family were at first told they would be sent abroad, then held in a series of fortresses and finally at Kholmogory near the White Sea, where Anna Leopoldovna died after childbirth in 1746. Ivan was separated from them and ended up in solitary confinement at Shlisselburg, where his guards were forbidden to tell anyone who he was.

How it came to this

Peter the Great had changed the law so that a ruler could name any heir, and then died in 1725 without naming one. Russia had four rulers in the next fifteen years: his widow Catherine I, his grandson Peter II, his niece Anna Ivanovna, and finally a baby. Elizabeth, born in 1709 before her parents’ church wedding, was passed over each time. Plans to marry her abroad came to nothing when her fiance, a Holstein prince, died in 1727. Under Empress Anna, who ruled from 1730, she lived quietly and under watch while Anna’s favourite, Ernst Johann Biron, and other Baltic Germans dominated the court.

Anna died in October 1740, leaving the crown to her great-nephew Ivan, two months old, with Biron as regent. Munnich overthrew Biron within three weeks and the baby’s mother, Anna Leopoldovna, became regent. Her government was divided and slack. In the summer of 1741 Sweden declared war, claiming to fight on behalf of Peter’s true heirs, and the French ambassador, the Marquis de La Chetardie, encouraged Elizabeth and offered money. When the regent confronted Elizabeth at court on 23 November about her contacts with the French, and the Guards were ordered to march to the Finnish front, her circle decided to act at once.

How each side saw it

Elizabeth and her supporters

Elizabeth’s manifestos presented the coup as a restoration: Peter’s daughter reclaiming her inheritance from usurping foreigners and their puppet. Court poets, Mikhail Lomonosov above all, wrote odes in that spirit, and the nickname ‘daughter of Peter’ was used as a political programme. She also made a show of mercy. She is reported to have vowed before the icon that night not to sign a death warrant, and through her reign no one was executed by her order, though torture, flogging and mutilation continued. Supporters later counted this restraint as proof of a gentle, pious nature.

The Brunswick family

The deposed family left almost no voice of their own. What we know comes from the reports of their guards, the instructions sent from St Petersburg and a few petitions. They show a family moved from fortress to fortress, Anthony Ulrich refusing an offer of freedom without his children and dying at Kholmogory in 1774, and Ivan raised in isolation, barely educated, known in documents only as a nameless prisoner. Catherine II finally allowed Ivan’s surviving brothers and sisters to leave for Denmark in 1780, after thirty-nine years of captivity.

France and Sweden

La Chetardie’s dispatches to Versailles gave the impression that the coup was largely his work, and French diplomats expected a grateful Russia to drop its Austrian alliance. Sweden hoped Elizabeth would return the Baltic provinces her father had taken. Both were disappointed. Elizabeth kept fighting Sweden and won a slice of Finland at the Peace of Abo in 1743. In 1744 her ministers produced deciphered copies of La Chetardie’s letters, in which he wrote scornfully about the empress, and he was ordered out of Russia within a day.

Historians of the ‘palace revolutions’

Vasily Klyuchevsky called the decades after Peter’s death the era of palace revolutions, and the phrase stuck. Nineteenth-century nationalist writers read the 1741 coup as a Russian reaction against German rule. Evgenii Anisimov and other modern historians are more sceptical: several foreigners kept their posts, and the real lesson of 1741 was that the Guards regiments could make and unmake rulers. They did so again in 1762 and, with the murder of Paul I, in 1801.

What is disputed

The date depends on the calendar: 25 November in Russia was 6 December in western Europe. The number of grenadiers is usually given as about three hundred, though accounts vary. How much La Chetardie actually contributed, beyond promises and his own boasting, is argued. The most vivid details, the cuirass, the soldiers carrying her, the words over the baby’s cradle, come from later memoirs and anecdotes. Popular books say Elizabeth abolished the death penalty; she did not change the law, but commuted sentences. The famous count of 15,000 dresses left at her death cannot be checked.

What followed

Elizabeth reigned until her death on Christmas Day 1761 by the Russian calendar. Her reign saw the founding of Moscow University in 1755, Rastrelli’s baroque palaces and Russian troops in Berlin during the Seven Years’ War. In 1743 two court ladies, Natalia Lopukhina and Anna Bestuzheva, were knouted and had their tongues cut for alleged plotting. Her heir was her nephew Peter of Holstein, son of her sister Anna Petrovna, whom she married to Sophie of Anhalt-Zerbst. Sophie, as Catherine II, deposed him in another Guards coup in 1762. Ivan VI was killed by his guards in 1764 during a failed attempt to free him.

Read further

  • Evgenii V. Anisimov, Empress Elizabeth: Her Reign and Her Russia, 1741-1761 (1995)
  • R. Nisbet Bain, The Daughter of Peter the Great (1899)
  • Simon Dixon, The Modernisation of Russia, 1676-1825 (1999)
  • Lindsey Hughes, Russia in the Age of Peter the Great (1998)

Same day, other years

1177

The leper king routs Saladin at Montgisard

Near Ramla, Kingdom of JerusalemMiddle East

Saladin had marched out of Egypt with a large army, expecting little resistance because the crusader field force was tied down in the north. King Baldwin IV of Jerusalem, sixteen years old and already disfigured by leprosy, gathered a few hundred knights, the Templars from Gaza and Raynald of Chatillon, and caught the Ayyubid army strung out and plundering near Ramla. The surprise attack broke it. Saladin escaped on a racing camel, according to one account, and much of his army was killed or lost in the desert on the way home.

Seen from elsewhere. Muslim writers, including Saladin’s secretary Imad al-Din, treated the defeat as a lesson in overconfidence and dispersal rather than a judgement of God. Ten years later Saladin destroyed the crusader army at Hattin and took Jerusalem. Christian chroniclers credited the victory to a fragment of the True Cross carried into battle.

1510

Albuquerque takes Goa

Goa, IndiaAsia

Afonso de Albuquerque, governor of the Portuguese in the Indian Ocean, had taken Goa from the Sultanate of Bijapur earlier in 1510 and been driven out. He returned in November with a larger fleet and stormed the city on 25 November, the feast of St Catherine. By his own letters he then had the Muslim inhabitants who had not fled killed, men, women and children, over several days, while sparing Hindus. Goa became the capital of the Portuguese Estado da India, the base from which Portugal sought to control the spice trade by force.

Seen from elsewhere. Portuguese tradition long honoured Albuquerque as a founder of empire. For Bijapur and for later Indian historians the conquest began four and a half centuries of colonial rule, including the Goa Inquisition from 1560. Goa stayed Portuguese until India took it by force in 1961, an action Portugal refused to recognise until 1974.

1915

Einstein completes general relativity

Berlin, GermanyEurope

In the middle of the First World War, Albert Einstein presented a short paper to the Prussian Academy of Sciences giving the final form of his field equations of gravitation. It was the fourth paper in four weeks, after years of false starts. The equations described gravity not as a force but as the curvature of space and time produced by mass and energy. A week earlier he had already used them to explain an anomaly in the orbit of Mercury that Newton’s theory could not, a result he said gave him palpitations.

Seen from elsewhere. The mathematician David Hilbert submitted a paper with closely related equations at almost the same moment, and a priority dispute was argued for decades. Historians who studied the printer’s proofs, including Leo Corry, Jurgen Renn and John Stachel, concluded in 1997 that Einstein got there independently. The theory won public fame after the eclipse observations of 1919.

1960

The Mirabal sisters are murdered

Near Salcedo, Dominican RepublicThe Americas

Patria, Minerva and Maria Teresa Mirabal were leading figures in the underground movement against Rafael Trujillo, who had ruled the Dominican Republic since 1930. Two of them had been jailed; two of their husbands were still in prison. Returning from a visit to the jail at Puerto Plata, they were stopped on a mountain road by agents of the secret police, beaten to death with their driver, Rufino de la Cruz, and put back in their jeep, which was pushed off a cliff to look like an accident. Few believed it.

Seen from elsewhere. The regime’s press reported a road accident. After Trujillo was assassinated in May 1961, several of the killers were tried and convicted. The surviving sister, Dede, kept their memory alive for decades. In 1999 the United Nations made 25 November the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women in their honour.

Also on 25 November